ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Oh-eight (R): Enter Snowman

Posted: Tuesday, November 27, 2007 9:07 AM by Domenico Montanaro
Filed Under:

The Washington Post has been combing through the submitted questions for tomorrow's CNN/YouTube debate, and it finds one of the toughest questions could be one of the shortest: "What does the word 'Republican' mean to you?" "The period for submitting questions via YouTube video ended yesterday, and almost 5,000 were offered up as fodder for the debate. The videos are as diverse as the questioners themselves, coming from all ages and backgrounds, and from Republicans and Democrats alike. In one, a black woman from Dallas, soon to be out of college and lamenting that she needs to learn Spanish to secure a job, asks how the candidates feel about non-English-speaking immigrants. In another, a middle-age man from Tucson, sitting in his wheelchair, asks about stem cell research. A gay Republican from Atlanta asks: "How can we make the Republican Party a more large, open tent?"

The New York Times adds that the GOP CNN/YouTube debate was postponed in summer in part because one of the candidates, Mitt Romney, thought the Democratic debate was demeaned when CNN showed a video of an animated snowman asking a question about global warming. Mr. Romney eventually relented. A new snowman video has been submitted for the Republicans. Will it be shown? ‘Tune in and see,’ said David Bohrman, CNN’s Washington bureau chief and executive producer of the debate.”

GIULIANI: The former mayor said yesterday he "never had any doubt" that if he were president four years ago, he would have invaded Iraq. He said he is now "even more certain" that it was the correct national security move. “‘I actually believe that Democrats are going to agree with me on that by the time we get to the general election,’ the Republican former New York City mayor said. Giuliani addressed a wide range of issues in an hour-long meeting with editors of the New Hampshire Union Leader.

HUCKABEE: The New York Sun notes that in the five-way contest on the GOP side, two candidates have avoided "direct conflict, exchanging more compliments than criticism." Those candidates: Giuliani and Huckabee. "The comments only add to the perception that even as he rises in the polls, Mr. Huckabee is angling for the vice presidential slot on the Republican ballot, should Mr. Giuliani win the nomination. As an affable Southerner with a solidly conservative record on social issues, Mr. Huckabee could provide precisely the kind of geographic and political balance needed for a ticket topped by an occasionally abrasive New Yorker who supports abortion rights, analysts say."

MCCAIN: Does this help McCain in New Hampshire? "…Iowa and New Hampshire must make good on their commitments to vet the candidates without fear or favor; they must be motivated by good citizenship alone, serving as unbiased jurors," writes the Boston Globe's Peter Canellos. "This year, only one of the states is living up to the ideal. New Hampshirites are checking out the candidates freely and fairly, without imposing any special-interest agenda of their own. But there is strong evidence that Iowans are using their early-voting status to make the candidates pass a litmus test on ethanol subsidies." More: "There could be other reasons for McCain's low standing in Iowa. But if a presidential candidate can be derailed for taking a stand against a regional sacred cow like ethanol, there's something wrong with the system."

PAUL:
Paul picked up the endorsement of the owner of the Moonlite BunnyRanch, a brothel in Nevada. "I'll get all the (working girls) together, and we can raise him some money," Dennis Hof told the Reno Gazette-Journal. "I'll put up a collection box outside the door. They can drop in $1, $5 contributions." Hof and two of his prostitutes, Brooke Taylor and a woman who goes by Air Force Amy, attended a Paul news conference.

And check out the AP's video report on the endorsement. The correspondent's lead: "Working the polls have taken on a whole new meaning."

ROMNEY: The Des Moines Register analyzes Romney's newest ad, which focuses on family. "This ad continues one of the main themes of the former governor's campaign for president, attempting to appeal to evangelicals and social conservatives with a focus on traditional Judeo-Christian values.”

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

In one, a black woman from Dallas, soon to be out of college and lamenting that she needs to learn Spanish to secure a job, asks how the candidates feel about non-English-speaking immigrants.

This is America....you speak English.
Where was this job, serving enchiladas?

English needs to be and should be the main language in the workplace.
PAUL: Paul picked up the endorsement of the owner of the Moonlite BunnyRanch, a brothel in Nevada.

LOL....
This is what Ron Paul is all about?.....

I could make a few comments about this one, but I doubt First Read will post them, so I will refrain...

I expect something like this to come from the Clinton's....
republicans, party of religous hate,outrageous spendiing,corporate welfare,foreign diasters and endless wars .

bet NOT one of the candiates are that factual
Giuliani is a riot, he can't even get everyone in his OWN party to agree going into Iraq was the right thing to do.  Not only Paul, but also Huckabee, have disagreed with that.  
I hope Ron Paul runs as an indepentent. He's no right winger, so has no chance of getting the GOP nod. A dem or repub in the White House will only keep this country divided. That has to stop before it destroys our country. Besides, both parties are responsible for all our problems. Vote anti-incumbent and kick them all out!
GOP = The otrture party. That and feinstein and shumer. Y'all are forgetting what America used to stand for and stand against. Now the Bushies made the party the torture party, outed covert cia agent who was working against Iran's nukes, Missiung executive branch emails, stonewalling, pardoning a co conspirater (libby), domestic spying (like all the citizens have now become suspected terrorists) on and on. No video of a plane hitting the pentagon. And all those cameras. Go figure.

We are living under an undefined coup of sorts. Looting the treasury, taking away civil liberty, destroying those who question you (plame) and more war. All behaviors that immediately follow every coup across the face of history. Just like what is happening with us now. Think about it.

Bush Cheney Hague '09. Or impeach now.
They are all losers. Americans are stupid. They vote for these losers who give tax benefits to the wealthy and the corporate interest. Exxon only made 10 billion (boo hoo) The middle class is disappearing, millions will lose their homes in foreclosures. Health benefits are disappearing. Bush will not even give health care to children for fear that a middle class family man might benefit. Rudy is a liar and everyone believes these numbnuts. What a country !
Jerry, you are useless as a person and the enchilada comment just goes to show how out of touch with the way America needs to be that it's not even worthwhile reading the drivel spilt from your uninformed, racist mouth.
The middle class in this country are just standing by and watching their class disapear!
This is America....you speak English.
Where was this job, serving enchiladas?

English needs to be and should be the main language in the workplace.

jerry/corpus christi texas (Sent Tuesday, November 27, 2007 9:17 AM)

Spanish speaking people are in high demand at my place of occupation.  We don't serve enchiladas, we serve banks all around the United States.

Now, I agree that English should be the primary language in the United States, but you don't have to be a racist pig to say that.
"The former mayor said yesterday he 'never had any doubt' that if he were president four years ago, he would have invaded Iraq."


I doubt it.  We invaded Iraq because Bush had a score to settle with Saddam.  I doubt that another President would shine the nation's focus on Iraq in the first place and there would have been no weapons of mass destruction discussion.  And if Giuliani would have invaded Iraq, would he have also falsified the intelligence, because was integral in our nation's collective decision.  My question: Is that a lacking of good leadership or foreign policy experience or both?  And of course the Democratic candidate will agree that you are/were always insane, because that is what the American

Brilliant Giuliani to shift the discussion to what you would have done, but I want to know what you would do now.
Ron Paul is about restoring the constitution creating personal liberty . He is the only candidate to end the Iraq war immediately , lower the income tax and create a better Amerika for all of us. It is sad to see the smearing campain from big media linking him with a brothel owner. Vote Ron Paul !
To JR: Mike Huckabee is not one of those losers.  If he can win the Presidency, he will work hard to return this country to the principles which once made it great.  He has expressed outrage several times about the obscene salaries paid to the Big Corporation CEOs.  He is on YOUR side.  Come and help him really take this country back for the people.
I take offense to your post JR, ny. We are not all stupid however, I do agree with your assessment. To whom are you speaking be a bit more specific.  Way too general do not throw us all down the drain just because we disagree. We complain on these post all the time about politicians basbing each other but here you are doing the same thing. Be nice !!!!1
I guess I should be happy Ron Paul has gotten popular enough to even be mentioned in this piece. Though, when the author maliciously reports on a novelty item, it is really a piece of s*&t.

Join the revolution!
Vote Ron Paul.
GIULIANI....THE RE-INCARNATION OF THE "EVIL" COUNT ORLOV, OF LEMONY SNICKET STORIES!!!!!!!!!!!
GIULIANI....THE RE-INCARNATION OF THE "EVIL" COUNT ORLOV, OF LEMONY SNICKET STORIES!!!!!!!!!!!
Do you believe it's a mistake for CNN to make the questions available for viewing ahead of the debate?

http://www.youpolls.com/details.asp?pid=1105

.
What does "Republican" mean to me -

R - rendition
E - English only
P - patriarchial
U - un-American
B - Bushies
L - liars
I - incompetent
C - closet gays
A - anti-Constitution
N - NOT GOING TO BE IN POWER COME '08


Joe Scarborough...What a hack, and did you notice that little twerp that brought it up. I think the american people are wise to this kind of garbage. They are just trying to keep Ron from gaining any more momentum. Go Ron Paul!!
Ok! Only half the country is stupid. Americans vote on fear. It was a sad day after 9/11. The country shutdown from fear. 9/11 was bad, but no where near the damage done from the Pearl Harbor attack. Fighting back is not an issue for patriotic Dems or Repubs, including liberals. Republicans fail to recognize that all americans love their country. We just don't want to send our sons and daughter to their death, just so politicans can save face. Huckabee ! give me a break. His own state gives him a 19 % approval rating. Maybe you should check into his actual record of raping his state, before you promote him. I will tell you one thing Jesus would never support any of the candidates, they are all political hypocrites.
So...Being a staunch Democrat and my own son headed for Iraq next September, I am going with Giuliani??
I don't think so...Rudy...
Huckabee, that's all we need, a Baptist preacher in the White house. How about the Pope? We could go Back to believing the world is flat and burning heretics at the stake. If we didn't have this "my God is better than your god" mentality, we wouldn't be in Iraq.
Did someone say "snow"?
Ron Paul is the people's choice because he will restore our republic instead of selling it to special interests. He dominates in straw polls, debate polls, fund raising, web traffic and grass roots networking. I have created a website to support this statement.

Please visit www.thecaseforronpaul.com and judge for yourself.
Nice one laurie,
heres my version of what a republican is;
R-Revisionist historian (RAYGUN didn't want to trade missles with Iran)
E-Environmental Rapist
P-Profit Monger
U-Ugly Thinker
B-Bull**it Artist Supreme
L-Loony Religious Believer (the earth is so young!)
I-Introspective Bathroom Inspector(is that my leg?)
C-Currently looking for Work(anyone want a used neo-con?)
A-Alien hater from a different time(IRISH NEED NOT APPLY)
N-Neo/Con Dream Fairy(democracy from a rifle)
Crying in their beer everyday, blaming THE HILL for George Bush and Dick Cheney, how pathetic! Your party has went so far out in the ozone that they don't draw a breath anymore, living on fumes from the past!
I am a Republican, but I foresee a split in the Republican party over the next decade.  The Libertarian faction (which I am part of) and the Religious Right will split into two different parties.  We are going to end up like the UK with the Labor Party (left), Conservative Party (right), and Liberal Democrats (libertarian).

Ron Paul in 2008!
To JR:  If Mike Huckabee raped his state, why was he voted one of the five best governors in America?  And since you were speaking of hypocrites, I once knew someone who told a preacher he didn't want to come to church because it was full of hypocrites.  And the preacher answered, why not? There's always room for one more.....You better re-examine Huckabee...
D estroy the middle class
E xpand welfare
M andatory diversity
O utrageous tax increases
C linton worship
R uin national pride
A mnesty for illegal aliens
T otal surrender to terrorists

Wow Laurie and John, that was really thoughtful and
inciteful.  Why don't you 2 mindless twits go post
on the romper room board now?
John McCain is the only realistic canidate that has taken a stand against the oil companies. He would favor getting us off the herion (oil) that runs through our veins. He is the only canidate to actually try to fix immigration, rather than Ron Pauls "We'll just put up a big fence and everythign will be fine. I promise." He has taken a stand against pork-barell spending, and has had experience in foregin relations all over the world. When offered a spot on the Armed Forces committe many years ago, he turned it down, prefering to "get to know his district and their wishes better." Thats the type of man who cares about what you think
I have to laugh at those who believe the democrats are for the "little guy". They portray Republicans as being for corporations and the rich. Those two groups made more money when Bill Clinton was president than they have under any GOP administration. Bottom line is that the top 1% of taxpayers pay 59% of the federal tax bill today even after Bush's so called tax cuts for the rich. I am in the middle class but it seems to me they are paying their fair share already. Beware if the democrats control the house, senate and presidency. Here is what you will see. Massive Federal tax increases and major increases in the Social Security and Medicare/Medicaid tax, rollback and increases in capital gains and death taxes, amnesty for 20 million illegal aliens in our country, National Health Care that will cripple our economy and cause rationing of health care, UN control over US interests, liberal court appointments, anti-religion court decisions, expansion of abortion rights and options, gay marriage rights, expansion of government control in all areas of business, commerce and personal/moral issues, crippling environmental controls on our businesses while developing countries have none (Kyoto Treaty)causing US job losses, massive shifts in federal tax expenditures away from the military and infrastructure to our ever failing public education institutions, (teachers and professors make more now than they ever have and our global educational ranking continues to fall as do our test scores and basic reading, writing and math skills), welfare and social services that have done nothing to reduce poverty, continued decline in moral/ethical social behaviors, sin taxes will be added to beer, wine and  alcohol purchases fot help pay for massive deficit spending on health care and as tax revenues fall due to income tax increases (the wealthy will move away from investing to tax sheltering) taxes will be rasied further to make up for those shortfalls. Wew need only look at Europe for an example. Most countries there are socialistic. They have massive income and property taxes, sin taxes, gas and utility taxes (some near 80% taxation) and as a result they have 0% growth economies, double digit unemployment, heatlh care rationing and they are now looking at what we do to try and "fix" the mess their socialistic policies have created. They are actually exploring getting out of health care etc.. to reduce taxes, spur growth and reduce unemployment. The "Dems" want to follow their examples... Remember tax revenues go down under dems because they reaise taxes thereby reducing investment. Government receipts tripled under both Reagan and Bush II following their tax cuts. The problem for Reagan was constant compromise with the dems in congress kept spending too high and Bush has failed to deliver on reducing the size of govt. as he'd hoped to do. As for those crying Bush doubled the deficit, Clinton's reduction or balanced budget came because the GOP congress's "Contract with America" to balance the budget (the first time the GOP had been in control since the 50's) would not let him spend like he wanted to spend. We in Wisconsin have a democratic governor who spends like there is no tomorrow and our deficit has doubled under him because he can't tax us the way he would like to, not because he is doing anything to reduce the size of governement.    
John wisconsin

Reagan not only cut taxes, he raised them a couple of times afterwards.
Don't you think it is irresponsible to cut taxes during a time of "war"?
My working class family did very well during the 90's under Clinton.(by the way I hated him while I was in the service USMC 94-98) Working families and American corporations both did well during his time. Not so much anymore, it seems that it is only corporations and the richest that are doing well. They are the only ones that aren't fearful of bankruptcy.
smaller government, lower taxes, fair tax in america we speak english, secure the borders, kill terrorists. LIBERTY.  
I think there's something to J Q Public's post about splitting the republican party. I think you could do the same for the democrats. It just kills me that each party has part of what i believe, but also a lot of things I can't stand. The republicans (in theory, not so much in practice these days) believe in small government, low taxes, basically the free market and individual economic choice. I like that. But I hate starting wars against countries who have not attacked us. that is criminal and if the rest of the world wasnt intimidated by us they would all say so! might does not make right. i hate entitlement programs and any form of the so-called redistribution of wealth which is just stealing from some to give to others who have not earned it. it ruins any economy to the extent it is done. on the other hand i am an environmentalist who believes the most important thing is to preserve our earth. i dont want any wacky born-again believers telling the rest of us what to believe. this country was not founded by fundamentalists, just read thomas jefferson and james madison. i sincerely doubt either of them could be elected today due to the influence of america's version of islamic fundamentalism, the religious right. and that is very sad as none of the current candidates come close to matching those two's intellectual firepower.

so where is the party for someone like me?
"We invaded Iraq because Bush had a score to settle with Saddam.  I doubt that another President would shine the nation's focus on Iraq in the first place and there would have been no weapons of mass destruction discussion."

Wait, what?  Are you seriously suggesting that we hadn't invaded Iraq already before Bush became president!?  I lost three friends to the war in Iraq before Bush became president, when Clinton was in office, back when it was called a battle instead of a war but was still the exact same actions we're doing now.  And to say that there would be no WMD discussions is ridiculous, since we already were having them long before him.  That should be more than apparent, especially since the intelligence regarding the weapons was obtained before Bush ever came into power, and Bush used that prior evidence in his declarations (evidence proven to be factual, what with the 38 jets found hidden and multiple chemical traces leading into the desert).  We know there were WMD's, it was known before he took office and it's known now, shown on all sides by all parties.  That part shouldn't even be a debate anymore.  Not much is different between the actions over there during the Clinton years and the Bush years, the nation's focus became driven to Iraq because of the media.  One president chose not to talk about it much, and the media didn't pay much attention to the tens of thousands of soldiers and sailors over there, while this president changed the title to war to allow better funding and shine more focus on the issue, bringing out the media whores.  Actions overseas are the EXACT same, it's the actions and politics here that are about the only thing different.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=482053

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google