ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC Political Researcher



GOPers speak at IA Reagan Day dinner

Posted: Sunday, October 28, 2007 5:14 PM by Mark Murray
Filed Under:

From NBC/NJ's Adam Aigner-Treworgy
DES MOINES, IA -- Iowa’s GOP faithful filed into the Hyvee Hall here last night for the state’s Reagan Day Dinner, which featured speeches from most of the party’s presidential candidates. Notably absent were McCain and Giuliani, the two candidates often thought to have the hardest road to success in the Iowa caucuses.

The mostly decided crowd came wearing stickers in support of their favorite candidate, and many left after the candidates finished speaking -- skipping the anti-climactic keynote address from GOPAC Chairman Michael Steele.

The speaker thought by many to have given the best speech of the night was Huckabee, who went second to last and touted his ability to beat the Clinton political machine as evidenced by four successful gubernatorial elections in Arkansas. “I’m often asked, ‘Do you think you can win, particularly against Hillary?,’” he said. “Folks, may I suggest to you I’ve been battling against the headwinds of Hillary Clinton and Bill Clinton’s political machine in Arkansas more than anybody else running for president. I didn’t just win once, not twice, not three times, but four times in a statewide election against the Clinton political machine. Bill Clinton and Hillary campaigned against me every time I ever ran, and I won and they didn’t.”

Huckabee used the same rhetoric on CNN’s Late Edition the next morning, saying that Arkansas is overwhelmingly “outfitted” with “Clintonistas,” and he is the only candidate in the race that has beaten the Clinton machine.

Bonnie Hall, who represents Iowa’s 4th District on the state’s GOP board, said that Huckabee had growing support among caucusgoers, whom she called true “conservatives.” The competition for Iowa’s conservative vote was between Huckabee and Thompson, Hall said, but to win Iowa a candidate has to work hard, and the candidate currently working the hardest -- Romney -- could shake up the race.

Thompson, who worked the crowd for more than 30 minutes during the dinner and received a better response on the floor than on the podium, closed the candidates’ portion of the night by emphasizing his campaign’s new anti-illegal immigration plan, which was introduced in Tampa last week. He called illegal immigration a “matter of national security.”

“We are apprehending, over a period of time, thousands of people who are from state sponsors of terrorism,” Thompson said, avoiding specifics. “[That] doesn’t mean they are terrorists, it just means that we don’t know.”

Then Thompson launched into a condemnation of sanctuary cities, which his campaign has positioned as a veiled attack on both Romney and Giuliani -- due to their governance of two so-called sanctuary cities, Cambridge, MA and New York, NY. 

Romney appeared before the crowd via video, but he sent his wife Ann to introduce him. During the introduction, Mrs. Romney said that she often tells supporters, “I wish I could take you and put you in my back pocket and introduce you to the people of Iowa,” after which her husband apologized for his absence and once again told voters that Republicans can’t beat Democrats by acting like them. 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

As a lifelong democrat, if the republicans nominate Huckabee and my party is so dumb as to nominate Hillary, i may end up voting for him.
Actually I know alot of democrats who are looking at Huckabee as a possible choice against Hillary if our party is stupid.
Romney "governed over a sanctuary city"?  Ummmm . . . he was a GOVERNOR of THE STATE of Massachussetts.  As a State official, he really had no say whether a CITY enforced FEDERAL immigration law.  

If that's the best Thompson can do then I'm feeling good about Romney's chances.  Especially considering Romney has an actual RECORD of being tough on Immigration (Sought and obtained Federal permission for MA state troopers to enforce immigration laws, achieved "English immersion" in educational system, opposed in-state tuition breaks and Drivers Licenses for Illegal Immigrants) where Thompson has NONE.  And Thompson actually is just mimicking Romney's long-standing call for witholding federal funds from sanctuary cities (Fed Gov says:  You won't enforce our laws (actual flagrantly oppose them)?  Fine, we won't give you our money.

Thompson's swipe on Sanctuary cities does work for Rudy though since he personally signed and re-instituted NYC's official status as a "Sanctuary City" (and still seems to defend it)
The conservative vote lies between Thompson and Huckabee? I think Huckabee is finally getting on track to breaking through. Unfortunately, Thompson is never able to seem like anything more than a slightly lazy actor who has name recognition and therefore has support.

Between Thompson and Huckabee, I say Huckabee. Between all the candidates, I think Romney is definitely showing that he is the most hard working and most capable to lead. I'd be very interested to see if he would shake up Washington like the past organizations he's lead. I'd love to see that happen. He's got my support.
Well, Mitt, the Republicans can't beat anybody if they keep acting like the Republicans of the last seven years. I'm an Independent down to the Ground, and I'd say, this bunch has got absolutely nothing new to say. The Democrats are at least looking at the rest of the world and its' disillusion with the USA. The GOP continues to keep a Superiorist stance that does no one any good. Just an observation.
I think the real message Romney meant to send out was that Republicans can't beat Democrats this year... period, not simply just by not acting like them. I'm dreaming of next year's Blue Christmas.

Makes me sad that my favorite color is red... lol
er, mr. huckabee....
The clintons haven't lived in Arkansas since 1991, and you are still crying "victim"... you are NOT what we need in the leadership catagory.
NO OFFENSE BUT THE NEW HEADING, WITH THE ANEMIC DONKEY AND BLOATED ELEPHANT, IS SIMPLY BUTT-UGLY.  I THOUGHT YOU GUYS HAD A DESIGN TEAM.
Huckamentum! This man has been rising in the polls, raising a lot more money than previous quarters, and getting a lot of buzz. He is definitely the man!
Romney "governed over a sanctuary city"?  Ummmm . . . he was a GOVERNOR of THE STATE of Massachussetts.  As a State official, he really had no say whether a CITY enforced FEDERAL immigration law.  

If that's the best Thompson can do then I'm feeling good about Romney's chances.  Especially considering Romney has an actual RECORD of being tough on Immigration (Sought and obtained Federal permission for MA state troopers to enforce immigration laws, achieved "English immersion" in educational system, opposed in-state tuition breaks and Drivers Licenses for Illegal Immigrants) where Thompson has NONE.  And Thompson actually is just mimicking Romney's long-standing call for witholding federal funds from sanctuary cities (Fed Gov says:  You won't enforce our laws (actual flagrantly oppose them)?  Fine, we won't give you our money.

Thompson's swipe on Sanctuary cities does work for Rudy though since he personally signed and re-instituted NYC's official status as a "Sanctuary City" (and still seems to defend it)
diane, then you are NOT a democrat. Look at the issues and what he believes diane. Much like Bush. Look at the issues......
Anyone who votes for Huckabee is stupid is as stupid does, since he's a narrow minded, Creationist, who wants to replace real science in schools with religious hokus pokus Adam and Eve nonsense.  He's also very dangerous....  Also, what's that nonsense about having already beaten Clinton?  If memory serves, Clinton never ran against this guy.  Rather, the Clintons had the good sense of leaving that backwoods state for better place to live in NY
I think the USA version of how the world looks at us got pretty much tossed in the dirt when the President of France walked out on 60 minutes last night.

All you liberals that are just so scared of how the world percieves us is nothing but smoke and mirrors. Bill Clinton tried to play nice with the world and it led us up to 9-11.  By playing a weak and sex crazed president, it showed the world we were nothing but a bunch of Yokohama mama's who wouldn't lift a finger to destroy the terrorists, who ended up taking advantage of our laxness by flying some planes into buildings.

Now you want to elect a president who is so obsessed about our standing int he world, she is just inviting our enemies to attack us again.
What is a Clintonista?
Please give me a definition and a list of all the "sanctuary" cities.
We can't have a informed discussion if we don't know what we are talking about.
I thank you in advance for your input jerry,  but anyone else can shed some light?
"she is just inviting our enemies to attack us again"
---jerry why did you call "bring em on" Bush a she?
Huckabee was referring to the fact that everytime he ran in election the Clintons personally came out and campaigned for his opponents. Many of the former Clinton campaign workers also are stationed in Arkansas.
"By playing a weak and sex crazed president, it showed the world we were nothing but a bunch of Yokohama mama's who wouldn't lift a finger to destroy the terrorists, who ended up taking advantage of our laxness by flying some planes into buildings."

Bush isn't "sex crazed." "Crazy," yes, but not "sex crazed." Psychotic, war criminal, tool, fascist, drug addict, alcoholic, CRAPPY FATHER - yes. "Sex crazed," - not since he gave up snorting Peruvian BLue Flake off the butts of Mexican prostitutes

(OH! I'm sorry! He was drilling with the Texas Air Natinal Guard.)
reading what thompson said makes my head hurt, what the hell does he mean? It is 'mourning' in america for the repubs if this is the kind of political discourse coming out of their candidates mouth. I hear the funeral dirge and see the coffin coming out of the wagon, each of these pall bearer candidates thinks they can carry the coffin by themselves. Dig yourselves a larger grave, so many need to be buried so many people with shovels in their hands.
diane you are a BIG LIER. Lifeling democrat my butt. I suppose you voted for Bush twice too.
"Reagan Day?"  I forgot all about it.

C'mon, Dick - we've got nuns to face shoot.
Forgetting about Reagan day is how it is celebrated


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=435418

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google