ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Oh-eight (D): Obama targets Bill?

Posted: Tuesday, October 16, 2007 9:13 AM by Mark Murray
Filed Under:

The new USA/Today Gallup poll has Clinton leading the Dem field at 50%, followed by Obama at 21%, Edwards at 13%, and Richardson at 4%.

CLINTON: She launched her second ad in South Carolina “focusing on her plan to make college more affordable and preschool available to all children.”

OK, if this isn't an example of micro-targeting, then we don't know what is. Former Young and the Restless star Victoria Powell is stumping in Iowa on behalf of Clinton. She was in Waterloo over the weekend.

You never know when one of these stories gets legs. The Hill reports on how some Republicans are seizing on a buried allegation in the Gerth/Van Natta Clinton book that she listened to an illegally obtained recording of Clinton critics during the '92 campaign. “Gerth told The Hill that he learned of the incident in 2006 when he interviewed a former campaign aide present at the tape playing. He has not revealed the aide’s identity. Clinton’s campaign has not disputed any facts reported in the final version of his book, which became public this spring, he said. ‘It hasn’t been challenged,’ said Gerth. ‘There hasn’t been one fact in the book that’s been challenged.’”

EDWARDS: On getting the endorsement of 10 local SEIU chapters, Edwards said, “We will have people and organizers and support for what we’re trying to do here. No one will out-organize us in Iowa.”

OBAMA: Obama is now going after the OTHER Clinton, NBC/NJ’s Aswini Anburajan reports. At a rally in Madison, Wisconsin yesterday, Obama said, “We've had enough of ... triangulation and poll-driven politics. That's not what we need right now.” The triangulation term was coined during the Clinton Administration, when advisers to the president urged him to split the difference between opposing views in policy proposals.

This isn’t the first time that Obama has referred to the “other” Clinton. Just two weeks ago in New Hampshire, Obama quoted Bill Clinton to prove that too much experience in Washington is a bad thing.  “The same old experience is not relevant… And you can have the right kind of experience and the wrong kind of experience,” Obama told the crowd in Concord, adding in his punch line that this was a quote from when Bill Clinton was running for office in 1992.

The rhetoric directed towards the Clintons from Obama has increased, Anburajan adds, and the distinctions he’s drawing are not just issue-based. In Newton, Iowa on Oct. 12, Obama told the crowd, “There are other candidates in this race who are a lot more cautious, they will poll every questions in this race before the say a word.” And the next day at the Sisters on Target Dinner in Des Moines, Obama said, “I'm not going to win just by being the most calculating politician in this race.”

The Chicago Sun-Times also reports on Obama railing against “triangulation.”

The Boston Globe's Derrick Jackson writes, "The first-in-the-nation Iowa caucuses have emerged as perhaps the only chance for Obama or any other candidate to stop Hillary Clinton's nomination."

The Chicago Tribune does the "how Obama's ground game is different from Dean's ground game in '04" story.

The Quad Cities Times, meanwhile, looks at Obama's religious outreach. "Beyond the forums, the campaign stages a weekly interfaith prayer conference call, runs a "People of Faith for Barack" Web site and has a page on FaithBase.com, a social networking site modeled on Facebook and MySpace.”

Also, a Chicago Trib reporter was booted from Michelle Obama's London fundraiser yesterday.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Hillary Clinton will be the first women President in the United States. hillaryclinton.com  , take a lookie.
There are so many people who want to vote for Hillary just because they liked Bill, when honestly, Obama is clearly the better decision. We need new blood in the political arena and Obama will get us there. He has hated this war from the beginning and has a wonderful plan for change.
Janice Hill, Spokane, Wa. (Sent Tuesday, October 16, 2007 9:24 AM) / 'Hillary Clinton will be the first women President in the United States. hillaryclinton.com  , take a lookie.'


very original, with those writing skills one wonders why you have not written a novel or something, possibly about processed meat in a can.
I wonder what the calculated risk was for Obama not to vote on the Iran resolution a couple weeks ago.  Say what you want about Hillary, at least she has the guts to vote on a resolution and not fear what people will say.  The same with Biden and Dodd.  At least they voted Obama.  The excuse that he was campaigning is ridiculous, because Hillary, Biden and Dodd were campaigning too and some how found a way to get back to DC to vote.

The new poll shows that the voters are warming up to Hillary once they find out more about her and realize the right wing hit machine is just spewing the same lies from 1993-1999.  The fact that Obama and Edwards are now trying to repeat the same lies and talking points of the republicans is just sad.  Instead of telling us what they would do, they now just bash hillary every chance they get.  Hillary remains above the hate and just keeps telling the people what she will do as President.  That is why she is crushing these guys in the latest poll.  

I know the Edwards and Obama people will jump on the poll and say you can't believe the polls, but each time a new poll comes out Hillary gets stronger.  If they didn't believe the polls, then Edwards and Obama would not be attacking her at every turn.

Next October, Bill Clinton will win the Nobel Peace Prize for his Global Initiative and next November, Hillary will be our next President.  All of you Hillary haters will have to deal with it.  If you're a Democrat and you say you wont vote for Clinton no matter what, then please change your registration to something other than a Democrat.  We don't want you.  Once she gets the nomination, all Democrats need to come together and support our nominee and I would say that for any of the democratic candidates.  
My problem with Hillary is the sociopathic personality that simply can never be trusted; example George W. Bush.  A sociopath has no conscience, can say or do anything without guilt, is capable of faking most anything, is dishonest yet often impressive, is totally self-indulgent and egotistic, can be very arrogant, has no shortage of nerve and is without humility.  As we have seen over the last seven years, a dangerous combination that offers little real value.
What's the sample size of this poll?
Took a look a hillary.com.  Now there is a virus on my computer.  The computer won't work and the fan keeps whining.  I think its the liberal virus.
Democrats howl when President Bush is using wiretapping to root out suspected terrorists, yet they stay quiet when Hillary Clinton (allegedly) is listening inside the United States to her husband's political enemies....

Sounds like there should be a federal investigation into this allegation.  How do we know Hillary won't be pulling a Nixon in the White House?
REG, Stop watching Fox News.

The Right calls her a socialist liberal and the Left calls her a facist who is just like Bush.  If you getting it from both sides, you are probably the best candidate for the majority of us who are in the middle.  
Michelle Obama goes to a top secret dinner in London to raise funds.......

What is with the democrats and all their secrets lately?
Jerry - if she did what's being alleged, it's not a crime. What Nixon - tape recording conversations - was not a crime either.  The Watergate cover up he was part of that was revealed on the tapes...that was the crime.  So your analogy is fatally flawed...as is your faith in your man Rudy and any other rethuglican.
Oh, and Obama's criticism of Hillary vote on the Iran resolution is wholly disingenuous since he was even there to vote on it! I agree with her vote and so does many Americans.
I agree jerry, all domestic spying should be investigated. It has a long history in both parties and goes back to J. Edgar Hoover who had dossiers on all the politicians and used it to blackmail them into keeping him in office and giving him what he wanted for the FBI.
This is to 'whomever' who says for those who will not vote for Hillary if she's the nominee to change their party, I say NO I'm not.  I WILL NOT VOTE FOR HILLARY NOR WILL I CHANGE MY PARTY!!
If you really care about your privacy and liberty, Hillary Clinton cannot be trusted.

Remenber what she said about Scooter Libby to Chris Matthew.

Here an interesting article about Clinton dirty game.

http://thehill.com/leading-the-news/gop-targeting-clinton-on-phone-call-snooping-2007-10-16.html
Jerry - Rudy was raising funds in London a couple months back, so I guess that disqualifies him for President in your eyes.
Pat, Huntington, Ny / 'Oh, and Obama's criticism of Hillary vote on the Iran resolution is wholly disingenuous since he was even there to vote on it! I agree with her vote and so does many Americans.'

doesn't it trouble you that those 'many americans' you speak of are all war mongering neo-cons? kind of makes a statement about hillary's true allegiance doesn't it?  
Pat...yes it was a crime

GOP targeting Clinton on phone-call snooping

Republicans are focusing on an allegation in a recent book by two Pulitzer Prize-winning reporters, which suggests Clinton listened to a secretly recorded conversation between political opponents.

In their book about Clinton’s rise to power, Her Way, Don Van Natta Jr., an investigative reporter at The New York Times, and Jeff Gerth, who spent 30 years as an investigative reporter at the paper, wrote: “Hillary’s defense activities ranged from the inspirational to the microscopic to the down and dirty. She received memos about the status of various press inquiries; she vetted senior campaign aides; and she listened to a secretly recorded audiotape of a phone conversation of Clinton critics plotting their next attack.

“The tape contained discussions of another woman who might surface with allegations about an affair with Bill,” Gerth and Van Natta wrote in reference to Clinton’s husband, former President Bill Clinton. “Bill’s supporters monitored frequencies used by cell phones, and the tape was made during one of those monitoring sessions.”

It’s been clear that since 1986 it was illegal to intercept an individual cell phone call,” said Barry Steinhardt, the director of the technology and liberty program at the American Civil Liberties Union

http://thehill.com/leading-the-news/gop-targeting-clinton-on-phone-call-snooping-2007-10-16.html


Looks like some of it was spent keeping track of Bill...LOL

BTW they have not denied any of it so far.
If I had a recording from my critics--legal or not legal--I would listen to it.  I don't think it's a bad thing to do, it's human and smart.  I think these accusations can only have base if Hillary can be tied to the obtaining of the illegal recording.  They can't do that, so that story should be moot.

I hardly think that warrants a headline of B. Obama targets Bill?  Did he mention the Clinton's by name?  Anyway, I think it is another example of B. Obama borrowing from J. Edwards who has been talking about no triangulation for a long time.  Obama's not good at being critical of his opponents (which I don't feel is a bad thing), which Edwards is better--not malicious, but better.  But as Iowa approaches, he is using those strategies to try to set him apart from Clinton.

--StopWatchingFauxNews: Yes, democrats (25% of voters) will support any democratic nominee for president.  But they will need equal in numbers of independents to win.  I think that partisan democrats (a group said yesterday to support Clinton) will think about this when it comes to the polls on January 3rd?
I don't watch Fox but I have watched Hillary and have read a lot of books like 'The Sociopath Next Door' and have a degree in psychology - she fits the mold very precisely (as does George W.)!
For what it's worth, I was at the Obama fundraiser in London last night - far from being secretive it was open to any American voter who could pay $100 (or $50 for students) as well as the high dollar donors. And Michelle did an advance interview to a major UK paper. But there was a large-ish scrum of press hanging around outside shoving cameras in all of our faces - it was pretty intimidating.

Michelle gave what I am told is her standard stump speech then answered some questions - the most interesting of which was when she was asked about the kind of first lady she wants to be and she talked about the difficulties of being a professional woman, how society tells women to reach for the stars but then leaves them to fend for themselves without childcare or decent public schools. She was very heartfelt and down-to-earth but not at all controversial (in fact, Hillary was talking about some of the same things in her book It Takes a Village, though her first pass at the White House doesn't seem to have fixed any of those problems).
Jimmyhill, that is hilarious.
Hillary is tough and experienced.  The way she dodges questions without answering. Can you believe she was first lady.  She avoided doing anything of substance during that time, yet look at her now.  People still buy her cow dung.  She can fool people.  She polarizes.  She is hard to like.  She deceives.  All the characteristics of what America seems to prefer in the Office.
NO MORE BUSHS/CLINTONS................End This War!!
NO MORE REPUBLICANS/CLINTONS..........End This War!!

Clinton uses the politics of hope statement to avoid interaction or answering questions. Thanks again for addressing this.

OBAMA/EDWARSD '08.
Obama can bring this country together.  This is what we need.  No more polarizing figures who will divide and keep dividing this country.

WHAT WE NEED IS CHANGE, AND OBAMA IS THE MAN TO DO IT!! HE HAS STOOD BEHIND ALL THAT HE HAS STATED, HE DOES NOT FLIP FLOP JUST TO GET THE SIDES OF THE AUDIENCE. BARACK DEMOSTRATES HIS INTELLIGENCE & JUDGMENT BY STATING THE OBVIOUS.

Hillary Clinton, 15 years of dishonesty, scandals and divisiveness.

Don't nominate someone that doesn't have a chance in the general election.
END 15 YEARS OF DARKNESS AND CORRUPTION
NO MORE BUSHS/CLINTONS................End This War!!
NO MORE REPUBLICANS/CLINTONS..........End This War!!


Best Ticket: OBAMA/EDWARDS '08

OBAMA/EDWARDS '08


The GOP want Hillary to win. They are scared to death of Obama. Hillary is the only dem running that will invigorate the GOP base to come out and vote for anyone but Hillary.

The GOP controls the media, This is why the media has already crowned Hillary has the nominee. Even though no one will vote for another 3 months. Don't you love how the media and corporate America have already chosen our leaders for us. And because most people are sheep, they will always vote for who the media is calling the winner.

Obama is the only one running that has a chance to beat the Hillary/GOP machine. And it scares the hell outta the rich money hungry slime that have always ran this country. This is why they are still attacking Obama and not Hillary.

Isn't about time the lower & middle class(97%) take this country back the rich(%3)?

GO OBAMA 08

Yes, I am white gen X :)
OK, all free advertisement in cable news and print media and online outlets of MSM helps Clinton to a huge extent to save her campaign money from spending. But still she is a hardsell to half of the country because her unfavorable rating is so high. All those free advertisement still can not create a commanding lead for her in IOWA. MSM, in today's day and age, you can not make all people fool all the time. You can make some people fool sometime.

She speaks from all sides of her mouth. She says on thing on media, other on private. She thinks presidential candidates should think big inside their head but can not share those with people even when he/she will represent the people and act on their behalf. She condemn Bush on secrecy yet her 93 healthcare failed effort was done in closed door. Her senate ear mark, tax returns, documents from first lady period, Bill's financial contributors to establish his library: ALL ARE LOCKED in safe box. I wonder if there is nothing to hide, why someone would hide documents. She thinks she is running on her own. But again "I want african american community to feel when I am president, it's another Clinton presidency". So it's Bill Clinton's 3rd term with Hillary on front? She votes part of an Iranian army as terrorist. And then she is preparing for diplomacy or she does not know how Iran operates. Well if you don't know Hillary, how do you know calling Iran's IRG will help you advance diplomacy with them. On that same ground, each and every country can call US army same for invading or occupying Iraq for 5 years. But I guess people know that US Army is just carrying order of civilian leadership. So is Iran's IRG. Negotiate with their government who are in charge of IRG instead of name calling. This woman is all about her political ambition, relentess pursuit of power and dynasty. 300 million people have much more to worry about then sacrificing a nation's future to the personal ambition of one extremely partisan, power hungry woman.
I know America people are idiots, they can't read let alone undertsand who is fit to be their leader. As long as i am alive, i'll continue to traingulte and decieve the American people.
Going after Bill Clinton is proof that Obama is not ready for primetime. By not voting on the Iran resolution just shows how much of a wuss he really is. Hillary will be the first female POTUS.
Anyone who says the GOP want Hillary to win because they think they can beat her easily needs to get in touch with reality!  Rudy Giuliani is extremely nervous about Hillary and so are Republicans in general.  

Afraid of Obama?  I don't think so.  Afraid of John Edwards?  I don't think so.

The Democrats have one candidate who is leaving all the others far behind.  And she will be our next President and God how women around the world will celebrate!

TO:  Stopwatchingfoxnews, Rochester, NY and Pat, Huntington, NY

I also was upset that Obama missed the vote on Iran, only to learn that he was in Congress when the vote was originally supposed to happen.  Reid postponed the vote without giving a future date.  Conveniently, when Obama was away campaigning, Reid brought the vote up, not giving Obama enough time to get back.  Instead, Obama gave his opinion that he would have voted NO if he could have been there.  It's pretty well known that Reid and Hillary Clinton are good friends.  Convenient no?  Anyway, I don't think it's fair to criticize Obama when he did everything he could to be there to vote and let America know where he stands. If you don't like him, fine, but criticize him for something he had control of.
Pat:  Thank you for supporting President Bush and the eavesdropping of people.  Since you support Hillary wiretapping her husband's enemies, maybe I'll see you on Fox News outside the courthouse holding your FREE HILLARY sign LOL.
MK your girly claws are showing again. Or is it you despise woman, or both?
Bill Clinton is not immune in this campaign. Nobody says anything when he was the Attacking in Chief to clinton campaign. I am sure he will like to have those days back.

Obama is right to point to his triangulation as a means of scoring political point.

I am not interested in triangulation anymore, i want fundermental change. If Democrats don't see this coming then, they must be naive. Republican will use all clinton dirty baggage to win the election again.

It is time to change the ways of whashington that doesn't work for American people.
know America people are idiots, they can't read let alone undertsand who is fit to be their leader. As long as i am alive, i'll continue to traingulate and decieve the American people ....hahahahahaha

Hillary is my darling, i can't wait to get to white house. I am sure the fine ass intern will be waiting for me. Perhaps, Venom Jordan has all those ladies ready. I like them plump and juicy...No blonde please.

jonnyraygun, yea, and Hillary is going to win.
I actually like the fox news channel but i don't like their coverage on Monica Lewinsky. They were not been fair at that point in time; however, since they are supporting my wife for Presidency i don't have a problem with Rupert Mudorch.

These "polls" are a joke, pay no attention to them, learn as much as you can about the candidates and base your vote on what you consider to be important.
Does anyone know someone who has actually participated in one of these polls?  
If you vote Democrat, you my friend, are a complete idiot.
I am a big fat ignorant slob man, who doesn't work and is a right wing republican. I have no friends so I go on this website all day and insult and criticize because I know my party is in the crapper. I am totally in love with Mitt because he's the hottest man running and I fantasize about what I would like to do to him. I hate woman and especially strong, intelligent ones because they make my pee pee shrink and remind me of my controlling and abusive mommy.I hate Hillary because she scares me.
"Victoria Powell is stumping in Iowa on behalf of Clinton. She was in Waterloo over the weekend."

No tid bit is too small for MSNBC to seize on to promote Hillary Clinton. Barack Obama has this year's academy award best actor winner stumping for him, and it gets no coverage here, but a soap opera "star" stumps for Hillary Clinton and it's 'news at 11.'
I have to leave now folks. I'm on my way back to the psychiatric hospital for an overnight stay. I'll try to keep in touch. Love ya.
Obama not voting on the Iran resolution just proves that humans can't be in two places at the same time.  He is fighting an uphill battle for the presidency shouldn't he be talking to voters, like he was?
Jerry is Bill Clinton now. Ohh, maybe he does secretly fantasize about Hillary. Jerry, you bad boy!Now we know why you obsess about her so much.
I think Sen. Obama's comments about "triangulation," "old experience" and who is the "most calculating" politician are the kind of thing that is too subtle to register with most of the public. Most people are not paying close attention yet. Rather than veiled comments directed at Sen. Clinton, Sen. Obama needs to do more to tell us where he would like to take the country if he is elected, and he needs to do it in a way that is covered adequately by the media.  
REG, you must go back to school. It appears you don't know shit from shinola about psychology. If you think that Hillary Clinton is a sociopath, you are incredibly ignorant about psychology. George Bush is also not a sociopath although he shows very strong narcissistic personality traits. If you don't know crap, don't say anything.
wonder what the calculated risk was for Obama not to vote on the Iran resolution a couple weeks ago.  Say what you want about Hillary, at least she has the guts to vote on a resolution and not fear what people will say.  The same with Biden and Dodd.  At least   The excuse that he was campaigning is ridiculous, because Hillary, Biden and Dodd were campaigning too and some how found a way to get back to DC to vote.

Once AGAIN, Obama WAS there for the vote, but the vote was cancelled by Sen. Reid for the week.  But when Hillary arrived the vote was taken with Obama ( who was enroute to New Hampshire) only 1 hour to get there.

Hillary, please explain this since Sen. Reid's son works for YOUR compaign.  This sounds like a very cheap shot by the Senator.  Now people have the wrong impression, or maybe that was the paln.  SPIN away Hillary


If Hillary Clinton gets the nomination she should put Barak Obama on the ticket as her VP running mate. If Hillary Clinton picked Obama to be her VP running mate it would be the smartest move in her campaign. I think Hillary and Barak could work out their differences they both want agree we need real change. I think Barak Obama would accept to be Hillarys running mate if she asked him to be her VP running  mate.  If Hillary picked Obama as her VP running mate it would be a powerhouse ticket.  If Hillary picked Obama as her running mate there would be a woman and African American running for President and Vice President. It would turn out a record amount of voters. It would turn out a record amount of women,young voters,college students, minority voters, and indepedent voters to the polls.  The 2008 Presidental Election is the most important Presidental Election in US History.  This Presidental election will really mean stay the course or change direction.  If a Republican is elected in 2008 it will mean stay the course because a white man will still be elected President because there are no women or African Americans running for President on the Republican side.  If Hillary gets elected in 2008 it will mean change direction because we will have the first woman and possible African American elected President and Vice President.  The 2008 Presidental Election is going to decide history in the Untied States.  If a Republican is elected President in 2008 the United States will be a backwards country because England, countries in Europe, Chile which is a poor country, and Pakistan which is a muslim conservative country have all had women elected as their heads of state.  I really incourage the who don't vote, the undecided on the fence voters, and Independent Voters to vote in the 2008 Presidental Election because they could really decide if the United States stays the course or changes directions.  The 2008 Presidental Election is a make or break election.  The 2008 Presidental Election is going to decide if the United States moves forward into the 21st century or remain a backwards intolerent country. The 2008 Presidental Election is going to decide history in the United States.  So the message for the people who don't vote is to go out and vote in this election.  This is also a message for people who are old enough to vote who are not registered to go out and register to vote.  This is a message for the undecided voters and Independent voters to think about how they want their country to go before they pull the lever or press the vote button. So on Election Day 2008 while standing in the voting booth think for a minute the direction you want your country to go before pulling the lever or pushing the vote button because once you pull the lever or press the vote button you won't be able to change your vote. The 2008 Presidental Election will be a down to the wire election. Have a good day. God Bless America
What I find sad is that the democratic party has been making the same mistake in nominating a candidate for almost 30 years and keeps doing the same thing over and over.  
I have had to decide on whether to vote or stay home because my party gave us:  Mondale, Dukakus, Kerry, ect.  All boring, establishment, stale old same old.  Time and again and now I find no one has yet figured out you cannot possibly keep nominating these same failed establishments types without any personal likability and expect to win.
We will never win until we stop picking the same type over and over.  Just changing gender is not going to help.  She is still stale old establishment with the same stale old failed cw thinking and totally lacking in any likability at all.
It's time to wake up from this '1984' ad type of drone thinking and start nominating people who can win.
Barack Obama is exciting, liked by people across the spectrum, highly intelligent, has excellent judgment, takes real stands on the issues and drives the traditional media insane with his repudiation of the stale cw and old tired thinking and definitely not being part of the washington establishment(that alone is enough to nominate him).
Bill Clinton has been Hillary's shill for some time now and as such has been aimed numerous not so subtle jabs at Obama.  In fact, it is doubtful Hillary would be running for President, or even in the Senate, if it were not for her marriage to Bill.  


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=413002

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google