ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC Political Researcher



Rove reactions

Posted: Monday, August 13, 2007 2:34 PM by Domenico Montanaro
Filed Under: , ,

From NBC’s Domenico Montanaro, Kelly O’Donnell, Mike Viqueira, Libby Leist, Joel Seidman, Ken Strickland, Carrie Dann and Jenny Anzelmo
In response to Karl Rove announcing he will leave the White House at the end of this month, presidential candidates and inside-the-beltway officials have been reacting on both sides of the aisle. Here’s some of what was said from Edwards, Obama and Huckabee to Joe Wilson, Karen Hughes, Senate Judiciary Chairman Pat Leahy and others.

Hughes said the White House will be losing “the Energizer Bunny of the West Wing.” Obama called Rove the “architect,” who “left the country more divided.” Edwards was more flippant, saying just “Goodbye and Good Riddance!” Huckabee said he thinks Rove “wants to spend more time with his banker.” Wilson said, “Rove's resignation signals the final chapter in the Bush administration's betrayal of the identity of a covert CIA officer.” Leahy said, “Rove's apparent attempts to manipulate elections and push out prosecutors citing bogus claims of voter fraud shows corruption of federal law enforcement for partisan political purposes.”

Here are the full quotes:

EDWARDS in Iowa: “Goodbye and Good Riddance!"

OBAMA: "Karl Rove was an architect of a political strategy that has left the country more divided, the special interests more powerful, and the American people more shut out from their government than any time in memory.  But to build a new kind of politics, it will take more than the departure of a man or even an Administration that constructed the old - it will take a movement of everyday Americans committed to changing Washington and reclaiming their government."

HUCKABEE on MSNBC’s Morning Joe on Rove leaving to spend more time with his family: "I think he wants to spend more time with his banker"

WILSON: "Karl Rove's resignation signals the final chapter in the Bush administration's betrayal of the identity of a covert CIA officer. When this breach of national security occurred, the President promised the American people that anybody in his administration responsible for the leak would be removed. Rove, identified by the prosecutors as one of the leakers, not only was not summarily dismissed, but has been allowed to leave on his own terms, to praise from the President. This sordid tale of compromising national security to cover-up and distract from the false rationale for the invasion of Iraq will forever remain in history a black mark on the Bush presidency."

HUGHES, a longtime Bush adviser, on camera at the State Department: She said she choked up when she called Karl Rove this morning to wish him well now that he's leaving the White House. Speaking after a public diplomacy event featuring Baseball Hall-of-Famer Cal Ripken, Hughes said she called "to let him know that I knew what he was going through. I felt those same emotions several years ago when I left the White House." Hughes, who is now in charge of public diplomacy at the State Department, described getting emotional waiting for him to pick up the line: "I thought about what a huge impact he's had on the president’s life and career and on my own life and career."

Hughes and Rove have a long history in Texas politics and with President Bush since his days as governor and she said today she didn't think his advisory role was over. "Karl is brilliant; he is funny, and he's a passionate advocate for the president and his policies. And I know that he will continue to play that role outside the administration.”

What will the White House be like without Rove? “The Energizer Bunny of the West Wing," Hughes said.

"Karl is definitely constant motion and action and booming voice and presence and a funny, witty voice and presence. Always upbeat. I don’t recall ever seeing him down"

On the Valerie Plame case, Hughes would only say, "Let’s put it this way, the people that I know and the caricatures that sometimes are portrayed are two very different things and I think that’s been the case with Karl and a number of other people that I know well"

Was Karl in part responsible for the President's low approval ratings? "Polls rise and polls fall," Hughes said, "Karl has been an instrumental part of what i believe has been a very successful Presidency"

PAT LEAHY: "Earlier this month, Karl Rove failed to comply with the Judiciary Committee's subpoena to testify about the mass firings of United States Attorneys. Despite evidence that he played a central role in these firings, just as he did in the Libby case involving the outing of an undercover CIA agent and improper political briefings at over 20 government agencies, Mr. Rove acted as if he was above the law. That is wrong. Now that he is leaving the White House while under subpoena, I continue to ask what Mr. Rove and others at the White House are so desperate to hide. Mr. Rove's apparent attempts to manipulate elections and push out prosecutors citing bogus claims of voter fraud shows corruption of federal law enforcement for partisan political purposes, and the Senate Judiciary Committee will continue its investigation into this serious issue.

"The list of senior White House and Justice Department officials who have resigned during the course of these congressional investigations continues to grow, and today, Mr. Rove added his name to that list.  There is a cloud over this White House, and a gathering storm. A similar cloud envelopes Mr. Rove, even as he leaves the White House."

RNC Chairman ROBERT M. "MIKE" DUNCAN: "I have known Karl Rove since we were both in the College Republicans. His devotion to Republican Party principles and to our nation was strong back then, and has never wavered. He will be remembered most for engineering two successful Presidential campaigns, but those of us who have worked closely with Karl know that his dedication to politics was not for its own sake: Karl was and is, at heart, a policy person, someone who has strong beliefs and a deep commitment to making our nation better.
 
"The President and our party have benefited from his commitment, along with his good counsel, his optimism and his sense of humor. He has served his country long and well. I would like to thank him, and wish him, his wife Darby, and their son Andrew all the best."

MITCH MCCONNELL: "Karl Rove has made an enormous contribution to our country and our party. Now, as he leaves the White House and turns to new challenges, I wish him and his family well as they begin this new chapter in their lives."

****UPDATE****

CHUCK SCHUMER: "Karl Rove's resignation will not stop our inquiry into the firings of the U.S. attorneys. He has every bit as much of a legal obligation to reveal the truth once he steps down as he does today."

**** UPDATE 2 ****

JOHN CONYERS: "The need for Karl Rove to explain his role in the firing of the U.S. Attorneys does not diminish when he leaves the White House. Our investigation to date has revealed the White House's contempt for the rule of law and its interest in the politicization of the Department of Justice. While resignations at DoJ and the White House continue to mount, questions raised by this investigation remain. We will continue to seek answers to these questions and expect full cooperation from Mr. Rove and other officials regardless of whether they are employed by the White House."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Good riddance indeed. I hope to see more of them cry as VB-Day - Victory over Bush Day - inexorably draws closer. The clock is ticking.
Rove reactions, I got a itch !
Rove has made an enormous contribution to our country?  I'll admit that he is a political genius, but how is that contributing to our country?  He managed to twice get elected a man who has demonstrated time after time that he is more concerned about convincing everyone he is right than actually being right, and more concerned about his agenda than the Constitution.  What a contribution!  
The house cards are starting to fall. Lets hope this trend continues. It can't happen soon enough for me.
m. boley - you do realize bush isn't actually running? this is a small point that seems to be lost on quite a few...
My fellow Americans, I know nothing about Gonzo-Gate.
How about the devil incarnate-Karl Rove.
Alberto, George wants to see you immediately !
Going to be back to the basement hearings for Leaky and Chuck in 08
The lefties are jealous of a successful Republican political operative. Imagine that?
Does this mean as a private citizen he can now be made to testify??  Maybe we will get him to admit everything yet!
Since Huckabee is starting to make a name for himself out there, I would like to see a reporter ask him about his decision in 1999 to appoint Fay Boozman as the head of Arkansas Department of Health.  Dr. Boozman was infamous at the time for his stated belief that rape victims only very rarely get pregnant, as they were subject to a "rush of hormones" that prevented it.  Huckabee supported this guy despite that statement and other highly questionable activities of the "doctor."  What does thta say about Huckabee's judgment?  Please look this up, MSNBC types!
Leahy and Schumer are so out of touch it's funny
Yes, claire, thank you for telling me something that I already know. Duh!

'Bush' as used by yours truly is defined as a symbol - a symbol of everything that could possibly be wrong with government and politics today. 'Bush' includes not only GWB himself but his veep, Condi, Gates, Snow... the whole lot of 'em!
Than you for listing,, yes Bush and the Republican party Suck !
With all of you powerful people in Washington DC from Texas, can one of you please talk to NASA about building a safe shuttle. Please.

See next blog below, no single replacement for Rove.
Karl Rove consistantly beat every democratic left wing politico that came up against him and his party. Any heckling and whining as he leaves is just wasted breath. He single handedly handed you guys your butts on a platter every single day. Wahhh. Boo Hoo.
Suck it up and try again. If he doesn't back the next candidate you might actually have a chance in '08.
Oh wait, your either going to put up a bumbling novice or a crooked politics as usual woman. Never mind we can go this round without Karl.
Thanks Karl for great service. Thank you, thank you, thank you that Albert Gore was not in charge during 9/11. Take a well deserved vacation. The peanut gallery will eventually implode they always do.
As the noose tightens around the Most-Corrupt-Ever administration, the Cheney/Bush admin, Rove runs from justice (small j, of course---Justice is run by Cheney/Bush's lapdog.)He's hoping he can avoid getting sucked down with the rest of Bush's Band o' Brigands, but being a private citizen only menas...well..that you can still get a presidential pardon...But maybe a post-Bush Consgress-With-Cojones will finally put all those "evildoers" behind bars yet.  
Bush either resign or be impeached.
August 31 should be made a National Holiday!  Someone should pour salt over Karl so we can watch him dissolve. He is a white collar criminal who wrapped himself up in the American flag. Shame on him forever.
Just remember to take a quick looksie at the next blog.
Yes we're inside the Republican Headquarters, and apperantely someone turned the lights out. Was that you George?
Thanks G. W. !
Hey Carrie from Iowa, it's called being a leader. Leaders command with their convictions and are not easily swayed by outside influences like yourself.

You and the left are giving Karl to much credit. Of course, you can't expect too much from those who believe an "idiot" like Bush can hoodwink such clever minds like yourselves. If an "idiot" can dupe you, that doesn't say much about your intelligence.
karlbeatyourbestonhisworstday -- I suggest you return to your home planet as soon as possible. You certainly haven't been living on this over the last 61/2 years. Karl Rove was the mastermaind behind the most disaterous presidency in American history, a legacy we all will be paying for for a very long time. Thank goodness for small favors although much too late to undo the damamge he and his incompetent friend have wreaked on us.

"Karl Rove consistantly beat every democratic left wing politico that came up against him and his party".

That’s why you had you’re a**** handed to you in 2006. Face it the walls are tumbling down and the GOP is ducking and hiding just like they always do.
Um Karlbeatyourbestonhiswortday?  You care to explain what happened in 2006 then?  The wave year in the last election cycle is a direct result of Rove's tactics and the lowering of politics by the Republicans.  Praise the man for his past victories if you want, but remember that the political situation that Rove was instrumental in forging is going to keep the Republicans in the minority for years to come.

In that sense, I think I will say thank you to Karl Rove. Without his tactics and his influence on GOP politics the progressive movement would not have unified and pushed as hard as we are doing. The ascendancy of the left would probably not have happened if Rove and company hadn't been as succesful at electing incompetants and idiots as they were. Heck of a job Karl!
This man is irreplacable!  Is there anyone Machiavelilian enough to fill his shoes? Goering comes to mind, but he died a long time ago.  Maybe this adminstration might just be forced to embark upon a totally new approach.  Perhaps the truth for a change?

"The lefties are jealous of a successful Republican political operative. Imagine that?"  A Bush brown shirt morally incapable of distinguishing between "stealing" and "winning." Imagine that?
I recommend Rove consider a nice long vacation to The Hague.
I'm sure this point will be dismissed as Obama cheerleading, but I do think he nailed the correct response - at least the one I wanted to hear, both in terms of tone and content.
"Good bye, Turd Blossom!  The Dick and I will miss you!"
His work is done. Now he will move on to do the same thing with someone else. This means nothing except that he won't be around to have as a focal point.

I don't want him to resign. I want him escorted from the building between 2 federal marshalls in the glare of a million TV cameras, wearing handcuffs and with his coat over his large head.

I want him to have a jail cell roomie who is 6'3", 320 lbs, bald, covered in tatoos and who says his favorite fragrance is Turd Blossom.

I want him to live in a jail cell for at least 20 years.

I don't like him.

Part of what disturbs me is that now, more than ever, it is evident that American politics have more in common with marketing and branding a product than presenting positions of principle.  The Democrats are just as guilty of this as the Republicans; under Rove, however, the Republicans managed to stroke the fear of an imaginary jihad to a fever pitch in the minds of millions of American voters... and these idiots followed after Bush and Cheney like sheep.
Franklin said, "Those who would exchange liberty for security deserve neither."  Rove perfected the art of not only getting people to exchange their liberty for an imagined security from an exagerrated enemy, but also figured out how to make those poor sheep grateful that they had done so.
"I want to spend more time with my family," is the oldest political euphemism ever.  It really means, "I have become a liability and prefer to depart before things get too hot."
thanks to rove,bush,cheny the dems will own the whitehouse and congress for next 20 year.
Rove may be a political genius, but his instincts do not serve a democracy.  I am sure the shade of Thomas Jefferson is relieved by his removal.
Ah yes the democratic come back in 2006... What an ubermajority your have. And with it you are accomplishing what??? Ubernothing..
Palme - nothing. If you had something there would be charges.
Wiretaps - You gave in, we need them obviously. Or did you just want to go to recess???
The Iraq war - Everyone read the intelligence, everyone voted.
2000 - Albert Gore. Enough said. Great guy for the environment. Not a leader.
2004 - John/John . A leader from the rear echelon. Lead from a foxhole on the backline.
2006 - Again that Ubermajority takin' on the man...

Have a nice vacation Karl. '08 is looking like a walk in the park..
Mr. Independent, there is something wrong with you prison scenario. Sweet looking, pasty faced Karl would like it too damn much. I'd say we put Hillary Clinton in office and THAT might kill the little sissy.
Bush would have to stay in office another 30 years just to catch up to Clinton in number of friends and cabinet members indicted and jailed.
Don't let the door hit your backside Karl, as a matter of fact, better leave it open for Albert. bja
s.b.p. What world do you live in that the muslim jihad is imaginary? Wow, close your eyes and go back to sleep. You are right about the marketing of politicians but your blind if you think that the islamic threat is not real. Check the msm story over the weekend on Jakarta and the 90,000 muslims that gathered there and their aims. http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/20236318
They don't want Iraq or Sudan, they want the freakin world. Read history, if you think the Christian crusades were brutal, just wait for life under the caliphate. Republican or Democrat if your not worried about these guys your in lala land.
Rove is no doubt a genius for engineering the greatest division amongst Americans. Leaders make a country better by uniting the population towards a common goal. This man's accomplishments benefited a very few. Shouldn't he be tried for treason?
Anybody notice that since Rove announced his resignation, there have been no posts from Jerry in CC?

I knew they were one in the same person.
Check the definition for terrorist in Webster's and you will see exactly the type of person Rove will go down in history as.  Using "fear" for "political gain".  Sound like any recent presidential re-election campaign themes?  Dirty politics always has a "mastermind".  Rove leaving DC is the first step to cleaning out the gutters.
"The lefties are jealous of a successful Republican political operative. Imagine that?"

I don't know about "lefties," but a lot of criminals must be jealous of how Rove got off the hook for a treason rap after he helped blow the cover of a CIA agent, endangering the lives of her overseas contacts and rendering the CIA front company she used worthless. Benedict Arnold at least had to flee the country.
When and where is the going away party? I have some gag gifts in mind.
We will be saying the same thing to John Edwards very soon I hope. Hey John, which picket line are you going to be joining this week????
We heard it from Edwards and Obama, and a mildly cute quip from Huckabee. I'll go along with Leahy, Schumer, Wilson and Obama. I would like to hear from Hillary. The responses from Republicans in high places and Repub morons on this blog gives me the feeling that we, Dems and Repubs, are not just enemies like the Sunni and Shea, but are on a course to split off into two human sub-species. I feel pretty much the same about someone who would defend BushCo as I do the Muslims who danced in the streets because of 9/11, despite the fact that the morons in question are victims of brainwashing not of their choosing. Karl Rove is running scared. Only the dregs of the population who voted for Bush both times haven't jumped ship or otherwise seen the error of their ways. The dregs amount to about fourteen percent of the voting public. You people are powerless now, and will suck up the blow-back from your stupidity after Jan '09. You fools may be bitter now, but your future is to get your faces wiped in it over and over, even though it will be like punishing a dog that doesn't understand why. Rove can't escape from justice by becoming a civilian.
Karl Rove's statement, "I've got to do this for the sake of my family" is a cover story a two-year-old would not believe!! It’s always the “family” excuse; the same one that George W. Bush saw fit to use in part as an excuse to commute the sentence of I. Lewis Scooter Libby.  

PLEASE!! The “believable” and more accurate reason would be to defend himself against current investigations and certain pending and unspecified scandals or legal “annoyances”.

The Rove-led forces have proved over and over again, and with vulgar blatancy, that they are experts at pulling off electoral scams.  They are pure criminal slimes, and have done whatever it has taken to keep themselves in power and evade justice.

Rove has played by his own rules period; as does George W. Bush and Dick Cheney.  Heck, they don’t even recognize our society’s rules at all. Rove is a ruthless political operative, who has been stimulated by his obsessed appetite to remain in power. He has shown absolute disdain for the judicial system and up to this point, absolutely zero fear of incarceration for the high crimes and misdemeanors he has been at the heart of over the past six plus years.

Karl Rove knows where each body is buried. With scandal after scandal in this Administration, Rove’s arrogance has amplified.

Let’s review his “greatest hits”!!

Outing a Covert CIA Agent -

Knowing it is a felony to reveal the identity of covert CIA agent, Rove decided that Valerie Plame, in his words, was "fair game," because her husband, Ambassador Joseph Wilson IV, told the truth about the use of phony WMD intelligence to convince Congress of the necessity for an immediate war with Iraq.

Two "senior Administration officials" told a number of newspaper reporters that Plame was a CIA agent, and one of those reporters, rightwing ideologue Robert Novak, actually ran her name.
Gees, Plame's specialty at the CIA was tracing sources of weapons of mass destruction. So, for political ends, Rove was willing to place the national security of the United States at risk by ending the career of an agent who worked for a decade in developing contacts around the globe that could provide clues for where the WMD was going. Reprehensible!!

Swift Boating a Decorated War Veteran -

Rove was the man behind the “Swift Boat” attacks against John Kerry. None of those “men” (and I use the word loosely) served on Kerry's boat with him; but were angry with him for his anti-war statements after he returned from Vietnam. Rove, armed with cash and logistical support from major Republican backers associated with the White House,  launched the “big lie” barrage about Kerry's medals and heroism. Truth was never the object, rather the false spreading of lies that made people question Kerry's record. Disgraceful!!

Hurricane Katrina -

In August 2005, Bush assigned Rove to oversee the administration's political 'damage control' effort following Hurricane Katrina in Louisiana. – We all know how deplorable this was handled then and today!!

US Attorney Firings -

“Allen Weh, chairman of the New Mexico Republican Party, said he complained in 2005 about then-U.S. Attorney David Iglesias to a White House aid for Rove, asking that Iglesias be removed.] Then in 2006 Rove personally told Weh “He’s gone,” Rove said. Weh was dissatisfied with Iglesias due in part to his failure to indict Democrats in a voter fraud investigation. Weh followed up with, "There’s nothing we’ve done that’s wrong." The White House spokeswoman, Dana Perino, has said that Rove "wasn’t involved in who was going to be fired or hired."
According to Newsweek, Kyle Sampson, Alberto Gonzales' chief of staff, developed the list of eight prosecutors to be fired last October, with input from the White House.

Timothy Griffin, a former Rove aide, was the replacement for fired attorney Henry Cummins. Specifically, Sampson sent an email that stated "The vast majority of U.S. attorneys, 80-85 percent I would guess, are doing a great job, are loyal Bushies, etc., etc." Later in the e-mail, Sampson wrote that home-state senators may resist replacing prosecutors "they recommended. That said, if Karl thinks there would be political will to do it, then so do I."

On March 14, 2007 former U. S. Senator Peter Fitzgerald said he believes Rove was trying to influence the selection in reaction to pressure from Rep. Dennis Hastert, then speaker of the House, and allies of then-Gov. George Ryan, who knew Fitzgerald was seeking someone from outside Illinois to attack political corruption.” – You’re “outed” Karl!!

E-Mail scandal -

Email communication related to the firing of United States Attorneys, revealed that Rove had exchanged documents using Republican National Committee e-mail servers such as gwb43.com, or personal e-mail accounts with third party providers such as Blackberry, considered a violation of the Presidential Records Act. – Busted!!

Investigation by the Office of Special Counsel -

On April 23, 2007, a federal agency began an extensive investigation into the activities of Karl Rove, to determine whether Rove broke federal laws by making political presentations to government employees encouraging them to find ways to support Republican candidates. Here come the nails for the coffin Karl!!

On April 24, 2007, it was revealed that Rove was being investigated by the Office of Special Counsel for his involvement in the email scandal, the firing of US attorneys, and for "improper political influence over government decision-making." – FINAL NAIL IN COFFIN!!
------------------------------------------------------
Yeah, ok Karl, you really expect ANYONE to believe you are resigning for the “sake of your family”?? No, you are resigning for the sake of YOUR criminal slime ass!!

I hope the only “Roving” Karl does is in a prison yard, for if not, we will continue to watch our democratic system get strangled and die!!

PEACE!!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=315001

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google