ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Prominent NY minister endorses Hillary

Posted: Sunday, January 20, 2008 2:16 PM by Domenico Montanaro

From NBC/NJ’s Athena Jones
NEW YORK -- Hillary Clinton returned to Harlem's historic Abyssinian Baptist Church Sunday to pick up the endorsement of its minister, a prominent figure in New York's African-American community who made a point of explaining why he was supporting her and not her chief rival.  

The Rev. Dr. Calvin Butts cited his long relationship with the senator and her work on education and healthcare among the reasons for backing her and shared that he had received phone calls from people in the black community questioning his decision to support a white woman rather than Obama.  

"This was not and is not and will not become a race-based decision for me,” Butts said, “and I hope that it has not and will not become a race-based decision for you either. I respect Sen. Obama. I applaud him and I love him as my brother, but a vote for Hillary is not a vote against Barack Obama or any community, be it African-American, Latino and others, for that matter. A vote for Hillary Clinton is a vote to elect someone who has proven through time to me and to this community and this country that she has the experience to make things happen and the vision to return us to a place of prosperity.”

A shout out between small groups of Clinton and Obama supporters that began as reporters stood outside waiting for the press conference to start was revived for a moment during Butts' brief statement, as Hillary backers tried to drown out the people chanting for Obama.

Clinton followed Butts, echoing his remarks. 

"I have the highest regard and admiration for my friend and colleague Sen. Barack Obama," she said. "I am honored to be running with him. I hope that this election remains focused on the big challenges that confront us."

In response to a question, the senator said the Democratic Party would unite behind whomever becomes the nominee.

The announcement came after a worship service during which Clinton addressed a mostly black crowd.  Several state and city leaders and the actress Cicely Tyson were on hand to here her speak. 

She focused on Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. calling his "I have a dream" speech one of the "great speeches that has ever been given in the history of the world", before going on to deliver a speech similar to one she delivered at a black church in Compton, CA last week.

The senator heard King's sermon about staying awake through the revolution for civil rights and economic justice in the 1960s in downtown Chicago as a high school student and talked about how it inspired her.

"It's a revolution that has to keep going on inside the hearts and minds of each of us and inside every level of government and every institution in society. I always feel challenged on Dr. King's birthday and I think it's a challenge that each of us has to accept," she said, praising the work the church has done for the past 200 years.

Clinton also talked about her work to support single-sex educational opportunities like Harlem's Eagle Academy for young minority men and about how politics and strong leadership matter

The black church is a common stop for Democratic politicians running for office and while the senator has insisted she does not think of voters as "groups" but as "individuals", her campaign has been making an effort to reach out to the black and Hispanic communities -- with Clinton visiting the California church and interviewing with Spanish-language television network Univision Saturday in Nevada.

Polling data in South Carolina show much of the black vote trending toward rival Barack Obama, who also polled particularly well among blacks in the Silver State.

Obama also spent the morning at a famous black church. He visited Ebenezer Baptist Church in Atlanta, where civil rights icon Martin Luther King Jr. served as pastor.

Abyssinian was once pastored by Adam Clayton Powell, Jr., one of the first blacks to be elected to the U.S. House of Representatives in the post-Reconstruction era.

The church has played host to numerous political figures and community leaders over the years, like John F. Kennedy, Lyndon B. Johnson and Jimmy Carter and Dr. King. Butts hosted the Clintons back in October for a celebration billed as a "Homecoming" for Hillary. Bill's office is in the neighborhood. 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

It amazes me how illiterate, ill-informed, and unintelligent the posters to MSNBC's First Read are about the issues and their candidates. First, Obama has done a lot for African Americans as a community organizer, but he also doesn't believe in racial divides. Second, as has been documented many times, Obama works with his speechwriter in such a manner that they both heavily contribute to the speech. Third, a "present" vote in the Illinois legislature does not mean "sit on the fence". This is the 21st century, and we have the Internet. Why don't you look this up for yourself? Fourth, regardless of the President's policies and ideals, the guiding factor for any presidency is going to be the person's character, integrity, and leadership. I don't know any knowledgeable, reasonable person who can look at me with a straight face and say that either of the Clinton's has character, integrity, or leadership. On that basis alone, a Clinton presidency would be a disaster. Besides, do people REALLY want to continue the Bush-Clinton dynasties? You know, Jeb Bush is "waiting his turn" for Republicans..
FRIENDLY NOTE TO OBAMA SUPPORTERS:
WAKE UP; GROW UP; AND MAN UP; OR SHUT UP!!!

Or as Sean Connery's character phrased it in his death scene in "The Untouchables":

"WHAT ARE YOU PREPARED TO DO?"

I am not talking about dirty politics here at all. I am just suggesting they recognize the external shifts and substitutions that their opponent has made and respond according.

Start by facing these clear, simple facts:

1. You are beating beaten by Bill Clinton, not Hillary.

2. The Clintons are running the fall campaign against you that they argue Republicans would, complete with attack-dog running mate; and that many DEMS believe you should be able to effectively deal with to earn the nomination.

3. DEMS will never endorse OBAMA until he shows a willingness to run the campaign against the Clintons that the Republicans would as well.

4. Be prepared to openly compare and contrast the complete record of the Bill Clinton White House issue for issue and line it up against what you have done in Illinois and the US Senate and what you would like to do for this country.

5. No one has beaten Bill Clinton in a national campaign and if you don't man up and take him on; he'll keep trouncing you while his wife plays the innocent role.

More importantly, if you don't back up Bill Clinton now before he gets up a head of steam that carries HRC to the nomination; it is a near certainty that the ROVE/BUSH wing of the party will do it for us in the general election.

Bill Clinton is no more the 800-pound elephant in the room. He has become the big DEM bully to theABC wing of the party, a Ghost of DEMS past, that must be frontally addressed if this party and/or this nation is to move forward with any type of cohesion. Would it be a surprise to learn that the ROVE/BUSH Republican party has been game-planning this run against Hillary for some time? Only a weird public opinion coalition of faith-based Dems, anchored by African-Americans, and fair-minded Independents stopped them from defeating him in their 3rd and last national campaign which was the Impeachment Referendum. They are said to relish the opportunity to finish the job and completely expose the Clinton record in what may be the last chance they get to salvage any Bush legacy. Since this would undoubtedly include unearthing the 911 Commission that equally blamed the outgoing and incoming administrations for negligence; isn't it fair for Obama to start bringing that up again now. Rove, who left the White House early will likely be the Republican architect for their nominee in the General Election, has probably been planning to campaign directly against Bill Clinton all along, whether he had interjected himself into this election or not. And if so, we can expect them to frame a national debate that will undoubtedly start with assessing blame for 911 and continue on invoking the worst psycho-drama of the 90's that bring back not only the "moral malaise" feeling the Clintons' are known for, but also our unresponsiveness to bombings in the Sudan and un-preparedness as evidenced by large military cuts he deemed a peace dividend, which hindsight or not, the opposition points to as naively premature.

Since it now appears that the inadequacy of HRC to have her voice and mobilize women or young people through IOWA and NH forced Bill's hand to intervene on her behalf in a way that frees the Republicans to campaign against the Bill and the Clinton legacy. And they don’t need new material. Those old dogs will hunt fine once they’re brought out, dusted off and seen through the prism of that event that changed everything.
Even if Bill Clinton were to shut up right now through the rest of the Primary, it is clear that Republicans have the opening they need and won't hesitate to remind us that most pundits see the turning point in HRC's campaign as Bill's NH election eve, "Fairy Tale" rant and previous "Roll-of-the-Dice" reference.

The good news for the Obama campaign is that it provides you the same opening.

And isn't it only fair that Obama now give HRC some practice against what will surely be the Republican appeal to America this Fall:

A) That we don't want to return to the moral malaise of the Clinton years in the White House (see campaign tactics: they were for the NV Caucus Rules before they were against them); and

B) That we are tired of hearing about their martial woes (see: Tyra) and more tired of seeing Bill Clinton lie to us (see: "I have been against the war in Iraq since before I was born")?

More importantly, it is necessary from the point of view of this Obama supporter, that Obama take on the complete Clinton Record right now to UNITE, yes unite the DEM party against allowing our entire agenda and current Congressional majorities to be jeopardized and seriously put into play, which is what will happen if we allow that discussion to happen in the Fall out of some false sense of loyalty.

The only way Mr. Obama can strengthen all our chances to rid this country of the REP grip on power that began with Reagan and was never really threatened during the Clinton Administration is to forcefully engage the former President in that debate.

There is no shame in losing a campaign to Bill Clinton; but there is shame in not even recognizing that you ARE in a campaign against Bill Clinton; or worse, recognizing it and shrinking from it.

So as Sean Connery's character also implied in that movie, "Don't bring a knife to a gunfight".

Step it up Obama; it's now or never for you and us. Go down that path with the former President; and you may just come off even more Presidential than you already are. Is he a better speaker or debater than you? Take up his challenge and keep inciting him like you did with the Reagan comment.

Tell America that you agree with his assessment like most of us do, that supporting you represents a ROLL-OF-THE-DICE or leap of faith. It certainly does, but not for fear of loss but for hope in coming up 7's. Tell him it is a gamble on a big, sweeping DEM victory that can usher in real change against the downside of a ROVE/CLINTON conversation that REPUBLICANS are well prepared for.

Fair is fair. Right now it is not clear to this Obama supporter if Barack defers to the Clintons out of politeness or "political correctness", adherence to principles or fear. If he's chivalrous, then he should do the right thing: not shrink from Bill Clinton's future engagements and challenges but take him head on. Only then will we really know who is best suited to be the next "Head of Household" in a DEM White House.
and to this day black folks cant stick together
Cshm Il - love you baby!  I have read your posts in the past and you are s00000000 right.

Hilary will be a great president so get over it
superficial Obama supporters, he is just another black man running for president now due to his own
doing.  Jessie Jackson ran in 1984 and also 1988 and I think he did win around 12-13 primaries but he never made it to the White House- Thank goodness! I can only imagine what this country would have been like under that hot headed, irrational black man.
Obama won't make it there either. He in reality is a dirty underhanded politician who belongs to a black "racist" church that supports Louis Farrakhan, not to mention his illegal activities with Tony Rezco when he was in the Illinois State Senate.  Sorry guys but he ain't gonna make it.
Betty, S..C. (Sent Sunday, January 20, 2008 4:30 PM)
___________________________________
Betty, S..C... are you just ignorant or are you just ignorant....

My God people like you still exist, WOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!.....
Is there really any substance to this endorsement since Rev Butts is from New York and Bills office is in the neighborhood? I noticed he was quick to praise Obama as well, not too many ppl who endorse sincerely will praise the other guy. I am sure he is conflicted
Are we selecting a speech writer? or a preacher?

Please let me know which one so I can vote.

Oh wait, we are voting for President of USA. Did he get a prepared speech to talk from? You bet, that's why he did so well. Put him in a debate where spontaneity counts, and he flip flops and UHs and AHs.

You guys know who I am talking about, dont you? The same moral ethical Brack Obama who ran the shameless low class pathetic UNITE ad.

Talk about hope, it's in despair!!
I feel sure if the GOP wanted Hillary to win they would be going after Obama and not her. They know they won't stand a chance against Hillary. From what I've been reading it sounds like the Obama camp are the one's playing the race card. Hillary's record speaks for itself on fighting for not only Africian-
Americans, but all Americans rights. We are one people and no room for the race card. We need a President who will stand up for everyone. Hillary has proven she will.
Reverend Butts goes one way...and his flock usually goes another.  The good reverend endorsed Rudy Giuliani for mayor--an endorsement that he had to eat later.
This speech brought tears to my eyes. It is the most spiritual speech I have ever heard a politician make. In my heart of hearts if I were to make one wish, I would wish for the unity he describes. What a different world we would live in. It is idealistic, but if we shoot for the moon we might actually land and walk on it.
We need a man like Obama to represent our country. He inspires my heart that has only been left broken for too many years now. I am ready to move on to greater heights. Maybe this is MLK mountain top I desire to reach.
I wonder if Pastor Butz has heard of the Bounced Check Speech?
Endorsement or no, if Hillary's the nominee, John McCain will be the next President of the U.S.  The Hillary people can tout how great she is and all the rest, but those dirty campaign tactics won't work on McCain.  McCain's trouble is with the base but the GOP has only 1 candidate right now that can unify their base -- Hillary Clinton.  If it's McCain and Hillary, McCain wins.  If the Dems want to lose another election they should win -- go with Hillary!
the democratic party is disinigrating on this very site.Whining ,hating,writing such long e-mails that you do not bother reading them---copying the Bible,writing down whole speeches,repeating the same crap over and over and over----one states preachers should not endorse candidates(they have been doing it at least since the religous Bush was running)but turn around and cheer when Joe Blow endorses Obama.The republicans have nothing to worry about---George said they will keep the oval office and it seems that is the only thing he has ever been right about.
GO TO CLINTONS CHRONICLES.COM---WATCH VIDEO OF CLINTONS 10 MILLION A MONTH COCAINE CARTEL  AND THE MURDERS FROM IT, INCLUDING 2 YOUNG BOYS--YOU WILL KNOW WHY HE PARDONDED ALL DRUG DEALERS THEN   IT WILL SHOCK YOU
Vote Obama if you are looking for good speech giver. Yeah that is what we want for president. NOT!
To S.K.M. MA

Let me see if I can enlighten you.

Hillary Clinton, provided she is the nominee, will beat who ever the Republicans put up. But let’s assume that person is John McCain...someone I have a great deal of respect for. I respect Mr. McCain for his service and for his passion for this country. I disagree with him on many issues and the most important being the war. Hillary will easily beat McCain because of his very pro-war stance. Remember “Bomb Bomb Bomb...Bomb Bomb Iran” great commercial...I can see it now. Plus he said he can see us in Iraq for another 100 years. Seventy plus percent want us out. John McCain sees no end. So the war and his pro-war positions are problematic for him against Hillary. The current recession we are in or about to go into is another problem for Mr. McCain. Is this country going to continue to spend billions on an occupation when people are losing their homes, jobs, savings accounts? Short answer: No. I can hear Hillary making that part of her stump speech to cheers from her supporters. So that is number two. It is the economy stupid. And last but not least...the country is overwhelmingly seeking “Change”. Mr. McCain is hardly change. On the other hand Hillary, being the first woman president, is change. And let’s be real here...she will have Bill out there campaigning for her...and this time we can be sure we are going to be getting two for the price of one. Given the choice I will venture to bet the people will choose...to end the war....to invest in America again...and they will choose “Change”. That is how Hillary Clinton will beat John McCain.
What happened to choosing a candidate on how good they are able to do the job?  Personally, I think the African-American population is smart enough to know not to vote for someone only because they might match their own skin color.  I mean isn't that what all of this is about?  If the reason to vote for the guy is because he is black, then isn't that racist also?  The endorsement Hillary received shows that MANY things need to be considered before a candidate is chosen.  This is bigger than "we have a black man in the White House that can understand our issues".  He/She will be president for the whole country, and ALL of its problems.  We need the best person to do that job.  Stop the bickering and consider all of the options before you.  Our country deserves and NEEDS that desperately.  If there is to be change, then WHAT change?  Change is not always good.  It depends on what the changes are going to be.  Personally, I think experience needs to count for something.  Obama may be the right person next time.
Suzi from California,
i'm not sure you read my post correctly. I clearly made it clear that i do not agree with obama supporters over all the hate they spit and personal attacks. you should go though the columns and read carefully. you'll see that obama's fans with all their negativity completely undo the 'feel good' their candidate is promoting.

PLB,
Here is your post - Please stay humble..It's not atrractive...Things can change so quickly... This is a close race...Keep that in mine

O.K. PLB, I will keep that in "mine" for I do want it to be "atrractive" but I also know how to spell and obviously you do not.

BUT, Of course I am a Hilary supporter and we are smart and even write our own speeches. We are also winners, not racists nor members of questionable churches and we certainly do not support Louis Farrakhan and we abhorr him in lieu of honoring him.

All I hear and read from Obama supporters is how nice and how sweet he is from his speeches. Yeah, ok, so he has some really good speech writers on his team, but does that make him prez material.  Listening to a speech and it makes you cry so you are going to vote for him, oh yeah, now that is the way to choose a prez.  I want someone with the grit to "git it done". Not someone who speaks purty! As far as black ministers using their pulpits as a place of political support for candidates, this is what they have always done.  It was one of the safest places to do it, since meeting out in the open on a street corner could get you arrested or killed. If you read Hillary's book you will find out what her conection was to Goldwater and how she came to be a liberal Dem.  But one thing I really want to know is where does Obama's white mother fit into his black support.  Why can't he be considered a white candidate with dark skin?  Would all of the brothers support him then if his mother was still alive and at his side campaigning?
jj
What does "Remember me? (we'll keep it private)" mean?  I marked X in Remember me box, yet my full name was used followed by instructions to you to us JN only.  Naughty, naughty.
As a liberal independent I can tell you the FACT that Daily Kos blog is a radical left wing site that highly endorses Obama and hates Hillary.

I'm sick of seeing those who post lies about the Clintons just because they found it on Daily Kos. I am finding this all over the net. It makes people no better than the Bush administration, the most incompetent, the most CORRUPT administration this nation as ever seen.

I live in Las Vegas and there were 2 robo calls going around. One was against Obama. The other was a VERY NASTY one against Hillary.  Funny how people and Daily Kos don't mention the other robo call, eh ?

The robo calls, neither of them were done by, or endorsed by the campaigns of Hillary Clinton or Obama.

This is a FACT if anyone in this country cares about facts anymore.

Obama is a great orator, he has presence.. and that's about it. He's an empty suit, has a very questionable voting record and twists important topics to keep people from caring about the truth about him.

If he did cocaine at-19, 23, or 27, whenever it was, then why is this not relevant in comparison to what Hillary was doing at that age? (By the way, the woman has been working for families and children since she left college).  

How is it these topics aren't relevant?  How many know he's spent a 1 1/2 yrs in the Senate and missed over 100 votes?  He's voted "present" on controversial votes so he couldn't be cornered for voting yes or no on some intense issues.  How is this not relevant?  He does have connections to lobbyists, he has supported the war 100% since he's been in the US Senate and the public seat he had in his hometown he won because he was unopposed in the race..how is this all not relevant?   He claims he didn't vote for the war, well he wasn't even in the senate then, he didn't have access to the secret documents the others were given to base their judgment on..he was a guy sitting at  home like you and me with an opinion of the war.. how is this relevant?  

If he's so honest, why won't he clarify that Hillary and others (200 others) didn't vote for war but a resolution with MANY amendments that clearly stated they'd consider an attack, under the assumption of PROOF of wmd's, ONLY AFTER the inspectors thoroughly did their job.. and then Bush intentionally and secretly pulled the inspectors out early, because he and Cheney always had the intention to invade Iraq.. it had nothing to do with WMD's, it had nothing to do with 9/11. it was about oil.  Need proof? google it.

If he's so into facts why does he spin and avoid them?

People who support Obama, how much seriously do they know about this guy? Have they researched on their own the facts of his background, personal and professional, much alone political?

This smear campaign against Hillary is insane and it is fed by the right wing media, one of the worst of which is msnbc-tv.. they are fox wannabe's and trash her 24/7.   Have others not noticed how the media handles Obama with kid gloves and they NEVER even discuss important issues?  this is insane!

yeh he's a great orator, he sounds like a preacher and he's arrogant as hell.  He promises the moon.. well anyone can promise anything.. empty words..

Reminds me of ummmm.. oh yeh,  BUSH!  the good ole guy everyone likes so much...  by the way, how'd that turn out for ya?

By the way google info on Obama's family.. nuff said.
wavey, omg, the info you post is incorrect on what happened in Nevada. Hillary had a clear and precise victory. I cannot believe the spin I'm seeing.
Time for Billary to bring out her black southern accent accent again .
HILLARY, RELEASE YOUR RECORDS TODAY!!

Prove your record of experience in the White House for 8 years:

Release your First Lady Appointment Calendar-

Release your Clinton co-president strategy meeting notes-

Release your Cabinet and Clinton Administration Advisory Notes-

Release your Clinton Health Care Task Force Notes-

Release your First Lady Security Clearance Listing- (appropriate proof)

Immediately, Release all of the documents that have been requested through the FOA.

TODAY - Hillary, Make the CHANGE from secrecy to transparency.

Where’s the INTEGRITY Hillary?    Where’s the INTEGRITY?
HRC and her pandering and wondering Billy are a joke. And PLB, I really think you have a "racist" streak; if you do not, then i misjudged you - you are lost in the dumbness pile. Get a life...:-)
I don't usually get into this but, someone said something about Lincoln(president) I have this to say as a learning tool for all; the so-called freeing of the slaves was nothing but a political move on his part and all presidential candidates and those in office do this...
Regardless of who you support...
The next president is going to TRY to dig us out of the deepest hole this country has ever been in. GW Bush has nearly destroyed this country. This isn't JFK taking over after Eisenhower...a pretty flat landscape...soaring is easier when you are on a flat surface. Soaring is hard when you are in a hole. Obama or Hillary...either first black or first woman...in the end they will be blamed when they can't solve all the problems overnight and it will be a generation before a 2nd gets elected.
Tuscaloosa News endorses Barack Obama (Alabama)


There is much to be said for (and against) his main challenger Hillary Clinton. But after four years of George H.W. Bush as president, followed by eight years of Bill Cinton, followed by eight years of George Bush, most Americans would prefer a fresh face in the White House, someone who can move away from the cycle of partisan warfare that these two families have furthered.

That person, we believe, is Barack Obama.  

http://www.tuscaloosanews.com/article/20080120/NEWS/801200303
-----------------------------------
Gainesville Sun endorses Barack Obama (FL)

Come November this is the best choice Americans could make in deciding who will lead the nation: John McCain or Barack Obama

http://www.gainesvillesun.com/article/20080120/OPINION01/801200308/1017
---------------------------------

A Times Editorial (St Petersburg, FL)-
Published January 20, 2008-

No wonder many voters are torn, wishing they didn't have to choose one over the other. It is a close call, but as much as we admire Hillary Clinton, we recommend Barack Obama for president in this primary vote. (John Edwards is still actively campaigning.)

http://www.sptimes.com/2008/01/20/Opinion/Obama_for_Democrats.shtml
---------------------------

WASHINGTON -- Ex-Sen. Jean Carnahan, D-Mo., will endorse Sen. Barack Obama, the Post-Dispatch has learned.

http://www.stltoday.com/stltoday/news/stories.nsf/politics/story/7E21094589C268BE862573D60065E99B?OpenDocument

ST. LOUIS , MO -- Former Senator Jean Carnahan  joined current Missouri Senator Claire McCaskill and announced her endorsement of Senator Barack Obama for President, citing his ability to bring people of all different political beliefs and backgrounds together to achieve real change.

---------------------------------------

FLORIDA PRIMARY: Democrats: Obama

Palm Beach Post Endorsement

Sunday, January 20, 2008

Barack Obama has set the tone for the presidential campaign, which is why The Post endorses him in the Florida Democratic primary.

One irony is that Sen. Obama has influenced all his major challengers despite his youth (46) and the fact that he was little-known nationally until his riveting address at the 2004 national convention. Another irony is that Sen. Obama is downplaying the state primary because of a fight between the national and state Democratic parties. But all the candidates are on the Jan. 29 ballot, and we hope that voters ignore the sideshows and turn out.

Why vote for Sen. Obama? Because his opponents, Democratic and Republican, now tout the "hope" and "change" on which Sen. Obama has campaigned from the start. No candidate has more directly and correctly addressed the unease that pervades the country after seven years of a terrible presidency.

http://www.palmbeachpost.com/opinion/content/opinion/epaper/2008/01/20/a2e_obama_endorse_0120.html
My email to Dr. Butts was returned "undeliverable".  I will share it here:

Dear Dr. Butts:

I am writing to you to ask that you reconsider your endorsement of Senator Clinton.  Our country is at a crossroad, and we can either continue to go down the wrong path, or we can make the changes necessary to move forward in a positive direction.

I am a supporter of Barack Obama because I believe with all of my heart that he is the one who can help us find our way.  He has the judgment and the character to guide us through these difficult and dangerous times.  He has the wisdom to speak out against wars that are wrong, injustices to the downtrodden and the divisiveness that is like a cancer to our nation.

I don’t know what your relationship is with the Clinton’s, though I suspect you feel a sense of loyalty to them.  I beg you to review some of their behavior during this campaign, and to rethink your choice.  I beg this of you for the sake of our country.  For my child and for her children, I ask you to think about the implications of your endorsement.

My U.S. Representative is Elijah Cummings.  His parents were preachers and he has inherited the gift that they both have for speaking in ways that will move your soul.  He is Barack Obama’s co-chairperson in Maryland, and recently I was fortunate enough to attend a press conference where he announced that 200 Baptist ministers in Baltimore were throwing support behind Senator Obama.  While I can’t begin to emulate his speech, I can tell you his main point.  He told us that when a man does everything that a community could ask of him; like getting an education at Harvard and becoming the first African American president of the Harvard Law review.  And when he turns down a seven figure income on Wall Street in order to work as a Civil Rights attorney in Chicago, and becomes a good husband and a good father, how can you not support him?  When he does everything possible to make his people proud of him, how can you not extend your hand to him?

The Clinton’s are engaging in despicable and hurtful tactics during this campaign.  I volunteered to go to New Hampshire for Senator Obama and I saw this first hand:

http://blog.washingtonpost.com/the-trail/2008/01/18/trying_to_heal_a_rift_in_new_h_1.html

Please think deeply in your heart about supporting Barack Obama.

As we celebrate the life of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. this week, I can’t help but think that he is smiling from above at the possibilities that an Obama presidency would help us begin to heal these deep wounds that we have suffered for so long.  I think that he is extending his hand to Barack Obama.  Please, won’t you join him in doing this?

I sincerely appreciate your time.

Regards from my heart,

As a member of this supposedly "rascist" church, I encourage you to come to Chicago and attend a service or two before you make such grand and incorrect statements.  Our church does not support Farrakhan but does support the work the nation has done to support and clean the an ignored neighborhood on the South side of Chicago. Urban race politics are very different.  I did not understand how different they were until I moved from Jacksonville.  Some alliances mean safer streets for children and access to quality doctors which out weigh whatever religious opposition one might have.
Our church has members of many different races and belongs to a mostly european congregation.  We are unashamedly black because the reality is that while christians serve the same God, for generations we have celebrated Jesus in the fashion of our culture.  Trinity is church steeped in black culture.  
It's interesting that the media has skewed this into bigotry.  We welcome all visitors and even sing songs in German to welcome our visitors from Germany (where our denomination was born).  

Also, all of the money from Rezko (not rezco) was dumped onto charities and I challenge to find not one blemish in the Clinton campaign.  

Have you realized that if Hillary wins the election that the Dems are done.  Repubs and independents would rather have my dog in office than Hill.  
Also if she wins we will have been led by that same two families for about thirty years.  Ewwww...
Is there really any substance to this endorsement since Rev Butts is from New York and Bills office is in the neighborhood? I noticed he was quick to praise Obama as well, not too many ppl who endorse sincerely will praise the other guy. I am sure he is conflicted
Tommi (Sent Sunday, January 20, 2008 4:50 PM)


There is no harm in praising good things about the other guy. It shows you have a big heart and you are civil and polite. Hillary praises Obama always as she has a big heart. But Obama says "you are likeable enough" which is low. Show respect and you will earn respect.
All Hail the Preacher, our Spiritual Leader Barack Obama. His speeches are so spiritual, I cry when I read it.

Then I feel hungry and look for money and go out to work in this sinking economy and wish Hillary can change this economy quickly along with Bill.
JN - you need to read the instructions and stop waving your finger at MSNBC. Remember me is if you want you name remembered for your next post.
Well "jeff" I was talking to Jeff Rathburn, is that you? If it is you and that was your point, you did not make it very well. My point still is that Hillary will have difficulty in the general election due to her high negatives nationally - more than 50%. I'm no math wizard, but that does not seem too hard to figure out
Cshm Il - love you baby!  I have read your posts in the past and you are s00000000 right.

To Betty, S.C - Love you too, we sane people have to stick together!

Go Hillary!!
If you get your inspiration from political speechs you are looking in the wrong place.
You independents make me laugh, willing to believe anything to stay out of the political fray of party politics. Go start your own party, bunch of whinners.
"I hate the way the world is, I want someone to change it for me so that I don't have to do it".

You make changes in life by doing things, not by voting for a certain person. Put down your I-Pod get off the couch and get out there and make changes or just shut up already!
Senator Obama will not be your NEW MESSIAH, get another religion!
Where is the "hope" for the 15 million Americans Hussein Obamas health plan would leave uninsured? And where is the "hope" in Hussein Obamas close cooperation with the criminal Rezko?

Hillary's health care plan covers EVERY SINGLE American - look THAT IS "hope" and "change"!

Hussein Obama is all empty rhetoric.

Hussein Obama is Old School -

Clinton is Cool!

OBAMA GO - HOME!
Where is the "hope" for the 15 million Americans Hussein Obamas health plan would leave uninsured? And where is the "hope" in Hussein Obamas close cooperation with the criminal Rezko?

Hillary's health care plan covers EVERY SINGLE American - look THAT IS "hope" and "change"!

Hussein Obama is all empty rhetoric.

Hussein Obama is Old School -

Clinton is Cool!

OBAMA GO - HOME!
Newsflash Clinton operatives - 99% of us simply scroll through your inflammatory, erroneous, lengthy and redundant posts. We see them for what they are - pathetic and desperate. Resorting to dirty and false tactics are a reflection on you not the candidate you are smearing. Lee Atwater is dead, Karl Rove is semi retired and dirty nasty tricks are not yet working this election cycle
Obama seemed to be polarising the US Democrats, something that never happened before.
Ray, New York City, New York (Sent Sunday, January 20, 2008 4:35 PM)

That's why Ted Kennedy dressed down a Former President. Now That's Power!!!!!!!!!

I cannot believe how much the Obama camp is crying about the lost...  At my location I say just the opposite.. Obama's people were playing a nasty sneaky game.  Allowing people in after the doors were closed, adding fake ballots, making up their own rules trying to confuse people like me who were undecided.  

After seeing the way the Obama's camp acted, I changed my support to Clinton.  She has my vote for 2008!
The senator heard King's sermon about staying awake through the revolution for civil rights and economic justice in the 1960s in downtown Chicago as a high school student and talked about how it inspired her.

Inspired her so much, she became a Barry Goldwater girl( Republican) right down to the Cowgirl outfit.
Suzi, the most recent Rasmussen Reports favorability/unfavorability survey has Senator Clinton with a 48/50 split and Senator Obama with a 43/51 split.  The article is very explicit in noting that due  to the elongated campaign season, only one candidate (John McCain) is viewed favorably by a majority of voters.

http://www.rasmussenreports.com/public_content/politics/election_20082/2008_presidential_election/as_campaign_season_begins_only_one_presidential_candidate_is_viewed_favorably_by_majority_of_voters
I voted for Bill Clinton twice and was proud of Hillary and to have such a smart first lady. All pride in these two eroded away as scandal after scandal washed up, but the real clincher was the Lewinsky scandal and what he did to the honor of the office he held and dignity of the office. Hillary was there beside him crying right wing conspiracy, knowing full well he was (maybe still is) a terrible womanizer. What kind of woman who truly cares about womens rights, stands by and defends such a total creep. He just wants us to forget about his lying and cheating while he is out there attacking the character of Barack Obama, who really lives in a fairy tale I would like to know>
I used to watch MSNBC all the time. Even though I didn't agree with all the opinions, they seem even handed. Joe for the Republicans, keith for the Democrats and Matthews in the middle. Now of course, I hate to watch their bias coverage. They have decided that Obama is their candidate, and their coverage is so unfair to Hillary, especially Chris Matthews and Mika. The democrats should be proud of all their candidates. Mika should not allow Joe and others to degrade Hillary. She should speak out for fairness, even though her family works for the Obama campaign. Questions about each others capabilities for president are fair. If Obama cannot handle the "mild" criticism from Clinton, then how is he going to handle the republicans in November? or the North Koreans, or the Iranians if he wins? Will chris matthews be there to smash anyone who gives him trouble?
Rick, thanks for giving me the heads-up on that story.  I hadn't seen any stories about Kennedy or anyone else telling Bill to pipe down until you mentioned it and I did a quick Google search.  Unfortunately, the comments from the Clinton camp (in the Newsweek article) make it clear that regardless of what anyone says, Bill wants back into the White House so badly that he'll say whatever it takes to get there, regardless of how false his comments are, or how hurtful they are to the party.  Very sad.
Yeah jared and other polls show her negativity upwards of 60%. Polls are iffy for sure, but I know that there are alot of repub leaning independents who would never vote for her that will consider Obama. No republican will vote for her and some have already voted for Obama in the early primaries and caucauses. He has a much more unifying campaign and message than she does. His "experience" is much more unifying as well - he has worked well with Republicans his whole career. Hillary has openly fought with them and in the debate last week stated one of her first jobs would be taking on the repubs. She is always ready for a fight - too antagonistic
Jay Link, The only way the Clinton's can beat any Republican, is to have Senator Obama as her running mate. Without him it's not going to happen. If she is lucky enough to get the nomination, she will need every vote the Democratic party can put their hands on. She will get no Independents, no Republicans and lose a bunch of Democrats. WHY.....because the Clinton's have no integrity and will tear the party apart with their politics of destruction, and they have no problem with it......so be it!
Dr. Butts is a man of integrity as he kept his word in the face of a community with some who are insistent on devaluing Hillary Clinton's role in history as a champion of minorities. I watched footage this evening on Fox of an African American male who was spouting such crud as a group of Obama's supporters were demonstrating at today's event. Shameful. I am grateful to the Hispanic community who are not rewriting history and are remembering Clinton's life work on behalf of all.
FJR in L.A., CA, as a Barack supporter, i tend to agree with most of your post. However, it is very apparent of the Appeal & Message that has gotten him this far.How does he do what you mention without being Accused of destroying the Democratic Party? The Democratic party is in Unchartered territory, & it seems NO ONE knows, which is the best way to handle it all.Anyone with Any Common Sense can see the Clinton Double team!!!! How do you take down an Ex-President( who is'nt running (hehe) with the Popularity that Bill enjoy's in Most of the Democratic party & still Maintain the level of Credibility he has?
With Ted Kennedy dressing down a Former President, we would think that Bill should cool his heels.Barack need's to Attack Hillary on the bankruptcy bill, I MEAN HAMMER HER ON IT, Relentlessly & Not Stop. He need's to HAMMER her on her War vote, RELENTLESSLY. Make her explain & Not Stop until Democrat's have an answer.Barack need's to HAMMER her on this 35 year's so-called Experience( what a joke the media runs with without the 1st question about it). As the saying goes " I'm from Missouri, SHOW ME". All of this  need's explaining, yet he has'nt walked that line yet. Until he decides to show other's, that he too can Run with the Big Dog's, the Respect & vote's he need's to beat her will not come around. Leave Bill alone is my take on it, Just Hammer away at Hillary & her Non existent Resume of 35 year's Experience. Anyone beleiving that joke is still living in LA-LA-LAND.

My party is falling apart &  letting another Presidency slip away because of SHEER IGNORANCE!!!!!!!!!

If Democrat's lose with a Hillary Democratic ticket, all these poster's you see Praising her now, will be the 1st ones outta gate to complain of a Vast Right Wing Conspiracy, they simply REFUSE TO SEE THE BIG PICTURE, which is the Supreme Court.

It's frustrating to be a Common sense Democrat these day's!!!!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=593948

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google