ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Oh-eight (D): Bill, Hillary and Magic

Posted: Wednesday, December 19, 2007 9:09 AM by Domenico Montanaro
Filed Under:

BIDEN: In response to Robert Bork’s endorsement of Romney over the weekend, Biden -- who chaired the Senate Judiciary Committee that rejected Bork’s Supreme Court nomination -- issued this statement: “In my view, his endorsement of Gov. Romney is not something to tout; it’s a damning portent of the judicial philosophy Romney would promote as President. The last thing we need after eight years of the Bush Administration’s policies of eavesdropping on Americans, extra-legal renditions, and refusal to define waterboarding as torture, is another eight years of recklessness with our constitutional rights. If Gov. Romney is serious about leading the United States, I urge him to repudiate Judge Bork’s narrow view of the Constitution and acknowledge our privacy rights as individuals.”

CLINTON: The New York Times uses the Magic Johnson/Clintons event to note she's on a  "warm-and-fuzzy" tour. "Now another major question faces the Clinton team in Iowa: Did it wait  too long to try to humanize Hillary? The presidential caucuses are little more than two weeks away, Mrs. Clinton’s negative poll ratings remain high, and some of her advisers wanted to accentuate her personal side earlier."

The New York Daily News writes calls Bill Clinton a “Bill in a china shop. And Tuesday, he went on a minirampage, grabbing unflattering headlines and hogging the spotlight at an event with Magic Johnson while stumping for his wife in Des Moines.”

The Wall Street Journal profiles Clinton's Iowa chief, Teresa Vilmain, who is legendary in her ability to organize the state.

The Washington Post's Kurtz does the Clinton media bias story, and he quotes one reporter who attempts to speak for other reporters -- claiming reporters are not rooting for her to come back. Of course, it's hard for one reporter to speak for an entire press corps, but look for this quote to get plenty of play. 

Speaking of journos who aren't Hillary fans, here's Maureen Dowd’s latest on Camp Clinton’s new strategy: "The public still has no idea of what part of her is stage-managed and focus-grouped, and what part is legit. It’s pretty pathetic, at this stage of her career, that she has to wage a major offensive, by helicopter and Web testimonials, to make herself appear warm-blooded."

EDWARDS: The New York Times looks at Edwards final sale to Iowans. "[H]e is issuing a defiant  pledge to fight big business, to voters in a state that has been buffeted by national and global economic forces and is still reeling from the closing of Maytag plant in Newton in October. He is  accompanied on some of his stops by one of the 3,900 Iowans who used to work there, and points to the closing as evidence of the damage that trade agreements have done to the middle class. In his speech here, he used the word ‘fight’ about a dozen times in 25 minutes. And in nearly every appearance, he tells the story of the schoolyard bully, complete with his father’s salty counsel."

Bonnie Raitt and Jackson Browne sang for Edwards in New Hampshire yesterday.

The bickering over 527 groups and their advertisements is now well underway in Iowa. On Monday afternoon, the Richardson campaign blasted out a press release criticizing a TV ad that a 527 group called Working 4 Working Americans -- which is financed by the pro-Edwards Carpenters union -- is now airing in the Hawkeye State. And the Richardson campaign, which hasn't engaged in many dust-ups so far in the Democratic presidential race, didn't hesitate in whacking Edwards over it.

“Iowans who are now making up their minds about who to support in the Democratic caucuses do not need these shadowy 527 groups coming in with half-truths and distortions,” said Richardson Iowa state director Robert Becker in the release. “This ad ignores the role played by a certain hedge fund in the closing of the Maytag facilities in Newton, IA, which cost 1,800 Iowans their jobs… Can John Edwards be a champion for jobs in Newton, Iowa when he works for and invests in a hedge fund that helped eliminate those same jobs?" The Richardson campaign here is referring to Edwards' work at the hedge fund Fortress Investments, which owned stock in the company Whirpool that closed the Maytag plant.

The 527 ad, which began running in Iowa last week, discusses the recent plant closing in the state, and notes that Edwards wants to end tax breaks for companies that move their jobs overseas. "Tell John Edwards he's right," the ad concludes. Adam Shapiro, a spokesman for Working 4 Working Americans, tells First Read that the pro-Edwards advertisement is just one ad in a larger campaign assailing free trade.

Of course, 527 groups can’t coordinate with campaigns, and plenty of other groups -- Emily’s List, AFSCME -- are helping other candidates in Iowa. The Edwards campaign has also pointed out in the past the stock Fortress owned in Whirpool was a tiny, tiny amount.

OBAMA: Obama opened his statement at a foreign policy forum in Des Moines yesterday by addressing – as he did at last week’s debate -- a perceived weakness in the advisers he had assembled around him, NBC/NJ’s Aswini Anburajan reports. "I was asked how I plan to change our foreign policy, even as I'm advised by members of previous Administrations. I'm thankful to be joined on this stage today by two of those advisers -- Tony Lake and Susan Rice..." Obama went on to say that he wouldn't demand an "ideological or loyalty" test from his advisers. Calling the answer to that question "simple," Obama answered it in this way:

"There are moments in history when it is not enough to fall back on conventional ways of doing things, because the threats we face are unconventional. There are moments when we're called to stand up for what is right even if it's not popular, because that's what makes us stronger and safer. There are moments when new challenges demand new American leadership. This is one of those moments; I am running for President to offer that leadership; and I welcome the support of all who will help me chart this course."

The Des Moines Register’s Yepsen reviews Obama’s foreign-policy speech. “Using former Bill Clinton advisors in a campaign against Hillary Clinton was a neat tweak of his foe. They were also effective counters to the argument that experience is needed in the White House and that he would lack it. Obama argues a little judgment is important too.” More: “Obama hit just the right tone with the address. He was able to criticize Clinton and Edwards without sounding too negative about it.”

Not to play conspiracy theorist here, but since one of the big Democratic endorsement gets -- Ted Kennedy -- is still on the sidelines, one can't  help but wonder if the timing of this leak -- a YouTube of Obama in '03 calling Ted Kennedy "old" and spineless regarding Kennedy’s support for the Medicare prescription drug deal -- is insurance because of speculation that Ted may be leaning Obama?

Also, wouldn’t most Democrats – including Obama’s Dem rivals -- argue that the Medicare prescription drug deal (at least at the time and right afterwards) was a bad idea, as was the No Child Left Behind that Kennedy also championed?

A new California poll shows that Obama's early state surge is starting to show up in later states, as he's cut Clinton's lead in half. Clinton still leads by double-digits, though.

RICHARDSON: The campaign, in a last attempt to get some mojo, is up with a new ad that attempts to emphasize the differences between himself and the three front-runners on the issue of Iraq. Of course, as we've been writing  about this week, does Iraq resonate as great as it did six months ago with Iowans?

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

The Clintons treat the campaign like a checklist. Be tough - check. Be a policy wonk - check. Smile - check. Cry - check. Throw mud - check. Is it any wonder they are criticized for being too controlling?
Barack Obama for President of the United States of America.

Say no to nepotism.
Say no to triangulated Iraq vote disasters.
Say no to mud-sling machine politics.

It's time for America to Rise and Shine again.
I read Yepsens' DMR column about Senator Obama's foreign policy speech.  I liked what I read very much-and as I have said in the past, I will support Senator Obama if he is the nominee of his party--but aside from saying that he opposed policies of the past, did he really answer the question and say how he planned to change foreign policy?  If so, would someone tell me where I can find the whole speech?

Thanks.
LOL THE NY TIMES SAYING HILLARY IS TRYING TO HUMANIZE HERSELF, THATS IMPOSSIBLE.  WHAT PERSON WITH ANY DIGINITY WOULD STEAL THE WHITEHOUSE FURNITURE, OR TAKE DRUG MONEY FROM DEALERS FOR BILL S PARDONS THROUGH HER BROTHER, OR THOUSANDS FROM MARK RICH S WIFE FOR A PARDON FROM BILL.  HE WAS ON THE 10 MOST WANTED.  THEY HAVE NO CONSCIENCE OR ETHICS OR HE WOULDNT HAVE SEXAUALLY ASSUALTED A YOUNG INTERN WITH A CIGAR.  hOW SICK  OR HIS WORDS  HOW DARE YOU  WHEN QUESTIONED.  DEMOCRATS CAN SURE PICK THEM.
That's the Clinton's for you.....

Bring a guy who got infected having unprotected sex with a woman that is not his wife....

Sort of like a ex president we know.....
cigar bill and aids magic johnson on a tour to show Hillars human side, boy is she desperate, and im glad magic has some friends after he infected all those women with aids. I cant wait to have her for president, where she can be commander in chief of no one. Im sure no soldier would re enlist, and others would retire. They will not serve under a woman that ran their general Betraus, as KOS calls him.  This is Hillarys liberal organization.  Then i hope we will have a draft and put all you liberal dissenters in uniform, which would probably be the end of our freedom.
Speaking of journos who aren't Hillary fans, here's Maureen Dowd’s latest on Camp Clinton’s new strategy: "The public still has no idea of what part of her is stage-managed and focus-grouped, and what part is legit. It’s pretty pathetic, at this stage of her career, that she has to wage a major offensive, by helicopter and Web testimonials, to make herself appear warm-blooded."

That's a laugh...
A cold blooded woman trying to look human......


The Wall Street Journal profiles Clinton's Iowa chief, Teresa Vilmain, who is legendary in her ability to organize the state.

Bet she has the toughest job in the state....
dealing with a vindictive woman and her media grabbing hubby.......


Bonnie Raitt and Jackson Browne sang for Edwards in New Hampshire yesterday.

Maybe that should be Hillary's new campaign song....
Running on Empty....


a YouTube of Obama in '03 calling Ted Kennedy "old" and spineless regarding Kennedy’s support for the Medicare prescription drug deal -- is insurance because of speculation that Ted may be leaning Obama?

I'm sure that is the kindest thing said about Teddy....
A certain woman in a car comes to mind as well.....


“This ad ignores the role played by a certain hedge fund in the closing of the Maytag facilities in Newton, IA, which cost 1,800 Iowans their jobs… Can John Edwards be a champion for jobs in Newton, Iowa when he works for and invests in a hedge fund that helped eliminate those same jobs?" The Richardson campaign here is referring to Edwards' work at the hedge fund Fortress Investments, which owned stock in the company Whirpool that closed the Maytag plant.

Edwards would have made a good point.....
But if he is involved in that hedge fund, it just makes him look stupid....











cigar bill and aids magic johnson on a tour to show Hillarys human side, boy is she desperate, and im glad magic has some friends after he infected all those women with aids. I cant wait to have her for president, where she can be commander in chief of no one. Im sure no soldier would re enlist, and others would retire. They will not serve under a woman that ran their general Betraus in the ground, as KOS calls him.  This is Hillarys liberal organization.  Then i hope we will have a draft and put all you liberal dissenters in uniform, which would probably be the end of our freedom.
Yes, Jerry - funny times. Well, that was then and this is now. He's an ex president who also left us with a huge surplus and he's an ex president who will soon be first man of the white house as well. So, since you once again ignore everything Republican... which Repug woman could ever have a remote shot at winning the white house?

Come back to me when you think of one.
Has anyone seen the video of the stunned Hillary as the press walked away from her & followed Bill yesterday with magic? That show's me & no doubt other's, that her perceived campaign is nothing but a get Bill back in office again campaign.She can't even keep the Press with her & she want's you & me to vote for her for POTUS.J. Merle or Van, or any other Hillary supporter, explain that situation to us here at 1st read.How much longer will the people who say they are supporting her, continue with this charade of support? Voter's are starting to pay attention & we can all see why we don't want her back in OUR Whitehouse.



" DELUSIONAL THINKING BY COMMON SENSE AMERICAN'S IS OVER "
Even if it is just in alphabetical order, I like having Biden at the top.  I also like that he is getting more than one or two lines recently.  

He also makes an interesting point.  When candidates accept endorsements from various figures (political or otherwise) that are known for advocating certain principles, do we (and should we) take from their acceptance of the endorsement that they agree with those principles?  
Less than 3 weeks to the Iowa caucus and Hillary has to define herself? She's been in the national spotlight for YEARS. Its rather hard to believe she isn't just trying to redefine herself for votes. That's the problem with the Clintons, you can never believe anything they say or do is in the best interest of the country.  You can be assured its in the best interest of the Clintons, but sometimes its not the same thing.

I really laugh when she says she's been pushed around for years and is still here.  What did she expect, you can't dispose a first lady since they aren't elected.   And winning a democrat seat in New York isn't really much of a fight.  And when was she exactly a LEADER?  Was she actually in charge of ANYTHING by herself?

David Anders Pharr (Out) Tx, guess you never heard of stop loss!
The posts thus far are so tasteless, you people make me sick.  With those kinds of posts, no one will take anything you say seriously.  I truly hope Jerry and David and others like them get the therapy they truly need.
David ander's, on behalf of all American's, we want to thank you for showing us the very reason why voter's threw out the GOP in nov-2006. I'm sure the price of sugar has gone down, since the Kool-Aid euphoria wore off. Again, Thank you!!


"  DELUSIONAL THINKING BY COMMON SENSE AMERICAN'S IS OVER"
" ...a YouTube of Obama in '03 calling Ted Kennedy "old" and spineless regarding Kennedy’"
--I first got to like Obama when he talked out how the Democratic party needs to be tough.  Clearly, the party needs new leadership, sorry Mr. and Mrs. Clinton.  One thing that has disappointed me is that he, for obvious reasons, hasn't taken this tough language on the campaign trail for the nomination.  I suppose he has been tough on finance reform and the wars.
TO RICKY AND HILLARY SUPPORTER    TRUTH HURTS DONT IT, BET YOU CANT LOOK YOURSELF IN THE MIRROR.  I HOPE HILLARY IS NOMINATED SO YOU CAN SEE THE TRUTHS I HAVE WRITTEN ON TV ADS PLUS ALL HER COMMUNIST TIES IN HER EARLY LIFE, AND HER SUPPORT OF THE BLACK PANTHER PARTY, AND ON AND ON AND ON   WANT MORE  YOU LL GET IT.
TO RICKY AND HILLARY SUPPORTER    TRUTH HURTS DONT IT, BET YOU CANT LOOK YOURSELF IN THE MIRROR.  I HOPE HILLARY IS NOMINATED SO YOU CAN SEE THE TRUTHS I HAVE WRITTEN ON TV ADS PLUS ALL HER COMMUNIST TIES IN HER EARLY LIFE, AND HER SUPPORT OF THE BLACK PANTHER PARTY, AND ON AND ON AND ON   WANT MORE  YOU LL GET IT.
OK I APOLIGIZE FOR TELLING PEOPLE HILLARY STOLE THE WHITEHOUSE FURNITURE, AND TOOK DRUG MONEY FROM PARDONS, AND CRIMINAL MONEY FROM MARK RICH S WIFE FOR PARDONS, AND THAT IDOLIZED A COMMUNIST PROFESSOR THAT SHE WROTE HER THESIS ON, AND THAT SHE WORKED FOR A COMMUNIST LAW FIRM IN CALIFORNIA, THAT DEFENDED THE BLACK PANTHERS. NOW DOES MY APOLOGY MAKE ALL YOU HILLARY SUPPORTERS FEEL BETTER.  BUT FORGET IT I WONT AND NEITHER WILL THE DECENT PEOPLE OF AMERICA.
OK I APOLIGIZE FOR TELLING PEOPLE HILLARY STOLE THE WHITEHOUSE FURNITURE, AND TOOK DRUG MONEY FROM PARDONS, AND CRIMINAL MONEY FROM MARK RICH S WIFE FOR PARDONS, AND THAT IDOLIZED A COMMUNIST PROFESSOR THAT SHE WROTE HER THESIS ON, AND THAT SHE WORKED FOR A COMMUNIST LAW FIRM IN CALIFORNIA, THAT DEFENDED THE BLACK PANTHERS. NOW DOES MY APOLOGY MAKE ALL YOU HILLARY SUPPORTERS FEEL BETTER.  BUT FORGET IT I WONT AND NEITHER WILL THE DECENT PEOPLE OF AMERICA.
David, your use of caps really shows the intelligence you think you have. I am no Hillary supporter!!!

!

"  DELUSIONAL THINKING BY COMMON SENSE AMERICAN'S IS OVER "
Rick i just want them to get it, you know see what idiots they are for supporting Hillary, they have other democrats that dont have the clintons sleaze background. I truly hope she gets the nomination because im a huck fan and im originally from Arkansas and voted for Bill Clinton which now im so ashamed.
SEE RICK has changed he was a Hillary supporter, good boy Rick.
This post started out about Biden standing up for our rights as Americans and all any of you can talk about is Hillary.  Why oh why can't anyone see past those frontrunners?????????  I'm soooooooo tired of hearing about the same old same old. I'm a democrat and I am looking so forward to January 2009
David, this is getting old by now. Never was I a Hillary supporter. At the beginning of this looooooooooooooong political season, i was open to anyone on the Democratic side. I heard Barack speak somewhere, & i was struck by this man's charisma ( for lack of better words) & i have been for him ever since. A few months later, i began to think about this Bush-Clinton thing going on since 1988 with American politic's. Our country is better than this 2 family Dictatorship. So when Hillary & her supporter's talk about this change agent thing, I say, Hell Yes, change from the Clinton's & the Bushes. We as a Country must move on from these 2 family's if we are to move forward as a Nation.I'm not going to try & list everything bad  or good they have brought us. I just know it's time to move on from these 2 family's controlling Us & the world as a whole. thats why i allway's say,

" DELUSIONAL THINKING BY COMMON SENSE AMERICAN'S IS OVER"
DAvid Anders, you need some real help.  Just say President Hillary Clinton three times, and call me in the morning.
HILLARY VOTER  ILL CALL YOU A SHRINK  JUST GO TO BILL CLINTONS PARDONS.COM  YOU READ IT AND WEEP AND I PROMISE YOU THE REPUBLICANS HAVE ADS FROM THIS READY TO GO   HE S A SICKO AND SO IS SHE
Just say President Hillary Clinton three times, and call me in the morning.  


Isn't that nice? Two fantasies. One, that Hillary will ever be President, and two, that anyone ever calls you.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=525180

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google