ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Two lives, two campaigns

Posted: Thursday, November 08, 2007 10:10 AM by Domenico Montanaro

*** UPDATE *** The Clinton campaign says, "The campaign spent $157 and left a $100 tip at the Maid-Rite Restaurant."

*** UPDATE 2 *** The manager of the of the restaurant tells First Read the Clinton campaign did, in fact, tip.

"They paid their bill, and they left a tip," said Brad Crawford, manager of the Maid Rite restaurant in Toledo, Iowa. "Everybody was satisfied. No question about it."

From NBC’s Domenico Montanaro
Clinton used in stump speeches the story of a waitress, who waited on her at a lunch stop in Iowa -- a single mother who works two jobs, one at the restaurant and one at a nursing home. But the waitress isn’t so thrilled with Clinton or her campaign.

“I don't think she understood at all what I was saying," Anita Esterday told NPR, adding, "I mean, nobody got left a tip that day."

Clinton was also never given a bill -- “her meal was on the house,” NPR reports.

“Turns out the visit hurt Esterday in another way. The local paper ran photos of her with Clinton. She said her supervisor at the nursing home isn't a big Hillary Clinton fan, and she thinks that may be related to why her hours were almost totally cut. Now, Esterday is looking for a different second job.”

"It hasn't helped me. It's made things worse," said Esterday, who added that she is still considering voting for Clinton, but might choose Obama.

NPR also tracked down Geri Puteney, a woman who, during a question-and-answer session, began crying when she told Obama the story of her brother dying from cancer. Obama walked over to comfort her and held her hand. "I know what this feels like," Obama said, adding later, "Tell your brother we're thinking of him. Maybe I'll write him a note before you leave today."

Puteney said she sought out Obama after seeing his television commercials. "I'd seen the commercials," she said. "And he just seemed sincere, like he's for people like my mom, my brother and me."

Obama never wrote that note, but Puteney seemed OK with it. “He didn't have time, I guess," she said. "I understand. You know, he was bombarded by so many people. But just knowing he knows -- that's more important than a note."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

BLAB. BLAB, BLAB, BLOOB. GIVE ME A BREAK ! THIS IS MORE B.S.
What a crock of RUBBISH.  I do not believe one word of this stupid, waste of space, STORY???  Was the Big Bad Wolf and Little Red Riding Hood eating at the same greasy spoon?  And the dish ran away with the spoon!!! Did they pay for the dish and the spoon?

Politics at it's usual, stupid, crappy, mean, petty
propaganda hits.
Maybe this might explain why her hours are cut, she is not a reliable employee. she just lied to the newspaper to have her 15mn of fame.
Bee:  First she is evil because she doesn't tip.  Then she is evil because she tips too much.  Thanks for again showing the incredible amount of objectivity you demonstrate when it comes to Clinton.  (Please note the sarcasm.)  

As someone else pointed out, 15% (although the norm is now 20%, I believe) is a suggested amount.  I have tipped far more than that when I have been particularly impressed with the service I get; I have also not tipped at all when the service has been atrocious or the waitress was flat-out rude.  To rant about her spending habits based on this instance is just silly.
I will vote for Obama.
I will not vote for Hilary
Hillary was surprised there was a fee for the meal.  In her world, everything is free.
I am not complaining about TIPs. I am only complaining about excessive spending.

There seems to be correlation between her private spending and Allocating tax payers money to pork's project
Wow, the Clinton supporters are having an absolute fit over this story. Tough to have your hero shown for what she really is, isn't it?
Naysayers abound! Hillary Clinton will be our next president. I care none of who wins. I have a exquisitly clear vision of a female president. It will come to pass.
And yet congress subsidizes NPR and public Television LOL.

Makes me wonder if they did run back over there and leave a tip.

Knowing the owner, he probably is a Hillary supporter.

I would recommend Hillary just eat room service for a while....


And TEC:

I don't eat at Snoopy's.....
I'm a Red Lobster man myself......
As long as they keep my tea glass filled and not bring my dinner at closing time, my waiter/waitress will always find 25-30% tip.....

And what's bad about it NPR is seriously liberal...
shows you what side of the liberal coin they are taking.....

I wonder what side of the issue Hillary is on when it comes to proper tipping?......
"stiffing waitresses"

guess she learned that from Bill

did she leave a cigar?
Maybe Hillary did pay the bill - AFTER the story surfaced. But she DID pay - and could have paid the owner to say she paid.
More "confusing" Clinton facts - like this from NBC.

http://youtube.com/watch?v=LG3fOkLZeo8


The Liberal media got it wrong.  She DID leave a tip.  No, wait, by initially saying she didn't leave a tip the media actually went against Hillary.  Now I'm really confused as to the agenda, purpose, and journalistic credentials of the idiot who broke this useless story.  And shame on me for reading it too AAARRRGGGHH!
Hillary Clinton having a loose meat sandwich......

That will make the arteries harden a little faster...

Didn't she learn her lesson from Bill having his arteries cleaned out?

Next Clinton controversy:  Kathleen Willey is on her book tour.  Listened to her on quite a few radio shows yesterday.  What a disgusting fool Bill Clinton is.......
Humerous, but then again?

Judy Wallman, a professional genealogical researcher, discovered that Hillary Clinton's great-great uncle, Remus Rodham, was hanged for horse stealing and train robbery in Montana in 1889.  The only known photograph  of Remus shows him standing on the Gallows. On the back of the picture is  this inscription: "Remus Rodham; horse thief, sent to Montana Territorial  Prison 1885, escaped 1887, robbed the Montana Flyer six times, caught by  Pinkerton Detectives, convicted and hanged in 1889.

Judy e-mailed Hillary Clinton for comments. Hillary's staff of Professional Image adjusters sent back the following biographical
sketch:
 "Remus Rodham was a famous cowboy in the Montana Territory.  His business  empire grew to include acquisition of valuable equestrian assets and  intimate dealings with the Montana railroad. Beginning in 1883, he  devoted several years of his life to service at a government facility,  finally taking leave to resume his dealings with the railroad.  In 1887,  he was a key player in a vital investigation run by the renowned  Pinkerton Detective Agency. In 1889, Remus passed away during an  important civic function held in his honor when the platform upon which  he was standing collapsed."

And THAT is how it's done, folks!
So if she left a tip why did the waitress not know about it?  I was a waitress for five years-we always knew where are tips were and who had left how much.  The Clinton campaign obviously is doing damage control. How much did the Clintons have to pay to clean up this little mess-more than $257 I bet. Same old slime...
Yeah, how is this news or journalism for that matter? Seems like this blog should be "gossip from the high and mighty". Again the middle class suffers and continues to spin the wheel in lab rat cage a little faster. Lack of discussion on real issues, tunes me out, not worth my time. People in Washington DC wonder why the electorate are fed up, it's stuff like what gets posted on this blog that makes people feel disallisioned.  
There seems to be correlation between her private spending and Allocating tax payers money to pork's project
Bee (Sent Thursday, November 08, 2007 12:09 PM)

Considering Hillary gave a $1 million tip ( I mean Earmark) in exchange for a campaign contribution, Bee is dead on right on her statement.....
Wow! people are really ranting about this story.

I guess she shouldn't have used her for for photo ups  
$100 tip?  Sounds to me like Hillary was trying to BUY A VOTE...

But maybe it's just me.  A 66% tip is a bit out of the ordinary to folks that aren't very good at trading cattle futures.
Jerry,

Thanks for the comment. I know Hillary's supporter won't admit it but it is true.

The correlation is out there but they won't admit it
jerry from cc - Hillary Clinton having a loose meat sandwich......

You just know she went into the bathroom and purged.
MK,MO: '...the hillary campaign handlers apparently had to make a rather hasty trip back to the dinner after this was released to the press to control damage, at least the waitress finally got her tip, that hillary is a class act...'

MK, don't you HATE IT when poor, poor little Hillary gets's Seiftboated that that ?

The story was from NPR, not MSNBC.
I heard it driving to work this morning.
I'm SHOCKED that MSNBC covered this story.

MSNBC missed the story about Hillary rescuing 8 orphans and 3 puppies from a burning building and using the water hose to save the orphanage.
What a hero she is !!
Why can't MSNBC be 'fair and balanced' ??
Here is the drudge report on Hillary stiffing ANOTHER waitress back in New York in 2000....

http://www.drudgereport.com/flash.htm

Bill is a serial woman jumper.....
Hillary is a serial waitress tipper skipper....
This is a non story.
Typical overreaction from the anti-Clinton folks. Boooorrrriiiinnnngggg.
Naysayers abound! Hillary Clinton will be our next president. I care none of who wins. I have a exquisitly clear vision of a female president. It will come to pass.
Psychic Mary (Sent Thursday, November 08, 2007 12:18 PM)
@@@@00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
I see what you are seeing!  Hillary 08! Take it to the bank. Your crystal ball is so much smarter than bee's cloudy eyes.  Oh that silly buzzing bee....zzzz
How about we try actually reading the entire story including the updates: they paid the bill and tipped in excess. How sad the delusions of a minimum wage hack waste of space could lie about someone actually praising her in a stump speech. See if you're ever respected again (the lady who lied about Hilary's campaign not paying)
Now that the story has been updated with a correction, from rumor to fact, I'm not seeing any apologies from the Clinton Haters.
Y'all remind me of a pack of rabid dogs.
Bee, I'm guessing you go to church at least one or more times per week.
The "correction" is great, but misleading.  As it turns out, Brad Crawford is a Clinton supporter, so it looks like the Clinton campaign is just doing damage control.  The waitress's story hasn't changed, so it does not look like the real situation was any different than first described here.
Bee:  The same can be said for Edwards.  Remember he paid $400 for a hair cut.  Now if that isn't wasteful spending, I don't know what is.

I know Edwards is your guy but can you at least acknowledge that if you are going to blast Hillary for leaving too much of a tip, you need to blast Edwards for paying that much for a haircut?  

I'll be waiting.  :)
Wow, the Clinton supporters are having an absolute fit over this story. Tough to have your hero shown for what she really is, isn't it?
Megan Poole (Sent Thursday, November 08, 2007 12:10 PM)

Have you bothered to read the updates?  The story is WRONG.  It's shameful of MSNBC and of NPR to have reported it without verifying anything the waitress said.  Talk about sloppy journalism.  
Travis in Louisville says.....

How about we try actually reading the entire story including the updates: they paid the bill and tipped in excess.

Has she given a tip to the waitress she stiffed in New York in 2000?

A new campaign slogan.....

Hillary Clinton
Why should I give you a tip?........
Fact checking journalism does not sell papers. The average reporter, and news shows, would rather form your opinion first then apologize for it later - buried on page 10 of course where 5 people will read it.

I hate Hillary! She is a liar and a cheat. Anybody who thinks otherwise needs to read more and stay away for CNN and FOX news.
Carrie in Eastern Iowa says.....

Bee:  The same can be said for Edwards.  Remember he paid $400 for a hair cut.  Now if that isn't wasteful spending, I don't know what is.

But I'll bet the farm he left a tip......
Unlike another woman candidate that will remain nameless......

I think there was no tip in Iowa.......

When she releases her campaign records, I imagine everybody will be looking at this ticket.......
at least the waitress finally got her tip, that hillary is a class act
MK,MO

-- skeptic mode -- the report did not say the waitress got her tip. I had assumed it was the manager holding on to the tip that led to the waitress asssuming she did not get one.
Fact checking journalism does not sell papers. The average reporter, and news shows, would rather form your opinion first then apologize for it later - buried on page 10 of course where 5 people will read it.

I hate Hillary! She is a liar and a cheat. Anybody who thinks otherwise needs to read more and stay away for CNN and FOX news.
When you finally get the facts, this much becomes clear:  Obama's the real phoney, and Sen. Clinton's the real deal.
I'm a Red Lobster man myself......
And what's bad about it NPR is seriously liberal...
jerry/corpus christi texas

-- I go for Cracker Barrel for breakfast when I am in a traditional artery clogging food mood.
--- what's bad about NPR is how far it has fallen with Bush crony partisan leadership at the Corporation for Public Broadcasting.
Hillary Clinton
Why should I give you a tip?........
jerry/corpus christi texas (Sent Thursday, November 08, 2007 2:11 PM)

-- I thought in Texas only cows get tipped.

A cheap democrat?  That's something new!  Democrats are usually all about giving free handouts and pointless spending.  You'd think Hillary would be happy to leave a tip.  It only goes to show that you can't ever depend on a democrat to do something normal and note worthly.
nuanced - Let's say you are right an the waitress was never given the tip, but (as the owner said) the tip was left when they paid the bill.

I know that when I pay by credit card, I often add the tip to my card rather than leave cash.  Perhaps that is what the campaign did?  I'm doubting they got separate tickets and paid in cash.  
nuanced:

Based on the daily goings-on here regarding Hillary WITHIN the Democrat constituency, I think there is a good chance the supervisor was an Obama supporter, an Edwards supporter or Sierra.

Doesn't everyone tip 20%?  That's my standard and I'm a cheap, greedy and uncaring Republican.

Jan, Nashua, NH,

You want me to apologize to Hillary Clinton. You kidding, right. You need to re-read my post. I am not complaining about the tips but the amount of the tip.

As far as i am concern, that is an excessive spending. Tips shouldn't be more than 25% but Hillary spend 40%. Can i infere she is trying to buy a vote with her money?

Well, you be judge.
know Edwards is your guy but can you at least acknowledge that if you are going to blast Hillary for leaving too much of a tip, you need to blast Edwards for paying that much for a haircut?  

I'll be waiting.  :) .....Carrie

-------------------------------------------------
I still like Edward despite his $400 hair cut. Although, that $400 is another wasteful spending based on my scale. I need to see his pork barrel record before i can reach a conclusion on the correlation. Anything but Hillary.

FYI: Here is my pick for 2008

First Choice - Obama
Second Choice - Biden
Third Choice - Edward

Combine
Obama/Edward - 2008
Obama/Biden - 2008
Obama/Bob Kerry
Biden/Obama - 2008 --- This combination will be a juggernaut
I'm a hardcore Obama supporter and have no doubt in my mind that if Hillary is nominated, she will lose, and I really disagree & dislike her and her policies. But it's Completely wrong that she got her hours cut just b/c she took a picture w/ Clinton and there should definitely be some sort of legal action b/c of this. People can be such jerks.
Bee:

The tip was 63.7%, even more exorbitant than what has apparently outraged you.

Let's see.  Hillary and her entourage (or any of the other campaigns for that matter) descend on a restaurant, probably causing quite a bit more than the usual disruption, they incur a $157 tab and leave a $100 tip to spread around to everyone, including the waitress, maybe?

So, no, you can't infer that she is trying to buy a vote.  It was actually a decent gesture given the situation.

So good for Hillary's folks in this case, assuming the updates are accurate.  Meanwhile, you just go ahead and be the cynic.

I like Psychic Mary. I really do. She might be out to lunch big time with the Hillary Thing, but I like her style.
what a bunch of loons taking the word of some waitress in a greasy spoon dive, are some of you for real?
I see it in my vision.

Psychic Mary works for Hillary's office


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=455077

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google