ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC Political Researcher



Tancredo justifies controversial ad

Posted: Wednesday, November 14, 2007 10:32 AM by Domenico Montanaro
Filed Under: ,

From NBC’s Domenico Montanaro

Tancredo attempted to justify his controversial new ad in an interview with MSNBC’s Mika Brzezinski. He said the FBI has released reports on malls being targets and talked of “chatter” about “potential activity in the United States.”

“All I’m saying is what we know to be the case,” Tancredo said. “We know there are consequences to open borders.”

He also said he doesn't care if the ad hurts his campaign. "C'est la vie," he said, adding, "I don’t care what it does to the campaign. Whether the numbers go up or go down."
 
Questioned on whether the ad is fear-mongering, he said, "Why shouldn’t we talk about the most serious matters. ...I'm all for trying to stop someone from trying to get here. That’s the purpose of this ad."
 
He added that he doesn't think US involvement in the Middle East has made any difference -- one way or the other -- because we are in a "clash of civilizations." "This problem isn’t going to go away if we left the Middle East,” Tancredo said. “It's not about our relationship with Israel. This is not about our action anywhere. We’d still be in a fight with Islam.”

He has come under fire from the Council on American-Islamic Relations for the ad. But Tancredo said he doesn't care if the group criticizes him, because “it's known that they have ties to terrorists.” He said, in fact, he hopes they're upset because it shows they are threatened by the ad.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Tancredo, the crusader 'onward tancredo soldiers, marching off to oblivion', I think he would make a good King of Palestine, desperate men use desperate actions to prove they are not desperate. Tancredo tanks after Iowa. Good for the GOP, good for the country. What we need is a good old childrens crusade to alleviate the population of slakers and x-box users, let them use their finger skills to pull a trigger. lets also put mothers back on a pedastal so that we can secretly abuse them in our homes, make my god money, it is what drives our consumer society. Tancredo another example of intelligent design!!#
Shouldn't the headline be "Tancredo attempts to justify controversial ad"?  Or are you guys just that easily placated?
Republicans!!  Would you expect anything less?
Attention Beach-goers:  The shark has been jumped.
Tancredo should be concerned if his numbers go down, because it will be the first instance in politics where one's support can be measured in negative numbers.
Tancredo is the clown who says we should nuke Mecca if there's another terrorist act !!

Declare war on the Islamic religion !!
What a moron !!
Why do I get the feeling that people who say stuff like this, are Hoping for a Terrorist Attack? To paraphrase FDR, "The only thing we have to Fear, are Nuts like this!".
Shadow,
Good point, but this would actually be the second time when someone received negative support.  I believe Bush received something like 2% support of blacks which was within the poll's 4% margin of error which meant his support could have been minus 2%!
PS, I'm ashamed to say that Tancredo is the congressman from my district (as opposed to saying he's my congressman).
Tancredo reminds me of Oral Roberts.....

give me $50 million or I will be recalled to heaven....

I didn't give him a dime.......

still didn't work.........
 let's just kill everyone then all the terrorists will be gone
Bob in Denver, I can kind of relate to how you feel.  Steve King isn't my Rep. but he's from Iowa.  King and Tancredo are cut from the same cloth.  The sad part is that Steve King probably represents his constituents pretty well.  I once heard one of them (I grew up in western IA) go on a rant against government gone out of control when they installed crossing gates at a railroad crossing that sees almost 100 trains/day!
Will work for food Will kill you for a vote, ha ha that guys a joker ,he kills me or the arabs kill me or the mexicans will kill me but follow Tancredo I will live forever,like Bush he can promise saftey and well being from anything.
I think Jerry is really Tancredo...
Zionist politicians!!  Would you expect anything less?? They do not care about human lives or our wellbeing here. It is always Israel only that counts (and their selfishness)....
The Terrorists probably have this ad "favorited" in their YourTube accounts...it plays into the very feeling they are trying to generate...the ad is disgusting.
I give it up to Tom for calling it like it it. Why would he expect Americans want to hear anything less than the truth, the whole truth and nothing BUT the truth. Try as the "interviewer" this morning did to call out Tancredo as to some suspect agenda or whatever. Really. Kudo's, Tom. I want to hear anything and everything. I do not want my media telling me because it is a election year we have to sweeten and light the truth. The TRUTH should be what it is. God help us if we cannot handle the truth - and or choose to TRY to defame the truth-tellers. ANY truthteller, political party and/or political aspiration be danged...
Tancredo's been spending too much time in Cheney's office - or Corpus Christi.    
I think these comments illustrate why he is running this ad.  There are too many Americans that don't take border control seriously.  

Our border control and immigration process are a disaster.  Tancredo is pointing out some of the very realistic consequences of not taking this seriously.

According to the comments here, he is correct to be concerned.
This is a horrible ad, an insult to the American people and to all of those who have lost loved ones to terrorism.

Mr. Tancredo is stealing a page out of the Rove book of campaigning, attempting to scare people into voting for him.  The 2004 re-election of GWB was achieved with this tactic, and the American public won't fall for it again.  He should be ashamed.

His desperation is pathetic.  He should drop out now.
I'm a Democrat and the facts support Tancredo and his message. Apparently, telling the truth now is deemed "controversial." That's not a good sign for our country.

On the three "border issues" -- ie the terrorists, the massive drug shipments, and the foreigners who cross our borders without control by our government...

First, the FBI and CIA still hold to their estimate from several years ago that 60 terrorist cells are already here in the U.S. and that our unsecured borders provide the easy route in and easy escape out for them and others who seek to destroy us. But Tancredo is somehow inaccurate in restating this.

Second, none other than our own DEA, the Drug Enforcement Administration, has said with specific statistics and maps for everyone to look at, our southern border is how 90 percent of the drugs Americans use come into this country. To be perfectly sarcastic -- hey, it's only the losers of our society who would use drugs, so this clear threat to us doesn't really matter, does it? Doesn't really hurt our society or cause us to pay more taxes at all, does it. Tancredo states the obvious.

Third, the millions of foreigners who have come here secretly, without processing and without our approval on a case by case basis -- by following our current immigration laws -- are seemingly as important if not more important as our citizens to our elected leaders: Few speak out on behalf of citizen' rights but instead back the demands of illegals, because they have no political courage. Again, Tancredo does, and is considered strange for it. Amazing.

So that's the state of America today. Spineless leaders, another huge special interest group of foreigners that doesn't obey our laws, and an American society that apparently doesn't want something else from our leaders.

Tancredo speaks the truth, but some don't want to hear it. I applaud his efforts.
Tancredo made a few comments that are correct, Even if we left the middle east today and stopped all support of Isreal,today, Bin Laden and the rest would still contine to wage thier Jihad(holy war) against the United States. Open your eyes, at this point I dont really care if a democrat or republican is elected in 08, the terroist will continue to seek the destruction of our country. I dont understand how you cant see that.
John: So do I. Liberals are merely trying to shoot the messenger. What I find curious is that many will still accept 9/11 as ''an inside job'' as gospel,and then attempt to dismiss or downplay the very real threats observed by Tancredo. We have already observed in one of the most recent cases,the Ft.Dix Islamic conspiritors,where recently arrived immigrants to this nation immediately set upon contriving terrorist activities in order to kill more Americans. HEZBOLLAH cells have been identified in several American cities which is no portion of mere Tancredo paranoia either. These are documented facts resulting in criminal trials aimed at the American-based supporters of terrorism finally reaching into the highest levels of the CIA with the recent arrest of an agent now deemed to be a HEZBOLLAH plant.[MSNBC Nov.14,2007 for more on that].
                Obviously,the massive incursion of Mexican gangs including their mafia,MS-13,Surenos,Nortenos and other violent criminal entities is also causing its own grief to cities all along the Mexican border. There is no excuse whatever for certain segments of Americans to try and make believe that this problem does not exist. Towns and cities which have never seen a drive-by shooting in their incorporated lives now deal with several a month. Jails and prisons are packed to beyond capacity[Californias San Quentin and Folsom,meant to hold 3,000 and 3,500 prisoners respectively,now hold over twice this with most being Mexican illegals or those involved with its gangs].
            More crime as a result. Murder,rape,drug trafficking and manufacture,kidnapping,identity theft,robbery,DUI-DWI,are all spiraling upwards in all states of the West with tandem increases observed where Hispanic workers are centered in interior states including Maine,Connecticut,North Carolina,Oklahoma,Nebraska,and Iowa among others.[FBI Uniform Crime Statistics,By-State,2006 www.doj.gov].
            Tancredo is the canary in the mineshaft and while he has no chance whatever of putting up even a marginal race for president,his position is an omen for those who believe that we can ignore it,and yet prevent another catastrophe that will end up killing more Americans. His opinions will be vindicated by the passage of time.
             
There is no justification for an ad of that nature. None.
You know what, tom trancedo and the reprehensibles e had absolute control of the gooberment from 2001-2007...they failed miserably to address the illegal alien issue in any meaningful way...of course they also failed to address most things except their need to scare the heck out of everyone to get reelected or take away our civil rights...
Tancredo "fearmongering" has run the course along with "gay marriage" and the "earth warming conspiracy".  The only threatning chatter I hear is that espoused by the Repugnicants and their dedicated chatter box, Fox News!  You talk about securing the border, which one?  The border south of Colorado Springs between Pueblo and Colorado Springs or north between Castle Rock and Colorado Springs.  I fully concur with you.  Secure both!  We need to contain the neo-conservative "feramongeres" within that area.  Indeed I hope your campaign runs out of funds ... you are already out of compassion, out of any testimony worthy of emulation, out of touch with the rest of America and out of ideas!  Since you used French (to my surprise) I'll respond in French, "adieu" and in Spanish, "adios"!  C'est la vie!
Tancredo "fearmongering" has run the course along with "gay marriage" and the "earth warming conspiracy".  The only threatning chatter I hear is that espoused by the Repugnicants and their dedicated chatter box, Fox News!  You talk about securing the border, which one?  The border south of Colorado Springs between Pueblo and Colorado Springs or north between Castle Rock and Colorado Springs.  I fully concur with you.  Secure both!  We need to contain the neo-conservative "feramongeres" within that area.  Indeed I hope your campaign runs out of funds ... you are already out of compassion, out of any testimony worthy of emulation, out of touch with the rest of America and out of ideas!  Since you used French (to my surprise) I'll respond in French, "adieu" and in Spanish, "adios"!  C'est la vie!
jOHN lUMA ARE THE MILLIONS WHO CAME HERE SECRETLY ARE THEY ALL YOUR white EUROPEON BROTHERS AND FATHERS MOTHERS AND SISTERS WHO stole this land from the indians,OR ALL THE SLAVES YOU BROUGHT HERE TO BUILD YOUR NATION OR ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT THE CHINES AND IRISH YOU BROUGHT IIN TO BUILD YOUR RAILROADS AND DIG YOUR MINES,DONT HAVE A PROBLEM WITH ALL OF THEM DO YOU,JUST KEEP REPEATING WHAT YOU HEAR YOU SAD LITTLE PEOPLE .muttsmutts mutts who think they have class.
Rick: And yet the only ones rasing the alarm were the Tancredos of the world. Democrats will not touch border safety with a ten-foot pole and they will be held to this standard once the backstretch into Nov.08 comes into view.
.Rick, Certainly the Republicans had control of Congress during that time.  When you look at the lack of support for Congress now and then, this is one of the main reasons.

What is truly sick is that people argue Republican vs. Democrat when it should be citizens vs. politicians.

Our country is mess due to both parties and changing the seat in the WH or even party control in Congress will change nothing.

Here in MA, we have a full delegation of inept, left wing fools that take more from MA than give back.  They are the problem.  As it is in many states.

No change in President or party control of Congress is going the change the fact that our government is a mess.  Absolute mess.

Some of the things not being done just cost us extra money, many of the things actually leave people without the services they need and some things not being done actually hurt national security.

Tancredo is right.  Too bad the squeamish don't want to discuss the truth.  His ad isn't reprehensible.

The fact that politicians in both parties won't fix the problem is reprehensible.

And the fact that too many people find the truth reprehensible is reprehensible.
You seem to think the terrorists came from the south, you are building a fence down there but what about Canada? Seems you are more afraid of brown people than terrorists or the french canadians, that is why we think this is not about terroism. Tancredo is the anti brown candidate of the nativist wing and decided to tie it to terrorists and mall bombings, we know the reports about where they want to attack for maximum effect, we are not dumb nor will we be cowled into submitting to the fear candidacy of many in the pachyderm party. We would like to fix this problem but we can't when it is a political issue instead of a national issue. Tone down the rethoric and talk to the people across the congressional aisle, oh yeah your group don't do diplomacy, tooo messy.
If you know Tancredo you know he isn't in it for the votes at all. He ran for president for the purpose of getting people to pay attention to the issue of open borders. While the ad is over the top, its no different than any other republican or democrat scare tactics, Republicans: if you don't vote for me we will all die. Democrats: If you don't vote for me, all of your rights will dissapear and you will be locked in Gitmo.
  I support this man.  Finally someone who GETS IT.
Colorado is one of the states that has really been hit with illegals.  It is the truth.  Not scarey.  Just the truth.
  I support this man.  Finally someone who GETS IT.
Colorado is one of the states that has really been hit with illegals.  It is the truth.  Not scarey.  Just the truth.
Then open up the concentration camps and start with the 11 million who are here already you bunch of nazis and the puckers couldnt stop abortion and couldnt stop terrorists from hitting the towers but im betting they can win this.
Where were all these super tough on immigration guys for the past 6 years? They have no credibility. They should step aside and give someone else a chance.
My thanks to Tom Tancredo for bringing America's attention to the issue that Midwesterners have been talking about across lunch counters and over the breakfast and dinner tables for the last 30 years.

We Americans ought to take Tom Tancredo's concerns seriously...because they are the same concerns that millions of Americans have had for the last several decades.  It is time to shut the border and stop sanctuary cities.  It is time to enforce the law and discourage illegal immigration.
I do not understand the mindset of those who are offended by Tancredo and his video.  Why can't you see the danger?? Did you hear the news today?  60 Al-Quaida smuggled across the border at Laredo, with the help of Mexican druglords.  I guess Tancredo wasn't wrong, and all you ostriches were.
Where is your national pride??  It is not racist to say, "Speak English and respect our culture"  It is racist to move to another country and REFUSE to adapt.
I do not understand the mindset of those who are offended by Tancredo and his video.  Why can't you see the danger?? Did you hear the news today?  60 Al-Quaida smuggled across the border at Laredo, with the help of Mexican druglords.  I guess Tancredo wasn't wrong, and all you ostriches were.
Where is your national pride??  It is not racist to say, "Speak English and respect our culture"  It is racist to move to another country and REFUSE to adapt.
Tancredo is right. The problems of unchecked immigration in California, Texas, New Mexico is spreading like a blight into Arizona, Nevada, Oregon and Idaho.
It is a matter of numbers..39 million in 7 years is more than the population of the State of California.
Any one who is psychotic, antisocial can be run up or down over the border ..Why should Mexico jail their criminals or revolutionaries..Drive them north..and problem solved
Remember that illegal who was riding the trains, killing women who lived along the tracks..dodging police in both countries..
The 9/11 Hijackers were all Illegals..and Iran is moving into Nicaragua..
Get your head out of the sand and pay attention..
Tancredo is a very mellow man who is stating an obvious truth..but if the truth hurts..some here want to attack the messenger..
It won't save anything to deny the reality..King Harvest will surely come..


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=466099

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google