ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



NBC-WSJ 9/11 poll - America 'more safe'

Posted: Monday, September 11, 2006 7:00 AM by firstread
Filed Under:

From Elizabeth Wilner, Mark Murray, Huma Zaidi, and Jennifer Colby
Five years after the September 11 terrorist attacks, and 57 days until election day...  As President Bush takes part in a series of observances and prepares to address the nation tonight, pluralities of voters say the country is "more safe" than it was before September 11, 2001 and give his Administration and its policies "some of the credit" for the absence of another terrorist attack on US soil since then, per the latest NBC/Wall Street Journal poll.  The results also suggest that some of the key arguments being made in the partisan debate over the war on terror -- Democrats' claim that the nation is less safe because of the war in Iraq, and the Administration's effort to take credit for the absence of another terrorist attack on US soil -- are having limited impact.

Democrats have been trying to keep the spotlight on the unpopular war in Iraq by arguing that it has made the nation less safe.  Their congressional challengers around the country are observing today's anniversary by "reminding local voters that this Republican Congress should be doing more" on border and port security and more to implement the recommendations of the September 11 commission, per a party release.  Yet public opinion on whether or not the country is safer now than it was before the terrorist attacks remains pretty much unchanged from two years ago: 42% say the country is more safe, compared to 41% in September 2004; 32% say the country is about as safe, compared to 31% two years ago; and 23% say the country is less safe, compared to 27% two years ago.  Our pollsters point out that voters in the Northeast, the region most directly affected by the attacks, feel as safe as voters in other regions of the country.

The White House casts tonight's address as part of the President's ongoing effort to build support for the war in Iraq as central to the broader war on terror, an effort which will culminate with his appearance at the United Nations on September 19.  Public opinion on whether the war on terror has succeeded in disrupting international terrorism remains roughly where it was in September 2002.  Today, 15% say the WOT has succeeded in disrupting international terrorism "a great deal," compared to 18% four years ago; 26% say it has succeeded "quite a bit," compared to 25% four years ago; 32% say "just some," compared to 36% four years ago; and 18% say "very little," compared to 15% four years ago.

The Administration lately has tried to claim credit for the absence of another attack since September 11, 2001, but only 32% of registered voters give the Administration and its policies "all" or "most of" the credit for that fact.  Forty-five percent give the Administration and its policies "some of" the credit, while 21% give them "very little" credit.  The poll was conducted from September 8-10 of 602 registered voters and has a margin of error of +/-4%.

By the time he speaks tonight, Bush will have laid wreaths at Ground Zero; in Shanksville, PA; and at the Pentagon, among other events.  His primetime speech, per White House spokesperson Tony Snow, will not be political -- "there are no calls to action, there are no attempts to segregate Democrats from Republicans."  Bush will talk about "how September 11th reshaped the way in which we view the growing menace of what we now refer to -- the Islamist terrorist threat represented by bin Laden, Zarqawi and others, and that as a nation we don't have the luxury of sitting around and waiting for them to hit us again."  The speech pits Bush against Monday Night Football (Washington Redskins vs. Minnesota Vikings), and also will cause ABC to interrupt part two of its broadcast of its controversial September 11 docudrama. 

Vice President Cheney stays close to home, observing the anniversary at events at the White House and Pentagon.  Members of Congress attend an observance at the Capitol. 

And candidates facing tough primaries tomorrow in places like Rhode Island and Maryland will have to finesse hitting the campaign trail today.  Moderate GOP Sen. Lincoln Chafee of Rhode Island may lose his party's nomination to conservative Steve Laffey, furthering the anti-incumbent storyline of this cycle and potentially costing Republicans this Senate seat.  The party's Senate campaign committee has suggested they would see better races on which to bet their resources this fall than on helping Laffey win in this blue state. 

In Maryland, it's Democrats who will be watching the outcome of their Senate primary between leading contenders Rep. Ben Cardin and former Rep. Kweisi Mfume, with their chances of retaining the seat potentially hanging in the balance as Cardin is believed to be the stronger general election candidate.  An Mfume win would set up an unprecedented contest between two African-American major-party nominees.

More from First Read to come -- check back here after 9:00 am.  Got calendar

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

The administration makes much of the fact that we have not been attacked for five years. Bin Laden said right after we invaded Iraq that he was cutting back operations in Afghanistan because he could kill Americans in Iraq easier and cheaper. every time a soldier is killed or wounded we are attacked. Ask the foot soldier in Iraq if he is safer.
Anyone who says that America is safer now than before 9/11, is either not from this planet or just plain ignorant. It's amazing that even to this day, this administration still says that invading Iraq was the right thing to do. That we are better off without Saddam. While I do agree that he was a tryant and a murderer of thousands of his own people. Iraq had no connection to 9/11, the American public was fed a pack of lies by this administration, and they continue to do so. Let us not forget that in their war with Iran, it was America that gave Iraq the techonology to make chemical weapons.The same weapons we accused him of producing. America is now the most hated country in the world. This will be the case for years to come, even after this president leaves office. What we have is an arrogant administration, that refuses to listen to anyone outside of it's inner circle, and will brand anyone who disagrees with them as being un-patriotic. We've lost over 2600 soldiers. Our armed forces are streatched thin, we are asking them to serve 2 and sometimes 3 tours in Iraq. Thousands have returned without limbs, eyesight and brain damaged. Now with elections close at hand  we again have the administration spin doctors saying that if you do not vote Republican, you are inviting another attack. Spreading their fear tatic,which they seem to do so well, with the likes of Karl Rove, Dick Cheney and Condelezza Rice. I conld only hope that we as Americans can see through this sickning rhetoric.
Between Osama Bin Laden and the anthrax poisoner, BushCo is 0 for 2, but let's pretend it has something to do with Elvis drinking cold coffee and support our president.
Are we safer in the U.S.A.?  That is a question that not one of us can answer, at least in this short amount of time.  It will take years, and years past in order to truly have enough data to prove factually that we are safer.

Jack Dillon's comments are of the absolute truth.  My beliefs are that Americans should come together as one, release all ignorances, and truly respect and help one another as we did after 9/11.  This is the way I try to live my life everyday.  People will always have differences but, if we live by respect, everyday business and life could be so much sweeter.

I respect many of the actions our current administration has taken against terrorism.  I only hope that some of the focus can be applied over the next couple of years to American People and American Soil.
In the words of Thomas Jefferson, a TRUE founder and
caretaker of Democracy--------"America will never be defeated from without  ----  but will be destroyed from within."  Are we listening yet?
It's amazing, I read in these posts so many references that we had the world's sympathy and support on 9/12/01 and "somehow" lost it along the way. We lost all that sympathy and support the first time President bush publicly said the word Iraq. Every justification for that war has been proven false. That's where all the divisiveness in America and hatred towards the US across the world came from. No one objected to us engaging the Taliban, it was only when we engaged Iraq that the we alienated the rest of the world.
I don't know how people can say we are safer when we bombed the heck out of a country that had nothing to do with 9/11 and then invaded it creating a terrible destabilization in the region and a golden opportunity for terrorists to recruit volunteers and then, to be unable to protect our own people when a natural disaster hits because of the ineptitude of those in charge at the top and the dispursement of our national guard to an unnecessary and immoral foreign war.  The greatest threat to us is having a leader who principal mantra is "The Buck Stops There, or There, or Anywhere but Here," and who stifles honest debate on these critical issues by questioning the patriotism of those who disagree with him.  Such actions from a President do more harm than any terrorist.  This President has much to answer for.  I am reminded of the words of Jacob Marley in A Christmas Carol when he tells Scrooge about the chains he has observed that Scrooge has forged with his actions, "'Tis a ponderous chain!"
It seems in todays world, some people confuse Nationalism with Patriotism. Thomas Jefferson (our 2nd president, Founding father and main author of our constitution) said dissent is the highest form of patriotism.
Compare that to the current administrations rhetoric; your either with us or against us.
 Ben Franklin said "Those who give up Liberty in the name of security, deserve neither."
 Compare that to the current administrations "The Government must spy on you in order to protect you."
 Franklin D. Roosevelt said, "We have nothing to fear, but fear itself."  
 For the last 3 election cycles, the current administration have used fear and the attack on 9/11
to keep themselves in power.
 In the past, America was fortunate enough to have great leaders step up in times of national crisis, today we have Karl Rove and the administrations spin machine to keep the truth from the american people.
 God help us all!











we are not safe
phone
big
japan
book
house


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=3381

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google