ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Romney criticizes Rudy on NYC budget

Posted: Saturday, November 24, 2007 10:28 PM by Domenico Montanaro



From NBC/NJ’s Erin McPike
ROMNEY WEEKEND CAMPAIGN NOTEBOOK

AMHERST, N.H. – Romney dialed up his attack rhetoric a notch this morning at a town hall forum at Souhegan High School here. Just a few minutes into his speech, he set his sights on Giuliani, calling him a good friend first before launching into his attack.

“I know he did a good job as mayor of New York City,” Romney began, “but on spending and fiscal matters, there was a problem there, because when he came in, there was a budget gap, but when he left, he left a budget gap twice as big as the one he inherited, over $3 billion.”

He went on: “And Mayor Bloomberg has said he’d never leave a deficit like that to the person that follows him. And by the way, that $3 billion deficit doesn’t include the costs associated with 9/11.”

Giuliani also is in New Hampshire today for a bus tour of the state, but it wasn’t just the former mayor who took hits from the state’s Republican primary front-runner.

“You’re going to see a lot of whining next year from the Democratic side,” Romney told the crowd, and added that “optimism and hope” will be the banner for Republicans.

As usual, Clinton was the primary target. He said so far, his favorite moment of the campaign was when his picture showed up in her most recent ad in the Granite State. “She said, ‘Mitt Romney: Part of the Republican attack machine.’ Isn’t that great?” he said to laughter and applause. “It’s really exciting to have a campaign that’s that strong. She hasn’t seen nothing yet, of course.”

And further into his remarks, he joked, “Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama and John Edwards – did you see them at the debate the other night? I hope not. I looked. I’ve got to be honest, I didn’t inhale, but I did look,” he said, taking a veiled swipe at Bill Clinton.

Obama withstood the same attacks from Romney that he often does, which is opposition to the war in Iraq. “Thank heavens Barack Obama wasn’t president nine months ago, saying ‘Gosh, it’s not going very well right now, so let’s just pull out.’”

He also worked in a couple of lines against Edwards toward the end, saying that since he had talked about Clinton and Obama, “it wasn’t fair” not to talk about Edwards. Enter his criticism of Edwards’ hypothesis of “the Two Americas.”

Later in Derry, N.H., Romney confirmed with reporters on the steps of the Derry Opera House in front of dozens of cheering supporters early this afternoon his belief that Judge Kathe Tuttman should resign her judgeship. Shortly thereafter, he zoomed down through the county's holiday parade.

Late Friday afternoon spokesman Eric Fehrnstrom told the Boston Globe that it was the campaign's belief that Tuttman showed a lapse in judgment and should resign after allowing convicted killer Daniel Tavares to be released from the prison sentence he served for 16 years. Tavares reportedly had threatened to kill Romney and has now allegedly killed a young married couple since his release. Romney today said he came to that decision after reviewing the case and meeting with his staff to discuss it.

He was also asked about Obama's judgment. Obama this week told a group of New Hampshire high school students that he had tried drugs when in high school. Romney explained: "President Bush said it best when he said, 'When I was young and irresponsible, I was young and irresponsible.'" And as presidential candidates, he thought they should all leave it at that, because no one is perfect, but again insinuated that they should set an example.

After the short session with more reporters than usual, he hurried down another set of stairs and joined the Derry holiday parade -- beginning with a brief session of pretending to conduct the high school band. As he's done before, he ran back and forth across the parade route (but stuck disproportionately to the right side). Several times those on the other side of the street tried to summon him over, and at one point, he did run across, saying, "Oh, there are girls over there!"

Most of those staffing him kept falling behind him in his jogs when trying to shake hands as quickly as possible with everyone he brushed by.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Like I have said before, Giuliani needs to be stopped, he is no different than Hillary and her goonies.  The only voice of reason is Ron Paul on the Republican side, and he will take Hillary down like a clown.  Look Ron Paul up. He is for Liberty and Freedom and what is important to us Patriots.

http://RonPaul2008.com
Romney's right.  Rudy left quite a budget deficit for a fiscal conservative.  3 billion.  Ouch.  But Romney, on the other hand, took a 3 billion dollar deficit in Mass and turned it into a 2 billion dollar rainy day fund.  The fiscal conservative in me says vote for Romney.
I think Romney should be critical of Giuliani, that saves us the time in having to do it. I hope the American public will be critical of both these guys, as well as McCain - Mr. War#2, as well as the illegal guy Huckabee.  
Beware those who begin with, "my good friend," then continue to disparage: "I know he did a good job...but..."

Interestingly, former governor of 'Romney's state,' Paul Cellucci, and former Massachusetts treasurer, Joseph Malone, have not only endorsed Giuliani--instead of Romney--but have joined Giuliani on the campaign trail.

According to Cellucci, the fiscal deficit for NYC, which Romney is claiming for Giuliani, occurred in the fiscal year after the middle of the fiscal year Giuliani left office.

Cellucci and Malone report Romney Increased the tax burden for Massachusetts by increasing fees, property taxes and corporate taxes--saying Romney failed to achieve his goal of rolling back income taxes from 5.3% to 5%. Celucci stated Romney said one thing and did another. [not again!!]
(Boston Globe 11/25/07)

See a lot of whining from the Democratic side??? Pleeeease not more than from Romney, already! Romney continually hides behind cruel accusations of "RELIGIOUS BIGOTRY," "RELIGIOUS INTOLERANCE," and "UN-AMERICAN" rather than answer to clear up the inconsistencies in his statement of 'faith.' (His 'faith' Romney threw into this campaign). Voters, including LDS and Christians, those who "believe in the Bible," are perplexed by Romney's claims to believe in God, Jesus and the Bible. Is he referring to God and Jesus of the Bible? Or, God and Jesus of LDS? MANY Voters want to know.

As for "RELIGIOUS BIGOTRY," Romney is SWORN to uphold and sustain LDS scriptures, which include LDS 'deep doctrine' not readily shared with outsiders or new/prospective converts, (over which, it is reported, some have lost their lives for sharing, that is how important I feel these POLITICAL-LDS TEACHINGS should be shared), such as:

LDS "LAW of LDS God" regarding the "AFRICAN RACE" is that if any "WHITE MAN OF THE CHOSEN SEED" mixes his blood, it will be "DEATH ON THE SPOT. THIS WILL ALWAYS BE.The AFRICAN RACE is MARKED with FLAT NOSES AND DARK SKIN and this CURSE will remain on them until all Adam's other children have been resurrected. (eg Journal of Discourses,vol.10,p.110; vol.7,p.290,291; vol.2,p.143; vol.11,p.272).

LDS "RELIGIOUS INTOLERANCE," includes such LDS 'deep doctrine' as:

The time's coming, ANYONE NOT HEARTILY FOR LDS God WILL BE HEWN DOWN (eg Journal of Discourses, vol.3,pg.226). LDS God is Man of flesh and blood (eg Moses 6:57,7:35; Doctrine and Covenants 130:22).

As for "UN-AMERICAN" consider the OATH OF VENGENCE AGAINST THE GOVERNMENT OF THE UNITED STATES once required in LDS temple rites, taught to LDS children and children's children in which:
SWEAR ETERNAL HOSTILITY TO--
TO RENOUNCE ALL ALLEGIANCE TO--
TO STAND ABSOLVED OF ALL OATHS OF FEALTY, PAST OR FUTURE, EVER MADE TO--
AND,TO DO ALL IN THEIR POWER TO OVERTHROW--
THE GOVERNMENT OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Teaching children, that in the event of failure, they are to take up the cause after them.
This, too,
SWORN TO FIDELITY AND SECRECY.

I,too, would like to know just how Romney intends to answer to oaths of obedience to LDS prophet and priethood authority, in all things temporal and spiritual, all the LDS oaths, sworn on his life AND, THE OATH OF OFFICE OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA.

Romney compares himself to JFK. The Catholic church doesn't require members to swear a most solemn oath before the heavens and the earth, to uphold, cherish, sustain and build up ONLY LDS 'kingdom' and NO OTHER on earth. (eg "Ensign" Nov.2000,p.7). JFK helped voters understand where he stood with his religion and his politics.

I, too, have taken up the march to help voters make educated votes.
still undecided-
Hiding behind a false name but still bearing false witness.
One of the big TEN, remember?  
I'll give you a hint, "thou shalt not..."

Go Romney! We love you!!!

Undecided, wow, what a rant on your part.  Somehow I doubt you're undecided.

A vote for Rudy is just BEGGING for a swiftboat attack!  I can see the march to the general election now, the narrative about Rudy would be Kerik this, NYFD for truth that.  It would be attack after attack on Rudy and he would spend the whole time defending himself until he finally lost.

A vote for Huckabee is a vote for Rudy.

Just say no to Huckagiluianabee
Agreed. As this article ( http://miraclesdaily.blogspot.com/2007/11/rudy-giuliani-cannot-beat-hillary.html ) points out, the establishment machine will shred up Giuliani and recycle him. If America does not more of the same and worse, Romney must win the Republican nomination.
Why attack me for sharing verifiable public information? Making no sense and making cruel accusation? who are you ts
Someone else's doubts don't matter.
Eric, study H and G some and you will see why a vote for H is NOT a vote for G.
christian prophet, study r some and see why he Would be MORE OF THE SAME OR WORSE.
The message boards are helping me decide who I DON'T want to vote for, anyway!
Does anyone know that Sen. Harry Reed of Nevada is a very devout Mormon convert? What about Evra Taft Benson, Secretary of Agriculture?  He became the prophet of the Mormon Church until his death.  Marion Romney also a Mormon.  The list goes on and on in the government.  Mormanism is not new in the U.S. government.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=479445

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google