ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Oh-eight (R): Rudy returns to NYC

Posted: Friday, December 21, 2007 9:15 AM by Domenico Montanaro
Filed Under:

Giuliani, Huckabee and McCain are locked in a three-way tie in a national FOX News/Opinion Dynamics poll. The numbers: Giuliani 21%, Huckabee and McCain 19%, Romney 11%, Thompson 10%.

GIULIANI:
The NYT tries -- and fails -- to get more details on Giuliani's condition.

The New York Daily News caught up with him at his NYC condo late last night, where he told reporters: "Thank you all for waiting. We're gonna go straight to bed now and sleep late tomorrow. We'll probably take the day off, check our schedule and then continue campaigning." The paper adds that he spoke in a slightly "raspy voice."

More: “Privately, advisers said the former mayor was simply rundown after a grueling few weeks of travel that culminated with a particularly long day Wednesday, when plane trouble forced Giuliani to squeeze an unplanned, two-hour drive into his day. A nagging bug got progressively worse, and he felt so ill aloft that he decided to seek medical help right away instead of enduring another two-hour plane ride back to New York. Once at the hospital, aides said, it was inevitable that a high-profile patient like Giuliani was going to get a full workup.”

The New York Post: “In 2000, just before he was to face Hillary Rodham Clinton in a race for the US Senate, Giuliani announced he had prostate cancer and dropped out. As he underwent cancer treatment, he slowed down his pace - a bit. Giuliani's latest illness comes amid an ailing week for the campaign.”

Here's a story that could become trouble for Giuliani if he's the nominee (unless he's facing Clinton): "Giuliani's decision to commandeer his historical records in late 2001, as he prepared to leave office, was just one of many episodes during his term, both in and out of the courtroom, that demonstrate his efforts to control, withhold or massage information to advance his agenda and hobble critics. The litany of questions Giuliani has faced in recent weeks about undisclosed business clients and furtive billing practices for police security during trysts with then-girlfriend Judith Nathan are reminiscent of the dozens of lawsuits filed by news organizations to obtain public records, of the numerous state Freedom of Information Law requests that nonprofits like the Coalition for the Homeless were forced to file, of access to City Hall steps denied to protesters.”

“At times, the number of working water fountains in city parks was hard to ascertain without making a formal request. Under Giuliani, it became more difficult to determine the number of complaints filed against the city's home care program, the number of firearms discharged by police and the number of inspectors in the housing and buildings departments. Even details about the city's recycling program were hard to come by."

HUCKABEE: Salon's Walter Shapiro compares Huckabee’s populist rhetoric to Edwards.' This will be a comparison that will deserve re-visiting if both win Iowa. Will it mean that the populist Midwest streak is back?

By the way, is this Day Three or Day Four of Huckabee having to defend himself over his Christmas ad? Both the New York Times and the Washington Post use the faith issue to delve into whether Huckabee is over-selling his faith to win voters. The Washington Post even has an editorial lambasting Huckabee for the Christmas ad.

MCCAIN: Communications Director Jill Hazelbaker released this statement yesterday: "It is unfortunate that rumor and gossip enter into political campaigns. John McCain has a 24-year record of serving this country with honor and integrity. He has never violated the public trust, never done favors for special interests or lobbyists, and he will not allow a smear campaign to distract from the important issues facing our country. "Americans are sick and tired of this kind of gutter politics. John McCain is the most experienced and prepared to lead as commander and chief, and he will continue to run a positive campaign on the issues."

McCain lawyer Robert Bennett “said he sent prepared answers yesterday to written questions submitted by New York Times reporters who have spent weeks investigating questions about whether the senator did favors for a Washington lobbyist or her clients. She has also retained a lawyer, according to a knowledgeable source who spoke on the condition of anonymity because he was discussing legal matters.”

The candidate nabs the Boston Herald’s endorsement for a clean sweep of the major Boston papers.

The Des Moines Register profiles the Arizona Republican. McCain “has risen to national prominence with a reputation as a politician who does it his own way.”

McCain is up with a Christmas ad, and the campaign “said the ad was shot quickly and put up on the air yesterday as a result of positive response the campaign received from a mailer telling the same story that arrived in mail boxes this week.”

PAUL: The AP writes the Ron Paul-as-spoiler story.

ROMNEY: Apparently Romney's father did NOT march with MLK as he has claimed previously. "Romney said his father had told him he had marched with King and that he had been using the word ‘saw’ in a ‘figurative sense.’ ‘If you look at the literature, if you look at the dictionary, the term  'saw' includes being aware of in the sense I've described,’ Romney told reporters in Iowa. ‘It's a figure of speech and very familiar, and it's very common. And I saw my dad march with Martin Luther King. I did not see it with my own eyes, but I saw him in the sense of being aware of his participation in that great effort."

“But historical evidence, including news accounts at the time, shows that George Romney never marched with King, though he supported King's agenda."

No word if Romney plans to reach out to Al Gore for advice on how to handle a potential feeding frenzy on something like this. Speaking of… The AP looks at Romney backpedaling on various statements, including his hunting claims, seeing his father march with Martin Luther King Jr., an NRA endorsement he never received, having wept while in law school after blacks were given full privileges in the Mormon Church in 1978. But he graduated from law school actually three years earlier. 

The Des Moines Register has a clip this morning about a working class GOPer who is worried the GOP field is too "affluent." The Republican asked Romney about his ability to relate to her problems. Reading this account, it doesn't sound like Romney satisfied this woman.

TANCREDO: Tancredo made it official and withdrew from the race -- and he threw his support behind Romney. “The cause that vaulted the Colorado congressman into the race illegal immigration also motivated him to abandon his pursuit of the nomination, Tancredo said. His continued presence in an election he could not win, he said, may have helped the campaigns of Gov. Mike Huckabee and Sen. John McCain candidates Tancredo says are soft on immigration.” More: “Tancredo claimed victory on the immigration issue, arguing that his stance in favor of strict enforcement forced the entire Republican field to move toward his position.”
 
The Des Moines Register’s Yepsen writes Tancredo’s obit and says his endorsement of Romney “provides Romney with an important boost at a critical juncture in the campaign.” 
 
THOMPSON: Is Rep. Steve King what the doctor ordered for the easy-going Thompson? “The outspoken King, one of the loudest critics in Congress of illegal immigration, provided a fiery vanguard for Thompson's campaign, giving stirring introductions for the candidate and escorting him around King's northwest Iowa congressional district.”

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Rudy tried, and failed, to get sympathy votes with his BS hospital antics.  
Your numbers are off by 1% point here.  Rudy has 20% not 21%

See:http://www.foxnews.com/projects/pdf/122007_release_web.pdf

For details of the poll
Merry Christmas everyone, see you next year. Remember it's just politics, take the time now to hug your family, enjoy time with friends and count your blessings, we can come out swinging next year, Iowa coming fast.
Remember disagree, don't hate!
... a sentence for Paul. And you still wonder why Americans car get a bit miffed about your biased coverage against Dr. Paul?
More Flip Flopping from Mitt Romney

A photograph of GOP presidential contender Mitt Romney at a 1994 Planned Parenthood fund-raiser has surfaced, once again raising questions about the former Bay State’s governor’s abortion flip-flopping.

The picture, a copy of which was obtained by the Herald, shows Romney and his wife Ann at a house party fund-raiser in Scituate with Nicki Nichols Gamble, who was the president of the Planned Parenthood League of Massachusetts at the time. Romney has already downplayed ties to Planned Parenthood after revelations that Ann Romney donated $150 to the group.

Gamble said the pic was snapped at an event at GOP activist Eleanor Bleakie’s house and that she “clearly” remembered speaking with Romney at the event. At the time, Romney was running as a pro-choice Republican against U.S. Sen. Edward M. Kennedy (D-Mass.).

“My recollection is that we talked about his senate candidacy and the fact that he was supporting Roe v. Wade and a choice agenda at the time,” Gamble told the Herald. “It was a Planned Parenthood event. We were there to discuss our programs and our advocacy.”

The event was held the same day Ann Romney wrote a check to the pro-choice group. Romney has previously said he had “no recollection” of his wife writing the check to Planned Parenthood.

Romney spokesman Eric Fehrnstrom called the flap “a dog bites man story.”

“Governor Romney used to have a different position on abortion,” Fehrnstrom said. “He is now firmly pro-life and has made it clear that as President he will advocate for a culture that welcomes life and protects the sanctity of life. This is the same path that Ronald Reagan and George H.W. Bush followed.”

Because of his abortion shift, Romney has been branded a flip-flopper by his GOP primary opponents, as well Democrats. Romney has stated he became pro-life in 2004 during the stem cell debate in Massachusetts.

Beyond attending the event, Romney filled out a 2002 questionnaire for the Planned Parenthood Advocacy Fund in which he said he supported Roe v. Wade, sex education in schools and increased access to emergency contraception.

“With Mitt Romney, this has been more than a flip-flop. This has been an extreme makeover,” said Planned Parenthood spokesman Angus McQuilken. “What voters need to know about Mitt Romney is this: where he stands on any issue is always a moving target.”

Romney reacts to photo:
+ Romney dismisses photo suggesting he attended Planned Parenthood event
dwedge@bostonherald.com
Dear Mr. Rudy,

I am happy to have this oprotunity.I believe a New Yorker is able to bring in the cash for us.Your prosperity has been greatly encouraging to me, in ways.I believe you are a practicle man, and I must pursue practicalities as an American citizen myself. I am sure you would respect that, since you are respectable yourself, in the ways that I desire to discuss with you today. I am requesting a legal contract (without legal loopholes, of course).
I'm am not suggesting that you would do such a thing, it is just a practicality to have an understanding between the American peoples and yourself,as you could imagine (I am sure a gentleman like yourself would hold no ill will towards me for that).
I would like it to be between you and the people of America, so that we will recieve our fair share of the bling bling.
I am not suggesting you become inappropriately(according to our perspective) generous, but I cannot, in good concious, vote for a man that will not share willingly.It is just not good for Americans, as you could understand.
         
Sincerely, and Thank You for your time, which I am sure is very valuable, because you are very busy:))))
Merry Christmas Happy New Year, vote Ron Paul in 2008 for Freedom. MSM ignores him, but won't everyone be surprised come February 5, 2008!!
Rudy911 mania has run its course...finally after 6 years he can't blame clinton for 911 and ignore his 7 previous years at the helm in NYC...why was it he put the command center in the most likely target? He was a macho non server who caused the unnecesary deaths of real heroes....happy holidays rudy and judi
All i want for Christmas is Ron Paul for President - America was a great country when we pushed liberty with wind and required that freedom had to be rung with your own hands.
PAUL: The AP writes the Ron Paul-as-spoiler story.

Are you kidding?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?
"Reading this account, it doesn't sound like Romney satisfied this woman."
--First Read, you are too funny.
The Book of a Flip Flopper Mitt Romney come check the facts about a person that has become the Greatest Flip Flopper n History!

http://www.romneyfacts.com/
The Criminal Record of Mitt Romney

Arrests and Other Contacts with Law Enforcement
WAYLAND, MASS. (1981) -- ARREST- DISORDERLY CONDUCT.
In June 1981, ROMNEY attempted to launch family motorboat at Cochituate State Park despite park ranger advising that he was prohibited from doing so because his boat did not display proper registration. ROMNEY was arrested and charged with disorderly conduct. ROMNEY handcuffed and transported in bathing suit to Natick police station, where released on own recognizance.5 Disposition: Charges were dropped when ROMNEY threatened to sue the state for false arrest; case dismissed at Natick District Court in February 1982. ROMNEY successfully petitioned that the files be sealed.6

BLOOMFIELD HILLS, MICH. (c. 1965) -- ARREST- CHARGE NOT KNOWN.
ROMNEY was arrested along with future wife Ann Davies for actions in connection with practical joke at Cranbrook Academy. Reportedly ROMNEY and several friends "bought huge blocks of ice from the local gas station, laid towels over them, and went sliding down the slopes of a nearby golf course."7

HUNTSVILLE, UTAH (2002) -- USE OF PROFANITY WITH LAW ENFORCEMENT
On February 10, 2002, while overseeing 2002 Winter Olympics, ROMNEY became extremely angry upon encountering a traffic jam at a venue and proceeded to berate two persons authorized to direct traffic there, including with obscenity laced tirades, according to a police captain at the scene and a volunteer targeted by ROMNEY. The traffic volunteer Shaun Knopp stated that ROMNEY "asked me who the f___ I was and what the f___ I was doing. We got the Olympics going on we don't need this s___ down here."8 Weber County Sheriff's Office Capt. Terry Shaw, commander of the Snowbasin venue, stated that ROMNEY twice used the F-word while also berating one of his officers, Deputy Kodi Taggart. Capt. Shaw stated that ROMNEY "was abusive" to his officer and advised, unsuccessfully, that "he needs to apologize."9 ROMNEY denied part of the allegation, insisting he hadn't used the F-word since high school -- but admitted he used a word he described as "H-E-double hockey sticks." Disposition: The Utah Department of Safety advised it had decided against initiating a "profanity probe."10

Known Associates
FABIAN, ALAN: Until August 2007, FABIAN was a national finance committee co-chair for ROMNEY. Now under federal indictment for mail fraud, money laundering, bankruptcy fraud, perjury, obstruction of justice and defrauding companies of $32 million in Maryland.11

GARRITY, JAY (a/k/a "Trooper"): Until July 2007, GARRITY provided security and advance for ROMNEY whom he codenamed "LXX"; GARRITY now under investigation in Massachusetts and New Hampshire for impersonating a police officer and other charges.12

HEALEY, KERRY MURPHY (a/k/a "SHERRY" 13): HEALEY recruited by ROMNEY as accomplice for 2002 Governor's race; subsequently relegated to background role.

Additional information
POSSIBLE ANIMAL CRUELTY (1983)
In 1983, ROMNEY transported the family Irish setter, SEAMUS, in a dog carrier strapped to the roof of his Chevrolet station wagon during a 12-hour drive from Boston, Mass. to Lake Huron. No complaint was made or charges filed at time. However, Massachusetts law prohibits carrying an animal "in or upon a vehicle, or otherwise, in an unnecessarily cruel or inhuman manner or in a way and manner which might endanger the animal carried thereon."14

POSSIBLE RECKLESS DRIVING (date unknown)
According to a published account, "red lights make [ROMNEY] impatient." Per the report, at a red light at an intersection in Boston, "There was a truck in front of him but no other traffic anywhere in sight... .So [ROMNEY] pulled out around the truck -- to the left of the truck and then right in front of it -- and made a right turn. Then, at the next intersection, where again there was no traffic, he stopped and then went straight on through a red light. And then, suddenly, a policeman appeared out of nowhere.15

ALLEGED BRUSH WITH INTRUDER (c. MID 1960s)
Subject ROMNEY maintains that while a high school student at Cranbrook School in Michigan he encountered an intruder in his dorm: ROMNEY, who says, "I figured I was dead for sure," states he escaped the unknown intruder by jumping out a ground-floor window and running for help.16


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1 People Magazine, 5/13/02

2 Boston Globe, 10/20/94

3 Quincy Patriot-Ledger, 5/26/04

4 Fox News, 2/26/06

5 Boston Herald, 5/5/94

6 Boston Globe, 5/5/94

7 Fortune Magazine, 7/9/07; Boston Globe 6/12/05

8 Standard-Examiner, 2/14/02

9 Standard-Examiner, 2/14/02 and Associated Press 2/14/02

10 Salt Lake Tribune, 2/15/02; Boston Globe, 8/11/02

11 Boston Globe, 8/12/07

12 Boston Globe, 6/22/07; 6/23/07

13 Boston Herald, 9/17/02

14 Boston Globe, 6/30/07

15 Deseret Morning News, 7/6/00

16 Boston Herald, 8/1/94
Ron Paul received contributions from over 100,000 different people this quarter. He received $18,000,000 from those 100,000 people. His support is wide and deep. Look around your town and notice you see RP signs everywhere. Grab a cup of coffee and go to http://freeme.tv
Robert Jorgensen--man, you really are fixated on Romney--you poor guy.  I guess he scares you pretty bad?  So who do you support?

Try meditation or something and relax.
Romney is not pro-life or pro-choice, he is pro-Romney and will say whatever it takes to please whatever group of voters he is trying to appeal to at the moment.

Why anyone would even consider voting for him is beyond me, especially since we have an honest and honorable alternative -- Ron Paul.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=529442

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google