ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Oh-eight (R): Guy rips Fred

Posted: Thursday, August 23, 2007 9:08 AM by Mark Murray
Filed Under:

GIULIANI: The New York Times picks up on the attacks Giuliani is receiving from Romney and Thompson over guns and immigration, and it notes they are coming via references to "New York City."

Meanwhile, Giuliani supporter Guy Molinari decided to rip Thompson for the gun attack. "Giuliani's adviser called Thompson out of bounds for penning a column on his blog blasting New York City's gun-control laws under Giuliani and his successor, Mayor Bloomberg. ‘He's not just attacking Rudy. He's attacking every resident of New York City,’ Molinari charged.”

Giuliani again said, "I will end illegal immigration," which won him “his loudest applause of the evening,” the New York Daily News writes. Giuliani added, "And one of the strict requirements of citizenship should be that you have to read English, write English and understand English.”

USA Today looks at Giuliani's attempts to ramp up his operation in New Hampshire under the header: "Giuliani out to win a state 'made for him.'"

The Los Angeles Times begins what appears to be a profile series of sorts -- either specifically on Giuliani or on the 2008 candidates in general. This Giuliani profile focuses on Giuliani's days as a Justice Department aide in the Reagan Administration. "Years before he would become the swaggering, crime-busting U.S. attorney in Manhattan, before he would serve two terms as mayor and help lead New York through its darkest day, Giuliani already was demonstrating a florid sense of self, a high degree of self-confidence and a daring to pull the levers of bureaucratic power."

By the way, Andrew Giuliani is a REALLY good golfer. He just might have a chance to go pro.

HUCKABEE: At a media avail in South Carolina yesterday, Huckabee said, per NBC’s Lauren Appelbaum, "We've certainly exceeded all of the expectations we've had everywhere we've been since the Iowa straw poll. People are realizing the campaign is alive. It has momentum. We've separated from the pack. And that's evident not only by the crowds that are coming, but also by hits to the website, by people who are scheduling fundraising events, by the fact that people are giving money to the campaign that have been sort of sitting back and waiting until now."

The Boston Globe has kind words for Huckabee on his attention to arts and music education. “Regardless of how the Republican presidential contest plays out, Huckabee is right to bring attention to art and music. The right side of the brain is a terrible thing to waste.”

ROMNEY: The Washington Post: “Former Massachusetts governor Mitt Romney said this week that as president he would allow individual states to keep abortion legal, two weeks after telling a national television audience that he supports a constitutional amendment to ban the procedure nationwide… The two very different statements reflect the challenge for Romney, who has reinvented himself as a champion of the antiabortion movement in recent years and is seeking to become the conservative alternative to former New York mayor Rudolph W. Giuliani in the battle for the Republican presidential nomination.”

A day before Romney gives a major health-care policy speech, the Boston Globe writes in a staff editorial that he has “health care amnesia.” “As he campaigns for the Republican presidential nomination, Romney makes the law seem like a triumph of free-market economics… There was a little bit of that in the final law, but what really makes it work is a system of government subsidies and regulation.” The paper adds: “The state intervened to tame the cruelties of the free market.” 
 
Romney discussed with the AP that movie that’s coming out next week about the Mountain Meadows Massacre. He shrugged it off, saying, “There are bad people in any church and it's true of members of my church, too."

THOMPSON: “His image has been cultivated as much by Hollywood as by his time as a real-life Republican senator in Washington,” the AP writes. “While many have used acting to launch political careers, including President Reagan and California Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger, few have made the transition from an acting career to a political career and back again.”

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Rudy is a lying greaseball crossdresser.
After a life-long political record of voting conservative, I thought I was going to have to choose between Obama and Edwards this time around.  Wait.. I have to break out my hand sanitizer after typing that...

I'm so thrilled that when I ducked to avoid the latest round of mud-slinging... I found Huckabee just kinda lying low.  

Rudy, Mitt, Tom, Ted, Curly and Mo can beat themselves into a political oblivion.  I found my candidate for 08.  I like Mike!
OK OK illigal alien who kills in newark shows all illigals could be trying to kill americans .How many of the 600 plus dead in phila were killied by illegals?And why not get rid of guns to they kill alot of young people ohh hold on there is a disconnect here NO GUN LAWS but get the aliens on a train car and off to the american work camps yopu go ,how did americans turn from give me your poor huddled masses to we will beat you till you leave and not share our freedoms with the world kind of people.Could it be thier rights have been so tred upon they are scared to share with others which they lack ,HABEUS CORPIS,ILLEGAL SEARCH and
,WIRETAPPING, why not send people to a gulag or work camp,But rememeber american peoples guns dont kill people only illegal alien guns do .
let the republicans out religion each other-----Had enough of GOD supposedly speaking to Bush to last in my lifetime.Good morals will suit me just fine and truth and honesty would be refreshing.No more secret energy meetings,hiding documents,arresting silent protesters,and only being the president of a select few that agree with him.More than half of this country has not had a president representing them.
Whoever you republicans vote for as your nominee, please dont' vote for the redneck gun toting dixieland singing first cousin marrying Fred Thompson. He's worse than Bush.
So Beth you're going to give Hope a second chance? :-) I like Mike better than all the above too, but I'd still like to see Duncan Hunter rise to the top.
Giuliani is a media creation. I can not vote for a man who married his cousin as his first wife and treated his second wife like trash. A man with no family value and a liar. He lied about been a hero of 911 while the true heros are the victims and the fire fighters. Giuliani is not fit to be president, he need to focus on saving his family.
I'm starting to like Giuliani. I know there's been some supposed "flip-flops" but I'm realizing that flip flopping could be interpreted as realizing that one's own views are out of line with a voter base. Isn't that what democracy is supposed to be? The voice of the people rather than one leader? Would God that G.W.B. had done a little bit of flip-flopping while preparating for the Iraq invasion in '03. Maybe what this country needs is more leaders who will change their agenda to match the concerns and thoughts of the American people? I say bring on the opinion changes, so long as they reflect what the masses really want. Let's bring a quick end to illegal immigration and support legal immigration. Giuliani in '08.
By the way Beth, Huckabee will start slinging mud the moment he becomes a real contender. Just watch and see. He seems very sanitized right now due to having escaped the fray thus far, as nobody is taking him seriously enough to fight with. He'll have to start throwing punches to get attention and once he gets that attention, he'll start getting mega-scrutinized like everybody else is.  
Just remember, Republicans don't flip flop, they evolve.
Guiliani is Bush in sheep's clothing. Don't be fooled!
"Rappin' Rudy 'G' The Gigolo of The G.O.P.!"
I like that other people are finally talking about Mike. Vote Huckabee. Yes, he's got quite the challenge ahead of him, but it's not even September yet, the year BEFORE the election. If Mike is who you like, don't give up on him now. C'mon America, get behind your man.
The Boston Globe should remember Hitler was an artist and he loved Wagner.  What a load of ****. To use this as a means to judge a candidate is ridiculous.
Hey Pat, Guiliani is Bush in womens clothing!
Desmond, but I thought several of the GOP candidates did not believe in evolution?
Can't wait for the pictures of Rudy dressed up like a woman and wearing panty hose and make-up, what was it 5 separate time? Oh that will go over real big. Of course republican men might like that for some reason.
Anybody want to tell me, including Guy Molinari, how it's going to hurt Fred Thompson to alienate voters in New York City?  Are they going to vote 70-30 Democrat instead of 69-31?
Just as a right brain is a terrible thing to waste, so, too, is the left, which the Boston Globe apparently doesn't understand as they make their backhanded stereotypical "compliments".

Robert Catalano: For your information, the Hitler analogy is right-brain induced since it has no basis in, or pretense of, reasoned analytical thought processes.

John Henry:  Interesting, that's what I thought about Clinton in '92.  Except I don't think he had the class to marry his cousin.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=329551

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google