ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Protestors booted from Giuliani event

Posted: Saturday, November 10, 2007 3:06 PM by Domenico Montanaro



From NBC/NJ’s Matthew E. Berger
LOVELAND, Colo. -- About a half dozen protestors were asked to leave a local coffeehouse Saturday where Giuliani was visiting, after they shouted questions about conspiracies surrounding the Sept. 11, 2001 terrorist attacks.

No formal arrests were made, according to Loveland Police Sgt. Greg Eisentraut, but about a half dozen protesters were removed from the event, after trying to ask Giuliani whether he had advanced knowledge of the terrorist attacks. One protestor, who was detained by police, described himself as the publisher and Editor-In-Chief of New York Megaphone and was led away by officers on both arms, yelling, “I have an excellent attorney.”

“What you did was illegal,” he screamed at police officials. “What you did was a violation of the f------ Bill of Rights.”

The protesters used megaphones to scream that Giuliani had advanced knowledge of the pending towers' collapse. They also made other claims, including that Giuliani was not a true conservative because of his views on abortion. After Giuliani left, attendees honked their car horns to drown out the protestors, who remained outside the parking lot, yelling into megaphones and arguing with Giuliani backers.

Giuliani downplayed the protestors, who dogged him throughout the coffeehouse visit.

“It’s part of America,” Giuliani said. “You learn when you are mayor of New York City that people have all kinds of different opinions, all kinds of different views. It’s not anything I don’t expect; it’s not anything I haven’t faced before, probably considerably bigger than this. After being mayor of New York for eight years, I would consider this event kind of a minor, four-, five-person protest.”

He said conspiracy theorists are protesting all over the place. “It’s very sad,” he said. “It’s not true. But you’re not going to convince them it’s not true. Somehow their emotions overtake they logic and their rationality.”

A day after McCain said the indictment of Bernard Kerik raised questions about Giuliani’s judgment, Giuliani continued to express disbelief that the remarks were McCain’s real feelings. “I will never attack John McCain personally, nor will I question his judgment,” Giuliani said. “We can have differences on policies, but I’d be very surprised if John would do that with me. We’ve been good friends; we respect each other.”

Giuliani reiterated that he made a mistake in not vetting Kerik, but said he would have to leave the matter to the federal courts. He also said he didn’t know anything about the Clinton campaign planting questions at town hall meetings.

“I think the biggest problem for the Clinton campaign is not whether they plant questions at events,” Giuliani said. “It’s the whole shifting positions of Hillary Clinton, which I think have now caught up with her.” He then went into his frequent attacks on drivers’ licenses for illegal immigrants.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Huge news in a new New Hampshire poll just released. Hillary Clinton's lead is cut by 11%... while Romney expands his lead: http://www.campaigndiaries.com/2007/11/hillary-clintons-new-hampshire-slide.html
Who does Rudy serve...  One hint, It is not Christians.

Watch this...   http://www.brasschecktv.com/page/200.html
9/11 was an inside job.  Giuliani had advanced knowledge.  I'm using my logic Rudy!!!
I'm not a republican or a democrat but I do know this.

Steel buildings do not collapse from being hit by a plane. It has never happened. In fact, those buildings were designed to withstand such an event AND THEY DID.

FACT: Steel burns at a degree higher than fire

FACT: There were explosions in the SUB-BASEMENT of those buildings before they fell. The windows of the first floor lobby were blown out. This is on video and several witnesses heard those explosions and saw the damage prior to the buildings falling.

FACT: Security systems were shut down the weekend prior to 9/11 for "repair".

FACT: A few workers who were working the weekend prior to 9/11 heard strange noises coming from the reinforced floors.

FACT: The last name of the person who was head of security at that time was BUSH. Yes, a relative of the president.

FACT: Building 7 fell all by itself. There was information in there the government never wanted revealed to the American public.

Not a fact, but my strong opinion, those buildings fell due to a controlled demolition.

Not everything is what it appears to be. You only get the story big media presents.


This is exactly why we need RON PAUL for President.  We have lost the right in this country to peaceably assemble and petition for redress of grievances (First Amendment, read it).  When cops arrest people for simply speaking their mind (assuming they did nothing violent), don't wonder why rapists and murderers are out on the streets.

VOTE RON PAUL, he'd give these people a presidential pardon I'm sure.  THE BILL OF RIGHTS STILL STAND!!!
I really dislike Giuliani, he's Bush in an Italian suit.

These people who believe in a 9/11 conspiracy should have darn-well been booted.  I'm shocked to hear that these people are Paul supporters, and I will tell you straight-out: YOU ... ARE ... CRAZY!!!

I just want to respond to the last post.

I'm a precinct captain for RON PAUL here in Minnesota.

Big media says he's a long shot. I say he's our ONLY shot.

Another money bomb 12/15 (Bill of Rights Day) and 12/16 (Boston Tea Party).  

A True American Underdog Story
http://www.youtube. com/watch? v=4aXl3vj2n9M&eurl=http:// community. eons.com/ groups/topics/ ron-paul- for-president
Angelo Serignese

Give some Love:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CuSUR2wNHtk

These videos were more "volunteer" projects.
Isn't this AWESOME!!??  Turn up your sound!
I hope Dr. Paul sees these. He will LOVE IT!

Paige,

still not sure I subscribe to the theory but thanks for the info and you do have valid points. I did watch an excellent presentation a few months ago on c-span that had physicists and professors addressing your same issues. I would put nothing past the bush administration. but please be careful you now may be on a list. the only reason I listen to ron paul at all is because of his 9/11 theories.
Rudy Giuliani deserves to be hounded everywhere he goes. Even if he didn't have advance knowledge of the 9/11 attacks, he certainly has profited from them, with tens of millions of dollars in speaking and consulting fees. His decision to locate the Mayor's Office of Emergency Management inside WTC-7 after the 1993 bombing made no sense at all. That, and his callous disregard for the families of slain firefighters, are enough to damn him.
How much longer can guys like Rudy afford to perpetuate this myth?  The myth that is the official story of September 11th?  Really, even in this article he still cannot scientificaly address any claims of the truth movement.  He resorts in public statements to ad hominem arguements such as "these people are controlled by their emotions."  All attempts to shore up the governments official story of "pancake-collapse" have been disastrous.  Popular Mechanics has failed.  NIST has failed.  An internal standards review by a NIST employee just criticized NIST's own official report of the collapse of the Twin Towers saying did not adhere even to the simplest of scientific standards nor could its results be reproduced experimentally.

Yet here we have Rudy, still fiddling the same tune.  These guys are like a hundred little Nero's, although Rome is burning around them, they refuse to change their song.  I, like other truthers, will never believe that jet fuel melted steel causing 110 stories of steel reinforced concrete to transform into a dust cloud in mere seconds.  It is beyond stupid.

you can trust your eyes people.

SEEING IS BELIEVING-- WATCH THE TOWERS COLLAPSE

These guys look so stupid right now. What can they hope to accomplish?  NIST has changed its story five times about what should be a scientific and predictable event.  It is so ludicrous to believe what they say.  Get with it, Rudy.  If you plan to dominate people with lies they have to be smarter ones.  This lie is all-too-dumb.
We will be posting a video of our Loveland experience very soon!

wearechangecolorado.org
RUDY G SHOULDN'T BLAME THE MESSENGERS, HE SHOULD BE BLAMING THE PERPS but I forgot---- he probably wouldn't be a witness against himself!!! JUSTICE WILL BE SERVED! LET THE TRAITORS CONTINUE TO WEAR THEIR CLOWN FACES! THEIR MAKEUP IS RUNNING...BIG TIME!  

WWW.NWO666.COM
1. Towers 1 and 2 were 207 feet across.  Using that figure for comparison, watch videos of the towers collapsing.  In particular, watch the size of the dust clouds.  You can see the concrete is not collapsing---it is being pulverized to dust particles, right from the very top.  Also watch the steel pieces.  There are huge steel beams being blasted out hundreds of feet.
2. WTC7 was not hit by a plane.  It fell straight down in under 7 seconds.  It did no damage to the buildings on either side.  The CIA, the FBI, the Secret Service, the SEC and Mayor Giuliani's emergency bunker were in that building.  The collapse of this building was not mentioned in the 9/11 Commission report.  FACT: Buildings do not demolish themselves.
3. Go to Google Images.  Search Pentagon 9/11.  Find the plane.  Find a wing, find the tail, find a piece of a wing or the tail, find an engine (one that fits the supposed aircraft...), where's a body, where's a piece of luggage, where's the debris?  How did that guy not hit the ground?  He must've been one hell of a pilot!  (In one of the news videos of that morning, there's a line of men covering the ground at the Pentagon, slowly walking side-by-side in a line, hunched over and scouring the ground.  What are they looking for?  DNA?)
4. Now google Shanksville 9/11.  Where's the plane?  Show me one body, one piece of luggage, one piece of the tail or wing.
5. 503 first-responders accounts were taken by a captain of the NY Fire Department in the weeks following 9/11.  Many of the accounts of the firemen, policemen and emergency medical techs mention bombs and explosions going off in lower levels.  All of the accounts were left out of the 9/11 Commission report.

There are many more unanswered questions, important questions, way too many for America to let this go.  The actions of that day carried us into Afghanistan, then Iraq, and now we're preparing to attack Iran---and it all started with those "Islamofascists" that supposedly attacked us on 9/11.
9/11 was a Zionist false flag, Giuliani was intimately involved & admitted getting a warning to Peter Jennings
It would seem that the majority of Americans do not believe the official story and seem to want the 911 investigation re-opened immediately.  I think for the sake of saving your country you should at the minimum have a completely open investigation and those who may have been negligent or even responsible punished if only for the sake of saving the Nation. Until this happens those who refuse to answer clear questions to the American people seem to be hiding something and therefore the suspicion of guilt hangs over them.
In Rudy's own words
http://tinyurl.com/3ageht
it's funny he mentioned the lack of logic due to emotions - isn't that the effect 9/11 had on the people..  allowing the illogical wars that followed?

and if you don't have serious questions about 9/11 - then you haven't done the research.. http://ae911truth.org <-- Architects and Engineers for 9/11 Truth..  

those buildings broke the laws of physics when they collapsed.
Giuliani is one of the September Criminals.  We know.  Who will be our Jim Garrison?
911 inside job FACT!
Chemical Analysis: Thermate
Amazing, the link to the last post does not work, thanks msnbc.  anything else you would like to keep from the public?
100 miles out, 50 miles out, 10 miles out, ahhh Mr. Cheney do the orders still stand ?  Yes you SOB, they still stand...!!!"  Mr Cheney is responsible for the Pentagon attack.  Jeb Bush was head of the Security Firm for the Twin Towers.  Black outs occured there for weeks before the "attacks", what were they doing???  Why were there glowing melted steel in the sub basements for MONTHS after the "collapse"????  What the hell went on down there?  Millionaire Fienstein or whoever he is from NY admitted on National Television WTC7 was demolished, so clearly all three was demolished.  RON PAUL is the only person running for office I would vote for now.  This country is now hated by the whole world because of our policies.  Germany went down in flames, the whole world put a stop to that insanity.  Why is Bush Co. so determined to follow in Hitlers footsteps?  
rudy is a mafioso dictator who exploits 911 families and troops and does not answer to the american people,only to the corporations and foreign interest just like most of our polititians,that's why my choice and only choice is RON PAUL.
If the 80 floors under the 30 floors coming down were jello it would impede the speed of the fall by many seconds. Just as diving a belly flop would do in the water. The oficial report is like saying a great oak tree collapes into dust straight down at the speed of gravity because lightning struck it at the top. What made the majority of Americans so gulible? It's unbeleivable yet true how they buy the oficial report.
The very fact that he's even in the running for President is disgusting and disturbing.

Vote for RON PAUL!
http://www.ronpaul2008.com
http://www.prisonplanet.com

WAKE UP!!!
do your job MSNBC ! ! !

otherwise We the People will be holding you acccountable for complicity in cover-up of the monstrous crimes of 9/11
Its their own fault people are questioning things.  Even if the people asking questions are sad and wrong and not using logic like Rudy suggests...their secretive, elitist way of running government creates this line of questioning.  Rightfully so I might add.  If these people were not around you would not be living in a society that is free in anyway.

Why don't they just answers the questions people are asking.  Having popular mechanics parade a video editor as an expert and answer only a few questions, in a way people question themselves is not answering questions.

Some people in this government need to grow up and start acting like adults.
I see the truthers are out in force trying to spread thier unprovable crap.
Follow your hearts America... I'm voting for Ron Paul 2008!
It is interesting what questions the leading politicians do and don't answer.  It is understandable they wouldn't answer: to do so would open them up to all kinds of s**t they wouldn't want to step into.  Silence is the most powerful hammer on the head of dissenters.  They don't stone the Prophets anymore - they ignore them.

Uncle Raisin
www.UncleRaisin.com
"Raisin" the Standard Against Injustice
I'm supporting the only honest man running and the best Presidential candidate in generations: Ron Paul!
I can NOT wait until the day that the media will finally pick up the well known FACT that Giuliani is a CROSSDRESSER...Fact!

Thank you Lord for sending the American people a sign that we need to turn this ship around before it sinks like the titanic.
Also, hey Rudy G...(aka foreign policy expert via 9/11 tragedy) if you read this blog or any of your PAID people do, it's called National DEFENSE not OFFENSE ya dumb *** ! Read the consitution and get a clue as to what our military is supposed to be used for.

MUST SEE VIDEO FOLLOWS

Ron Paul: A True American Underdog Story
http://www.youtube. com/watch? v=ZJDqneN4weE

My brother died in the World Trade Center.

911 Was an inside job.  Please do your own research.


www.RonPaul2008.com

Freedom isn't free. Protect the constitution and the Bill of Rights. This isn't a football game of us "Democrats" vs. them "Republicans". Stop the madness to stop articles like this.

Give on December 16th to the cause of freedom.

MUST SEE VIDEO. TURN UP YOUR SOUND.

http://www.youtube. com/watch? v=ZJDqneN4weE
9/11 is STILL a naked fraud no matter how you spin it.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=459736

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google