ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Hillary volunteer sends anti-Obama email

Posted: Wednesday, December 05, 2007 3:34 PM by Mark Murray

From NBC's Mark Murray
The liberal-leaning blog TPM is reporting that the Clinton campaign has "acknowledged that an Iowa county chair volunteering for the campaign passed along the now-notorious email" that repeats "the false claim that [Obama] attended a madrassa as a child." This comes a day after the Clinton campaign charged the Obama camp with dirty tricks and making rude phone calls to Clinton supporters.

According to TPM, the charge originated from a Dodd supporter, who wrote on the DailyKos blog that he received an email from "a Clinton county chair," who repeated the Obama-is-a-Muslim-and-was-educated-in-a-madrassa story.

The Clinton campaign's internet director, Peter Daou, responded with this comment from Clinton campaign manager Patti Solis Doyle: "There is no place in our campaign, or any campaign, for this kind of politics. A volunteer county coordinator made the mistake of forwarding an outrageous and offensive chain e-mail. This was wholly unauthorized and we were totally unaware of it. Let me be clear: No one should be engaging in this. We are asking this volunteer county coordinator to step down and are making it clear to every person involved in our campaign that this will not be tolerated."

The Clinton campaign confirms to First Read that the comment from Solis Doyle posted on DailyKos is legitimate.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Timeline of denials:

The first Madrassa smear where Clinton was pointed to the source.  Clinton denied then Clinton response: We will not tolerate this type of behavior.

Hsu financial campaign mess.  Where Hsu is convicted.   Clinton denied then Clinton response: We will not tolerate this type of behavior.

Clinton has a plant in one of the townhall.  Clinton denied then Clinton response: We will not tolerate this type of behavior.

Robert Novak column where he said Clinton had secret behavior on Obama.  Clinton denied then Clinton response: We will not tolerate this type of behavior.

See a pattern???
This is as bad as what happened to McCain in South Carolina eight years ago. The only difference seems to be the Bush campaign had the sense to do it only a few days before the voting.

It also makes the Clinton campaign's denials about the madrassa thing, as well as the more recent Novak thing, harder to accept.

I think they should have stuck with the kindergate line of attack, lol.
Come Jan 8, 2007, I’ll vote for Obama in NH; however, if Hillary wins the nomination, I’ll switch my affiliation back to independent and vote against her in the general election.

No offence to Hillary lovers and this is not a matter of hate. I just can't stand her ruthless approach to power.
It will be Huckabee and Obama in Iowa.
Freeman Female, Dallas, TX: '...See a pattern???...'

Yes, I do ....
There's another pattern I've noticed.
It seems like the Clinton campaign accuses other campaigns of dirty tricks, just before they do them....

At the Philadelphi debate, she accuesed others of 'throwing mud' and using the 'Republican Play book'
Just before she started slinging 'mud'

According to Salon.com, only the Clinton team has been sending negative clips on other candidates.

The Clintons learned their campaigning from Lee Atwater when he ran George Bush's (the GB I) campaign against Dukakkis

Clinton's campaign manager is Mark Penn, a Karl Rove wannabe

The Clinton campaign's unethical behavior starts from the top, dowm

Edwards/Obama '08







This is why Clintonian politics is over.  
Obama wants this.  Obama wants mud.  He is fanning the flames.   Obama is dirty.
"You can fool some of the people all of the time, you can even fool all of the people some of the time but you can't fool all of the people, all of the time." Abe Lincoln.

Mark Penn, Howard Wolfson, Mandy Grunwald,
Patti Solis Doyle and last but not least, Bill and Hillary Clinton, haven't y'all heard this before?  The triangulating house of cards is falling down.  Man, am I ever ready for the 'politics of hope'.
Obama '08
Simple question:

Should we hold Obama responsible for every hate filled, lie filled twisted acts of Sierra, Bee, Jesse, Diane, etc?

No! They are all over zealous blind supporters, they will do any nonsense whenever they can. Just like Obama doesnt represent Sierra, Bee, Jesse, Diana, Mike Denver, etc., Hillary doesnt represent such over zealous supporters spreading false things.

If anyone thinks otherwise, they just proved themselves stupid or assumed Americans as stupid.
Hillary turns me off more and more every day. I would easily vote for Huck over her, although I want to be a Democrat.
This whole story makes me think of a story my mother tells of my younger sister and I.  Mom would come into the room after hearing my sister start crying, to see me holding a toy away from her and about to punch her.  I got in trouble several times for this "Bullying" my sister.  One day Mom happens to watch my sister come into the room I was playing in, check to see if she could see Mom, and then go over to me, grab at my toy and sock me, she then sat down and started crying her head off.  My Mom came in, having seen the whole thing of course, and grabs up my sister asking her "What do you think you are doing young woman?"  to which my sister replied "But He hit me back First!!"

 Sounds sort of familiar huh??
This Clinton volunteer was simply acting like a "Clinton".  This incident illustrates the mentality within the Clinton campaign -- "WIN AT ALL COST".
any one who is supporting the Do anything at any cost campaingof Clinton is just as dishonest a she is turning out to be

wake up people are you blind!!!

Hilllary is more of the same bull crap that has been shoved down the throats of the middle class. and you want more of that bull. amazing ....HRC will say and or do anything at this point. I lose more and more respect for her with this daily trash throwing by her and her campaign. Hillary will not unite this country it will remain divided.
I am a volunteer with the Obama campaign in Minnesota.  I have worked on the campaign, first as a grassroots volunteer with an ad hoc organization, and now in conjunction with the staff now on the ground since Obama announced in January '07.  We have always discussed the other candidates with integrity.  In fact, we have been strictly advised that we are not to denigrate the other candidates in any way.  I say this because the kind of problem experienced by the Clinton campaign as described above is systemic--it speaks for the larger organization.  If this person, who was apparently well-versed in politics since she is a county chair, forwarded this hateful email to 8 persons, knowing it was untrue and a smear and that if discovered, it would be a problem and did it anyway, it is because of the culture of the campaign.  This is the same culture that planted questions.

When I was a volunteer at a speech Obama gave in Waverly, Iowa I asked the local Iowa staffer if I could ask Barack a question about energy that I personally was interested in.  The staffer told me that people associated with the campaign (I had my Obama t-shirt on) could not ask questions of Obama during the forum because it might give the appearance of a planted question.  I waited until after the forum and gave my question in writing to one of Obama's aides.  

The campaign was obviously going to make certain no questions were planted or even given the appearance of a plant.

This is the difference in the two campaigns.  One stands for integrity and one for politics as usual.  Which would you choose?

According to the Muslim bylaws once you are Muslim, you are a Muslim; If you are borne from a parent (s) that are Muslim you are Muslim. I suggest that someone ask Obama when in debate if "he is a Muslim and if he believe in the Koran. (he would need to give straightforward answer. He can not extend the answer.
About Hillary: Why each one of those that somehow don't like Hillary ask yourself a question "Why do I hate or dislike Hillary?", It is because I have been influenced by the media?.See what is happening now with disclosure of the inteligence report on Iran; the entire right wing machinery is trashing down the report, soon no one will believe the report and Bush will get his way. (Don't you get it?)This elections is not a game is the future of our nation. My friends this is your hands.
Now lets go to the facts. What better way to know that Hillary is the best chance we have to face the right wing cult machinery. Look who are those that are attacking her: Her own party, the right wing cult 24/7, the republican wannabe and the mainstream media; friends; she is handling all of these negative campaign by herself. Don't you think that there is hidden agenda why everyone is against her. Please don't tell me is because they don't like her or because they trust her ectc,etc. It is a Muslim because she is a Clinton and because she is trying to be the president for everyone and because the media need a scape goat to maintain the public watching and listening to their respective programmation.
The bottom line is that the media, whether you like it or not, they have an influence over you.
Obama will not take our party to the white house he is too good and to naive, he need more time to mature. He need to go back to the senate and show more of his vision by continuing maturing.
Jennifer:

You clearly don't know the first thing about me, other than that I defend Hillary on a regular basis.  Not because I think she is perfect and not because I support her as a candidate, but because the amount of ridiculous, irrational hatred spewed her way on this blog is intolerable to me.  

You obviously don't pay attention to anything that I say on here, but yet you make like you know EXACTLY who I am and how I think.  I have said repeatedly that I am not caucusing for Hillary.  I have only donated to one campaign, and it is not her campaign.  

But I guess you are just one of the ignorant, rambling people on this blog, who only see what they want to see, and skip over that which does not fit into their narrow minded little picture of reality.
Bee: we got it that you are voting for Obama and will not vote for Hillary. Not sure why you see the need to keep repeating this.
Carrie. Eastern Iowa: Don't ever be on the defence be always on the defence. If you have a strong belief stick with it. There are many ignorant that are taking this election as part of a game because that is the way the right wing cult wants. The right wing cult exploit the ignorance and that is for my part the battle between right and wrong is on.
That is why the republican right wing cult want to attract Christians and that because they are already programed to be followers and are not free from the control of others. so, stay firm if you really believe.
Jose Alemar: go here for factual info and not spin:

click
http://www.barackobama.com/factcheck/2007/11/12/obama_has_never_been_a_muslim.php

Barack Obama Is Not and Has Never Been a Muslim. Obama never prayed in a mosque. He has never been a Muslim, was not raised a Muslim, and is a committed Christian who attends the United Church of Christ.


Here is an article related to this topic:

click
http://www.asiamedia.ucla.edu/article.asp?parentid=62743

quote:  Bandung said he had heard the rumor that Obama went to a radical Islamic school. He showed a picture of Obama with the Scout group.
"The girls wore miniskirts. There's no way miniskirts would be allowed at a madrassa," he said. Another photo of teachers at the school shows both males and females wearing Western-style clothing. The women are also wearing miniskirts.
Mitchell, Add Chris Lehane to your list of operatives. He is a strategist infamous for running a sleazy campaign in 2004.
Additional info on smear emails against Barack Obama:

UPDATE: The email address for the sender is associated online with the name "Judy Rose," and there's a Judy Rose as one of 250 members of Clinton's Iowa Women's Leadership Council.

---Judy Rose, a Clinton coordinator in Jones County, Iowa, forwarded the e-mail without comment to eight people, according to a copy of the e-mail obtained by The Associated Press. One of the recipients was a Clinton staffer and another was a Democratic Party official in Jones County.
I would never *NOT VOTE* for my candidate because an "Unknown volounteer" did something stupid.
If any of you have ever in your volounteered for a candidate then you would know that they have no close ties or association with the candidate.
The stupidity that was done has nothing at all to do with Hillary.
Im assuming some wacko like many of you here, got onboard Team Hillary and sent out the same type of garbage that you spew on message boards daily.

You only show your ignorance by even attempting to blame Hillary for these acts of stupidity by unknown volounteers..
Bee,NH
You go ahead and do that!Throw your vote away.
Thats what the Rep are hoping you will do.
If Hillary is the DEM Nominee, and Idiots like you vote against her then you will deserve it, if the REP win yet again the The White House.
If you are not mature enough to look past your personal problems, you deserve what you get.
Regardless of if you "personally like" Hillary.
She HAS always stood up for those who needed a champion, and fought FOR children and women, and our Veteran's healthcare.
So throw your vote away BEE...
Then continue to suffer through High insurance rates,No healtchare for MILLIONS, a suffering economy, and a dangerous future for our children.
Go ahead Bee in NH, show us how stupid you really are.
President Bush looks better and better every day. As an independent I have seen no indication of quality in the Dem lineup. To teresaS Nv I'm not voting for President Bush but a whole group of new canidates both Dem's and Rep's.I will say this that if the wrong Dem gets in office you can kiss any job goodbye.  Kindest Regards
No siree, Barak Hussien Obama is not a muslim, was not a madrassa student or a would be Manchurian candidate. Do you have proof otherwise? Heck he is not even of an African descent. In dog parlance he is a mongrel, but a smart and ambitious one. If he is the democratic president candidate he will be eaten alive by republican. Yes, siree.
PUH-LEEZE this is a non issue. So Barack Hussein Obama is not a muslim. This is news? In the age of email, there will always be crap like this during campaigns. This would only be an issue if the campaign worker was not let go or if the email was sent by clinton herself. Obama groupies please get a life. And please MSNBC just come out for your support of Obama. MSNBC makes FOX REALLY look fair and balanced.  
Which is the lesser of two evils?
Of course democratic party is going to be in shambles after Oprah gets through with it. More power to her and them.
As far as the mud slinging and "rumors", it is as old as campaigning, however, Hillary is an avid socialist and Obama, although professing Christianity, is still muslim and I agree with one blogger's opinion...we, as muslims put it,  are infidels and the country will be overthrown from within. Obama might be a key player for them.  He can hide but he can't run, that's politics but it is frightening to the citizens of this country to risk such of a greek theater two masks of comedy and tragedy.
A Mongrel??? Mr. John Doe..You sir are an IDIOT. There are no mongrels in the human race only MORONS, and you sir are clearly a member of that group.
Clinton wants to win at all costs. She is known for dirty campaigning, she represents an America we do not want. We need CHANGE, we need PROGRESS...

VIVA OBAMA!!!!
i am PROUDLY independent and pleased to see the meltdown of the snake in the rose garden: Hillary Clinton. Much as i anticpated it occuring, i did not expect such a hollywood sort of event. i just want this country to see the dishonesty PRIOR to entering a 'contract' our congress is for whatever reason unwilling to break.
The Clintons have never had any values.  Every thing is in some gray area. Every thing is for sale. Why is it that some dirty trick comes as a surprise?
Well, it was bound to happen.  The first year that anyone other then an old white man from a wealthy family runs, everyone gets upset and begins with the racial slurrs.  Imagine how the southerners must be feeling -- they have to choose between a chick and a black guy.
Well I read articles on MSN, listen to the nightly news and listen to talk radio and feel that I am informed enough to know that I will NOT be voting for another Clinton ... The current administration isn't doing a great job and part of their problems stems from ( History Channel did a story on this) the Clinton administration when he had the opportunity to get rid of Bin Laden and didn't want to hurt the Bin Laden family so it was okay for Bin Laden to kill innocent people on Sept. 11th ..it seems to me that it has been forgotten already... So take the time to research before you vote...This woman isn't voting for her I think I have done my homework ...
In retrospect electing Obama might be just as bad as electing a Muslim to the highest office in the land. This whole election stinks of racism. Oprah only backs Obama because of his skin color. I predict a strong white voter backlash might send Hilary over the top. By the way; I am a very conservative Republican and I would rather see Hilary elected than Obama.
She's learning from her BEST SUPPORTER, her husband.  All they both do is try to smear the others to make themselves look good. Now Billy has a new book out, timing, timing is perfect for them to make a bundle of money.
Will never vote for Hill and didn't vote for Bill.
Nominate Biden and you won't be wasting your time on attack politics.  I can only imagine how much energy will be diverted on mudslinging if HRC is elected.  You folks really ought to think about it.  As is the campaign, so is the administration.
I have a concern about Obama; specifically his use of cocaine. Why is this a non- issue? Is it ok for the president of the United States to be a confessed felon? How many times did he use cocaine? What was the largest amount of cocaine was he around? How many drug dealers did he aid and abet? How can this country even consider voting for a man whose moral compass was so broken, and whose moral authority in such question? What are parents going to be able to say to their children if they are caught with cocaine if this man becomes president? Why are people afraid to ask him these questions?


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=498088

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google