ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC Political Researcher



Immigration: Another vote likely

Posted: Thursday, June 07, 2007 2:20 PM by Domenico Montanaro
Filed Under: , , ,

From NBC's Ken Strickland
Even after it failed this morning, Democratic Majority Leader Harry Reid says there will be an identical procedural vote later today on the immigration reform bill. That vote, which requires 60 for passage, would limit debate and amendments and put the bill on the path to a final vote. It failed earlier 33-63, with all the Republicans and about a third of Democrats voting against Reid.

Moments ago in a off-camera briefing, Reid said if the vote failed again he'd pull the bill from the floor indefinitely saying, "the bill's over with. The bill's gone." He never said it was dead, but indicated he clearly had other priorities to put before the Senate in the coming weeks.

The main conflict between Reid and Republican Leader Mitch McConnell comes down to this: McConnell wants members to have more votes on their amendments to change the bill; Reid says they've already had plenty and would be given more opportunities after the procedural vote. 

Democratic leadership is putting the onus on President Bush to move the bill forward. The original bill was written by a small bipartisan group of Senators and two cabinet secretaries.

"This is the president's bill," Reid said. 

The time for the vote hasn't been determined, but staff "guesstimates" range from as early as 4 p.m. to as late as 8 p.m.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

"This is the president's bill," Reid said. "< Another case of Liberals reaching into their own dirty diaper, and trying to smear feces on Republicans
Just think of amnesty this way. If we give amnesity to these people that have invaded our country then that is what every soldier will have fought and died for through out American history. I bought myself 5 ICE tshirts at www.teequick.com and proudly wear them.
Dave, just what the devil do you think the Republicans did to the democrats when their corrupt, power hungry thugs were in the majority?
only deep south tailer trash spoken here
only deep south trailer trash spoken here
Dave, Tn / best trim back the damper a few notches on the ol crack pipe
The Democrats can't blame this on the Republicans. When the Pubs were majority, all the Dems could do is try to filibuster and change the voting procedures.
Gosh Dave, not sure where you are in Tennessee, but where I live in Tennessee all we have heard on the news and radio and read in all the papers for the past 6 years is that georgie is the decider and everything is his way or the highway. Now it is not true? HaHa, good one. And my parents did not raise me to speak southern with your dirty flair, not everyone in our state is a trash mouth or stupid republican.
Kill the darn bill. Security first. Once the borders are secure then deal with the 20 million illegal aliens already here. That to me is the grand compromise. People like me on the right of this issue (Democrat here) were never willing to allow amnesty. Now the shift is, Amnesty is a possibility if and only if the borders are secured. That is a big concession folks. If the left allows that to unfold then they get their Amnesty. That is a grand compromise folks.
Sean Penn said about Bush -- "soiled and bloody underwear"
Charles. The same thing democrats did to republicans for 30 years or more. The Republicans were stupid,, power hungry & lazy. I'm still wafting to see if they've learned their lesson. Sad thing is right now with the democrats being so extreme left I don' have another option.
I was called today on an automated poll. I said #3 which was No amnesty, and no to having any rights for those who are here illegally. Why should we give any rights to non-citizen criminals? By what twisted logic is that ok?
Think the only thing they haven't voted on is what tissue paper they are going to put in the prisons that house the illegals after they are caught. I have to agree with Dave in TN, my guys seemed to have fallen off the tracks a bit, but the democrats are no locomotives themselves. If we elect Hillary and her socialist goverment, maybe the white folk will be jumping onto trucks to go out and pick the lettuce and strawberries like they do in Cuba
How can this government possibly do all the paperwork and legwork needed in order to track the millions of illegals? This government cannot even keep up with the procedure for passports and is now waiving some of the procedures for that. Even if they pass this idiotic immigration bill, it cannot be implemented by the DHS, ICE, INS because of the massive paperwork involved. So then what? Why should the illegals even worry about false identity papers or anything else? Millions will never be tracked or traced.
The amnitcy bill, a document written to reward the totally disrespectfulness of invading lawbreakers, and thereby create a whole new under class, that the democrat party can then exploit by promising free-bees, in exchange for their votes!! Thankfully it appears to have met the agonizing death that it deserved! Now bury it and do some common sense and rational thing like [maybe?]sealing [closeing] the border.
Reid will bring it up as many times as it takes for Dubya and company to deal, cajole, threaten those who are not for his AMNESTY for the illegal aliens. The media claims those of us opposed to legalizing them are in the minority. I think not. The only way we can keep the momentum going though is to keep the pressure on our reps. Google your state, find your senators and congressmen and phone, email, fax, vist local offices, whatever it takes. Be heard NOW or your great grandchildren will look back and wonder why we were too lazy and too cowardly to stand up for America. They will wonder why our nation became a Spanish speaking, Hispanic cultured nation from what it is today. If you don't want it to happen, YOU, each and every one of YOU and everyone you can recruit for the fight must work at it and work NOW. We have a small window to keep this amnesty from happening this year. But it will take ALL of us working very hard together. Takes only a couple minutes to call - Now I will see if my comment is posted because it is encouraging people to be heard in DC where it counts - not just here on this post. Google for information on organizations both pro and con illegal immigration - choose which way you want to support - Legalizing those here, or enforcing the laws we already have and securing our borders. What is the big RUSH to get them legalized - Big business, money, money, money. Sooner that is done, sooner they can cut our wages more, and totally sell us down the Rio Grande. One call, one email, one fax, one visit - yes YOURS does count. This is now at critical stage and America is limping along on life suppport - WE must take back our nation from those who would steal our birthrights. Your reps need to know NOW exactly where you stand on legalizing millions of illegals with the border still wide open and a sorry promise of securing it. Heard that before? Does 1986 ring a bell? Silent no more - we must speak up for our nation.
MESSAGE FROM A MEXICAN I am Mexican. Part of my family lives in USA, part of my family lives in Mexico. One of my uncles fought in the Second World War. Two other were stationed ready to go abroad when the war ended. A cousin of mine went to VietNam. One of my nephews has been to Iraq (not only once but twice). Other nephew is presently in Afghanistan. Both of my nephews are with the Marine Corps. The parents of all these American soldiers came here first without proper documentation, with the exception of one, thus illegally. Even one of these Marines was born in Mexico. Some of these soldiers are from parents that were once illegals. They have even joined the military and died in Iraq and Afghanistan. I have a neighbor who criticizes jews and I am almost sure that I am a target behind my back. He did not joined the army in the WWII and he has a big mouth like many others. After September 11, I wrote to the army to become part of the fight against international terrorism. My petition was declined because I am not that young. Those so called illegals and foreign immigrants from Mexico and other lands have been fighting for this country. Why do you hate us so much, why do you want to harm us? We are not terrorists.? Do you believe in God? Do you have a religion? The New Testament begins with a migration story, of Joseph and Mary traveling to Bethlehem from Nazareth for the birth of Jesus in an agricultural outpost. Later, facing religious persecution, his family would flee to Egypt. Jesus was not only the child of migrants, but, Christians believe, he came from another realm to rescue humanity — an "alien" Why are you claiming the rule of law against people that came here to work? Work that many of you don’t want to perform. “Rule of law” means enforcing laws that are capable of enforcement, otherwise people merely learn disrespect for the law. Obviously, immigration laws that refuse to recognize the inevitable attraction of a lack of unskilled labor on one side of the border and a lack of employment for unskilled labor on the other is not workable no matter how much of the taxpayers' billions get poured down a rathole of “enhanced enforcement Did you know that President carter gave pardon for those that did not join the war in Vietnam? Many went to Canada, and others flew to Mexico. You sure know that President Ford Gave full pardon to Nixon because of the Watergate scandal. And according to what it is known, Nixon violated blatantly the law in many issues and in a great scale. This does not mean that therefore, others must violate the law. But what I am saying is that in the history of this great country there are some examples of amnesty or whatever you want to call it. But you are in uproar claiming this very same rule of law. What does it prove to the valuable and strained military resources to round up all the indocumentados if radical Muslims manage to pull off another 9-11 or worse?. Let me remind you that some of the terrorists and all failed attempts came through Canada never through Mexico. Let’s concentrate in chasing our real enemies. Not us. Let me also point out that our countries in north and South America belong to the only continent in the world, besides Europe, with common origins in religion and cultural heritage. No other continent in the world has such homogeneity. Our countries are not in war against neighboring countries. There are no conflicts because of religious differences. But, one thing is sure, we are not your enemies, we are not terrorists. As a matter of fact, down the road, we are your only potential allies against international terrorism. I do not understand why you cannot see who our common enemy is, nor why you would have us waste time and effort chasing down immigrant workers, instead of chasing terrorists, such as the Fundamental/ radical Islam followers that hate the West, us included. Please do not forget what happened with Hitler and Jews in Europe. Not so long ago, the biggest dictator on earth came to power driven by anger and hate. Everything started little by little in Germany. Jews started to be blamed for everything. Just take a look to some of the movies made by Hitler about Jews. In these films, they are depicted as criminals, thieves, a disgrace to Germany, they are filthy, they bring diseases, they are greedy, they should be removed, they should be deported, etc. Your arguments sound familiar. Similar to the attacks made to Jews that escalated until deport them to concentration camps and exterminate a great deal of innocent people. All based in hate. Hate against other race. Hate against other people. America had to go and rescue Europe from Hitler and his fanatics. Maybe some of your relatives fought abroad. Maybe some or many died in this fight against hate. The hate against Jews made Hitler to climb to his actual position. As a result of his ascent and silence and approval of the German population, the killings and destruction were countless. This is also what the Ku Klux Klan tried to do against African Americans in USA, luckily without success. The white supremacists, Nazis, and the KKK are closely related. Perhaps unknowingly or unwittingly you are helping them. Don't make the mistake that Germans made with Hitler. God bless America as a country and as a continent!!! "We lead the world because, unique among nations, we draw our people -- our strength -- from every country and every corner of the world... Thanks to each wave of new arrivals to this land of opportunity, we're a nation forever young, forever bursting with energy and new ideas, and always on the cutting edge, always leading the world to the next frontier." - Ronald Reagan
Memo - The late, great Ronald Reagan. The one we can thank today for the great amnesty of 1986 and lack of law enforcement that was PROMISED and not done, lack of border security that was PROMISED and not done, and now for God only knows how many more millions of illegal aliens that have walked across the border with the full intent of staying and waiting for the NEXT great amnesty. Yes, the late, great Ronnie - thank you for the mess you left and nobody since has bothered to try to clean it up until now when it has gotten so out of control none of our leaders wants to be responsible for cleaning it up. They would rather sell us down the Rio Grande to illegal aliens who have proven they have no intention of learning our language and assimilating into American culture. They want to be IN our country, EMPLOYED in our country, but they want their allegiance to remain in Mexico. Unfortunately the late great Ronald Reagan was stricken with a horrible disease that made him unaware of the mess he created and he was spared the pain of watching the country he loved go to hell in a handbasket. He opened a Pandora's box that now we all are having to fight to stop. He loved this nation, he believed he was doing the right thing - and perhaps if he and those following would have DONE what he proposed and ENFORCED the law and secured the BORDER as promised - none of this mess we are dealing with today would be happening. But - none did and now here we are with hoards of illegal aliens providing cheap labor to big business and making them richer while our wages are depressed and the money the illegals are making is being sent back home - not circulated here. The politicians pretend that Hispanics contribute to our economy with their businesses - well if the illegals are sent HOME, then those businesses will not be needed here. They should be creating and running those businesses in MEXICO and contributing to their economy, and providing jobs in MEXICO for their own people in their own land. Wake up America - call, email, fax, visit your representatives and let them know we will not be duped again. This is OUR land and we had better work to save it NOW or it will be gone in a flash. They are trying awfully hard in DC. Reid lied and said if cloture failed it was dead - when his bluff didn't work - now bring it up again after Dubya tries to strong arm and buy the votes to pass it. Keep the pressure on the senators. WE are the ones with a vote - therein lies our power. Memo, thank you for that reminder of what we can thank Mr. Reagan for doing for us back in '86. Sure am glad he was FOR America, just imagine if he had been FOR illegal aliens by now. Oops, excuse me, no need to imagine - we are living it now.
The Bill will eventually be passed. We must oppose it.

Here is what is happening:

Reid's idea is to quash the president's credibility sofaras possible, limiting damage to his own tenure. '08 is the issue. If Reid can maintain the perception of overwhelming failure for administration's domestic policy, next prez is democrat.

Why else would Reid move for cloture at so prematurely, and then withdraw the bill claiming he had to "consider energy issues" - ONLY TO TABLE A MOTION TO CENSURE THAT CHARLATAN OF CHARLATANS, Gonzales. It's a comic strip. (Gonzales is a whole other can of . . . .)

Concluding point 1 - Do not misread Reid: he's keeping accolade from a failed prez, and ensuring failure of the bill by the premature cloture call. I do think he's a pansy on this issue, see below, but politics may save him from betraying the country.

Point 2: REID'S LINE
He talks a very bad line - like someone who has had too much corporate money stuffed up his ssa. The doctine he propounds is all over California: "they come here to work hard and just want to feed their families"; ( correction: "they come here to work hard and have YOU feed their families" ).

The real money is here though: corporations have laid out an excellent trough for democrats since the election. The democrats are taking an equally pro-corporate stance even though the average american (see this blog, listen to c-span morning) is basically against it.

Democratic support for the bill favors corporate interests (not the humanity of the illegal living in the shadows, working hard) :
1. Keeps wages down - illegals work for less.
2. Illegals displace americans.
3. Lower costs (from illegal labor) DO NOT EQUATE TO CHEAPER PRICES FOR CONSUMERS: Corporations have not lowered prices due to cheaper labor (illegal labor); viz., we have not seen prices drop based on a 90-95+% reduction in labor costs of producing goods in China in the last 5 years. Corporations slop it up.

Prices have not dropped nor have wages risen.

Accordingly, corporations are free to keep price levels where they were prior to the time they took on illegals who work for less, or prior to the time they destroyed the U.S. manufacturing base and outsourced production abroad, saving manufacturing costs of 90-95 cents on the dollar.  

If we removed 12 million illegals, rephrased, IF WE CREATED 12 MILLION JOBS FOR LEGAL U.S. RESIDENTS:

1. workforce wages would rise - people would have a reason to pursue jobs which pater familias bush says "normal Americans don't want to do" - (Seriously, mr. bush, people DO work at burger king at the prevailing $7-8/hr., why would they not take a janitorial job at 2-3x the pay? I doubt they would not.)  

2. unemployment would drop - not a bad thing for working class americans.

I do not see any reason why we want illegals in this country, MUCH LESS DO I SEE ANY MORAL PURPOSE TO GIVING THEM A REASON TO STAY HERE.

Another amnesty bill is merely a blanket invitation to people to come in and wait for their welfare checks to issue.

Long live the rule of law, the U.S., and let's preserve our thinning moral fibre.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=217464

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google