ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Debate fallout

Posted: Monday, April 30, 2007 9:20 AM by Mark Murray
Filed Under:

 

Lynn Sweet of the Chicago Sun-Times breaks down Obama’s performance on Thursday. “‘Last night I was a little nervous,’ Obama said at a rally in Charleston on Friday, where he filled the gym at Burke High School. Constrained by a 60-second limit for replies that worked against Obama's speaking style -- a very long windup to the pitch -- his tendency to generalize meant he did not directly answer some questions. Even when asked something noncontroversial, what he personally did to improve the environment, he said 3,000 campaign volunteers planted trees on Earth Day. With a prod from moderator Brian Williams, the NBC anchor, Obama added he's "been working" to install energy efficient light bulbs at home. He sounded out of touch.

More and more analysts are picking up on the fact that one of the front-runners (John Edwards) does not believe there is such thing as a "Global War on Terror."

The Los Angeles Times writes about Richardson’s response that Byron “Whizzer” White, who dissented in Roe v. Wade, is his model Supreme Court justice. "Richardson was asked Sunday to square that response with his support for abortion rights. He fumbled at first, questioning whether White was on the court at the time of the 1973 decision. He then explained he had been ‘thinking really fast during the debate’ and had chosen White because White was appointed by Richardson's hero, President Kennedy, and ‘was an All-American football player besides being a legal scholar.’”

More: “The misstep, Richardson said, reflected his take-me-as-I-am philosophy. ‘You're getting somebody who's candid, who's honest, who's not going to be a consultant-driven candidate,’ he said. ‘That's pretty obvious, eh?’”

In the wake of Thursday’s debate, the Hartford Courant noted how Dodd was disappointed he didn’t receive more question -- but still remains upbeat.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Good thing they planted 3000 trees, because the liberal New York school board voted to ban metal bats from their baseball games, so they will need a heck of a lot more timber to make wood bats. It's kind of hard for Edwards to know about a global war on terror when he is on that other side of the two america's, watching the world from his gated house out in the middle of god knows where, getting his $400 haircuts and supposedly taking care of his sick wife. If Dodd had Obama's clean glow, Edwards face and hair and looked like Hillary Clinton, I'm sure he would have gotten a lot more questions. But Chris, seriously, you are from a state that threw Libermann under the bus, why should we care about you?
I thought all in all, the democrats had a very strong, united and intellectual debate. I was unable to watch it Thursday night, but took it in this weekend, and I am able to say I am I AM PROUD TO BE A DEMOCRAT. I think there are 4 or 5 potentials here unlike for the republicans. WAY TO GO DEMS!!!!!
Edwards should stick to his guns. He needs a niche to pass the other two, and this could be it. He could present himself as the candidate who isn't giving in to mass hysteria. Yes, there are terrorists who would love to kill Americans. Yes, that fact mandates certain actions, and responses whenever a terrorist act is executed. But terrorism is crime. A war on terror is like a war on rape - when viewed as such it becomes as rhetorically ridiculous as the wars on drugs, illiteracy, poverty, trans-fat, etc. Edwards ought to counter any criticism very directly, forcing others to define what they mean by a war on terror, and asking why congress, when led by the same president as our rhetorically challenged president, never declared war on terrorists. He should stress that point - we are a constitutional republic, and our Constitution requires Congress to declare war. Where's the declaration? Obviously there isn't one, because how would it be worded? Who would be the enemy, other than anything as non-descript as generic "criminals." I think the public is ready for a candidate to make these points and examine the logic behind what, for five and a half years, no one else has had the courage to question.
I wish the other candidates especially Hillary received the same scrutiny for each question that Sen. Obama receives. It's unfair and shows how much some folks in the media want to hand the nomination to Hillary on a silver platter
war on terror, war on drugs, war on crime, war on crime, war on U.S. Constitution. I think we need a new concept that will work.
Hey Jerry , your having another hissy fit. We're all sick of your whining.
Paul, We haven't officially declared war since WWII.
"The Wiz"--A movie
libberman should be thrown under a bus
Susan, I hope Jerry keeps on posting, even though I suspect he is a paid poster (the Republics employ quite a few of them). When people read the ridiculous posts he writes, it reminds them of what kind of individuals they get in government when they vote Republican. The Democratic Party couldn't ask for a better example of a neocon crazy to scare sane people away from the Republics.
"Throw Momma From a Train"--A movie
Planes, Trains, and Automobiles"--Another movie
Jerry - the ban on wooden bats in NY was sponsored by the REPUBLICAN leader of the NY City Council. But that's OK - in 5 years, you will be blaming the Dems for getting us involved in Iraq!
"Planes And Boats and Trains"-Dionne Warwick
In reading some the things on here, I am amazed at what some people really want to do with this country. PAID???? Boy I wish, but, no people, the RNC does not pay me, in fact I should be the GOP Nominee for president because I have a bigger pair then the one's who want to be the GOP main guy. I would be like warren Beatty in that movie where he told the truth(Put the chicken wings and malt beverag down). I would debate snow white and the seven dwarfs anywhere, anytime. Once we are out of Iraq, I'd have to listen to you libs whine and cry about"why can't I get my share without working for it?" Why am I still living in a trailer two years after Katrina? Why is the unemployment rate only 4.7, it should be higher? Why isn't gas $5.00 a gallon? Those are the kind of statements I would expect to hear from liberals if I was running for president? Judging from the liberal media, that is what they are wondering as well.
But jerry, if you're planning to run for the republican nomination, you'd have to debate the American Gigolo and the nine men in waiting. Will you pledge, on this blog, to debate them? Can we say you are in, then? Is it official?
CynicalGeek - I realize that... and legally we haven't been at "war" since World War II. That's why our military expeditions since have been called "conflicts" or "police actions." Somewhere along the line, we lost that discipline and in a development that I'm sure has Orwell laughing from the grave, we started using the term "war" much more liberally. Thus the "war on illiteracy," etc. The problem is that some folks don't seem to realize its all rhetorical nonsense and want to use the exclusively use the Armed Forces to combat crime, plants, fat kids and those who can't read.
"Leavin' on a Jet Plane..."--Peter, Paul & Mary
"Fly Away"--John Denver with Olivia Newton-John


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=174838

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google