ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



McCain attacks Romney on abortion

Posted: Wednesday, June 13, 2007 1:50 PM by Domenico Montanaro
Filed Under:

From NBC’s Domenico Montanaro
Everything was all “He’s my friend” between Romney and McCain at the Republican debate. But the behind-the-scenes jabs are keeping up -- and getting more overt. Today, punches were thrown over Romney’s stance on abortion and statements he made at a May 2005 event.

McCain’s campaign accused Romney of flip-flopping on the issue, circulating a release this afternoon with this headline: “Mitt vs. Fact. Say. Do. Anything. Shifting positions on abortion.” The Romney campaign – recognizing its lead in recent polls -- came right back at McCain, describing the campaign’s motives as “borne of desperation” and “sad and unfortunate.”

Both link to different videos of the same event. (McCain’s here). Romney’s here.)

The McCain campaign links to a video of the event they say is proof that Romney has shifted his position on abortion. The Romney camp accuses the McCain team of “selective editing,” links to this video and adds this 2005 op-ed Romney wrote in the Boston Globe about why he vetoed a Massachusetts contraception bill.

Matt David, McCain’s deputy communications director started the back and forth with, "Mitt Romney's biggest challenge in this election will be convincing Republicans he has principled positions on important issues, especially now that it's known that he remained committed to pro-choice policies after his 'epiphany' on abortion in 2004. In stark contrast, John McCain has a consistent 24-year, pro-life record."

That prompted this response from Kevin Madden, a Romney spokesman: “A campaign that is faltering and flailing has again resorted to calculated distortions in last ditch effort to maintain relevance. Governor Romney is firmly pro-life and can rely on his record of having protected the sanctity of life when faced with those issues as governor. Governor Romney consistently maintained, in an effort to protect the sanctity of life, that he would fight attempts to weaken the state’s existing abortion laws. Maintaining existing laws in a state like Massachusetts was an important fight in and of itself.”

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

IF men could have babies abortion would be a SACRAMENT.
The funny thing is both McCain and Romney are correct. Romney did flipflop on abortion and McCain's campaign is desperate.
Why are they all competing to be as single-minded and bull-headed and lacking in nuance as George Bush. different questions at different times sometimes require a different answer. They are killing each other with the flip-flop bludgeon the used against the Democrats, it is stupid --  but fun to watch.
And McCain hasn't ever flip-flopped?  
Desperation is nothing but a tool of defeat in politics. Flip flopping for the sanctity of human life that will benefit even the desperate? Is not a political tool.
Romney vetoed a contraception bill?
Romney is LOSING voters to Fred Thompson. Romney will be the sad one soon and already in the polls : LOOK at 6/5 Rasmussen then look at 6/12 Rasmussen -Romney dropped from 15% to 10% !
It's so stupid that abortion is such an issue for a presidential candidate.  If a state wants to remain in the dark ages about a woman's right to chose then fine, but it should not be a federal issue.  With all the other problems facing this country, these candidates picking on each other over this type of thing is PATHETIC.  Neither one of these people will ever get my vote.    
McCain is acting both petty and petulant.  It's high time for him to withdraw with his tail between his legs.    This is just another episode in the saga:  McCain makes a catty personal attack (a la "varmint guns" and "Guatemalans off his lawn"), and Romney responds succinctly, and with class.  Needless to say, the contrast between the two candidates could not be more stark.
Desiree: They probably wasnt getting your vote anyway. So whats the problem? Its not a stupid issue. If it was people would not be in an uproar over it. There are things you probably think are important and others think are stupid.
Another episode of the "gasbag mccain showboat show"
Over 50 MILLION dead "choices" and counting.  Roe V Wade
Oink!
Manchurian McCain exit stage Right already. Shut Up and Go Home!!
Before reading this article, I was waivering between Romney and McCain. However, after reading it, I am more likely to vote for Romney and less likely to vote for McCain. I followed the link above and read Romney's 2005 Op-Ed. It's impressive. One thing is certain, if Romney is elected, he won't need a speech writer.
How many adoptions under your belt, Rick? You speak with such authority, I'm sure you're not just a pontificating gas bag.
hey if Mitt loses and decides to run for governor of Michigan  he will change his positions yet again.  I've seen his act up close here in Mass and he said all the right liberal Republican things to get elected in Mass and then promptly dropped them to get ahead in the Republican primaries.  Question:  after he is elected president, who will he be?  Can you conservative Republicans be sure of where he stands?
Rick in Germany. Why don't you adopt a few foster kids and help even things out- it will make your conscience feel better. No wait, go over to Catholic Charities and bring into your home the 2 most unadoptable kids you can find there and be daddy for them the rest of their troubled lives. Or maybe you can do what some American families do and wait til their 18, and send them off to their deaths in Iraq.
The thing about politicians is that while there is typically some honesty in their reasoning, there's always intellectual dishonesty when they try to resolve their reasoning with the party's talking points. In Romney's op-ed piece, he argues that it's ok for victims of incest to get abortions - a point that most would agree with. However, then he goes and tries to tow the party line by saying that there should be parental consent before a girl gets an abortion. That's where things get problematic. I believe that this is a very complex and nuanced issue that requires honest debate -- and cannot be solved by one-liner bumper sticker slogans.
My conscience is fine.  I didn't choose to kill any unborn babies. (50 million and counting)
I also didn't make poor decisions resulting in an unwanted pregnancy.  I have dealt with my problems without killing them. I don’t think it is too much to ask anyone else to do.  Don’t blame the Catholic Church or anyone else for the poor choices of others.

Poor choices Rick? Thats your opinion.
If you abort it or give it to someone else to raise then I would say it is a pretty piss poor choice.  
They both suck.
How about when a young woman is raped by her stepfather and becomes pregnant Rick. What would YOU suggest all knowing, all powerfull wizard of OZ. You don't have to carry a child around for 9 mos and possible risk your life giving birth and/or possibly have to raise your rapests child sooo.... keep giving your opinion if you wish but it means nothing.
This issue is a choice by a woman to be in charge of her own body & her child. I'm a Mother & Parent of 8 children. I defend a Women right to abort or have a Child as her own perogative. Men should have no power determining what that choice should be. Republicans have enough to worry about. Their President & his suicidal mismanagement of everything he comes in contact with. None of the aforemention are going to be elected to the Presidency so all their babbling is moot. John McCain is a tired bitter clone of of President Bush that says it all & Rommney is not a Republican nobody knows what he is except being a Mormon. This country cannot take another minute of Republican autocracy, bye bye.
bb. I don't need nor desire your permission to say or do anything.  
Why is John McCain attacking Mitt Romney?
One may think why not attack Rudy he is the front runner. But McCain is no dummy this is not a battle for 3rd and 4th place. He has been in a presidential election and knows how they work. The reason that John McCain is going after Romney is because that is what makes since.  Unlike Rudy who seems to see this as a national election and is following national polls McCain has be there before and knows how to stay in the race. McCain knows that who ever wins the fist primary states will probably win the election and that makes Romney the front runner. Do not be suppressed when you see Romney came from behind to win. McCains plan is simple lower Romney’s support (what every that takes) in key primary states.  McCain feels that he has a good chance in these first states. McCain knows that a win in the first primary states means national polls will follow.
I like McCain, he's good and honest man but with his support for Iraq war and support for Bush , it doesn't really matter what his stance is on anything else.
As for Romney, he seems like a smart guy and not stubborn. I am a democrat but I might vote for Romney if he makes it to the final.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=224891

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google