ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Not as smooth as you might think...

Posted: Tuesday, July 10, 2007 4:15 PM by Mark Murray
Filed Under:

From NBC's Carrie Dann

A picture-perfect family, a resume of Olympic proportions, and an impressively thick mane of hair have prompted no small number of observers to call Mitt Romney a "slick" or "polished" candidate. It may be true that his opinions on big-ticket items -- like terror and taxes -- usually appear well-cultivated and TV-ready. But bumps along the campaign trail are showing more and more that Romney might not be as smooth as his coiffe might have you believe.

The former Massachusetts governor has already attracted criticism for his less-than-perfect responses to his past hunting experiences (those varmints!) and the fuss over the unconventional travel arrangement for his old family dog ("He likes fresh air!"). And during his latest swing through Iowa last week, Romney stutter-stepped through his share of minor clumsy moments. The casualties of such instances are often Romney's own strengths. For example, he opened a meeting with supporters with an anecdote about his wife that was intended to highlight her easygoing companionship. But its brief hint of lewdness -- his story ends with a towel-clad Ann Romney mistaking a hotel maintenance man for husband -- hardly matched the squeaky-clean image of their marriage he's tried so conspicuously to build.

Romney's proneness to gaffes applies to the big-ticket topics, too. When he addressed global competition -- which should be one of the former tycoon's most robust issues -- he generalized that "Asian people are hard-working and numerous." And later, questioned about his campaign's Spanish language Web site, Romney appeared almost comically over-eager. "Oh, I do!... And I hope I get it in Chinese and in as many languages as we have people who vote. Cause I gotta tell ya, I want Spanish-speaking votes!"

But no setting more dramatically illustrated the roughness around Romney's edges last week than the one that pitted him against the man who made "Slick" his own. Romney appeared in the same Fourth of July parade in Clear Lake, IA, that featured Bill and Hillary Clinton. While the widely grinning Bill worked the parade crowd at a glacial pace, pausing for hugs and friendly chatter with adoring fans, Romney wasn't as smooth. He hustled down the line, breathlessly repeating general shouts of "Happy Fourth of July!" If Bill played the role of prom king, Mitt looked more the part of hassled student council president.

Of course, Romney's occasional gaffes and lack of polish could be seen as a breath of fresh air. They can be humorous and even humanizing for a candidate who might otherwise come across as overly rehearsed. But in this YouTube era, critics -- as we've already seen this campaign season -- will be eager to highlight a verbal blunder that could appear more sinister than merely artless.  Slick or not, Romney and all of his competitors would be wise to watch their step.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

"Romney's occasional gaffes and lack of polish could be seen as a breath of fresh air..."

I've had enough of this gaffe-air and no-polish sheen from W., and let's be honest, it smells purty awful and clearly won't shine.  

Maybe we can spin Hillary's grating voice as melodic and Obama's quiet demeanor as wonderfully intense?  

I'm wondering how gaffes can be fresh-air... do mistakes make one special? Did Mr. Rogers write this post?
Right on, Gary. No one wants another walking punch-line for a president (Never mind Mitt's religion. It should be a non-issue). Eight years of W will do that.
http://www.political-buzz.com/
romney- talk about Gomer Pyle...We the people are barely holding with the idiot/goober we got now.
You know, I just don't want another not-very-bright president.  I have had my fill of Bush and his cronies and their inability to lead our nation except into war.  
I can't wait until the general public gets a clear view of Mitt Romney.  He is head and hairdo's above everyone else in class and smarts...truly Presidential.

Bill Clinton may still be political smooth number one but one who is as calculated as he has been can only come to the rescue of his political business partner.  Let's please not talk about "overly rehearsed".  Too bad the left and their fake-o-meter doesn't work with Dems or even worse turn if off as journalists.

I'll put Romney against any of the candidates in terms of knowledge and policy.  As for smooth.  He's a genuinely smooth person.  You would have to be with the resume and the clout that he has. He doesn't back down from anyone who tries to challenge him.  This is refreshing. Put the others to task like you have with  him and you'd think that we were in a Merengue dance contest.  It's easy going after someone with high integrity and relatively "small" things to beat him up with considering that's all you have.

If Billary wins this election it's because of the glaring double standard of accusing someone of being a flip flopper you don't like compared with someone who is the biggest flip flopping walking contradition known as Hillary Clinton that you will go to the depths of H... to protect.

By the way wasn't trying to bring out the Southern accent in a black church a gaffe?  What about flip flopping on the War?  So many stones in many glass houses.    
what the hell happened with his towel clad wife and the maintenance man?
yeah, bb, inquiring minds want to know!  Is it on You-Tube?
The republican candidates must be the weakest bunch of candidates running the most amateur-like campaigns ever.
What is your problem...I think it's pretty sad if one has to stoop so low as to be overly concerned about a 'hunting' misstatement blown out of proportion and a silly fresh air for the dog story. Come on what matters in the presidential campaign is substance.  Romney stands for strong economy (looking towards the future) strong military and strong families (and all the good values that go with it). What a breath of fresh air! His background, accomplishments and experience in the business world more than qualifies him to be the next President of the United States of America!!!!!! Go Mitt!!!
So you are knocking the guy for 1) looking to good 2) diarrhea dog 20+ years ago 3) flat joke 4) wanting Spanish and Chinese speaking CITIZENS votes.  Wow, that alert the media.  Major scandles here!
Who cares? Republicans are going down this election regardless of how they look, speak, worship, how well they lie.. etc. etc. They might be trying hard to cover their fannies now but Bush's lipstick is a permanent tattoo. Pucker up.
Please...Mitt Romney is one of the most artificial presidential candidates we've had in years.

Either the voters in Mass. got lied to or the GOP primary voters are being lied to....we never know who the  real Mitt Romney is.

Can anyone name a position he's switched to lately that hasn't  been in directly lockstep with the Republican primary electorate??
Maurine-- I hope you apply such a breezy standard and sunny outlook to say, the endless Edwards haircut story.  Something tells me you would not.
So here is the towel story (I was at a campaign function when he repeated it):
Mitt, his wife Ann, and his finance director Spencer Zwick were in a hotel in whoknowswhere Iowa/New Hampshire.  Spencer knocks on Mitt's door to chat, and Mitt says, "let's talk in the hall, Ann is in the shower".  Ann had just stepped out of the shower, and so she put on a towel and opened the door and said "you can come in here if you want" - except it was a hotel maintenance man (not Mitt) standing outside her door, with a very big smile on his face.  Mitt and Spencer had already headed to the lobby.  
Frankly, "flipfloppers" often make great Presidents. Thomas Jefferson flip-flopped and went through with the Louisiana Purchase.  Abraham Lincoln flip-flopped on emancipating slaves. I'd appreciate a few flip flops from Bush. Bush could learn a thing or two from Romney. People who push on in the wrong direction are the ones that scare me.
Regardless of who becomes the Democratic Party's candidate and who becomes the Republican Party's candidate, I certainly hope that this coming election does not turn out to be like the previous one:  a choice between the lesser of two evils.  2004's election was not one of, "Who's the best man for the job?"  Rather, it was more like, "Who will screw things up less?"  I remain an undeclared voter mainly for that reason.  No matter the party, if the candidate follows proper words with proper action and takes in consideration the needs of his constituents (us) at the same time, he/she has my vote.  I just wonder where did the honor and the respect and the responsibility that comes with the office of the President hide, and can any of these candidates bring these things back.
Will the real journalist please ask Mr. Romney what he pays for his haircut? Get it on the record and then check it out. More or less than 400?????
Romney is probably the smartest and most knowledgable of the republicans. Please lets not let the media give him a pass on his experience though. I mean come on, you are saying he has as thick a resume as anyone because he was a one term governor of MA? The guy has ZERO foreign policy experience. I don't understand how america all the sudden decided they wanted the guy who can churn the most profits out of a corporation as their president and how the media has decided that it makes a candidate "qualified"; such a disgustingly subjective term. Rudy is a mayor of a freakin city and you guys are giving him a pass on the experience card as well.
I have to disagree with Maurine.

Romney has publicaly said he would try to talk his family out of joining the military and he hid behind God to bicycle through France rather than serve himself.  His substance is 100% coward.  He is an insult to the many LDS who have served with honor.
Unfortunately some people (including some in this thread) are so jaded to politicians that they can't recognize a good one when he comes around. What kind of criticism is "too smooth" anyway? The DNC calls Romney "smooth talking Mitt." Casting him as smooth is an underhanded way to spin his eloquence, integrity, and ability to work across the isle.

Wake up people. Mitt Romney can make real changes in Washington.
Blake, he stated in the second debate that in his first campaign in '94, he supported abolishing the Dept. of Education, a red-meat issue popular with the right-wing base.  Now, he doesn't believe that's the answer, that instead we should reform the existing framework.  So, yes, he hasn't always moved in the direction of the GOP primary electorate.
As for Ms. Dann's blurb, if the best ammo to be found on Mitt consists of silly campaign trail gaffes (which merely prove that he is a human being), he's in good shape.  Everyone else seems to have problems with divorce, adultery, bribery, corruption, hypocrisy, or plain old inexperience.
I live in Massachusettes and this guy is the real deal. Depth. Leadership. Lucid Inteligence. Experience. Courage like we have never seen Beacon Hill in 40 years.  The right leader for the challenges ahead...Iran, Education, Immigration, Economy, Security, Job Growth.  And I love how the focus is on how calm Bill Clinton is.  Wait, isn't his WIFE running? Ha Ha! Do we want a president still hiding behind her husbands reputation? I cant wait to watch Romney take Hillary to the wood shed in the debates.  And, I'm GLAD the guy can relax and tell a fun story or two.  Lighten up folks! We aren't voting in Jack Bower, the personal life stories give him character and personality. So JFK/Reagan. But when you get down to the serious business of making America a front runner in the world, Romney is the obvious choice for so many reasons. He is rock solid on issues. He has won my vote. GO ROMNEY  
Blake does the Olympics sound familiar?? maybe you should go look into it...
Actually, I would like to address the Dearth of Democratic Presidential Champions - If Shrillary, Obama & Edwards are the Best the Dem's can do... They are in deep excrement. Shrillary with all her Backflips, Luggage, Taints of corruption, Lack of Real experience AND no charisma. Obama - NO experience, Some backflips, lack of Policy. Lastly Johnny Edwards, well what can I say... a Bumbersticker. Cardboard cut-out with NO depth, character or morals.
Whereas the GOP has some Great Candidates - Especially Mitt Romney.
Another Daddy's boy who name was George.  Daddy was head of American Motors, also a Millionaire, Michigan (not Massachusetts) Governor, served in the entire Nixon administration in some capacity.  Mitty never got  his little hands dirty, work, let alone hunt.  He earned his money, the rich way: He had it handed to him!  Why are all of our presidents filthy rich anyway?  Hmm... maybe it is a pre-requisite.
Mitt's just another northeastern flip flopper...we already know what the right thinks of candidates like that...and now with senator mcbush sinking along with shrubs poll numbers what is the right to turn? There is still rudy but he's a cheating liberal gussied up in 9/11...except the parts of it where he lined the pockets of his cronies of course...lmao
Please Please Please with sugar on top make Mitt the repugnant nominee....please, then the Dems could even run Mitt's dog against him and win.  
Nitwit Mitt...sounds good to me.
hmmmm.  How many towel clad women were in Bill Clinton's hotel rooms I wonder?
Chuck and Mark, why don't you enlighten all of us about some of the rituals and requirements to be a good Mormon?  I hear religion should be a non-issue but I think it matters a lot.  George Bush got us into this war because he consulted his "higher father".  Giuliani is a Catholic and has had more marriages the a de Medici pope.  If character is an issue, and religion is the foundation many candidates base their character upon, I would think it is your duty to report on it.
jerry/cc  I think you are confused AGAIN!
It was Hillary Clinton who had towel clad women in HER room.
A come to soap and water meeting with the members of HILLARY-LAND.
Did you miss it, was in the papers for godsake.
I'm not too impressed with this blog entry, Mark. Yeah he seems to be having a few awkward moments. So are all of them, from either party. Now's the time to be having them, before most people are paying attention.

And for the couple folks up above who equatted Romney's intelligence with Bush's... come on. Not knowing how to work a crowd as well as Bill Clinton is hardly a comment on his intelligence. I wonder how well Albert Einstein could work a crowd?

Romney has his vulnerabilities. Mostly its the perception that his views are based on political expediency. And I do think the dog story is going to stick, only because its interesting in a weird sort of way. But the other stuff? No legs.
Romney & Sons  =  Cowards. Those 5 sons barely work ! (And 3 of them are pushing 40 !) They blog all day, like girly girls. (Go to their myspace pages and look at their 'work' histories !!)
So far on this Blog, I have heard people tell us that Mitt Romney is weak because he did not serve in the military. I have heard that Mitt is a flip-flopper on different issues. I have heard just about everything I can tollerate. Incidentally, how come there has never been a poll out about how people are becoming discusted with the entire political crap that they won't vote for anyone regardless of their credentials or stand on positions. It would seem to me that there are a great many people like those in this Blog (and they know who they are) contribute to that irony daily.

The truth is that no matter how good a person is, it is common for the voting public to twist things to fit their selfish needs. Politics is nothing more than placing your bet on a person who you think will represent you in all matters of state. Are we all looking to place our families, our economic outlook, job security, peace and happiness in one person as if he were the King of the United States?

The practice of politics is nothing more tham the practice of compromise. Can anyone here garantee that your candidate, whoever they are, will not compromise something you hold in high esteem for something that is inconsequential to you. Compromise is how the United States Constitution was formed. Even Benjamin Franklin told the members of the Constitutional Congress that "while he did not agree with everything, he was not so sure that it is the best that could be done." It is my experience that no matter who one votes for, the President will always offend someone. What if the President had the chance to end the war in Iraq and bring all of the troops home at the expenes of delaying immigration for the next several years! We all have to remember that we still have a Democrat controlle house and senate. Everything will be an uphill battle for a Republican president. If we elect a Democrat President, anything and everything the Democrats do that is bad business will be on their heads come another election cycle like what happened to the Republicans last election cycle.

In relation to the comment on a candidate going to France to serve instead of going into the military, should be perfectly acceptable. Having served in the military myself, the United States military would be nothing without the soldiers of our economy. We are all working to preserve freedom. Business can be just as trecherous as being hemmed in a fox-whole by enemy fire. There are multiple fronts on the war for freedom, some military, some economic, some social, some educational, some political, and some emotional. The presidency of the United States is required to fight wars on all of these fronts.

It doesn't matter if you are a Republican, Democrat, Independent, or some other political religion; it is required for all of us to do some research, make a decision under the prayer of faith to God, then follow your heart. Presenting multiple perceptions about a candidates' position on issues is foolishness. It would appear to me that people are expecting the President to be someone who
Oh, puhleeze - I have said that Bush's wife looks like one of the Stepford wives and now we have Romney, with is squeaky-clean image and his Ken (of Barbie and Ken) looks.

Let's get to the nitty-gritty of the man and see where he stands on immigration, the war, the budget, the economy, the trade deficit and our unconscionable national debt.

After living in Utah for almost 20 years, I would not vote for him as president of our country.  I see more trouble ahead if he were to be elected.
What does your living in Utah have to do with what kind of a president Mitt Romney could be? I am undecided as to which way I will vote. I only know so far that I will be voting next November. There is too much going wrong in our country not to take advantage of the freedom to elect our next president, whether you beleive in the electoral college system or not. I know only that no one, in the running so far, has much experience. I can't stand Hitlery Clinton, so she has already been eliminated from my potential choice. I see things that would completely suck if any one of the candidates was elected, but I also see things that could be much better with a lot of them. I think if being a mormon, a woman or black are qualifiers for becoming president, though, we should all just vote for Gladys Knight, and move on.
Mitt Romney wins this thing in 2008 hands down.  His creds exceed all the 3 Stooges on the Democrat side hands down.  And if Al Gore gets into the race, all that money the Dims have collected will be spent running against each other.



Get used to being disappointed again Dims!!  You're used to being unhappy though so it won't be that big of a let down.

Romney 2008!
Mitt Romney is an amazing individual, with a great family, and not to mention, leadership qualities that this country needs.  The more I am exposed to Mitt the more I realize that he should be the next president, hands down.
Hey, Dr. Trocar, Do some research.  Mitt's dad was a self-made man.  Born in poverty, never able to get a college degree, and becomes CEO of AMC and 3 term governor of Michigan by sheer brilliance and tenacity.  Mitt did go to nice schools (including Harvard Law and Business Schools) but he was NOT given anything on a silver platter.  His dad didn't have much to leave the children, and what Mitt did get, he gave to BYU to start a program in his dad's honor.
Surprise, the next president is slightly human! I would rather have the candidate the stutters once a month than the one who has smoothness down to an art yet also has a heritage of moral bankruptcy and is wrong on all the issues.
I am appalled to hear people say that Mitt Romney served his LDS mission to hide from becoming a soldier.  As a missionary myself it was the most difficult 2 years of my life.  I mastered a new language, worked by butt off 16 hour days, 7 days a week and was ridiculed and spit upon by many, just about everyday.  I've never served in the military, but certainly it's not because I'm afraid to do so.  I honestly can't see how much worse it can be than what I went through.  Although it was hard, it was also the most rewarding thing that I've done as I was able to learn so many skills.  I learned to work hard, communicate effectively, and to be patient - things that my friends who decided not to serve missions could never learn elsewhere.  

Lets talk about Hillary Clinton's experience.  What has she done other than write a book, and vote in the Senate for the last 10 years?  She's a celebrity from Bill's legacy, and that's what the Democrats are banking on.  Before you attack Romney about his inexperience, look at your own tenderfoots.

I have no doubt that Mitt Romney is the best candidate running for President.  For all of the so called "quirks" of the Mormon church, I believe that it produces the best men and women in this country, regardless of it's beliefs.

There are those of us who know family members of Mitt.  He is a GREAT MAN!  He does not need this job.  He unlike Hillary earn his money.  He did run a great Olympics and as has been said, was a great gov. of Mass.  He balanced the budget in a state where socialism and union corruption is at its worst. Most of those here who attack him, and check my words, do so with a second grade mentality of name-calling only.  Heck, I will be next for supporting him.  Instead of saying "America needs to be strong"  as many other candidates do, he tells us how he will do it.  Fact is that the issue of the Radical Jihadist's IS the most crucial problem facing Amercia today and Mitt has a plan, increase military spending and don't allow Iran to win in Iraq by pulling out.  The Iraq War was won!  The Civil War between Sunni's and Shities continues.  It is much harder to be a policeman than to defeat someone with an army.  There are 140,000 Turkish troops on the northern border with Iraq right now.  If we leave we create a power vacuum which will draw in Iran, Turkey, Saudi Arabia and eventually Isreal and then the United States.  Mitt has told us so, and that is substantive.  On the economy, he has a plan to balance the budget by vetoing spending over 1% of GDP.  He wants to redo the most unfair part of government, "the current tax code".  It is not fair that you have to read something much larger than the Bible and even more difficult to understand in order to just pay you taxes.  He wants to do away with the Death-Tax.  Inheritance Tax, the most unfair tax of all.  You are dead and can't even complain about it.  It starts of 55% of your estate value and goes up from there for those who have worked hard and have built up a business or a farm.  He will uphold the law.  Look at his stance on Immigration.  Heck, unless you are full blood American Indian you are an immigrant to this country.   He believes in immigration but he believes it should be done legally in order to protect Amercians.  Mitt does not need this job, he is offering himself as a candidate to serve us. By the way, Way to go Ms. Wheatley that was an outstanding comment.
MITT ROMNEY ....YOUR WORST NIGHTMARE.
He is a bush alike, only difference, he uses his veto pen all the time.  He is much more than a "quirkey Mormon". He is an airhead with hair! He flipflops so much he may become a catholic if he thinks that will be a road to his goals.
Senator Clinton can wipe the floor with that plastic man.  HE does and has suppoted the WAR.
She has fought the fight againt the monsters of the right wing killer party, has experienced
their venom.
If she were a Repuklican and a candidate for president, would I vote for her?  HELL NO!
A woman as president good stuff.. a woman republican as president, NO FREAKING WAY!

Well now if something is just to good to be true.....

Seems Mitt is a minor gem .....cubic zirconia?


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=264553

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google