ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Thompson echoes Howard Dean?

Posted: Tuesday, September 11, 2007 10:54 AM by Mark Murray

From NBC's Mark Murray
Does anyone else think that Fred Thompson's statement in South Carolina yesterday -- that "we've got due process to go through" in dealing with Osama bin Laden -- sounds a lot like what Howard Dean said back in 2003 about the Al Qaeda leader?

In December 2003, Dean told the Concord Monitor: "I still have this old-fashioned notion that even with people like Osama, who is very likely to be found guilty, we should do our best not to, in positions of executive power, not to prejudge jury trials." 

Dean later said he supported the death penalty for bin Laden, but his Democratic rivals pounced on his comment. "If Howard Dean is unsure about Saddam Hussein and Osama bin Laden, the American people are going to be very unsure they have the confidence they need to make Howard Dean their president," Joe Lieberman said back then. 

Once the Petraeus and 9/11 anniversary news subsides, will we see Thompson's GOP rivals go after him the way the Dems went after Dean?

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Joe Lieberman could be expected to say that he is the senator from the Likud party. if we are killing enemies of Israel he is happy.
Is Thompsno trying to lose? No Republican in their right mind makes a statement seen as loosely defending Osamaa. This is Dennis Kucinich stuff.

http://www.political-buzz.com/
That Howard Dean.  Truely a man ahead of his time.  In another dimension too.
Howard Dean lost his own race with the rebel yell
going to cost his party the 08 race with moveon.org.

what a combination!
Joe "torture" Lieberman is not a moral or legal authority worthy of quote.

Dean is too good for America. Maybe when we grow up.
mpp, maybe a Republican candidate in his right mind can't win the nomination. I think he was defending due process (you know, that quaint idea of law and constitution) not Bin Laden.
Thompson is correct as was Dr. Dean.  After all, even Saddam was given a trial.  Let's get beyond gotcha politics.  6 years after 9-11 shouldn't we be more united as a nation?
Good post, Rufus.  Joe Israel unmasked.
If you actually listened to Thompson's speech, he wasn't even talking about due process in court. He was just commenting on the "process as a whole". I just think NBC and other democratic leaning news organizations are scared out of their minds that Thompson is going to be the next President of our great nation.
I love the current republican talking points about moveon.org. A website is going to cost the democrats the '08 election? Isn't it more likely that the republican party's public restroom problems are going to cost them their election? Jerry, the next time you call in to Rush's or Hannity's show, ask them to give you substantial reasons to vote republican - not some flaky URL.
Mark, how long have you been a political director?  The rule on issues like this is that if you're a Democrat you can't say stuff like that but if you're a Republican you can.  

And Jerry, I am really going to be interested in what you have to say when the GOP gets thumped again in the 2008 elections. lol
When a Republican says it, it doesn't matter. Nothing to see here, move along.
I happen to agree with Thompson.  The one thing we did right in Iraq was capture Saddam and follow the law with respect to his imprisonment, trial and execution.  We didn't take him out back and shoot him, although I'm sure there was temptation to do so.  There will be an ever greater temptation to do so if we ever catch bin Laden.  It would be a mistake for us to abandon the rule of law in favor of vigilante justice - regardless of how horrific the criminal is.  
Oh my goodness, so now we are going to compare Fred to Howard Dean?  Yeah, that'll fly...  C'mon guys you can do better than this...  I agree with Andrew, how about we listen to the entire speech?
But it's OK if you're a Republican, right?
Very Good Post of both Rufus and Robert: America will only be safe when traitors like Lieberman are exposed as Israeli agents that want to warmonger and hate monger us right into a World War III. Not even now after the disastrous war in Iraq are they stopping. They are already inciting our country into a war with Iran and the whole Middle East. And it is easy to understand why too, zionists do not care about our country, they only care about Israel.
I fought the law. And the law won.
How about all the presidential candidates that support the war become imbedds with our troops for a month.
In a post up top, nuanced said Dean is too good for America. I agree that he is too good for most Americans, specifically those who voted for Bush. I am afraid Obama is also too good for America. People get the government they deserve, and too many really deserve Bush for Obama to be in our future. I'm afraid we will be lucky to get stuck with Hillary at this point in human evolution. There are altogether too many Jerry's out there for anything better to happen.
I believe in due process as well.

It says a lot about our nation that Loyal Bushies are so scared, they can't handle the freedoms in our US Constitution anymore. Instead, they believe in vigilante justice, with them pointing the gun at the "evil" world.

I've tried to figure out how this belief in "instant judgement" happened to America's justice system.
Well, aside from Gonzo, my only guess:

These critics of Due Process are part of the "Judeo-Christian" cabal that judges the rest of us but dismisses their own despicable behavior by assuring us that they are not perfect but -- contrary to us heathen -- they do pray about it.

They also say they believe in heaven but they seem unwillingly to actually test their theory, appearing to be the most afraid of death of any of us.

From my observation, they appear to hate their enemies... not love them, as instructed by their spiritual leader.

(psst! They also don't ever turn the other cheek when attacked, nor do they care about the poor.)
"Thompson echoes Howard Dean?"

I fear if the used up looking thompson try’s that demented scream that dean turned loose back in the day he will surely be spitting up lung chunks, nice trophy wife though
Joe Lieberman is cool, way!!!! better than billary Thompson is the man though
You got them pegged right on Jan.  Don't forget they also believe they get absolved of responsibility by asking for instant forgiveness while the rest of us must pay and suffer dearly for our transgressions.
This I found @ the "WHO CALLED US" site.....

2007-09-10D A. Wilkie
Don't call here anymore

2007-09-10Voter
Thank you for the info Won't Vote...
Now I know who not to vote for.... This guy "FRED THOMPSON" annoys me and my family with his un-welcome calls....

2007-09-10stan forde
This is the first time I have received a call from this unk caller; the call was blocked.

2007-09-11Grey Mike
Is this guy THOMPSON making a pass at my wife ?
He calls us relentlessly like nobody's business.
Hey THOMPSON, you have just violated our right to privacy sir. We know you are a freaking spy but please leave us honest Americans alone. STOP CALLING US FOR YOU CAUSE.
Place a commercial. an add or something, just don't call us, WE'LL CALL YOU IF WE ARE INTERESTED OF YOUR CAUSE!!!!

2007-09-11arzi
I appreciate finding this site and learning about the call. Annoying to get political phone calls at all, let alone when everyone is asleep. I pay the phone bill and I should be able to decide if you can call me...it's like stopping my car at a light and you jump in for a ride without asking. You lost any chance of a vote at this house just by calling.

2007-09-11madeline
Just recieved a call from this number answering machine picked and they hung up. I dailed back and it is from the Friends of Fred Thompson. All is pre recorded said they will be calling back .

2007-09-11madeline
Oh and it gives number and BLOCK NAME !!

2007-09-11Arnold D.
To this caller.
We do not answer calls from people wearing a mask ( PRIVATE CALLER or CALLER UNKNOWN )in this house.
You have to be man enough to identify yourself when invading our privacy to make us consider talking to you, but I guess it is too little too late... You have already annoyed us, you won't get this households vote sir. If you called us w/o a name, you must be up to something for my beloved country... You have violated our right to privacy and that cost you our votes. Kindly, Angry Voter...

Now, now, lets not be quick to judge others either folks.  We can't paint all people under the banner of Christianity with the same brush.  I for one am a Christian, and while I, like most of this country wouldn't mind it that much if Osama was dead, I believe that should be after he is sentenced to death after a trial.  Where that trial would be held is a good question to ask...would it be a trial in the US...would it be a trial held by the UN?  And after we have him, who is gong to take his place?  I have to say I agree with Thompson's first statement that we must not forget the symbolism of the man and if we take him out of the picture...terrorism doesn't just go away after that.

As to the comment that if we ask forgiveness that we are absolved of all responsibility or that we believe we're off the hook, that would be a no.  We believe that we must follow the laws of the land, and if we break them, we must pay the price for our actions.  The asking of forgiveness is for our souls and we aren't asking the world(although we do ask for that forgiveness from time to time)we're asking God.

Another point: do we fear death?  Yes.  And for good reason...if we know we haven't been living our life the way we should then we know what we will get in the end, and I can't think of anyone who would want that to be their end.  Although, you may remember back to those kids at Columbine when asked if they believed in God with a gun to their head, knowing full well that if they said yes they would be killed and yet they stuck to their beliefs.  One of these days, we'll all find out if that test of their faith was one that garnered them a passing grade.

One more thing, if you take a look at the satire and most other comedy that pokes fun at us Christians you might notice that we take it in stride.  But if the same type of humor is directed at a Muslim organization or any other hot button issue for the liberal side of things it is considered hate speech.

And our "spiritual leader" as you would call him even got angry from time to time(for example when he was angered by the moneychangers at the temple...read a Bible, its in there). But then again, he did give his life for those same people that spat upon him, beat him, made mockery of him and nailed him to a cross.  So I guess you could say that he turned the other cheek too.

And as far as not caring about the poor?  Uh ...what? Most of the shelters and food pantries out there are ran by churches or other religious organizations.  Or is it that you mean we don't feel that we should support those who will not support themselves?  As the old saying goes: you give a man a fish..he eats for a day...you teach a man to fish...well you get the picture.

I'll go ahead and step down off my soapbox now...


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=355070

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google