ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Oh-eight (D): Hillary's anti-war support

Posted: Thursday, September 13, 2007 9:07 AM by Mark Murray
Filed Under:

BIDEN: NBC/NJ's Carrie Dann reports that Biden today will pick up the endorsement of Iowa House Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy. Per the campaign, McCarthy's support for Biden is based on the senator's foreign policy background and his plan for a measured withdrawal from Iraq.  McCarthy's nod will be Biden's eighth endorsement out of the state legislature in Iowa.

CLINTON: The new Los Angles Times/Bloomberg polls in the early states finds voters who are the most anti-war are siding with Clinton. "Many of those voters who want an immediate withdrawal of U.S. troops support her candidacy and consider her best able to end the war, as do many who back a more gradual drawdown… The findings help explain why the New York senator has built a strong lead over Democratic rivals who have made their opposition to the war the centerpiece of their campaigns -- and who have laid out more-detailed plans for quicker troop reductions."

Clinton made her first public comments about Hsu since the campaign decided to return nearly a $1 million in contributions Hsu raised. “‘I believe that the vast majority of those 200-plus donors are perfectly capable of making up their own minds about what they will or won't do going forward,’ Clinton said in a conference call with reporters -- her first public comments on the fallout of Hsu's arrest and her decision to return the $850,000 he collected for her presidential bid.

The Clinton campaign has told First Read that they will NOT "re-solicit" the Hsu donors. But as Clinton said, if these folks make up their own mind and decide to donate, that's up to the donors. In fact, here is the New York Daily News: “Clinton opened the door yesterday to letting the donors rounded up by Hsu write new checks -- if they swear the money is their own and didn't come from her disgraced ‘HillRaiser.’”

And as if the Hsu story wasn't weird enough, now we learn he attempted suicide on that Amtrak train. The suicide notes hit mailboxes this week.

Giuliani’s former mayoral campaign manager and deputy mayor during his first term is supporting Clinton for president. "I'm not voting for Rudy. I'm supporting Hillary Clinton. I'm an 'ambassador' for Hillary," Fran Reiter told the New York Post. She “complained [Giuliani] has fundamentally shifted his positions on key social issues like abortion and gun control and called his health-care plan ‘appalling.’” The Giuliani camp responded: "We'll trade Fran Reiter for Louis Freeh any time.”

DODD: On his Web site yesterday, Dodd jumped on Petraeus’ assessment of whether the US is safer with fighting in Iraq. "It's a tragedy that the question of whether or not our strategy of escalating the presence of US forces in Iraq's civil war will make us safer was not asked before we put it into action," Dodd's statement said. "As a result we've seen the bloodiest summer since we've been in Iraq and no noticeable political progress."

EDWARDS: To rebut Bush’s Iraq speech tonight, “Edwards has bought two minutes of air time on MSNBC,” the AP reports. “The ad was taped at Edwards' home in Chapel Hill, N.C., in the style of an Oval Office address, with him sitting at a desk and speaking straight to the camera, with American flag in the background.” In the ad, Edwards says: "Tell Congress you know the truth. They have the power to end this war and you expect them to use it. When the president asks for more money and more time, Congress needs to tell him he only gets one choice -- a firm timeline for withdrawal." The ad likely will cost between $100,000 and $150,000.

OBAMA: The New York Times calls Obama's Iraq speech yesterday his "most extensive plan yet for winding down the war in Iraq, proposing to withdraw all combat brigades by the end of next year while leaving behind an unspecified smaller force to strike at terrorists, train Iraqi soldiers and protect American interests… Mr. Obama delivered his remarks in an address at Ashford University in Clinton, Iowa. While he did not directly mention Mrs. Clinton by name, the words in his speech and the name of the city in which he chose to give his speech made his point clear."

Newsweek also sees Obama's Iraq speech as a "fresh" attempt to contrast himself with Clinton. "Obama’s aides believe her vote for the war offers a possible chink in the formidable Clinton armor. They eagerly point out that she failed to read the full and classified National Intelligence Estimate on Iraq. Unlike the public version of that report, the full NIE included multiple caveats and disclaimers that cast doubt on key assertions by the White House.

On his Iraq speech, the Des Moines Register highlights Obama’s proposed “$2 billion a year in aid to Iraqi refugees and welcoming at least 7,000 Iraqi refugees into the United States as part of his strategy to bring peace and end the war.”

NBC/NJ's Aswini Anburajan interviews Zbigniew Brzezinski, who introduced Obama in Iowa yesterday. When asked why a freshman senator from Illinois who has had no real foreign policy experience could be qualified to take on the challenges of a new world order, Brzezinski said that Obama grasps the history of this moment. "The real test for qualifications is not some extensive record of travel or bureaucratic service, it's the ability to understand what is the nature of the historical movement," he said. "Why was Truman qualified? He was a haberdasher.  Look at some recent leaders. Look at President Clinton what were his qualifications?"

RICHARDSON: The Politico discovered a major donor with ties to Saddam Hussein in Bill Richardson's FEC report. “Richardson and a host of congressional candidates from both parties accepted cash from Oscar S. Wyatt Jr. and his wife, Lynn, since the federal government accused the Texas oilman of paying millions of dollars in kickbacks to Saddam Hussein.”

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Report: NBC/NJ's Carrie Dann reports that Biden today will pick up the endorsement of Iowa House Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy.



Somehow this matters?
Ehhhh John?

MSNBC????????
Fox news is seen by more people in that time slot then all the other news channels combined.

So Norman Hsu tried to go Vince Foster on us huh?
He must really have some info on Hillary that made him try that.  Why didn't he just drive somewhere and blow his brains out like Vince did?  I wonder why Vince Foster killed himself, he must have known the truth about Hillary as well.

Hillary may as well give up and go home.  The only people that want her to win are guaranteed 4 years of investigations and hearings week in and week out.
“Edwards has bought two minutes of air time on MSNBC,” and "The ad likely will cost between $100,000 and $150,000."

So does Edwards get the same discount Moveon.org got from the NY Times?  Usually a full page ad in the Times costs $165,000.  Moveon paid $65,000.

The NY Times and NBC, the media outlets for free (or largely discounted) Democratic propaganda.
Good morning Jerry, more people watch Fox News for a simple reason:  it's much easier to drink kool-aid than it is to swallow the truth.

To Frank in Raytown, newspapers give discounts to non-profit groups, political or otherwise all of the time.  It is a standard practice in the business.  Prove to me that the Washington Times or the New York Post have not done this for conservative causes.  If you're gonna tell a story you should tell the whole story.
"The new Los Angles Times/Bloomberg polls in the early states finds voters who are the most anti-war are siding with Clinton. "Many of those voters who want an immediate withdrawal of U.S. troops support her candidacy and consider her best able to end the war, as do many who back a more gradual drawdown…"

Is this the same group that was polled that had about a third or so still believe that Saddam Hussain was linked to 9/11 and had purchased enriched uranium from Niger?  Senator Clinton is many things, but to say she dominates as the "anti-war" candidate is hard to swallow.  Where - and HOW - do they get their data?
To my fellow Texan, Jerry, from Corpus Christi.  Can I interpret your comment as indicating that you accept that Vince Foster actually killed himself.  I was always troubled by the way certain elements of the extremely conservative faction tried to imply/persuade that Foster had been executed.  
As to free media propaganda, Bush and the GOP have gotten a free media ride for over 6 years - up to and including the simpering coverage of the Petreaus report.  Read Media Matters/Altermann today to see the national media coverage breakdown coast to coast - conservatives have it almost everywhere by a wide margin...but then mainstream media is owned largely by neocons and their minions - spinmeister neocon journalists and media 'commentators' abound, and unfortunately many so-called liberal/progressive jounalists are eating their own young, doing their part in keeping yellow journalism alive and well - ego is an ugly thing in the world of information dissemination - that is, 'objective' news coverage and truth in reporting --- not.
hmmmm Hsu would of thought??....Hillary, hillary, the heavily bottomed, sound byte, queen is certainly cut from the same cloth as her philandering, perjury prone husband.

She flew her flag high when she said, "lobbyist's are real people too"...Now, we find that, that statement must apply to con-men, flim flam artists and racketeers as well. This is the reason that controversey and scandal always follow the Clinton's for they can't find it in themselves to place morality, or law, in front of their blind ambition....What's amazing, is she's old school, hackneyed and a product of the "system" and you'd better think long and hard before you vote this jugular cutting bitch into office....

As an example of the mercenary female politician's "Peter Principle" you have to look no further than the laughable, sophmoric antics of "Speaker" Nancy Peolsi...."She" was going to take charge, pass 100 laws in the first 60 days.....Now, with that said and done, she's got the job and she's deservedly garnering the lowest approval ratings in the history of same......Switching from Pelosi to Clinton...Aside from being a woman, the first "Lady", (talk about a misnomer), What has Clinton done? What is her crowning achievement?.....Aside from sticking with Bill when he was burning through zippers, nothing, she's no more than a resume of unfinished sentences and flip-flops......tell'em anything, just get that vote!!!! Wake up.......Clinton is another zero, being pushed by big interests, lobbyists and worse.

Things are more confused than ever. Sheesh!  How can Hillary be viewed as the anti-war candidate when she ingenuously voted to authorize the president to use force in Iraq without first reading the NIE concerning (the lack of certainty about the presence of) WMD and then voted against the Levin amendment, which was to provide congressional oversight (to reign in the anticipated insanity of our cowboy president)?  Now, she's the anti-war candidate?!  Give me a break.  Wake up people and take your Alzheimer's meds.  The true anti-Iraq war candidates are Obama (speech 2002), Kucinich and Paul (voted against authorization in 2002).  Take your pick.  Obama wants to go after Al-Qaeda where they live, in the mountains of Tora Bora and in Pakistan (with our without our dictator friend, Musharraf).  Again if you're interested in American security, take your pick.
Obama '08
Vince Foster must have had some serious issues with Hillary to put a gun to his head.

Norman Hsu must have had some serious issues with Hillary to attempt suicide.

Wonder what is really in those warehouses she won't let anybody see until after November 2008?

If I was district attorney, i would cut a deal with Hsu.....probation in exchange for everything Hillary knew about her campaign money system.

The best is yet to come!
when is obama returning his $$$ from Hsu?

oh, he doesn't have to cause the obama folks don't care about his mafia ties,etct
Wow!! First we had Kerry the FLIP-FLOPPER, now we have Clinton the FLIP-FLOPPER!! Will the political BS ever stop?
TJB, the way you speak about women speaks volumes about you. Another man who despises females. Wow, what a shock. Your a repub no doubt.
"The new Los Angles Times/Bloomberg polls in the early states finds voters who are the most anti-war are siding with Clinton. "Many of those voters who want an immediate withdrawal of U.S. troops support her candidacy and consider her best able to end the war, as do many who back a more gradual drawdown…"

That is just hilarious.  Hillary Clinton is unelectable.  


These anti-war Democrats who support Hillary do know that the Republican candidate will have the advantage on the war, right.  The Republican candidate, be he Rudy, Fred, or Romney; will not have voted for the war.  Furthermore, he will be a Republican and will be assumed to be better on national defense, terrorism, war, and other military matters by default.

Hillary Clinton would be on the right of the war in a general election.  As the only one who voted for it she would be the Pro-war candidate.
>>>  To Frank in Raytown, newspapers give discounts to non-profit groups, political or otherwise all of the time.  It is a standard practice in the business.  Prove to me that the Washington Times or the New York Post have not done this for conservative causes.  If you're gonna tell a story you should tell the whole story.


You prove it Robert.  You're making the claim, you do your own research.  The NY Times gave Moveon a 60% discount for a full page ad, and that is a fact.

Show us all one time another newspaper did the same for a conservative activist group.  You're claiming they did, you prove it.  Until then, you doing nothing but blabbering.

The NY Times has been fronting for the Democrats for years, why should they stop now?
Hey Jerry, again with Vince Foster?  Seriously?  Hsu gave money to the entire democratic party, not just Hillary.  He also gave to Obama.(Tuck, youre totally right)  The media just uses Clintons name to get headlines.  

TJB- Pelosi said she would pass 6 major laws in a 100 days.  They passed them all and Bush vetoed all of them except the Min wage.  Get your facts straight.

As for the people who are complaining that Clinton is the anti war candidate.  I got news for you, every Democrat running for President is an anti war candidate.  If Hillary gets the nomination, please go vote for the republican, we don't want people who claim their democrats talking trash against other democrats.  The fact is, you are going to vote for whoever the Democrat nominee is and if you don't you never were a Democrat.  If you vote republican just because you don't like Hillary, then you are an idiot.  

Steve P, all politicians are flip floppers.  Get a dose of reality.  I can find a flip flop from every candidate running.  
Darrius/jerry your gonna be weeping like a baby on election day when Hillary wins. HaHa!

Know this: Like it or not, the most efficiently devastating political force in America is not Bushco.  The only people they really fear are the Clintons.

For very good reason.

The point is, there is no one who can stop them now, Democrat or republican.  All the Dems running are running for a place on the Clinton roster after the blitzkrieg (election) is over.

Will she end the war?  Expand federally based health-care systems?  Talk to our allies like a sociopathic dimestore cowboy?  Who knows?  I say, two out of three ain't bad.

One thing for sure, she will kick ass like it hasn't been kicked for a long time.

Hang on, it's gonna be a long, strange trip.  Don't worry, we're going to get our money's worth.  Sit back and watch the show.  Hee haw!

(Full disclosure:  I actively and professionally support Barack Obama, but I am close enough to see that the fix is in, from top to bottom.  Even if Obama wins in Iowa, he is still running for a cabinet post and he, more than anyone, knows it.)

frankie, why do you advertize that you're ignorant of how the media works?

sheesh, it's like your real name is george
To Darrius, Arkansas
I'm a republican myself, but unfortunately Republicans have lost all credibility when it comes to national security, defense and protecting our borders. With the mess of the Iraq war, more anti-american feelings, border security and the airport mess...along with the fiscal behaivior that Bush has followed in the last 7 years, many have lost faith in the Republican party. I think they will vote for Hillary because she is a democrat, not because she is Hillary.
It doesn't matter which democrat gets the nomination, the democrats and independents of this country will unite behind him/her. However, republicans are divided over the social vs. policy vs. fiscal issues and the party has been hijacked by right-wing social conservatives. It is a pity but Guliani will not stand a chance with his own party.
Addendum:

3 things could keep Hillary Clinton out of the White House:

1. Imposition of martial law before elections or inauguration.

2. Personal disaster (you fill in the blank)

3. Well timed political land mine planted by Bushco.

While Bushco is not beyond any dastardly deed, as history will attest, they are not likely to pull off anything as drastic as these three game-plan possibilities in this election.

Why?  Because the intensely ruthless Clinton Department of Defense has Bushco cornered (again). All off the record.  Way off.

So, short of a Doctor Strangelove ending, this play will be over in three acts and four standing ovations.

PS: Laura's neck is fine now.
This republican will be voting for Joe Biden.  The candidate with a viable plan for getting us out of Iraq in either party.
Uh-oh, Napoleon-complex Rudy's ex campaign manager dumping him for Clinton....  Interesting that the more individuals get to know him, the less they respect and like him.  This, according to reports, is just the opposite of the trend that we see with Clinton.  Not a good sign for Rudy.
Dear Mr. Fix-it,

Please tell all us poor, not close enough folk, exactly who put the fix in, how it's been fixed, and which cabinet post Obama is taking.
I, for one am grateful that I won't have to bother standing in line to vote in the primary or general election, now that I have been told that the outcome is a forgone conclusion, fait accompli, you know, fixed, but other people may still want to waste their time with the whole political process thing.

Why do you believe this? Do you have proof? Is this just a pre-emptive strike at whoever gets the nomination, that they didn't win fair-and-square?
That doesn't seem very sporting of you.
Pay attention to Bill Richardson. He has broad appeal, and would easily defeat any of the Republican candidates.

http://www.richardsonforpresident.com/issues/
tuck,realityville, kansas frankie, why do you advertize that you're ignorant of how the media works?

Oh, we know how the media works.  NY Times, ABC, CBS, NBC, CNN, la dee da, all front for the Democrats.

And yet, big smart tough guy like you can't show one example of the same being done for the Republicans.

Got something?  Show it.

George
Im with you.  Who is this Mark Theme anyway?  Never heard of him.  He's got it all figured doenst he?  Nobody knows this much.
I support Ron Paul and I don't beleive in any FIX.  If anything Dr Paul is getting the short end of the stick.  
Go Ron Paul!!!!!
Mark - One of these days we should have a conversation re: Obama and why you support him.  Unlike many of the overly zealous advocates here, I view you as being reasonable...which may or not be accurate.  :)
Walt Henderson,

The reason it matters is because Iowa representatives usually don't endorse candidates they don't think have a chance. So even though the MSM thinks the race is only between Clinton, Obama and Edwards, the people on the ground know otherwise, which is why Sen. Biden has more endorsements in Iowa from current Iowa legislators than any other candidate.
TJB the politician who best fit the Peter Principle was Dwight Eisenhower he did one thing that was good for the country and that was accidental. He is the father of the Interstate highway system because it would facilitate troop movements, when we became concerned about gold outflow he wanted to restrict the amount of money the military could take off base in foreign countries the pitiful amount we were paid would not even have been felt. He was totally incompetent. His cabinet ran the country his secretary of defense Engine Charlie Wilson  former GM president arranged for us  to reimburse GM for a ball bearing factory in Germany (which we destroyed because it was a former Opel plant. Since he was a war hero the comedians gave him a free ride with the exception of Victor Borge who cracked "I am just like president Eisenhower  when my mind is made up I am a quivering mass of indecision.
Darius... "The highest form of patriotism is dissent"... Thomas Jefferson
Carrie:
Simple answer to the Obama question.  This is my vocation. It is in my personal interest to support him.  He will be a player for a long time if he keeps his hands clean.

I write this stuff because I am appalled at how little the average person is allowed to see of the actual process.  And I do so at some risk.

How can anyone feel truly a part of the process when so much happens behind the curtain?

By the way, "fix" merely refers to political deals made in anticipation of an outcome.  I know nothing about Bushco's vote stealing... knowledge of that could land you in prison.
Mark....You must be SANTA CLAUS! I love my gift!
Who ever I vote for will win the election. I been voting for the best person dem or repub for over 50 years. I have never voted for a looser. I am voting for Hillary next year. So now you know your winner, so forget about it.
Walt Henderson,

The reason it matters is because Iowa representatives usually don't endorse candidates they don't think have a chance. So even though the MSM thinks the race is only between Clinton, Obama and Edwards, the people on the ground know otherwise, which is why Sen. Biden has more endorsements in Iowa from current Iowa legislators than any other candidate.


Well know, thats going to be a real nasty surprise to Biden.  Seems McCarthy had previously endorsed Lieberman back in 2004.  That kind of blows the "not endorsing candidates that don't have a chance argument" out of the water.  Looks like McCarthy endorsed Biden back in 2000 also.  Gore won by a lot.

So again, how does this matter?
Go, Joe!  You've got the goods.  The man with a plan.
Learn the Truth!

www.advertisefree.tv
Darius... "The highest form of patriotism is dissent"... Thomas Jefferson

Rufus - This quote, commonly mis-attributed to Thomas Jefferson, actually belongs to Dorothy Hewitt Hutchinson, a well-known World War II pacifist, who wouldn't tolerate any dissent from her own views about staying out of war.
Hey Frank Winters, my you are an angry fellow.  Here's your refutation from a report on this discount from another news organization:


"There's just one problem. The $65,000 rate is the Times' normal rate for an advocacy ad from a non-profit group, according to newspaper spokeswoman Catherine Mathis."

Walt Henderson:  You state "Well know, thats going to be a real nasty surprise to Biden.  Seems McCarthy had previously endorsed Lieberman back in 2004.  That kind of blows the "not endorsing candidates that don't have a chance argument" out of the water.  Looks like McCarthy endorsed Biden back in 2000 also.  Gore won by a lot.

So again, how does this matter?"

I really doubt that McCarthy endorsed Lieberman, I don't recall Lieberman had any Iowa House or Senate endorsements, he had so little support, despite the BS polls showing him in third in double digits in August, that he withdrew from Iowa in early September of 03.  Biden did not run for any race in 2000, he ran for re-election in 2002, and he ran for President in 1988, so I'm pretty sure that McCarthy didn't endorse Biden in 2000 given he wasn't running for anything, that would have been extremely dumb! I wonder if you are even from Iowa, because you certainly don't know much about the state! If endorsements from Iowa legislators were meaningless candidates would try hard to get them, and wouldn't list them on their websites. Bottom line is Biden has more endorsements from Democrats in the Iowa House and Senate than any other candidate, and that is a sign of support.
Hillary has always waited for the wind to blow before putting her foot down. And it has always been in the direction of the wind. She has never spoken her mind, for fear that she might say something that will drive some voters away. A person like that is not good to lead the country. She will wait for how other countries are doing things and just be a follower, rather than a leader. A leader leads by making their point and are successful in convincing the public to rally behind them. A follower like Hillary just doesn't cut it.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=359242

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google