ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Closing time for Giuliani

Posted: Friday, December 14, 2007 3:24 PM by Domenico Montanaro

From NBC/NJ's Matthew Berger
TAMPA, Fla. -- Don’t expect to hear any new policy ideas from Giuliani Saturday, when he delivers what the campaign is billing as a major address. Instead, Giuliani will be kicking off the final phase of his campaign with a rousing message of what he would bring to the job and what he would do if elected. 

Giuliani never had a formal announcement event and did not roll out big policy positions in the fall like some of his colleagues. He stuck to amassing a strong war chest and holding small town halls and retail events. So Saturday’s speech will be a rare, scripted event for him.

The other times that all eyes have been on Giuliani at a lectern -- the NRA speech and the Values Voters Summit -- Giuliani was in the unenviable position of proving a negative about his positions on gun control and abortion. This will be the first big speech in months where Giuliani can craft the topic and control the message. Campaign manager Mike DuHaime and speechwriter John Avlon were on the trail with Giuliani in recent days, undoubtedly finalizing the remarks.

Campaign aides said Giuliani will be making the argument that his experience and leadership makes him the most qualified for president. The slogan will be “Tested. Ready. Now.” Many of the campaign themes will be familiar, aides said, and his plans to counter terrorism and illegal immigration will likely be center stage.

Giuliani has been laying low in recent weeks, holding fewer events than his brethren and fundraising in states that do not have early primaries. The speech is supposed to transition Giuliani to a more active campaign mode, although there will not be a “get-out-the-vote” element. The implicit goal is also to focus his message away from the defense he has played in recent weeks, being asked about his relationship with Bernard Kerik, his businesses and the security detail for Judith Nathan, before she became Mrs. Giuliani.

Certainly, the campaign has seen the benefits of a big speech, after Romney drew the nation’s attention with his religious address last week. And many analysts have noticed that Giuliani has faded into the background in recent weeks, as he has focused on fundraising while Huckabee and Romney attacked each other in New Hampshire and Iowa. This address is likely to bring Giuliani back up to the main stage.

The location is not surprising. Holding the speech in Florida minimizes suggestions that Giuliani is trying to re-exert himself into the New Hampshire, or less likely, the Iowa contest. He continues to hold a strong lead in the Sunshine State, and by launching the new message here, he will be viewed as sticking to the game plan. The campaign will take the message to New Hampshire on Monday, Missouri on Wednesday and back to the Granite State at the end of the week.

What is surprising, though, is the choice to hold the big event on Saturday, where it will undoubtedly get less media attention. Campaign staffers played down that concern, saying the message would be repeated throughout the week and up until the voting starts.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Rudy single handedly saved us all on 9-11.  I thank God for the greatest of gifts of all...Rudy!  NOT!!!!  Rudy, your days are numbered.  Nothing you can say in that speech will get you into the White House.
"Closing time, hope you have found a friend" (because that skank you're with now is a home wrecker).

You don't have to go home, but you can't stay here.
"If elected, I will bring my Mistress to the Job." - Mussolini...I mean, Giuliani
Guiliani (noun) tested (verb) Tested (by 911)

Guess Joe Biden was right. Mr. noun, verb, 911 is at it once again.

Hey Rudy, that thing you see that is shrinking daily, that would be the number of your supporters abandoning ship.
Giuliani "most qualified for president."  That's a laugh if I ever heard one.  The New Yorkers I've talked to said he would have been booted right out of the Big Apple if 911 didn't happen.
Giuliani "most qualified for president."  That's a laugh if I ever heard one.  The New Yorkers I've talked to said he would have been booted right out of the Big Apple if 911 didn't happen.
Diane, Grand Blanc, MI (Sent Friday, December 14, 2007 3:43 PM)

------------
You got that right!
"The location is not surprising. Holding the speech in Florida minimizes suggestions that Giuliani is trying to re-exert himself into the New Hampshire, or less likely, the Iowa contest."
--But doesn't he need to at least have a decent showing in those states.  Won't ignoring them with a big speech elsewhere be like spitting on their corn or granite?
I can't reach even reach Giuliani's qualifications or chances for being president.  I can't get beyond the thought of Judith Nathan being the first lady of the United States of America - NEVER.  
"Don’t expect to hear any new policy ideas from Giuliani."

Don't expect Fred Thompson to show some energy.
Don't expect Huckabee to show knowledge of foreign policy.
Don't expect McCain to stop warmongering.
Don't expect Ron Paul to stop sounding like a crackpot.
Don't expect Romney to stop pandering to the crazy base.
Don't expect GW Bush to sound intelligent.
Of course, Rudy would be a darn good President.

I think the idiots on this post all love Hillary!

Hillary is the skank!
It is ok to criticize politicians for their policies and their positions on things.  Personal attacks are ridiculous.  Rudy Giuliani – whether you agree he would be a good president or not DID have a positive net effect on the city of New York.  Comparing Rudy Guiliani to Mussolini is just assinine.   Judge people based on their record in government and the things they did – NOT on partisan garbage.  
Rudy would be an excellent choice for President!
Rudy lost a Florida poll for the first time today.  He came in 3rd place behind Romney and Huck.  Repubs are too "holy" to nominate an adulterer like Rudy.  Even his own children are voting against Rudy.  They think he treated their mother like garbage.
Rudy would be an excellent choice for President!

Dwight Johnson Jackson Missouri (Sent Friday, December 14, 2007 5:01 PM)

Maybe if he were the only choice.
Rudy is the only possible step down from GWB, the lyingest coporate tool ever spawned in a fascist hatchery to usurp the office of president.

Anyone who thinks Rudy Tutti would be a good president really can't think at all. I'd prefer a brain hemorage to being as blindly stupid as your typical right winger.

Is Texas a penal colony? Is everyone there as stupid as a carp?
So what, all you people bashing Rudy would rather have Hillary Clinton in office???  That shrew who has a husband who lied to the American people, was impeached and disbarred.  Not to mention the utter failure of her own national medical program, her involvement in Whitewater, and her flip-flop positions on major issues (like the war).  Think of the alternative before you waive off Rudy.  Sometimes its the lesser of two evils...
What is wrong with Mussolini?
what's the problem?  Clearly, Mrs. Clinton is head and shoulders above the other candidates on foriegn policy around the world, and in dealing with national matters, including our national debt.  We really need her, and Bill Clinton also.
Scott...if you don't like personal attacks then Rudy is probably not the right candidate for you.
Rudy would be an excellant choice for president-of Iraq!
Mr.Guiliani should not be subject to any form of ethnic discrimination first of all.  Also, his peronal life is none of our business unless it is breaking the law.  Second the problems this country is having will only be solved by cooperation.  For one thing the war in Iraq was not the invention of one person in the government, just like the solution will not be by one person.  As for anyone ever bashing a veteran that has been in a prisoner of war, all I can say is just that only should warrent some respectful attitude.  Mr Giuliani has much experience and to say otherwise is just not looking at the facts.  Also, to attack Mrs Clinton like you did is wrong, if you disagree with her positions, then say something intelligent.  This is a time when Americans must act like responsible adults.  In case you haven't noticed these are difficult times.  Just remember terrorism has no logic therefore you can not reason with it.

God bless America.
THE GIRLD ALWAYS GET PRETTIER AT CLOSING TIME, SO AS USUAL HE WILL SAY ANYTHING.  tHIS RACE IS OVER. HUCKABEE

IS YOUR PRESIDENT JUST LIKE REGAN S LANDSLIDE
a good gust of wind would blow this guy over...only the fact that 9-11 happened on his watch and probably could have been prevented or at least managed better if the police and fireman were able to communicate...
How dumb are the American people to glorify this bumbling idiot...
I LIVED in NY during 911. It was the most frightening experience I have ever endured. We were frightened and confused for hours after the attack on the towers. Seeing Rudy on TV bringing attention to himself was not reassuring to me or my family. A lot of people fell for his "leadership" at that time, I was skeptical because he was a mediocre leader, at best, prior to the attacks. In retrospect I was right and many New Yorkers were equally skeptical about "His Honor".
I do look forward to hear what he has to say about why he should be our next president. It will probably be his last chance to change my mind.
Carmen Chicago, Illinois said:
"Mr.Guiliani should not be subject to any form of ethnic discrimination first of all.  Also, his peronal life is none of our business unless it is breaking the law."

Au Contrare! Mr. Guiliana's personal life will be, AND SHOULD BE, examined by voters.  It is the greatest indicator of his character, morals, and principles; all of which are important indicators of a person who asks to become President of the U.S.

Mr. Guiliana has a very messy personal life for which he could be forgiven if it could be credited to the bad judgment of youth, and if he now had a long enduring marriage.  That is not the case.  His travails continue and his latest marriage has not yet faced the test of time.  Sorry.  This is just not the type of person that should occupy the White House.
Good Leaders must have good characters; honest,smart humble, sincere, transparent and religious/law abiding persons. Thus, we expect them not to lie, deceit, embezzle, illusive and "practice" infedility (Clinton, Guiliani) Bad characters likely to abuse government funds and accept blantant bribery. Policies that are actually  served certain underserving interested parties, corporations and corrupted or unpopular governments (US liabilty).

Pick your President who has good personality, characters,  background and compassionate for the well being of all Americans and the world.

My personal observations, Obama seemed to have those qualities and apparently qualified to be a good US President.
Rudy was integral to 9-11 - it would not have come off without his help
Well-informed readers will remember that Giuliani pioneered a host of new ideas in government that have revitalized New York, the "capital of the world". The broken windows theory (which had never been applied in so large a setting) was derided at the time by the MSM, but look at how it improved the quality of life for New Yorkers. Compstat vastly improved the quality of policing in a city that went from a very dangerous place to live to the safest city of its size during his tenure. If you wonder whether he did a good job or not just look at how the candidates who competed for the chance to succeed him promised to continue his policies and how longtime Democrat Michael Bloomberg became a Republican just to receive his endorsement.

Anyone who says that he was made by 9/11 probably hasn't been to Gotham lately - the change is inspiring!

If you haven't acquainted yourself with the Rudy Giuliani experience, check out "Leadership" by Rudolph W. Giuliani and prepare to be inspired. Then register now so you can vote in the Republican primary!

This election is about experience. Whether the Republican nominee is Rudy or Mitt, you can believe that that person will be the best choice in the general election. HRC said it best this week "change takes...experience". Too bad that all of the top-tier Democrat candidates lack the executive experience to be trusted in such turbulent times.
Rudy is a legend in his own mind
These idiots also dislike rudy for cleaning up the crime in NYC - These idiots long for the grittier days of filth & corruption -
Rudy is THE CENTRIST to make the government work for WE the people who OWN the government - I urge all my fellow INDEPENDENTS to VOTE RUDY -
 Guiliani suffers from the same disablity that Nelson Rockafeller suffered fom the failure to keep their pants on around younger women.  As for Regan, he was divorced for over a decade before he was elected president.  Both Rockafeller and Guiliani were recent divorcees who had spurned their wives with younger mistresses. Guiliani has the morals of Bill Clinton.  If he runs against Hillary, he will lose, because women would rather vote for a victim instead of a sexist pig.  Further, Guiliani's indiscretion and his "little rudy" alienates him from the Republican base and Nixon's quiet majority.
 As for 911, Guiliani is an opportunist just like Jesse Jackson.  Jackson made his political carear based on the fact that he cried over Martin Luther King's body.  Guiliani cried over the souls of thousands of Ne Yorker whose lives he partly put at risk by putting the Emeregency Response Center in the twin towers.  He like Jackson have both profited over the deaths of people greater than either of them.  Guiliani and his friends' security agency is merely a money making machine for an opportunist,
anyone but,rudy, mick or hillary 20 years of of the bushes and clintons have been quite enough thank you. we can't afford to elect any of these 3 people it's time for a change and elect someone who will put this country first.
Please review my comments.  I did not say that moral integrity and good ethical behavior is not important.  What I said is that the personal life is not an issue when it is not breaking the law or hurting anyone.  I believe that many leaders in this country can be morally good.  What they do in their personal lives that do not hurt anyone has nothing to do with politics or running the country.  I say this for all candidates.  All people are different and approach problems the best way they are able.  As for experience, I do not think that experienced is a characteristic.  Experience is required for all areas of life.  Would you let an child of 9 with great morality babysit your child.  Would you let a private with great moral ability be a general.  Common, experience is a required attribute for leadership.  You do not understand the differences between having a second or third marriage that effects only your life with morality, just not the same.  To trust our country to inexperience at a time like this is just insanity, stupidity.  Common, obviously you do not have a concept of logic. Look at facts.  Many of the candidates have great experience.  And for all you finger pointers, I suppose you have not ever done anything wrong.  Ha!!! Grow up.  If you do not want to be reasonable, do not put my name in your comments, I only talk to reasonable people, not people just arguing and not trying to solve problems.  So talk to me correctly or don't talk to me at all.
The reason that Giuliani's skirt-chasing matters is that it displays a lack of personal integrity.  He made a promise to his wife at his wedding, and failed to keep it.  This is a bottom-line issue to conservatives.  To claim that one's personal life choices don't hurt anyone is to ignore the man's family.  If he can't keep his own family together, how in the heck could he be trusted to keep a country together?


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=518014

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google