ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC Political Researcher



Oh-eight (R): The GOP staffer gap

Posted: Thursday, October 11, 2007 9:05 AM by Mark Murray
Filed Under: ,

The Politico's Martin looks at large discrepancy between the number of staffers the leading Dems have in Iowa and New Hampshire versus the leading Republican candidates. In fact, Martin finds the second-tier Democratic candidates have more staffers on the ground in the early states than all of the LEADING GOP candidates. (By the way, considering how little of an organizational advantage Romney may actually have in the first two states, does that mean Thompson can get up to speed in Iowa faster than some believe?)

Writing about Tuesday’s GOP debate, the Washington Post's David Broder notes, "But what was striking about the performance of the leading Republicans was the absence of fresh policy ideas. A listener satisfied with President Bush's economic policies would be safe to assume their continuation -- if any of them wins. But given the economic travail in Michigan, such complacency seemed more than a little odd."

The Boston Globe reports that Giuliani and Romney are treating the campaign as a two-person race because it may best serve both of their agendas. Yesterday, Giuliani "ridiculed Romney for saying during a debate Tuesday that he would consult with lawyers before deciding whether he would need congressional approval to take military action against Iran over its suspected nuclear weapons program. Giuliani's campaign called it a ‘lawyer's test’ for national security, and sought to saddle Romney with a comparison to a former presidential candidate from Massachusetts, Democrat John F. Kerry… Romney's campaign responded by saying Giuliani gave the ‘most muddled and puzzling answer’ to the question of whether a president needs the blessing of Congress when Giuliani said during the debate, ‘it really depends on exigency of the circumstances and how legitimate it is.’”

The AP's Sidoti also writes on the Rudy-Romney spat.

The Los Angeles Times looks at whether the line-item veto fight between the two men is a worthy one. "Some voters may see the fight as turning on an arcane point of budgeting, but among the Republican faithful, the veto power is seen by many as a litmus test for candidates' commitment to smaller government."

BROWNBACK
: “Brownback said Wednesday he will drop out of the race for president if he finishes lower than fourth place in the Iowa caucuses,” the AP writes. “The Kansas senator had previously said he would consider ending his campaign for the GOP nomination if he could not finish in the top four. Brownback made the comments while fielding questions in a live Internet discussion on washingtonpost.com.”

GIULIANI: Is Giuliani a conservative or a centrist? A former aide to Giuliani (and Bill Clinton in '96), John Avlon, claims in his book "Independent Nation" that Giuliani is a centrist governing figure similar to Clinton. Avlon does work on Giuliani's campaign now. "A Giuliani campaign spokeswoman stressed that Avlon's book doesn't reflect the campaign's views or the candidate's."

The campaign is up with a new radio ad in Iowa, with Giuliani saying: “Democrats want to move in the direction of much bigger government, socialized medicine, increasing government regulation, much higher taxes. They are making the promise to raise taxes, the only thing I can tell you in addition to that is that they’ll raise taxes even more then they promised. They want to take more of the people’s money. I want to give the people back more of their own money, because I know that’s going to create more jobs for us.”

MCCAIN: Per excerpts his campaign provided, McCain will say this when unveiling his health-care plan today: “Has any candidate insisted that genuine and effective health care reform requires accountability from everyone: drug companies, insurance companies, doctors, hospitals, the government and patients? Democratic presidential candidates are not telling you these truths. They offer their usual default position: If the government would only pay for insurance everything would be fine. They promise universal coverage, whatever its cost, and the massive tax increases, mandates and government regulation that it imposes. I offer a genuinely conservative vision for health care reform, which preserves the most essential value of American lives -- freedom.”

More from McCain: “We must reform the health care system to make it responsive to the needs of American families. Not the government. Not the insurance companies. Not tort lawyers. Not even the doctors and hospitals.” 

The New York Times adds, “Like other Republican presidential candidates this year, Mr. McCain is focusing on market-based solutions for problems in the health care industry. But he is also placing a much greater emphasis than any of his opponents on judging the performance of doctors. Measuring such performance could prove controversial, which Mr. McCain acknowledged. But he said that without measuring their performance, particularly in treating chronic ailments like diabetes and heart disease, it would be impossible to cut wasteful spending.”

McCain pre-taped with Iowa Press yesterday. Asked about Iran, he said that some experts predict the rogue nation could reach "a tipping point" to go nuclear in a mere two years. "If that's the case, it could trigger scenarios which could be very dangerous. And I'm not predicting military action on the part of the Israelis or the United States of America, but what I am saying is that this administration's policy, and I agree with it, that it is unacceptable for the Iranians to have a nuclear weapon. And the Israelis have stated basically the same thing." Read local guru Kay Henderson's blog about it here.

ROMNEY: Per the New York Times, "A prominent evangelical supporter of Mitt Romney has written a memorandum to 150 conservative Christian leaders, warning of the prospect of Rudolph W. Giuliani or Hillary Rodham Clinton in the White House and making the case to rally around Mr. Romney. The writer, Mark DeMoss, a publicity agent whose clients include the Rev. Franklin Graham, wrote the five-page letter, urging the recipients to ‘galvanize support around Mitt Romney, so Mr. Giuliani isn’t the unintended beneficiary of our divided support among several candidates.’ … The letter is arriving in mailboxes as clashes between Mr. Romney and Mr. Giuliani have stepped up."

NBC/NJ's Memoli notes that Ann Romney seemed to take personally Thompson’s "actor" barb in Tuesday’s GOP debate, in which the former "Law & Order" star responded to a joke by Mitt Romney by hinting that he has not been a reliable conservative. "And to think, I thought I was going to be the best actor on this stage," Thompson said. In an interview Wednesday, Ann Romney called that idea "just utterly false." "He is a man of such principle and such conviction," Romney said. "It's ironic to me too because he was always personally pro-life. ... And so for people to say he's acting on those things is ridiculous."

Romney’s “trooper,” Jay Garrity, is safe from a New Hampshire investigation.

THOMPSON: The campaign cited personal reasons for cancelling a trip to New Hampshire this week.

But the decision is likely to spark speculation that Thompson may end up downplaying his chances in the Granite State and instead focus on Iowa and South Carolina.

Bloomberg News reports, “Republican presidential candidate Fred Thompson reported assets worth as much as $8.6 million as well as millions more in salaries and residual payments last year from acting jobs including his role on television's ‘Law and Order.’”

Per NBC/NJ’s Adam Aigner-Treworgy, Thompson picked up two new congressional endorsements yesterday from Oklahoma’s Sen. James Inhofe and Rep. John Sullivan. The Thompson campaign was quick to point out that Oklahoma will be one of more than 20 states voting on February 5. 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

The Republicans are incapable of coming up with "FRESH IDEAS" because they insist on pandering to 30% of the population why do you think they keep trying to resurrect Reagan.
GOP isn't wasting its time in Iowa.  There are other much more important states to deal with at this time.
No doubt about it, the "party of ideas" has nothing new, and their old ideas are falling flat with the public.
No doubt about it, the "party of ideas" has nothing new, and their old ideas are falling flat with the public.
John B, Des Moines, IA (Sent Thursday, October 11, 2007 9:55 AM)

That's right John, when will the DEMS get it together?
The republican party has come up with new never before ideas. Ignor the constitution. Invade and occupy another country for oil. Torcher. Lie and cover up. And their newest idea is to end the middle class.
Most of the public has woken up to the fact that today's Republicans are toxic for the country and its future.  Their war for oil is failing, the war on terror is a self-perpetuating joke (just like their war on drugs), and they've manged to spend our money to the point that our children's children will still be paying for this monumental failure called George W. Bush.
Shawn L- I second that!
Hey Blue state baby, "Ignor," "Torcher?"  Your not doing your party any favors by murdering English.  You might want to not paint all Republicans with such a broad brush either. To pigeon hole people based upon preconceived notions of what they are or are not is a form ignorance/prejudice, is it not? I would bet that if most people who call themselves Democrat or Republican could have a constructive dialogue, they  would find they hold more values in common than they think. I believe the movers and shakers of both parties have moved the core away from the center.  Its time for a third party candidate.    
Ideas are for sissies, the rebums have one idea only, govern by fear and everyone shuts up. Rudy told an audience that the terrorist hate us, well duh. Was he trying to inform us, no he was trying to scare us.
Stating the obvious is now a replacement for ideas. Rudy, Mitt and others can't run away from the white house just yet and having new ideas might confuse their base. The only people that think this party is has ideas also beleive Vince Foster was murdered, George Bush is a demi-god, Dick Cheney is sane and that they will win with hanging chads again.
Richard:  Don't complain about liguistic malfeasance when you use "your" as a contraction for "you are". Or is that how they do it in Idahoe? (The latter is Dan Quayle's spelling of your great state).
As usual the news industry ignores the most consistent and knowledgeable candidate, the Honorable Ron Paul. Pathetic propaganda is the news industry agenda of trying to control the elections. Vote Ron Paul for President.
First allow me to say that the current administration is likely the most reprehensible in the memory of most people.  The front runners for the Republican nomination  seem to want to offer more of the same.  However, before we all jump to support one of the leading Democratic nominees, let's first see if they are talking a different game.  Have any of them said they will end the debacle in Iraq?  No.  Have any of them said they will repeal the threats to our civil liberties know as the Patriot Act? No. (In fact Obama and Clinton voted for it.) Have any of them promised to curb the runaway spending that is causing our dollar to lose ground against all other foreign currencies? No. In fact they propose to increase spending.  So, why the hell just follow them because they are different.  Why not support someone who is actually talking a different game.  So far the only person I've seen do that is Ron Paul.
Richard in Idaho-I agree with you 100% that we need a third party ASAP;however;I do not see that happening anytime soon. The problem with the Republicans in the Congress and the canidates is that they have voted as a rubber stamp for Bush for years and have allowed and ignored the historical mess that is Iraq, record budget deficits that equal all 42 previous administrations combined. The Republicans have been hijacked by the neocons(former Scoop Jackson's proteges) like Wolforwitz who insisted on dramatically altering the Middle East by removing the dictator Sadam who by the way was our dictator in the 80's when Rummy and Cheney were shaking his hands and giving him all WMD'S to fight Iran inorder to assist with what the powerful Israel lobby and Lakud party wanted. Add to that the evil machievellian Karl Rove The Shrub's brain who basically stated to kowtow only to your religious fanatical base and 911 fear statics that gave them the win 2004. The Republicans I believe have surrendered their so-called fiscal conservative mantel and strong on defense because they have become the party of WIN AT ALL COST. Only a few like Hagel had the guts to speak out. Hopefully, more will stop shinning the shoes of THE DECIDER.
Giuliani is the worst. He is inflexible, has an anger problem, no family values and acts like a dictator. I lived in New York during his 8 years in office. Throw in his wife Queen Judith we would never know who would be in charge of the country.
The religious radical extremist Republicans (not all Repubs are radical extremists) remind me of the joke about a man trying to seduce a woman who was know to have rather loose morals.  When he finally offered a big sum of money she asked, "What do you think I am?" and he replied, "I've already established what you are.  I'm just trying to find out your price".  So, the religious radical extremists, too have a price.  They will vote for a man who thinks a woman should have a right to choose, a man who thinks marriage is between two people, whether they be heterosexual or homosexual,  and not subject to legislation, a man who believes stem cell research is a positive area of research not to be denied - all these things and more are acceptable to these folks who claim to carry the Moral High Ground - they will accept anything from their candidate if he can just beat Hillary Clinton!  Morals be damned.  Beat Hillary.  Their hypocrisy knows no limits.  They, too, are the ones so anxious to bomb anyone who does not agree with them, e.g., Iran, and before them, Iraq!  Unbelievable how so many of the American people do not search for facts and simply swallow the garbage (Iraq was behind 9/11, they had WMD, and on and on) this administartion puts out.  They believe Bush when he piously vowed he would be a uniter and not a divider.  I don't know of any President in our history who has been so DELIBERATELY divisive.  He thumbs his nose at the Congress, the Constitution, and ultimately the American people.  
The end is near for the neocon hoard
And George W. Bush, their unholy Lord
And Herr Karl Rove, whom is much hated
For being Goering, reincarnated.
And also Cheney, with hateful glare
Who can a Basilisk outstare
All three will fall in deep disgrace
Never again to regain their place
And the rest of true believers all
Will be included in their fall
Yes, all shall perish in the flames
Of deep disgrace upon their names
America will once again be free
The shining beacon for all to see
Our pride restored, our spirits healed
After the lies have been revealed
And let's not forget the last detail
Be sure to send them all to jail...

Thank you, and Amen.

juan,ft lauderdale,fl:

In 1984 Reagan was re-elected winning every state except Minnesota, which he lost by less than 2 tenths of a percent.  The idea that Republicans try to resurrect Reagan while "pandering" to 30% of the population is contradictory.  

What you think are fresh ideas of the Democrats is nothing new.  It's called socialism and it's been tried before.  
Hey 'Richard in Idaho'....talk about murdering the English language?  Last time I checked, it's "you're" not "your" for the first word here--

"Your not doing your party any favors by murdering English."




The Republican party is nothing but Russians undercover. They like corruption, they partake into causing people harm who disagree with them. It like the old Soviet Union. It is their way or the highway.
I don't beleive anything a republican says, on the war, economy, nothing they can they I will not  believe them at all.  
 If the American people vote for another Republican to run the country, something is wrong.    
Wow! $8,600,000 a year ought to be enough to keep an old country boy like Fred Thompson in chawing t'backey for quite a while.
All Hail Dick Cheney. The 'Real' President.
My father is a life long Republican.  His father believed almost every wrong in this society was traceable directly to FDR.  Even at that Dad recognizes the GOP is waging war on the middle class and talks of how the entire country is being made poor at the expense of those in power.
H R Cousen, Did you mean linguistic in place of "liguistic?"
Look to Ron Paul for change and new ideas!
all the republicans scare me except for ron paul.They are holding so tight to Georges coattails he just might straighten that slouch up.
H R Cousen Brunswick Maine:


malfeasance  
 
Pronunciation:  mal-fē-zən(t)s
Function: noun
Etymology: mal- + obsolete feasance doing, execution
Date: 1696
: wrongdoing or misconduct especially by a public official

Your improper use of the word "malfeasance" to me is torcher.  Or is that how they do it in Maine?
H R Cousen, if I were you, I would take your own sage advice about "liguistic malfeasance."  You need to try and commit fewer spelling errors yourself.  Or is that really how they spell "linguistic" in Maine?

Pot, meet Kettle.  Kettle, this is Pot.  And H R, have a fun time meeting with Richard and Blue state baby at your dsyelxia club.

(Yes, the spelling of dyslexia was intentional.)
Ron Paul has no problem getting boots-on-the ground, nationwide.
He has 60,000 registered volunteers on meetup.com. Obama has 4,000.
Maybe the rest of the GOP candidates should learn a lesson, "Freedom is Popular."
My advice to Republicans to avoid embarrassment and shame is too simply declare yourselves an "independent". Otherwise you will be in a position of defending the indefensible. The total degradation of our Country since Viet Nam.
A. Taxpayer: Who gives a rat's ass about Reagan? The senile bastard is dead! Get it! The second part of his presidency did not happened--he was too old to remember it. Remember the Iran-Contra deal? The idiot said he did not remember it! Who knows what the hell happened in the oval office while he was passed out at his desk!
Hey Blue state baby, "Ignor," "Torcher?"  Your not doing your party any favors by murdering English.  You might want to not paint all Republicans with such a broad brush either. To pigeon hole people based upon preconceived notions of what they are or are not is a form ignorance/prejudice, is it not? I would bet that if most people who call themselves Democrat or Republican could have a constructive dialogue, they  would find they hold more values in common than they think. I believe the movers and shakers of both parties have moved the core away from the center.  Its time for a third party candidate.    
Richard in Idaho (Sent Thursday, October 11, 2007 10:40 AM)

"Your" in your first sentence about murdering English should be "You're" since it is a contraction for "You are".
A Taxpayer-I suggest you forgo on your social security if and/when you retire as well as Medicare as it was started by FDR'S NEW DEAL and you seem to think that it is Socialism. Reagan left the biggest deficit until The Shrub. Just because Reagan won in a landslide considering that this man cut federally funded education money that was going to the inner city resulting in me losing my  first job out of college as a sixth grade teacher; he was too busy insisting that ketchup is a vegetable and trees cause pollution. Furthermore, American's earnings have declined tremendously on par with the Great Depression, becoming now the biggest debtor nation ever, and you talk about right wing spinmeister talking points. I guess the current Socialist led governments of Chile and Spain have got it wrong? Yeah! we owe the Communist Chinese goverment who fronted us billions of dollars to fight our oil war in Iraq so we Americans can drive SUV'S. Spare me the right wing platitutes which have been re-cyled since the hoola hoop was invented.  
Baby State Blues sentiments are very clear and absolutely 100% on target. In case there is any confusion....the Bush regime has ignored the tenants set forth in the Constitution whenever that document gets in the way of the continual power grab by the current administration.  Secondly, it is now appearing as though the disgraced former United States Attorney General Alberto Conzales approved various methods of torture in clear violation of not only the Geneva Agreements, but the very fabric that defines the civilty of the United States. Torture that even the neocon Sen. John McCain finds deplorable and has continually stated, yields bad/faulty or no real intelligence. One doesn't have to be an English major to clearly state the utter corruptness and incompetence of George W. Bush and his regime.
The Republican Debate taught me two things:  You can get attention if you run on the following two issues:

1)  FEAR
2)  MONEY

Went to school with a guy named "Ignor Torcher".  Russian.  Nice guy.
Richard: Not using proper structure and English is much worst then mispelling. You're murdering English.
Wheres Ron Paul on that list??? Media slacking again.
"GOP isn't wasting its time in Iowa.  There are other much more important states to deal with at this time."


Amen! States with corrupt Secs. of State to make sure Democratic voters are struck from the records and not provided voting machines, allow GOP operatives at the voters' confidential records, turn a blind eye to districts with more over-votes for the GOP candidate than there are voters in that district - MUCH more important states!

A. Taxpayer: It's called "Fascism," and it's been tried before.
Brian, that was great, I loved it!
Does anyone realize that it was Dick Cheney who was behind most of the cover-up activities in the Iran-Contra mess and that his recorded opinions at the time included believing Richard Nixon didn't fight Congress enough and should have usurped more presidential power, and that he is NOW using the services of an Iran-Contra arms dealer to report on any negotiations between Iranian officials and the US ambassador to Iraq?  Just a little to mull over while you get ready to pull the lever for those who are just itching to expand the powers of the Patriot Act.
I know someone missed a comma somewhere.  To whoever you are:  It's OK
Blue state baby:

Do not let these folks intimidate you.
You do not have to pass a spelling test in order to cast your vote.
Yes sir, even uneducated twits get to vote.  What a country!
Hmm. Looks like the ''Money and Greed''people are at it again I see. Except this time they are Democrats. ROLL CALL has now been able to at least make some sense of the massive fencing operation now being played out in the case of a singular company to the tune of over 100 million dollars of your dough,and that this operation only involves three people. To wit:

Jack Murtha[D-Pa]
Jim Moran [D-Va]
Pete Visclosky[D-In]

         Here's the scam. These three guys direct over 100 million to the Murtha -backed PMA Corp. Then they have billionare Californians funnel money to locations in Virginia and Indiana,[both of which just happen to be in Moran and Viscloskys districts],which is placed in PMA coffers which comes back as campaign funding to all three legislators. In return for their largesse,the Tinseltown billionares are steered millions in taxpayer dough by Murtha for ''yoga,crystal and magnet homeopathic research'',with the so-called ''PMA Junta''casting affirmative votes for the funding of such BS.
       Not wanting to be left out in the cold, Sylvestre Reyes[D-NM],who will be recalled as the Chairman of the House ''Intelligence''Committee who cannot tell Shia from Sunni,places his son on a fundraising PAC which lo and behold,is tied to PMA. Reyes is now watching the dough flow in.
          ROLL CALL has been in contact with federal investigators  who are ''preparing an extensive investigation of these activities and are seeking criminal fraud and corruption indictments''.
           Thus do the Democrats erect Potemkin villages for the insult of our intelligence. The ''swamp''that was ''drained''by Pelosi is now the Atlantic Ocean. The idea that ''greed'' and ''money'' and the influence of the ''corporate'' are the sole provinces of the GOP has been exposed as a sham and a lie. The party of several on these boards are engaged in graft,fraud,corruption,and the blatant ripoff of billions of their taxpayer dollars paid to favoured pet campaign contributors. While they chant the dubious mantras of ''change'',there is damned little of it to be found in a Washington that has been in congresional control by the Democrats for nearly a year. Heh. You guys merely traded Willie Sutton for Al Capone.

Also see: The Center for Responsive Politics www.opensecrets.org

ROLL CALL [non-partisan magazine covering political events and issues] www.rollcall.com
This country would greatly benefit from a viable third political party. The bipartisan bickering is undermining progress (political and otherwise) in this country. Although I think Ron Paul is way off track and do not agree with virtually every position he holds (sorry Paulites), I do think his anti-establishment sentiments need to be voiced. I find it difficult to believe that all of county's ideas and values can be boiled down to the platforms of our two major political parties.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=406994

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google