ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Giuliani tries to show effort in NH

Posted: Monday, December 17, 2007 3:28 PM by Mark Murray

From NBC/NJ's Matthew E. Berger

DURHAM, NH -- If the Giuliani campaign was interested in playing down talk that the candidate is struggling in the early nominating states and not taking New Hampshire particularly seriously, it had a funny way of showing it.

Giuliani came to New Hampshire Monday, but had only public event (he also had a retail stop in Barrington but didn’t alert the national media). Speaking to employees of Goss International Company, he seemed tentative and spent only half of his normal hour at the town hall (he was running late, campaign officials said, because of weather delays). After taking the last question, Giuliani seemed unclear what to do next, taking a long pause and outstretching his arms before transitioning to ask the attendees for their vote, which he has rarely done on the campaign trail.

“I hope you come back real quick after the holiday because -- believe me -- there is a primary right after that,” he said. “I know there is, so I’ll be spending some of my Christmas holiday here in New Hampshire, which I really look forward to... We’ll be here and we’ll be working really hard to get your vote.”

He then went into the importance of New Hampshire as a general election swing state, suggesting he needed their support in the fall as well.

The campaign has been stressing for days that it is not abandoning New Hampshire, despite dropping poll numbers. But it has done little recently to show effort in the state. Giuliani chose to give his major revitalization speech in Tampa, FL Saturday and surprised many by keeping a very light schedule Monday in the Granite State.

Giuliani officials acknowledged they were adjusting their television buy in New Hampshire, hoping to increase resources for Florida and February 5 states -- the core of Giuliani’s big-state strategy. But the campaign said it could go back up on the air in Boston markets before the January 8 primary, and suggested it would be on the air in another state soon.

Giuliani New Hampshire Chairman Wayne Semprini said after the town hall meeting that Giuliani was not abandoning the Granite State and continued to make the argument he has the most experience. “We feel the best way to pass that word is the New Hampshire way -- that’s person to person. So we’re gonna be doing more and more of that,” he said. But when asked why the campaign only had one event Monday and wouldn’t be back in the state until Friday, he raced out of the building saying he was going to miss his ride.

The town hall itself garnered little news. While Giuliani utilized the “Tested. Ready. Now” slogan, he seemed to not reiterate much of the closing salesmanship he unveiled in Tampa on Saturday. In fact, his opening remarks were only six minutes long, compared with his usual 20-minute opener.

Giuliani was asked how he could support abortion rights, which is not in the Constitution, -- but supported a handgun ban law in violation of the Second Amendment. “I support, let’s call it the right that it is, the right to bear and carry arms, that exists in the Second Amendment,” he said, adding his enforcement efforts in New York focused on people committing crimes with a gun. “So I did use the gun laws very aggressively in New York,” he said. “But I also used all the other laws aggressively. I had to, given the problems that we had.”

Asked about a local issue of giving contraception to middle-school students, Giuliani said “those things should be done with parents’ ability to control that” and then launched into his push for school choice.

He also was asked to elaborate on his experiences on 9/11. He spoke at length about the heroism that day, including construction workers who volunteered unannounced.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Rudy, the nation is finally seeing right through you...the rest of the nation is finally seeing you for the nasty arrogant freak show you are.
"hope you come back real quick after the holiday because -- believe me -- there is a primary right after that,” he said. “I know there is...."

An idiot, and yet - so much smarter than Bush.

I agree - he's a complete scum bag. I felt the same way about GW Bush when he first hit the national scene. To make it worse, Rudy has hired the neo-CONS to advise him. We really really really cannot afford another Republican in the WH..not from this bunch of liars...Huckabee is popular cause he's the only 50% good guy of the bunch.
Just ast Freddy-boy Thompson has already done, Guiliani will fall by the wayside and then the Repubs will be stuck with Rev. Mike as their nominee. The Dems could run Kucinich against Rev. Mike and win.

Dr Doug
Bye,bye Rudy! You started out like Gang Busters, arrogant, cocky, with high expectations, sort of like the way Dubya got started. Do you think that you and he thought a lot alike and the voters did not see that as any sort of change?
Many independents wish you well, you are not a bad person, just not in tune with the wishes of the masses. Hannutty,Limbaugh, O'Reilly, and Dennis Miller are not going to be happy about this, but it was a forgone conclusion, wasn't it?
If people were solely focused on what he did on September 11th, then he might have a chance.  I have to say that this gives me a bit of hope that the American public is totally asleep.  I hope they come to their senses and review what Rudy did during his time as mayor of NYC.  Look at what friends and opponents said about him; that could shed light on how he might do as president if we are stupid enough to elect him.  
I felt this "disturbance in the force" down here in South Florida this past Saturday, and then I found out that Giuliani was giving a "policy speech" in Tampa.
rudy is facing the same demise as hillary, people are beginning to see them for what they are, self-serving souls devoid of any integrity whose purpose is to perpetuate the corrupt washington machine at the expense of the american people, grabbing as much cash and power as they can along the way, a more despicable couple you will not find, defiantly two peas in a pod, may the good lord protect us from their evil
I am so glad that the American people are starting to see this charlatan for the sick twisted racist he really is. All of New York City hates this man with a passion and we are all scratching our heads wondering what the rest of the country sees in this cross dressing joker. Even though I am a democrat I would rather see ANYONE but RUDY.
"He also was asked to elaborate on his experiences on 9/11".
Wow ...someone asked him to elaborate about 9/11 ? Do you think that was a planted question ? Yes , the world wants to know...........it's time Rooty went on record about what he did after 9/11 .
I really think that people should take a look at what Rudy did in NYC prior to 9/11.  Kept a lid on spending, reduced crime...  I mean you could walk in Times Square again without fear of being mugged.  Cleaning the city up was not easy and required hard choices.   Not everyone was happy with the way they were carried out, however results speak for themselves.   NYC is a better, cleaner and economically stronger city because of Rudy.  It would be interesting to have a president that was trully concerned about spending.   Our current one doesn't seem to care.
I really don't understand what the fuss is all about. You shouldn't judge a politician by what he does on a stage but by he his actions. Because of Rudy’s work as prosecutor and mayor, New York City is safer than in any other city in the U.S.A.  He wiped out the mafia, an action which was characterized by TIME MAGAZINE as the "Case of Cases" and “possibly the most significant assault on the infrastructure of organized crime since the high command of the Chicago Mafia was swept away in 1943". He also lowered tax rates and, for those of you who consider yourselves “open-minded”, during his mayoralty gays and lesbians in New York received domestic-partnership rights. The presidency is about being able to solve problems and deal with things efficiently. It is not a TV show, and those of you who assess a candidate based on how beautiful his smile is or on whether his moves are nice on stage, well, you should be really proud of your level of intelligence.
MK, Hillary is no Rudy so don't even put them in the same sentence. Hillary is a smart, accomplished, caring woman...she is extremely hard working and she has already proven she is loyal...she kept her marriage together, she has gone thru the trial by fires and come out with her head high and self respect and she just keeps trying...she is a fighter...all of this and she is ready to put positive changes in motion on day one...I for one cannot believe the energy she has...this week alone under all this criticism she is walking thru the snow in NH going door to door to meet people and doing a blitz in Iowa to reach people so they can see for themselves that she is not the monster the MSM is trying to force on us...she is someone that deserves our respect...I watched her at three different events on c-span this weekend and this woman explains things in detail...forget all this emphasis on personalities...listen to the details of what the candidates are saying...you don't have to like her, but give her a chance...think with your brain...we can all learn a lot from her...and if you are a dem, you won't have to vote for rudy... if we stick together, the dems are going to win this time but we have to stop fighting each other...
Where is Biden ?
I thought everybody knew what Rudy did after 9-11---after the people refused to keep him in the mayors office(he wanted to stay)he went out and gave speeches for thousands of dollars started a company with Bernie,made millions both legally and illegally and then decided he wanted to be the king for his queen Judith.What a resume----and oh yes he was so grateful that George W Bush was the president and decided he wanted to the guy to replace him.I'm sure when he loses Hannity will be exasperated as he has been introducing him at his campaign speeches.Wonder what the gasbag was promised?
On Dec 7th 1941 we were attacked and FDR declared war the next day. On Sept 11th 2001 we were attacked  in 3 states, not just NYC. We were attacked not by a country, but by an act of terrorism, driven by a radical religion. Rudy was Mayor of NYC then, he is no longer Mayor. He sense of "protecting" us from further attacks are way off base. We have NOT been attacked since then. We should not have to pander to the useless UN for direction on how to protect ourselves. Iowa is not NYC and most of us do not believe that "big city" rules belong here. We do not have garbage pickup strikes, transit strikes, mobs running offices, loose port inspections.  The main population of New York do not live in NYC, it is a beautiful state, but I bet they, as a majority, do not support the Former Mayor of NYC.  I, myself am for John McCain , because I believe in his principals.  I believe, because I want a better,safer country for my children and grandchildren.  He can transend  all the bickering between parties and get something done for all of us.
New York City getting civilized......9/11.....beyond all that ....does anyone in their right mind believe that Rooty's attitude and the way he works with people is the kind of mindset we want for a president ?.............especially in these fractured times ?........certainly not a single republican candidate has the right stuff to be president....it's that simple.........
S / '...think with your brain'

s hillary has taken the low road, she's never met a lobbyist she didn't like, if you 'think with your brain' you will realize she offers nothing new, she is the business as usual candidate, she has surrounded her self with corrupt, even criminal scum and is basically a dishonest person, she is whets wrong with politics in washington, just like rudy
ruddy can not say enough about his greatness.
his wonder as mayor. untrue
his wonder as picking business associates. not very carsugession for  homeleful
his law firms and thier clients. very hidden and secret
his spending city funds on his girlfriend. very shady.
his sugestion for  homeland security head. cronyism
pleaseall of you left loonies get out the glass house and see how your party democrats wants only power and does not give shit about us. a bunch of hungry dogs whom will bring the country down and destroy what is left . wake up you party poopers
Rudy is taking on water and cannot bail fast enough, Freds forehead is the only thing showing above water, Huck is being stabbed in the back by his own party, Mitt will lose because of his religion, McCain will reap the benefits form the rest as they slowly sink into the maelstrom of the Georgie Bush years.
Carla, our country cannot afford to listen to your 'intellectual' repub points, we see what is left of our country and have decided that Marie Antoinette is not the way to go anymore. We are not party poopers we are the agents of change and your name calling makes us stronger everyday! Deal with it and calm down.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=521600

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google