ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Romney hits Huck on foreign affairs

Posted: Saturday, December 15, 2007 2:19 PM by Mark Murray

From NBC/NJ's Erin McPike
HUMBOLDT, IA -- One day after Romney said he wouldn’t contrast himself with Huckabee on foreign policy experience despite stressing that it’s fair for him to point out differences between the two men, the former Massachusetts governor lit into his Arkansan colleague for a forthcoming article he penned for Foreign Affairs.
 
Romney took issue with Huckabee’s claim that “The Bush administration’s arrogant bunker mentality has been counterproductive both at home and abroad.”
 
He said that when he read that, he “had to look again,” because he thought, “Did this come from Barack Obama? Or from Hillary Clinton? Did it come from John Edwards. No. It was one of our own. It was Gov. Huckabee.”
 
He went on: “I simply can’t believe that. I can’t believe he’d say that. I’m afraid he’s running from the wrong party.”
 
Later with reporters, Romney went further into his criticism. “The suggestion that foreign affairs is like children on a playground -- that’s not exactly the allegory I would draw upon. It’s a far more serious and monumental effort than kids at school.” He also leveled the following slam: “I was disappointed in the quality of the thinking and the quality of the recommendations there.”
 
The Associated Press reported that Huckabee said recently, “I may not be the expert as some people on foreign policy, but I did stay at a Holiday Inn Express last night.”
 
Asked about his typical references to some of the United States’ top allies such as Britain and France as second-tier nations, and whether that may also be counterproductive in diplomatic relations, Romney said, “No. There’s one superpower. I think they all agree. There’s one superpower on the planet. That’s us right now, and then there are nations which are one tier below that. And I’ve always said as well that they’re great nations, but they’re not superpowers that they once were.” He went on to point out that “The French call us a hyper power, so they recognize there’s a difference in our military and economic capacities.” He added, “In my view it’s important for us to remain as the world’s economic and military leader.”
 
Romney was also taken to task to on the Iraq war and his view of the mistakes that were made versus what went right. He said that he spoke on the issue at the beginning of the year in Israel about what he would do differently. But he also turned attention to Iran by pointing out that he put together an article in Foreign Affairs -- “gosh, it must have been six months ago” –- in which he laid out “a seven-step plan” to get Iran to abandon its nuclear ambition. He acknowledged that the management, organization, preparation and planning were sub-par heading into the Iraq war.
 
Immediately after Romney spoke with reporters, spokesman Eric Fehrnstrom further discussed the article and -- asked the implications of the timing of it -- he replied: “I think if you do a little research, you’ll find that Gov. Huckabee gave a very similar speech to this article this past summer. There was criticism of his views at that time on the blogosphere, but then it disappeared pretty quickly, because you know at that point, Huckabee was pretty low in the polls. But now with this Foreign Affairs article coming out, there’s going to be a lot more attention paid to what he says.”  

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Romney will do for this country what he has done for every other organization he has ever led.  If you want to understand what Romney's leadership would be like, go look at the fruit of his life's work.  Romney will lead this country to greatness.
Thompson's latest mailer about "Huckabee University, Welcomes illegal immigrants" is just brutal --  http://www.campaigndiaries.com/2007/12/republicans-can-huckabee-survive-deluge.html  -- and raises the question of whether Huck surged too soon.
"Did this come from Barack Obama? Or from Hillary Clinton? Did it come from John Edwards. No. It was one of our own. It was Gov. Huckabee.”

What a simpleminded and disingenuous comment from one of the campaign's masters of this sort of thing. Even his supporters will be thinking twice about this silliness.

And his 'disappointment' in Huckabee's thought processes cannot match the disappointment of the thousands, soon to be millions, who have abandoned his candidacy, as evidenced by his avalanchial drop in many polls.

Yet another reason we need to make this a Giuliani/Clinton/Romney-free election!
How sad of a race is the Republican party's primary anyhow? Mitt Romney is attacking Mike Huckabee because... Huckabee agrees with 73% of Americans who say Bush is doing a ridiculously bad job as president. So, Mitt Romney's argument against Huckabee is... he's rational? LoL Republicans, thank you so very much, deep heartedly - from a yellow dog democrat. Loud and proud!
Romney's the man!!!! I don't understand Huckabee either. You kinda feel sorry for him because the evangelicals are pushing him in the spotlight and you can tell he's just not qualified.
Romney still sucking on the Bush families failures.He must not be too smart.God forbid anybody speaks the truth about the nasty Bush administration.He sounds just like Rudy.
Huckabee never finished the seminary, so I can KINDA believe him when he said he didn't know about Romney's religion. Of course, comparative religion is a sort of low level class, but give him the credit for not being studious and drop it. He DOES believe in creationism, so at least he was awake PART of the time. I wonder how he does on other religious stuff. I know he got his Baptist girl friend Diane O'Connell a government job even though she had no experience. Cost Arkansas 1.6 million, so I guess he fails at not lying. Let's see, he stole $60,000 out of the taxpayer fund so I guess he missed that class about not stealing. He tried to pay himself as a consultant in his own Senatorial election, so he missed that class on not cheating too. He opened a wedding registry at Target and Dillard's while he was governor so his grateful subjects could buy him presents when he and his wife renewed their vows. Hm - guess he missed that class about not coveting his neighbor's possessions too. Wait - maybe there's a simpler explanation. Maybe the Huckster thinks YOU'RE stupid. After all, he DOES support the FairTax, which doesn't tax corporations AT ALL, and millionaires and up at the same rate as someone who is near poverty level - i.e. less than 5%. Here's the thing - religious people really ARE religious. Who among them wants any truck with THIS devil?
Actually, I am a Mitt Romney supporter and I whole-heartedly agree with what he said about Huckabee.  Bashing President Bush is the "politically correct" thing to do right now.  That's why he (Huckabee) sounds like he's running the left wing ticket when he whips out that sort of saber-rattling rhetoric.  It wasn't profound, it was just flippant.

Speaking of silly, is avalanchial even a word?
I voted for Bush and still support him on some things but he has been to arrogant on some things that hurt our party and Huckabee will correct those things.  Im glad we have a man that will stand up.  After all right is right and wrong is wrong and right will always win.  Im so mad at Bush for not pardoning the 2 border patrol sentences when info was withheld at trial about a drug dealer who said he was unarmed.  I live on the border and its a joke that a dealer bringing drugs across would not be armed.  They have to be armed to keep other cartels from taking their drugs.  These men live in solidarity confiement because of the dangers being with other inmates.  This is the bunker mentality Bush has and im glad Huckabee calls him on it.  Its amazing how many democrats and independents will support Huck.
I voted for Bush and still support him on some things but he has been to arrogant on some things that hurt our party and Huckabee will correct those things.  Im glad we have a man that will stand up.  After all right is right and wrong is wrong and right will always win.  Im so mad at Bush for not pardoning the 2 border patrol sentences when info was withheld at trial about a drug dealer who said he was unarmed.  I live on the border and its a joke that a dealer bringing drugs across would not be armed.  They have to be armed to keep other cartels from taking their drugs.  These men live in solidarity confiement because of the dangers being with other inmates.  This is the bunker mentality Bush has and im glad Huckabee calls him on it.  Its amazing how many democrats and independents will support Huck.
Bush made mistakes, but made the right choice to confront Islamic fascism in their neighborhoods. More could also be said about misinformation and bad advisers.

The media is just nit-picking something to make a story...Huckabee isn't bashing Bush. This is simply stating his differences from a 'bunker mentality' to working with more diplomacy in foreign policy.

Also, remember....9/11...this is all easier in hindsight. Bush did his job, we are just choosing who's going on with this fight from here.

Go Huck!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
It will be a sad day for Republicans if Huckabee is our nominee.  This guy is just not qualified to be President.  Get out of the way Huckabee, let the serious candidates focus on real issues.  Those of us in Iowa better get a clue and realize that if Huckabee wins Iowa, all that did is help Rudy win "Super Tuesday", and he will be on his way.  
Huck is fluff.  He's all about sound bites and cliches.  He has acted very influenced by his religion, and I guarantee he knew enough about Mitt's religion to innocently raise his doctrinal question.  I am a Mormon and while I respect Baptists and those of other faiths I have met plenty of Baptists (especially those higher up, like pastors) who smear Mormonism with similar and exact comments.  Huck would be the worst thing for the Repubs.
Don't trust the Huckster. Romney wins because he works hard. He's earned his status. Oh, and what the heck is that "I don't know nuthin' bout them furrin kuntriz, but I did stay in a Holiday Inn last night"? Huck is not a smart man.
Huckabee has lied on his resume yet again.  He said that he held a degree in Theology, he does not.  He then said he held a degree in Religion, he does not.  Come to find out his degree is in Communications.  Are you kidding me, how does someone like this rise up in the polls.  I guess it shows you how easy we Americans are to fooled.  Wake up America the Huckabee you think you know is a fraud.
The point is, how do comments like Huckabee's about our sitting president play around the world. The answer is, not well at all, and certainly not helpful.  

Its despicable that Huckabee would try to profit politically by repeating leftish mantra that undermines our national security. May he plunge in the polls faster than he rose!
Pete Caloger, from PA:
I too think Romney's comment was stupid, you've got my agreeance there. You may need to check some numbers on your other claims though:
You should be aware that Romney isn't really dropping in any national polls, he has only risen. Not as fast as Huckabee for sure, but he's not losing support by any means.
It will be an even sader day for most of us conservatives if mick or rudi the media has chosen these 2 nimrods for us. So will we just drink our kool-aid and be good little mushrooms and hide in the dark and wait for them to feed us more bs. Time to choose a real canidate .
[Romney took issue with Huckabee’s claim that “The Bush administration’s arrogant bunker mentality has been counterproductive both at home and abroad.”]

FR--Weren't you guys waiting for somebody to turn on Bush's policies?  All you other kidders out there, how many of you think that Romney won't change his stance once the general happens?
Louis, Sara, and Barc-  exactly.

The more Huck talks, the less capable he sounds.  The more I try to learn if he has any substance, the more unethical behavior I learn about.  

I don't think any of the candidates are perfect, but Huck is quickly falling to my second-to-last choice (in front of only Rudy).
Huck supporters, I just read this about Huck's own book.  Explanations?  Theories? Defenses?  Anyone?  I'd love to know how he justifies this one.


"In a 1998 book, Huckabee was a fierce culture warrior, equating environmentalism with pornography, homosexuality with necrophilia, and nonbelievers with evildoers."

http://www.motherjones.com/washington_dispatch/2007/12/huckabee-homosexuality-environmentalism-book.html
Maybe this makes me sound stupid, but I just don't know:

Will somebody please explain to me what the Holiday Inn Express has to do with Foreign Policy?  

So far the only thing I've heard Huck say about foreign policy is that Osama Bin Ladin is like the Brer Rabbit, and that he may not know much about foreign policy, but he stayed at the Holiday Inn Express.... supposedly that somehow relates him to Reagan, but I don't know how!

What?  Please someone clue in this confused independent- I have no idea what he is talking about!!!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=519008

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google