ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC Political Researcher



Oh-eight (D): On race and gender

Posted: Tuesday, October 23, 2007 9:10 AM by Domenico Montanaro
Filed Under:

BIDEN: Campaigning in Iowa yesterday, Biden discussed Iran and Iraq and touted his foreign policy experience for much of the morning chat. He emphasized the importance of his colleagues seeking the Democratic nomination to have a common agreement on Iran because of its future impact on the country. "We are going to say things in the spirit of trying to get ahead in the nominating fight that are going to give (President) Bush excuses, excuses that we should not take a chance on," Biden said.

CLINTON: “Clinton has paid 697 people to work for her campaign during the last three months, compared to 631 who have toiled for Obama,” according to an analysis by the Center for Responsive Politics. But “Obama has spent $12.6 million on salaries and benefits, compared with Clinton's $3.8 million.”

EDWARDS: The Los Angeles Times' Wallsten wonders if Edwards is treading on racial and gender biases with his electability claims, "Edwards' status as a Southern white male -- characteristics that helped propel Democrats Lyndon B. Johnson, Jimmy Carter and Bill Clinton to the White House -- has this year offered some limitations, to the frustration of his campaign… Now, as Edwards lays out the closing argument of his primary election campaign -- that he is the most electable candidate and the most able to help fellow Democrats in conservative states -- race and gender are forcing him to tread lightly.”

“‘He may not be saying it, but he's putting the argument out there that white male rural voters won't vote for a black guy or a woman,’ Taylor Marsh, a Democratic blogger and radio talk-show host, said in an interview. Marsh also recently raised the race and gender questions in a blog posting about Edwards' electability claims.”

“‘The Clinton people talk about her strength with women, and Obama has talked about how there would be record African American turnout if he were the candidate,’ said Harrison Hickman, Edwards' pollster. ‘So, is race a factor? Is gender a factor? Yes, probably all the way around. Each of the candidates does seem to do better than the others among some racial or sex groups.’”

Meanwhile, the Washington Post profiles Joe Trippi and notes how he's Howard Dean-ing John Edwards. "While Trippi was described as a senior adviser when he joined the Edwards campaign in mid-April, he has become much more in the intervening six months: the de facto campaign manager, lead media consultant and -- perhaps most important -- trusted confidante of Elizabeth Edwards, whose influence in the campaign far exceeds that of the conventional candidate's wife.”

OBAMA: NBC/NJ's Aswini Anburajan reports: First diplomacy, now Social Security? Obama voluntarily took a jab at Clinton yesterday morning, saying that she had downplayed the importance of the Social Security crisis in the country. “Social Security is actually not in as bad shape as George Bush said it was, but it’s not in as good shape as some of the Democrats have been claiming. They saw well we don’t have to do anything about this we just need to get our fiscal house in order,” Obama said while campaigning in Nashua, NH. “Senator Clinton and I disagree on this. You know she has not indicated that there’s anything that needs to be done other than to restore fiscal discipline,” he added.

Obama went on to say that he favored a plan to do away with the cap on the payroll tax, and tax all income above and beyond $97,000 to help put the program on the path to fiscal solvency.  Removing the cap is an issue that he has been increasingly vocal about on the stump in recent weeks, saying that it is the best way to help put the program on a path of financial solvency.  Previously, Obama had said that he would consider all options including raising the retirement age.

The Chicago Tribune's blog, The Swamp, gives play to a story that Obama's foes have been pushing on the blogs. "A Gospel concert tour organized by the Barack Obama campaign on behalf of the candidate is stirring controversy among some gay activists. The three-day tour through early-voting South Carolina starts this Friday and finishes Sunday with a concert that includes Grammy Award-winning Gospel artist Donnie McClurkin, who has provoked controversy among gay activists for his views that homosexuality can be ‘overcome.’”

“The Obama campaign issued a written statement from the candidate saying that he ‘strongly disagree(s)’ with McClurkin's views. Still, a spokesman said McClurkin would remain part of the concert line-up.”

Obama filed to be on the ballot officially in New Hampshire yesterday. And while he was there, he gave a bow to Secretary of State William Gardner. Obama also held a rally beforehand.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

LIGHTEN UP, folks.  A good song describes Hillary.  ' " A GOOD HEARTED WOMAN " BY BOXCAR WILLIE
That should tell you the motto for the Hillary White House:  Work more for less.

With all this talk about how bad the middle class is being beat up, talking about new taxes is not a good idea.  Of course, in the Northeast, $100,000 is considered middle class, so they are the one's who would get beat up more.

John Edwards probably is the most electable out of the democrats running.  But, between his haircuts and his mansion and saying he is for poor people while the companies that he has his name in are kicking poor people out of their houses, I doubt he will go far in a race.

I finally saw B. Obama's ad that came out yesterday.  A lot of the ads sound powerful and are very motivating, but this one had something else.  When B. Obama was speaking, I could hear the passion in his voice.  I heard somebody who doesn't just want the presidency for the power or the prestige, but to effect true change.  It is that passion and determination that sets him apart.  Not return to yesterday, but build a better tomorrow.
Obviously, people writing nonsense on the blogs don't understand how deeply religious people of south carolina are - most especially the African American community.  African American loves Donnie Mcclurkin and droping him off the concert won't be good for Obama.

Personally, i want him to stay on the agenda. The folks yelling and writing nonsense are not going to vote in South Carolina.
If Edwards is the most electable, if he does best in head to head match-ups against the Republican candidates, then he should be able to say it without regard to race or gender.

If anyone, it has been Hillary Clinton who has been genderizing this election recently, talking about "us women," etc., etc.

Really, many people are looking at nominating the first woman president or the first black president, and excited about their candidates for that reason.  Edwards has every right to point out his own strengths in the general election.  Many of us support him on the issues, not on his race or gender.
Go Bee!  South Carolina also needs to know that "just someone of faith" is Not all America's voters really want, no matter how many times it is repeated by candidates trying to steam roll into the White House. Romney called Rev. Sharpton a "Bigot" and "Intollerant" for being bold enough to say it like it is, while Romney's own scriptures teach: "Shall I tell you the law of [LDS]God in regard to the African race? If the white man who belongs to the chosen seed mixes his blood with the seed of Cain, the penalty, under the law of [LDS]God, is death on the spot. This will always be so" (LDS 'deep doctrine' not shared with outsiders or new-prospective members, still in LDS revered scripture today, Journal of Discourses, vol.10, p.110). This is a religion Romney says he is happy to be proud of, and that he will not distance himself from. So be it.I hope this makes getting posted. It is important, regarding blatant hypocracy.
[ LIGHTEN UP, folks.  A good song describes Hillary.  ' " A GOOD HEARTED WOMAN " BY BOXCAR WILLIE]


That's a funny joke.  Everyone knows Hillary has no heart.
Hey, people, have you considered why so many American voters are still absolutely opposed to the idea of a woman being elected President? Consider the many many other countries that have elected women and been managed very well:  Britain, Germany, Norway, India, Phillipines, Sri Lanka, Liberia, Israel, . . . ..  These include Christian, Hindu, Muslim and Jewish-majority countries in Europe, Africa, Asia, the middle East,  and Latin America.  They also include countries that are members of the U. N. security Council (Britain), rapidly developing (India), surrounded by dangerous neighbors (Israel), rich (Germany), and poor (Liberia).  Women leaders have proved their leadership in times of war: Golda Meir (Israel), Margaret Thatcher (Britain) and Indira Gandhi (India).

So where is there any factual basis for fear that a female President of the U. S. would not successfully lead our country in good times or bad, in wartime or in peace, in international affairs or at home, as commanedr-in-chief or as a person worthy of respect???????????  Why are so many Americans still so timid and personally insecure that they will not under any circumstance accept the election of a woman as President.

Why are so many Americans so stupid that they still believe in George Dumbush and his misadministration despite the massive evidence of his incompetence (failure to plan for the post-invasion responsibilities in Iraq), disregard for the truth (Saddam's WMDs as a threat to us), cronyism (Brownie doing great after Katrina hit New Orleams), meanmindedness (outing Valerie Plame), or even his plain inability to articulate a simple idea without making a fool of himself (saying "Childrens is learning . . .").  Can it be that they are fooled by his claim to be one who listens to God?  Any moron can claim that - but does it qualify him to be respected as a leader?  If so, then religious blindness has infected us an ways that could be fatal.  Why not be bold enough to follow the world's lead (come on, even you conservatives who rarely dare to venture out of your tiny little comfort zones) and elect a woman - yes I mean Hillary Clinton - as our next President?  Come on, you wimps!

Chatti    
Isn't working on a campaign more a labor of love than a means of gainful employment?  Obama is paying out an average of $6656 per person per month compared to Clinton's $1817.  Sounds like either poor fiscal management on Obama's part or he does not inspire as much loyalty as does Clinton.  Or maybe a little of both.
“Clinton has paid 697 people to work for her campaign during the last three months, compared to 631 who have toiled for Obama,” according to an analysis by the Center for Responsive Politics. But “Obama has spent $12.6 million on salaries and benefits, compared with Clinton's $3.8 million.”


Is Hillary paying her people a living wage?
Another reason why Clinton candidacy is bad for America. Shady!Secretive! I can't trust her.

http://www.newsweek.com/id/57351
Heart of Gold -- Neil Young
I agree with Bee, Obama should not drop Donnie Mcclurkin. I have friends who are gay and go to church. Obama can not let any group show kind of a reverse in tolerance themselves. This does not bring the country together. Instead of complaining about Mcclurkin the gay groups should come to the concert, show their presents, sit with him and talk out the issues. This will heal the nation instead of this back and forth of different groups jockeying for power. Some gays have to know that there are people who go to church who don't gay bash. We believe in love thy neighbor. The real question is are the gay groups complaining going to just demand or get involved and work together for change.
edwards still has the best plans, has not been bought by the lobbyists, and is the only candidate for real change, but he lacks novelty traits which seem to be all the rage in the media. but he still has my vote
In America today we like to act like we have transcended the issues of race, gender and religion, but the fact is we have not. The bloggers and analysts are right.  Rural white males will not vote for Clinton or Obama.  The "white is right" attitude is still too prevalent in the American heartland.  The fact that anyone takes serious the candidacy of one-issue bigot Tom Tancredo proves it.  
Jaye fl-

All i am saying is simple, a president should be for every body not a special interest.
Thanks Erik for elaborating the point.

I don't have a problem with Gay but i disagree with their method regarding the concert. The concert must proceed as schedule.

Mitt Romney would be the best thing that ever happen to the White House.  He is Honest amd forthright in all he does.  What Jaye fl said is not the way it is in the LDS Church.  I am LDS and there are people from all nations and all colors in my Church. Get the facts before you judge people. Don't listen to a few
who want to discredit over twelv million people. You are not talked about or disrespect in my belief's.
Donetta Michigan
Biden is an arrogant idiot & dangerous.
If ti came down to a morals debate between Mitt Romney and Hillary Clinton......

That would be like Joel Osteen debating Marlyn Chambers in a morals debate
Biden is an "arrogant idiot??????"

Have you been watching the debates??? It seems to me he has the best plan to get us out of the Iraq WAR responsibly. Fact of the matter is your not going to get out of the country for a long time, but the least we can do is stop the American blood shed in the middle of a civil war. His plan has been adopted across party lines by some of the candidates.

This war was always about oil we are down there simply protecting our interests right now and will be for a long time. The situation sucks and we have Bush and the last congress to thank for it. None of the Democrats with the exception of Richardson who is a real idiot can committ to leaving.

The best thing we can do until there is a better solution is re-deploy and interject when necessary so the region remains somewhat stable.

And any person who thinks otherwise Republican or Democrat is not thinking logically
John Edwards has the hightest poll numbers on the Daily KOS today at 32%. Hillary has 9%. Obama is at 16% on this website.  However, I feel Edwards will not win the Nomination as he is "yesterday's news" and too far left of the issues.  The country is in the Middle right now.  
American Voter

Hillary supporter aka "American Voter" you only wish your candidate had accomplished 1/10 of what Sen. Biden's accomplished. I've met all the Democratic candidates except Gravel, and none of them are idiots. While I wouldn't classify any of them as arrogant, if I were to rank candidates from the least to most arrogant candidate Sen. Biden would rank as the least arrogant candidate.

Not only is he not lying to his audiences, he also is not assuming that they are dumb, or that he needs to simplify his speech.

Dangerous? What a joke. How is he dangerous? Was it his failure to vote for declaring 1/3 of Iran's military a terrorist organization? Or was it the fact that he didn't play politics and voted for the war supplemental in May, which provided immediate funding for mine resistant ambush protected vehicles, that provide an 80% reduction in death from an IED (the leading cause of US deaths  in Iraq). And saved the lives of four Iowa National Guard last week!

No Sen. Biden's not dangerous, he is the most experienced, intelligent, knowledgeable and honest person running for President in either party.

Why is it clear "American Voter" is a Hillary supporter, because Hillary supporters provide bare superlatives regarding their support for Hillary (she's intelligent, she's a leader...), but when asked to provide facts to support those superlatives, they provide none.

It seems likely that a Hillary supporter, whose probably upset that Sen. Biden has criticized the Iran vote, and said that if Bush goes to war with Iran, all Senators who voted in favor of the measure bear some responsibility, wants to retaliate by bashing Biden. But just as Hillary supporters can't back up their Hillary superlatives with actual facts, they don't have actual facts to back up their criticism of Biden.
Jerry, i think you meant Guiliani is like Marilyn Chambers. They look like hotties when rudy is in drag. And Joel Osteen is a closet gay male, so hes like..ah..hmm so many closet gay repub males to choose from.... pick one.
Sara,

Absolutely true.  Hillary supporters can only talk about her plans, not her accomplishments.  Whenever they are challenged to come up with examples of her leadership all they can point to is plans, speeches, and press releases regarding her positions.  What about her Senate career?  What has she done?  What issues has she expended her political capital on?  Defending herself. She constantly needs to be clarified, re-written, explained, and repackaged.  If you need a 3 page letter to supporters to explain your position you are in trouble.

Biden is the person we need to lead this country.  

Biden/Obama 08
Today, Tomorrow, Together.
John Edwards never took a vow of poverty, he vowed to help the poor, which he has done and continues to do.  The people who were hurt by the lender he had some investments with were helped to keep their homes, quietly and with class by the Edwards once they found out about the imminent foreclosures.  The haircut issue is laughable when you think about what wealth and extravagance the Republican candidates have. I wonder what amount Mitt pays???
We should all be extremely concerned about American tax dollars that would be paid out on this scam called the dream act. What about a dream act for American children from poor families? The illegal aliens get priority. This has to stop!!Where are the politicians that represent Americans? I don't see any in the Democratic party.
Sara:

For once I will agree with a liberal; Joe Biden does have more experience then Hillary Clinton.

Problem is.....

Hillary is running on her husband's name and that seems to excite the democrats.
i am excited to see biden getting play on this site as its been dominated by the big 3. the electorate isn't making decisions based on position or experience its name recognition[mostlt bill's] and minority status. do i think its time for a minority to be elected, yes if they are the best qualified. clearly biden is the only candidate to address iraq in a comprehensive manner and in spite of a resolution that had 70+ votes he's stuck in second tier. wake up people this attitude got you bush twice vote on positions not the political decorations these candidates carry.
Senator Biden does have more experience than Senator Clinton but he and Senator Dodd don't seem to be able to generate any enthusiasm for their campaigns.  Of course, they also don't seem to get very much press(TV) time so that could be part of the problem.

This whole front runner issue is, in many ways a self fulfilling and self perpetuating phenomena.  The press gives the "supposed" front runners lots of coverage, yet by doing so they are, in a sense, furthering the perception that someone is indeed the front runner. That makes it difficult for candidates like Biden, Dodd, Huckabee, and to a certain extent, Edwards, who might be able to advance in the polls if they were given like coverage.  Senator Thompson had only to declare his candidacy and he attracted a significant amout of press, something the other candidates have to work to achieve.

Even in the debates, the "supposed" front runners usually are asked the most questions and are given the most time to respond. The results of polls are broadcast often and they too give the impression that one candidate is far ahead of the others. So the front runner idea snowballs until is accepted as fact.

Not sure that the playing field is completely even.
Sorry that this is a bit off topic, but I have to refute this piece of idiocy...

Charlie, Kasson, Minnesota:

So the American Dream Act is a scam?  Let's examine that statement.  According to EducationPlanner.org a person with a bachelor's degree will earn over $560,000 dollars more over a 40 year career than a person with only a high school diploma.  Given a 28% tax rate that's nearly $157,000 more that goes into just federal coffers.  In addition, a person with a college education is much less likely to commit a crime, generally gives more to charity, is much more likely to participate in the democratic process, and generally will pay many more times what a high school graduate does in property and sales taxes over a lifetime.  As a college graduate I personally have already paid back my Pell grants many times over in additional taxes, and I still have 20 years left in my career.

So tell me, how is it a bad thing to produce college graduates that pay much more in taxes, give more to charity, don't commit crimes, and participate in the democratic process?

Any person who would begrudge a child the opportunity for an education is despicable.  But then again we're talking about little brown children.  God forbid they out-compete you in the workplace.
mile high i agree with you, i'm babs [bach.arts.bull sh..] i like the bumper sticker"if you think education is expensive try ignorance". a brain is a terrible thing to waste, aspparent by some on these sites...
Heart of Gold -- Neil Young
nuanced


She better have one of gold. We all better too.  We'll need something to sell to pay for all her programs.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=426070

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google