ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Romney's Mo' in Michigan

Posted: Sunday, January 13, 2008 6:30 PM by Mark Murray

From NBC/NJ's Erin McPike
DETROIT -- It may just be that this time, momentum is on Romney’s side as he battles here to win the early primary in Michigan.

Romney took the stage at the bottom of a large atrium at Lawrence Technological University here before one of his wildest, most roaring audiences in weeks. Red foam mitts and long, red balloons dotted the crowd of more than 500, and a big chunk of supporters were decked out in multiple articles of Romney gear.

When Romney launched into his now standard lines about the trouble with Washington, he fell into a call-and-response with the crowd. Speaking about “Washington politicians, he said: “They say they’re going to reduce our dependence on foreign oil” -- which was met with a forceful “They haven’t!” from the attendees. The pattern continued with his complaints on a host of other matters, from Social Security to education to taxes to health insurance.

And the candidate, who’s often criticized for being too stiff, fed off the crowd’s energy at times, building in intensity along with them. “It’s nice to have a quiet crowd,” he later said facetiously, before adding: “This is the best crowd in Michigan I’ve had all week.” Near the end of the event, he even pointed out the Ron Paul supporter who was waving one of his signs as a Romney supporter had a triple-decker "Michigan For Mitt" sign that he was using to try and block the Paul sign. Noticing the struggle, Romney said that if the crowd wanted a doctor, they could have Paul, but if they wanted someone to fix the economy, he should be their choice.

WDIV weatherman and local Republican donor Chuck Gaidica introduced the speakers who pumped up the crowd before Romney took the stage. Other speakers included Romney’s brother, Scott, Michigan House Republican Leader Craig DeRoche and Michigan Rep. Joe Knollenberg. Joining Romney for a few early remarks were his son, Tagg, and his wife, Ann.

Not only is Romney starting to see bigger, more enthusiastic crowds, but he’s seeing his poll numbers rise here, too. In fact, Michigan GOP Chairman Saul Anuzis pointed out to NBC that the range of new state polling out this weekend shows that the numbers are starting to trend in Romney’s favor.

Indeed, Romney leads McCain by five points in the Detroit Free Press poll and trails him by a single point in the Detroit News survey, both of which were unveiled last night. And MSNBC/McClatchy/Mason-Dixon polling data out this morning has Romney ahead of McCain by eight points.

Meanwhile, Romney’s attacks on the Democrats, which subsided slightly prior to the Iowa caucuses, have picked back up. Not surprisingly, Obama has become a bigger target.

Discussing the need for change in Washington and Obama’s similar focus on the theme, he said, “I think that’s what you’re going to have in your pocket when he’s finished being president.” Romney earlier in the week said he’d heard that joke from someone else. And as it turns out, it may have been none other than Giuliani, who invoked the joke at the FOX News debate on Thursday night in South Carolina, and has been using it since prior to the New Hampshire primary, according to the Giuliani campaign.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

More Flip Flopping on Mitt Romney

It has now come out that George Romney never marched with Martin Luther King watch how his campaign manager flips and flops in this interview with Chris Matthews please watch this video.

Http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y5eKfC6TYjk&feature=related
Mitt Romney you Have Broken Us, as always more flip flopping

More flip Flopping from Mitt Romney, do you really want a scumbag like this.

Governor Romney…imposed a slew of fee hikes and tax 'loophole' closures….The largest of these was $259 million worth of fee hikes in FY 2004, the bulk of which came from higher Registry of Deeds fees.  Smaller fee hikes, including higher charges for boaters and golfers, we imposed in FY 2003 and FY 2005.  Romney also sought $128 million worth of so-called tax loophole closures for FY 2004; $70 million for FY 2005; and $170 million for FY 2006, which were later reduced to $85 million due to backlash from business leaders."
- Club for Growth's White Paper on Mitt Romney

"Romney continues to oppose the flat tax with harsh language, calling the tax 'unfair.'"
- Club for Growth's White Paper on Mitt Romney

The Governor would also seek to raise $128 million in revenue by closing corporate tax loopholes (Rick Klein, “Massachusetts Governor’s Proposed Budget Includes Layoffs, New Fees”, Knight Ridder/Tribune Business News, 2/27/2003)

Despite the governor's pledge of no new taxes, his proposal does increase some taxes and fees: The administration says it can collect an additional $70 million by "closing loopholes" in corporate and sales tax rules (Scott Greenberger, “Massachusetts Governor Sets $22.98 Billion Budget Blueprint”, Knight Ridder/Tribune Business News, 1/29/2004)



“…business groups objected so strongly to a proposed $170 million tax increase that Romney snuffed the idea and proposed $85 million instead.” (Alexander Bolton, “Romney’s Tax Record Gets A Closer Look,”  The Hill, 3/27/2007)



Governor Romney even raised taxes on some New Hampshire residents who worked in Massachusetts, taxing their income and their pensions.
Watch Tucker Carlson a True Conservative go after Mitt Romneys record and show that he is a True Flip Flopper.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w8bSyAihn18&feature=related
So where has Romney's voice been these past 7 years about Washington, the Bush crowd and the Republican Congress which had plenty of time to address Romney's issues? He certainly had time to layoff employees while he was "restructuring" private companies but now he says he'll fight for every job.  It's all about pandering for votes.  He'll say anything yet he has supported the Bush administration and GOP policies with nary a word of critcism until now.  And he fully supports Bush's War and would continue same, regardless of the human and financial cost.  He should be summarily rejected as a viable candidate for he only speaks of "change" with no history of trying to bring it about.
McCain = more war
Romney = Better economy

That's all it comes down to for me.
It's nice to see Romney gaining some traction...he is the brightest and most capable candidate to come in and fix some of Washington's woes...Good luck in Michigan!
America needs a president who knows how to repair a failing economy.

A vote for McCain is a vote for the failed policies of the past.

A vote for Romney is a vote for a strengthened economy.
Romney in 2008!  Look at his phenomenal successes at bringing order and an actual profit to the 2002 Winter Olympics in SLC.  He has great organizational and leadership skills.
Then, look at how he was able to be a successful conservative governor in Mass. perhaps the most liberal state in the nation.
Romney is not a lifetime Washington politician.  He's got creative and honest ideas to lead our country.  Plus, he has integrity.  
Go, Mitt!
Mitt Romney is by far the best choice for President. All the "flip flop" accusations are unjustified - look at the man's record (not the one taken from bits and pieces of quotes). Many people have worked for him and I've not heard one negative thing about him. I believe he is a man of character and will do the right thing. John McCain has been in Washington for over 20 years and has managed to side with the liberal agenda too many times. He has a not so cool head at times and has had a scandalous personal life as well. Mike Huckabee appeals to those who would rather have a preacher than a man with any economic, foreign policy or general sense...that is what they've said, as ridiculous as it sounds. Huckabee continues to ask whether we would be happier with the man we worked beside or the man who laid us off - typical Democrat speak (class envy). Personally I can't imagine  anyone I work with as President. Corporations are where the jobs come from - Huckabee fails to mention that little fact. I pray for Mitt Romney to win Michigan and many more!
Wow, the voters seem to be caring about the issues again.  What a breath of fresh air.  
Mitt in 2008!
Huckabee is going to win Michigan.
Only Ron Paul can fix the economy and the war. Be brave and vote what you´re heart tell´s you: stop the mess in Washinton, and take over you´re life youre self. Consider Ron Paul to help you do this.
I'm glad to see this for Mitt.  I was a McCain supporter but now I am in Mitt's corner.  Go Mitt!!!!

Bill Putman, Caro
(formerly with McCain)
you can always count on the first read team to flow to romney's defense. let's talk about all the flip-flops he has made since he announced. he has spent tens of millions of his own money thus showing a colossal ego bent on getting whatever he wants. this coincides with him saying whatever any crowd wants to hear. keep up the good work guys trying trying bolster his sagging poll numbers. remember, a third and he's done.
Mitt Romney has no integrity when it comes to politics and cannot be trusted.  Can those of you who support him really believe any promises that he makes?

A. Burns, David, and Tom-
Can you explain how a vote for Romney = "a better economy, a fix for Washington's woes, or a strengthened economy"? And by explain... I mean specifics. I keep hearing the word CHANGE from him, but I am have yet to hear how he will make these changes. I am interested to hear what specific plan you have bought into.
R.Merrell - I have to agree with you on one thing you wrote (the rest was bunk), and that is I am so SICK to death that politicians are out there saying they're going to change things without having proven it in the past. While I don't agree with everything that Romney says I do agree that if someone can change Washington economically, it's him.

In your message you tried to make it sound like he was the evil corporate guy that fired people just before Christmas. I mean, that is what is in your mind isn't it when you think of someone that goes around and changes failing companies, right? Well, did you actually think about what would happen or how many more people would be let go if the company went bankrupt? Did you? I'll make this easy for you. Let's say you have 1000 people in a company that's about to go under in six months and have all of them lose their jobs, and you have someone who comes in, restructures it so that you can save say, 600 of those jobs and make the company profitable. You seem to think that you'd rather have ALL of them be out of work, right? It's a good thing you're not in charge.

Actually, it's a good thing Huckabee isn't in charge either, he doesn't even know the definition of NET INCREASE in talking about how he lowered taxes 90+ times, but miraculously fails to remember the 20+ times he raised taxes that produced a NET INCREASE by half a billion dollars. Take Econ 101, come back, and then you can complain about Huckabee too. Of course at the last debate he didn't even deny it as he's done in the past when Thompson called him on it. In his eyes now, he didn't raise taxes... (get this) he "raised hope."

That's not a Republican platform and yes, Thompson was right. Deal with it.
McCain's penchant for chasing skirts has me voting elsewhere...

Hey John McCain - YOUR CURRENT WIFE LOOKS LIKE YOUR DAUGHTER
Mitt Romney WILL win Michigan because Michigan understands he cares about the state...
JOHN MCCAIN DOESN'T HAVE INTEGRITY....

THATS WHY HE HAS GONE THRU SO MANY ILLICIT EXTRA-MARITAL AFFAIRS!
Romney SHOULD have momentum in Michigan - he's only candidate who TRULY CARES ABOUT MICHIGAN!

He has a plan for the state - and isn't counting us out like McCain!
Egads - at least Michigan is not falling for the "CEOs are evil" populism shtick of Huckabee.  That's the LAST thing Michigan needs.  Scare off our last few remaining employers... yeah... that's a novel idea.

McCain: "Um... I'm aware of the economic problems here."  Merely AWARE??

If I were completely self-interested in Michigan's economic success, I'd be a dolt to pass up Romney.
John McCain would be the most raging womanizer since BILL CLINTON.

NO integrity there, John... The nation doesn't like to have ADULTERERS in the White House.
Romney graduated near the top of his class at Harvard, McCain graduated near the bottom of his class at the Naval Academy. I want a smart, articulate person representing Republicans.
MICHIGAN NEEDS ROMNEY AS MUCH ROMNEY NEEDS MICHIGAN!

WELCOME HOME, MITT!
Huckabee = dumb
McCain = adulterer (ask any of his wives)
McCain = old, angry
Mike Huckabee pretends to be a "holier than thou" just like John McCain pretends to be a man of moral character.

BOTH are hypocrits!

Mitt Romney is the ONLY candidate I trust - and the ONLY candidate who will remember Michigan when the primaries close...

Why does Obama get a 'Free Ride' from the "religion" questions that Romney continually faces?  I'm a "Mormon" (and, I AM Christian)!
It would really be interesting to see how Obama, Clinton, Huckabee, and rest of them could measure up to all of the critism Romney's had to deal with!
With a possible recession on the horizon, do you really want a dope like Huckabee in the White House?

Romney has the brains... be smart America!

McCain is just an angry, old man.


Romney is correct that he has the economic skills. My concern is that he is more of the same when it comes to all the other issues. He is my second choice.

Ron Paul stands for the greater bulk of what I deem important and has the record to follow through with it.

I vote for virtue; I vote for Ron Paul.
Romney is obviously bright. His academic and business accomplishments speak for themselves.

Is there anyone else in the race that knows anything about economics?
I am a Veteran USMC served during Cuban and V.N. Please do not support McCain... Just look at his record... Immigration, Econ., etc. His comments that Americans would not pick veg, for $50.00 an hour... Jobs lost to India will never return etc... He is a fool at best...
Go Romney!  As the only 1st tier candidate who has had no ethical accusations as a government offical, I am 100% behind you.  Neither McCain (Keating 5, etc) nor Huckabee (paying himself with taxpayer dollars to be his own consultant) can talk about integrity without lying!  Of course he has changed his view on some social conservative issues, which he is completely open and honest about.  I wish Huckabee and McCain were as open and honest about their records...it's refreshing to see someone who can be trusted because Romney has been the only one honest in his actions as a government official.
Good luck in Michigan, Mr. Romney
Romney/Thompson2008
He was running a state, the olympics and multi billion dollar companies over the past 25 years.... He was not in charge of the Federal government so he did not take action or call out George Bush. Dems do not like Romney, since he is the real deal.
Romney is clearly the most capable candidate on the economy and has prepared himself well on foreign affairs and national security, unlike the Governor from Arkansas.

Sen. McCain does not understand the negative impact of his misdirected legislation.

Romney is RIGHT for america.
Romney is clearly the most capable candidate on the economy and has prepared himself well on foreign affairs and national security, unlike the Governor from Arkansas.

Sen. McCain does not understand the negative impact of his misdirected legislation.

Romney is RIGHT for america.
Go Mitt.  Romney understands the economy better than any of the candidates, by far.  If you want someone to be president who actually cares about domestic issues, you don't want John McCain, that's for sure.
Mitt Romney is clearly the most qualified candidate to be president in these times of economic concern.  He knows how to bring about change successfully.  It is a no-brainer.  Tired Washington approaches just haven't worked.  Everybody knows that.  And this flip-flopper label is a joke.  Every candidate has changed positions on one thing or another.  McCain has done it numerous times as has Huckabee and all the rest.  If change means making things better I am all for it.  We need fresh ideas and a person who can make things happen and has a track record of doing it and that is Mitt Romney.

Go Mitt!
It seems that there are people who incessantly post the flipflop BS on every Romney post.  McCain or Huckabee operatives?  Maybe the same people who made the push poll calls in NH and IA right at the time of the Huckabee and McCain surges in those states?  

Has Huckabee ever flipflopped?  Sure he has.  Many many  times.  Anyone concerned about that?  McCain is the biggest flipflopper of all over the place - tax cuts and amnesty (oops, the jury is still out on whether he has actually disowned favoring amnesty).  Anyone concerned about that?

What it boils down to is that McCain only has two talking points: war and amnesty and Huckabee has some but I have no idea what they are because he only speaks in generalities and cracks some good jokes.

McCain's solution to Michigan's economic woes:  retraining.  I guess McCain thinks that we need more Wal-mart clerks and call center customer reps.  He wants to flush the auto industry.  Huckabee's solution will be forthcoming once he gets finished reading an economics text book someone loaned him.



We need a person who has the knowledge, support group, know how and ability to turn America around.  That person is Mitt!!  Who else would take over as CEO of an organization turn it around under the eye of the world, donate $1 mil. to the cause and then donate his entire salary to charity?  Certainly not someone who wanted to pass the plate at the debate in Myrtle Beach.
The Economist stated that most American voters want "executive competence" and that Mitt Romney is "competence on steroids".


As a republican from MA, I think Mitt is the man, the only real, honest, conservative who has both the desire and ability to bring change.
People, have you forgotten about Mitt and the Big Digg and the bridge is in trouble again??

Check out link please
http://www.textmap.com/cgi-bin/generateJuxta.cgi?version=0.1&actor_one=481808&actor_two=1536567&db=goodnews&juxta_type=complete&text_mode=textmap
I am a middle class American.  I care about my family, my job, and my nation (in that order).  I have never been actively involved in politics before, but Mitt Romney inspires me.  He has proved his capabilities - running a successful business, saving the Olympics (and turning them into the black), and being TRUE to his election promises as Governor.  There is no one else running for president that even comes close to having his resume or capabilities.

I am now an active supporter of Mitt Romney (I bought a bumper sticker for the first time ever).

GO MITT!!!
Is anyone out there fed up with Huckabee using his religion to leverage his campaign?  He knows that the bulk of his support comes from evangelicals that believe that Mormons are not Christians so in order to not offend this group he says things like, "You should not vote for Mitt because he is a Mormon just as you should not vote for me because I am Christian," or when asked by the press, "Is Mitt Romney a Christian?" He responds, "That is a question for Mitt Romney," and then rebuffs, "I don't know that much about Mormons, don't they believe that Jesus and the Devil are brothers?"  

These are all calculated comments to pander to his base.  If he answered, Mormons are Christians, they believe Jesus Christ is their Savior and they try to follow His example, he would lose his base, so instead he plays innocent to the matter but for those of his supporters with ears to hear, he is reinforcing their beliefs about Mormons.  

One final note...the SBC (Southern Baptist Convention) holds classes indoctrinating their members about Mormons (Mormon Bashing 101) in areas where Mormon churches are being built or growing.  Mike Huckabee was a guest speaker at their national convention in Salt Lake City, UT in 1998, the year famous to Utahns when the SBC set out to convert members in Salt Lake City to convert from their cult lifestyle.  Mike Huckabee knows what LDS people believe and has probably taught some of these bashing courses himself during his run as a pastor.  The fact that he acts innocent and uses his religion for leverage is dispicable and anything but an honorable campaign as he constantly asserts.  He is a wolf in sheeps clothing in more ways than one.  Watch out for this guy with his rehearsed preacher tone and manerisms, it comes across as approachable, but that is what they teach you at the seminary school.

Romney is the candidate that liberal Democrats fear..which is why he has been one of the only GOP candidates attacked by the liberal comic strip Doonesbury. The posters on here attacking him are probably Democrats. Sorry libs, I'm not buying it.
I am still out on deliberation about the candidates..McCain = no integrity, poor loser; Huckabee = no tactful strategy, platform non-existant; Obama = doing what?; Romney = questionable intentions to gain celestial kingdom?
Excellent article.  It is good to see Mitt finally getting the positive support he deserves.  This is a guy I would trust my country and the welfare of my family to.  He is the only Republican in the race that could win against a Democratic challenger.  McCain will be ripped to shreads over the morality issue and Huckabee is probably the slimiest politician short of Bill Clinton to ever enter Presidential politics.  We need someone of integrity and honesty in the Oval office; Mitt Romney is the man for the job.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=575063

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google