ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Oh-eight (R): Campaign lobbyists

Posted: Monday, June 25, 2007 9:16 AM by Mark Murray
Filed Under:

GIULIANI: In an interview with WNBC-TV, ex-EPA dir. Christie Whitman says Giuliani "blocked her efforts to force World Trade Center workers to wear respirators." She also said city officials didn't want EPA workers wearing haz-mat suits because they "didn't want this image of a city falling apart." Whitman will be testifying on the Hill today about the ground zero air quality issue. Whitman also criticized Giuliani's handling of a suspected anthrax attack at NBC's Rockefeller Center headquarters weeks after 9/11. "There was concern by the city that EPA workers not be seen in the haz-mat suits," she said. "They didn't want this image of a city falling apart. I said, 'Well, that's not acceptable.'" Giuliani's former Deputy Mayor Joe Lhota rejected Whitman's claims. "As the incident commander, F.D.N.Y.’s response was exemplary. They coordinated, conducted and affected a multi-agency response in a timely, safe and efficient fashion," Lhota said.

As some predicted, the New York City tabs are not going to be able to get enough of Bloomberg v. Giuliani. The New York Post decided to survey senior city workers who worked with both mayors to get their take on which "Hizzoner" is ready to be POTUS. "Bloomberg's laid-back leadership style received glowing reviews, but most said they'd vote for him only if there were no other choice but Giuliani."

Per Newsday, Giuliani will stand by his longtime friend Alan Placa, a Catholic priest accused of molesting students, "despite a new call by an advocacy group for priest-abuse victims to fire the suspended priest from his consulting firm, a Giuliani aide said Friday. The GOP presidential front-runner was urged to ax Placa by David Clohessy, national director of the Survivors Network of Those Abused by Priests, after Salon Web-magazine ran a story Friday about the 5-year-old allegations of molesting students against Placa and his job at Giuliani Partners. But Giuliani will not fire Placa, who is also an attorney, from his consulting job, said Giuliani Partners spokeswoman Sunny Mindel. "The mayor believes Alan Placa has been unjustly accused," she said.

Speaking of the Catholic Church, the New York Times looks at the troubles Giuliani might face from politically active Catholic bishops who aren't fond of Catholic politicians who say they are personally opposed to abortion but don't favor making the procedure illegal. Also buried in the piece is the fact that Giuliani doesn't take communion, possibly because he didn't get his second marriage annulled.

MCCAIN: Veteran political reporter Tom Edsall reports on Huffington Post that McCain has more registered lobbyists on staff than any other presidential campaign. The two lobbyists Edsall singles out are chief finance staffer Tom Loeffler and ex-Sen.-turned-lobbyist Slade Gorton. All told, "there are 11 current or former lobbyists working" for McCain. Romney is second in total number of lobbyists on staff, followed by Giuliani. On the Democratic side, of the top three candidates, Obama is the only one who can claim he has no lobbyists on staff. Edwards has a couple of current or former lobbyists on staff, while Clinton has the most of the Democrats (falling short of McCain's 11 though).

ROMNEY:

Today is Part Two of the Boston Globe’s series on Romney, “The Making of Mitt Romney: The Missionary.” Today’s piece chronicles Romney’s time as a Mormon missionary in France. And here’s Part One from Sunday, which detailed his relationship with his father.

The Globe also looked at the Vietnam deferrals the Mormon church obtained for Romney and other missionaries. "Before and after his missionary deferment, Romney also received nearly three years of deferments for his academic studies. When his deferments ended and he became eligible for military service in 1970, he drew a high number in the annual lottery that determined which young men were drafted. His high number ensured he was not drafted into the military. The deferments for Mormon missionaries became increasingly controversial in the late 1960s, especially in Utah, leading the Mormon Church and the government to limit the number of church missionaries who could put off their military service. That agreement called for each church ward, or church district, to designate one male every six months to be exempted from potential duty for the duration of his missionary work."

The Washington Post’s Dan Balz examines the fact that Romney is in a stronger position in the early states than he is nationally. "Romney's rise is an instructive story of seizing opportunities, maximizing small advantages, attention to detail and a few lucky breaks. The challenge his advisers faced at the beginning of the year was to prove that he belonged in the same conversation with McCain and Giuliani. Now he has done that, long before demonstrating any significant national support."

The Boston Herald interviews folks who worked with Romney's now-suspended rent-a-cop Jay Garrity during his days on Beacon Hill. “‘He thinks he’s a cop,’ sniffed one longtime insider. ‘That was always the persona.’ A Democrat said: ‘He wasn’t well-liked by those across the aisle. He was a little pompous. You could see that the pretense of power was going to his head.’ A Republican lawmaker added: ‘He looks and acts like Secret Service.’” By the way, Garrity apparently had a suspended license up until this weekend.  and

Romney is now speaking out on the attacks on his religion. During a weekend fundraising trip to Utah, Romney said criticism of his Mormon religion by rival campaigns is happening too frequently. “‘Clearly, any derogatory comments about anyone's faith -- those comments are troubling. The fact they keep on coming up is even more troubling’ Romney said on Saturday.”

F. THOMPSON: Despite some news to the contrary, Thompson will not be announcing his candidacy on Tuesday. If he makes any news tomorrow, it will be about where his campaign will be headquartered.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

As I said last week (and as far as I know I'm the first to declare this) Guiliani is done. Actually I think his doneness goes back to the debate when he jumped on Ron Paul regarding bin Laden's motivations. He won applause with the response, but in the days following, people started to realize he really doesn't know much about al Qaeda... and he's the national security candidate? This thing with Whitman is another blow. It cuts into Guiliani's single episode of performance on which he is basing his campaign. Yikes. Bad to be him today. But it was over before this, I believe.
Paul Miller, Woodbridge, VA / I believe corporate america has spent too much money on rudy for him to disappear, he may lag back for awhile but I would be shocked if he were not repub nominee, I think he has already been nominated, the powers that be just haven't let they're subjects know yet, a little thing like the actual voting process ain't going to change the outcome.
Lobbyists on staff of most candidates in both parties. Appears the profiteers will get to stay at the public feed trough.
MK - you're guess may be as good or better than mine, but I'm guessing the Republican race is Thompson v Romney.
Tear yourselves apart republicans...as usuall
I'm embarrassed to admit that I used to think of Mayor Giulani during 9/11 as a paragon of competency when it came to handling a catastrophe and that as New Orleans was flooding from the levee breaches Nagin could have taken a leaf from Giulani. Now that I read how Giulani blocked Christie Whitman's effort to have all WTC workers wear respirators and that NY city officials didn't want them wearing HAZ-MAT suits because they didn't want it to look like the city was falling apart, I really don't think Giulani was much more competent than Nagin.
Rudy probably will still win the Repub nomination...in a nation where most people do not care when the Attorney General writes in memos that its ok to torture children in front of their parents, who is going to care if Rudy supports a child molestor?
McCain has imploded, Rudy has begun to break apart and folks in this country are just not ready for a Mormon president. It will be Thompson against Senator Clinton- Hillary winning with the money and connections- add the womens votes and we'll have our first female president.
Ben, need to cut back on the Bourbon in the grape kool aid OK?  Seems like every election we have people who come out with stories about whatever someone else did or didn't do, this election is no better then the others. Every disaster is going to have fingers pointed at them, no matter what they did well or didn't do well.  Nagin though had ample warning to get the folks out of New Orleans but he didn't even try to do it, Rudy pretty much had 9-11 pretty much laid in his lap.  Big, Big difference between Rudy and Ray.
Susan I think you're right. The right wing and neo-cons will try as they done so successfully in our state in 2000, and Ohio in 2004 to rig elections thru voter intimitations, removing legitimate minorities who lean Democrats, allowing Republican secretary of states to be campaign managers, and lets not forget the diabold voting machines without paper trail.  
Enough about the same candidates with skeletons in the closet. How about info on the other candidates, maybe even the ones without skeletons for a change.
jerry,
when are you going to learn how to read?  topic was Giuliani, and you slag Nagin?????? do you have ADD?
Paul Miller, if the repubs go to Thompson, then they are probably trying to relive the Reagan years with another "actor".  However, as many people have stated, last Senator to be a Pres was JFK...I think that is one reason Romney has appeal as a former governor.  I hope out of the two major parties and several possible independent campaigns, there will be at least one candidate who can get the country working together again.
When do you think we will learn some really important stuff?
Maybe next week the toilet paper of choice will be dicussed. I do hope they all use some.
Mark do not be so hard on jerry.

He missed the school bus AGAIN!
He is so grounded.
I guess Ray nagin and I did miss the school bus.  Difference is, I didn't leave people to die like Ray did.  I was responding to Olivia's comment, the difference is a mile long and river deep between what Rudy did and what Ray did.  nagin had time to save people, Rudy did not.
Hasn't hit the MSM yet but Rudy's campaign manager in SC was arrested for possession of cocaine with intent to distribute. Another way of taking his campaign to new heights?
if you are depending on rudy to save anyone that doesn't have a fat stock portfolio you in for a major disappointment, rudy has no need for anyone who isn't wealthy, more people would have died in new orleans if he would have been running that show
Jerry/corpus christi (2:24) - Actually, to some degree Mr. Giuliani had plenty of time. He had been warned over and over about using the WTC as a central point and about the communications problems but did nothing. He couldn't have prevented the actual crash, but his decisions were absolutely part of the problem in response and recovery.
Acid Boy, AZ / a man would have to be on something to keep a straight face and promote rudy
Here we go again, Independent my friend.  Even though we both know it's pointless, neither of us can resist responding to jerry.  Your 3:17 post stated what was crying out to be said.  Was Rudy mayor of NYC in 1993 when the WTC was attacked the first time?  I am ingnorant in this regard because I try not to pay attention to NYC for any reason.  As for jerry's comment about the huge difference between Mayor Guiliani and Mayor Nagin, the difference that's important to jerry, et al is that Rudy is a republican and Nagin is a democrat.  This fits withing his belief system and reinforces his comfort zone.
"Kiss Me on the Bus"--The Replacements
And one reason why Liberals and democrats cannot be trusted on homeland security, Scott.  Juan, unless you have some proof that the Florida vote was rigged in 2000, that will always be the liberals cry.  I just think it was because people in Florida were too stupid to know how to punch a card.  Ohio, there was no proof that the GOP did anything improper, in fact they stayed past the time allotted for voting, trying to get everybody to vote.  Can't help it if people were just too stupid to wait till the last minute.  texas has early voting, does Ohio?
I thought everyone knew by now it was neither the 'hanging chads' nor the Diebold voting machines that won it for Dip-Stick-Boy, but the successful use of the fear card (and a heapin' helpin' dose of slime by the Swift Boat Liars for BullS**t).  Then again, with what I see in the news lately, God only knows what kind of crap was being pulled 'behind the sceenes' by the crooked GOP.  Hey Jerry- was it the Demorcrats and Liberals that wanted to sell one of the shipping ports to Arabs a while back?  And how about the job the Conservatives and Republicans are doing at our southern border?  Sure makes ME want to trust homeland security!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=234514

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google