ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC Political Researcher



Hillary commemorates MLK Day

Posted: Monday, January 21, 2008 3:29 PM by Mark Murray
Filed Under: ,

From NBC/NJ's Athena Jones
COLUMBIA, SC -- At an event commemorating MLK Day, held on the steps of a statehouse in front of which the Confederate Flag still flies, Clinton spoke about King's legacy and the need to continue the struggle to fulfill his dream. She kept the focus on work and action.

The New York senator also debuted what sounded like a new slogan, urging everyone who can vote to come out and do so, repeating several times some variation of the phrase, "It is time to stand up, speak out, act and vote."

She received a warm reception from an energized crowd in which several dozen people held up Clinton signs. As all of the candidates have done recently, she highlighted the historic nature of this race and praised her rivals, calling Obama an "extraordinary, young African-American man with so much to contribute" and calling Edwards a "son of the South, in fact a son of South Carolina."
 
Clinton spoke last and the longest, packing a lot of content into her 10-minute remarks. She continued to use two biblical references heard in recent days in speeches at black churches in California and New York. Telling the mostly black audience that people "cannot just be hearers of the word, we must be doers" and "faith without works is dead." Both of them fit into the talk-vs.-action theme she introduced in New Hampshire to try to draw a distinction between herself and her two rivals. In what sounded like a new play on that theme, Clinton said part of Dr. King's mission was to inspire people to action.

"We are called to something greater and larger than our own individual efforts to succeed. Dr. King knew that. He led a movement of works. A movement of people across our country who raised their voices, rolled up their sleeves and worked for justice," she said.

Clinton was the last to arrive at the event, and both she and Edwards missed a planned march from a nearby church to the statehouse, an event some observers described as "wild" and as an "Obama march". Recent state polls show Obama winning most of the black vote here and black voters made up about half of primary voters in the Democratic primary in the last election.

The Clinton campaign blamed her missing the march portion of the event on confusion surrounding the time the candidate's plane was meant to depart from New York. The traveling press waited more than an hour on the tarmac for the candidate to arrive this morning and the plane touched down in Columbia at just about the time the celebration was set to begin.

As she has done before, Clinton highlighted a moment of kinship between the black leader, Dr. King and a Hispanic one, talking about King's support for labor leader Cesar Chavez. In Nevada, Clinton polled particularly well among Hispanics -- but not as well among blacks. "Dr. King taught us that in the end we are all connected. All tied in a single garment of destiny," she said. "Dr. King knew that while we each confront different injustices, we are all fighting for the same cause. We believe no one should be on the margins or in the shadows. Everyone should be able to fulfill his or her God-given potential and we do have a moral obligation to listen to the voices of those who are often silenced or unheard."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

The Clintons are single-handedly destroying the democratic party to achieve -their own- dream of securing a 3rd term in the presidency.  Lies, deception... it's absolutely disgusting.  Bill Clinton USED to be a good president.  That was back when he still remembered he was in it for the people, in 1992, when he first preached the necessity of Washington outsiders, when he said that experience in Washington was the wrong kind of experience to make change in government.

How times have changed... let's elect a nominee who reflects that change... Barack Obama can move beyond the partisan flames and inter-party mud-slinging of the Clintons.  The 90s are over.  It's a new millenium.  We need a new politician.
A lot has been said about the black-white divide and the male-female divide in this primary season. What hasn't been mentioned enough is the college-educated vs. no-education-at-all divide. Four years ago, the college-educated favored Kerry and the uneducated favored Bush. In this cycle (so far) the college-educated seem to be favoring Obama and the uneducated seem to be favoring Clinton. I'm just stating an observation, but I'm also bracing myself for all the Clinton campaign folks to spin my words and call me sexist.
NOTICE    PLEASE READ OR WATCH CLINTON CHRONICLES.COM  SEE HOW THE CLINTONS RAN AND PROCTECTED THE BIGGEST DRUG CARTEL FOR 8 YEARS WHEN HE WAS GOVERNOR  AND THE COVER UP DEATHS AND SUICIDES INCLUDING 2 TEENS LEFT ON RAILROAD TRACK  PEOPLE ITS SCARCY  10 MILLIOM A MONTH TAKE----JUST PLEASE WATCH THIS IF YOU ARE A CLINTON SUPPORTER---YOU WILL SEE IT FROM THE REPUBS IF SHE IS NOMINEE----THEY SHOULD BE IN PRISON
Senator Clinton was so touched by the MLK speech she saw Dr. King give in 1963 that she worked on the campaign of Barry Goldwater a year later.
How can the women's movement get behind a canidate that has to stand behind her man. Please Hillary become your own voice again and dump Bill. And listen to Barack's Speech from the day before you use similar quotes.
Ron, TX: How does your posting (3:36 pm) has anything to do with the topic? She is honoring MLK - and you have to fill a post with negative comments? Give me a break.
watch clinton chronicles.com the scariest video of drugs corruption, and fake murders
LOVE IT DAVE   EVERGREEN    WATCH VIDEO ON CLINTONS CHRONICLES  I WAS THERE AND ITS TRUE   DRUGS  CORRUPTION AT ITS WORST   MURDERS   WILD SEX PARTIES FOR BILL   MONICA WAS NOTHING  TAKE A LOOK
Ron, WHO started slinging the mud dude?
It was Obama who said that Hillary was old and out of touch, and that baby boomers who lived through the 60's can't solve problems.
It was Obama who used 1990's NEO-CON rhetoric at the Phildelphia debate when he conjured up the Republican Party's "I hate the Clintons and you should too" mantra. Why would a faithful member of this party do that to another Democrat?
It was Obama and his proxies who played the race-baiting card, and then got angry when Hillarty didn't bite
You, yourself post hate filled, angry, vitriolic LIES about The Clintons all for the purpose of getting a nomination for Obama. A nomination that he will never again be able to pursue with the same rhetoric. In that sense he screwed himself into the ground.
You see, Obama painted himself into a corner when he started playing the "New Guy for Change" card. Because, after this election cycle, he won't be the new guy anymore.
That's why he and his people scratch, claw, and bite for every inch of turf. They know, and HE knows, that this is it for him, and the desperation is starting to show.
Its Obama, indpendents, Republicans, and people like you who are dividing this party with their rhetoric and the  attitude that Obama has some sort of birthright to the nomination.
If you can't tell us what Obama would change (and you along with most of his followers can't), then it's time to move on towards proven leadership and someone who has a plan.
Sorry, Ron.....but the Obama quick-step isn't going to work with intelligent, well informed voters.

Hillary For President 2008
"...Senator Clinton was so touched by the MLK speech she saw Dr. King give in 1963 that she worked on the campaign of Barry Goldwater a year later. ..."
Dave, Evergreen CO (Sent Monday, January 21, 2008 3:45 PM)

...and Barrack Obama is such a dedicated Democrat that he gives Reagan more credit than Clinton (a President who came from his own party.)

Hillary Clinton's remarks were very eloquent and inspiring.  She is the best candidate to carry out Dr. King's legacy.  She alone has the qualifications, experience, and strength to achieve the meaningful change that is so badly needed in this country.  America needs Hillary Clinton!
This seems to be the last real chance for black America. Within the next 20 years it will no longer be a white/black issue, but a white/hispanic issiue.
I think that is why so many blacks are running for Obama...Who happens to be half white...Ironic,huh
Clinton has her flaws, but at least she has a chance to win.
The Clintons and their friends are attacking visciously today.  They seem to take very minor (and obvious) points and twist them around on blogs everywhere.  It appears to be a shameless push to discredit their opponents.

That's rich coming from Clintons:  Exactly who was impeached for lying?  Who said they did not inhale?  Who said they did not have sexual relations with Monica Lewinski?  And this is where the list starts.
Dear Asad - I have a post-graduate degree as do many of my colleagues. We supported John Edwards four years ago and we support Hillary Clinton now. If one thing is clear in this election - you  can't generalize when it comes to how people vote. Yes, there are trends and the media seems to spin every nuance, but people tend to vote for a candidate that most closely addresses their concerns. Clinton is that candidate for me. My vote reflects my work ethic - I care more about substance,clearly defined goals, and getting the work done than I do about rhetoric and feel good messages.
Is there a Jefferson Davis Day to go along with that Flag?
She received a warm reception from an energized crowd in which several dozen people held up Clinton signs. As all of the candidates have done recently, she highlighted the historic nature of this race and praised her rivals, calling Obama an "extraordinary, young African-American man with so much to contribute!


Whoops there It IS!!! Hillary, he is an EXTRADINARY MAN PERIOD. You could have stopped there, but No, you have to add on African American. Race Baiting, YOU BET!!!

How anyone can beleive she's changed from a Barry Goldwater girl, is beyond ME.

You won't hear Barack say you're an Extradinary WHITE WOMAN!!!!!!!!

UNREAL
J. Merle,
Must give credit where credit is due--you are brilliant at the game of spin.

Most spinmasters can see other people's spin though.  You, however, seem to have bought the Clintons' bait without a second thought.  For someone who claims to be part of the intelligent wing of the party, you appear to be remarkably vulnerable to the manipulation of the master minds Wolfson and Penn.
Ron, take a look at the utter hypocrisy of your own post!

Ron, TX (Sent Monday, January 21, 2008 3:36 PM:

1. "The Clintons are single-handedly destroying the democratic party to achieve -their own- dream of securing a 3rd term in the presidency."

2. "Lies, deception... it's absolutely disgusting."
 
3. "Barack Obama can move beyond the partisan flames and inter-party mud-slinging of the Clintons."  

Ron, YOU are an Obama FOLLOWER and YOU are coming on this blog throwing "partisan flames and inter-party mud-slinging"!!!!

That means, Ron, that your candidate, Barack Obama,  is a FAILURE at leadership. He can't even get HIS OWN FOLLOWERS to follow his lead.

What a joke!
Sorry, the dirty tricks, including the Muslim e-mails from her camp, the accusation of drug dealing, shuck and jive quotes, etc., all came from Clinton's mouth. Obama's folks haven't had to resign in shame.

When Clinton made the MLK quote, folks out here were already up in arms. They were leery after she spoke with a faux Black voice, making comments about the plantation.

It doesn't serve Obama's purposes to talk about race, it serve's Clinton's.

What Bill did to Jesse Jackson after the riots are not forgotten out here.

Obama had nothing to do with the anger people feel towards Clinton, She does, and she needs to own it.

More and more people are vowing not to vote for her, even if she gets the nomination. Good luck trying to win less than 50% of Democrats.
J, Merle Stanley your statement was right on. Could not of said it better. I have predicited all along that if he doesn't get nomination you will see him not even run for the senate again but go to private sector. Senate was just a stepping stone for him to run for the presidency.
J. Merle Stanley, Westchester, NY ,

If you quote a candidate, then please quote a candidate accurately. THAT is the problem with this election - some people need to relay their interpretation of what a politician said and represent it as a quote. However, it isn't what was said at all.

You might want to review the actual scripts before you write. (Not line items, either. Or 30-second soundbites - read the WHOLE thing)

It is the same problem we faced with educated Senators and Representatives who didn't read the WHOLE report about the status of Iraq, and why we are now at war. Hillary thought it was to send inspectors back in. Duh!
On The Mark Dave!!

Senator Clinton was so touched by the MLK speech she saw Dr. King give in 1963 that she worked on the campaign of Barry Goldwater a year later.


Goldwater voted AGAINST civil rights.
allen you call murder coverups flaws   get a life  see clintons chronicles or keep quiet
Now Obama breaks his pledge not to campaign in Florida and is running ads in Florida. Yeah real man of his word! If Hillary did this Obama supporters would be all over her.
I won't trouble readers by going into a point-by-point refutation, I'll just say that it is simply disgusting that Hillary and her husband think that American people are not smart enough to see through all of her veiled characterizations and thinly veiled insults, so as not to realize that these two will say and do anything and everything to "vindicate what they perceive as their humiliation" and get back into our White House by any means necessary. Next Bill (Our "First Black President")will call Obama a racist, and then persuade Monica Lewinsky to publicly endorse his wife, in exchange for being named "Secretary of Conflict Resolution" in the new Clinton Cabinet. :-)
Asad, you are incorrect about educated and undereducated (not uneducated).
A person who does not have a college degree is educated, just not from a higher education institution.

You are not making an observation, observations takes more than what you have here, You are making an assumption, making an assumption makes me think that you are undereducated!
A college degree gives you the symbol of having a higher education and knowledge, you must use it properly to be considered an educated person.
So if you attack a Clinton supporter for being uneducated we will consider you sexist, HMMMMMMM, who really is educated here Asad, not you, this is not even an assumption, it is stupid.
Yes I am educated with a terminal degree in my discipline. How far have you gotten?
Thank you for giving me another reason to forget about Senator Obama as a strong candidate for the democratic party. If he has finagled you then I know I am correct in not believing him.
@Asad

In the New Hampshire exit poll, Clinton won most college grads, but Obama won most post grads. yes, there is a tendency for the "more-educated" to vote obama. However, who are the "more-educated"? I would argue that he won them because the "more-educated" are richer, and seem to be voting on that, rather than their education. Let's just face it, most people are getting caught up in this "vote for me and we can make history" rhetoric, which is a bit narcissistic in a way. However, as an educated Stanford student myself, I must say, that Hillary Clinton seems to have a better grasp of history than Obama.
Analysts say black women this year never have been more engaged in a political campaign or held such power in determining the Democratic nominee.Recent polls show black women are expected to make up more than a third of all Democratic voters in South Carolina's primary in five days.For these women, a unique, and most unexpected dilemma, presents itself: Should they vote their race, or should they vote their gender?

http://www.youpolls.com/details.asp?pid=1601

.
....sigh.....
obama never gave reagan any "credit", he simply said that reagan changed the trajectory of the nation and the face of politics/government.
that is neither credit nor discredit, it is statement of the facts.
why is this so hard to understand?
Bla bla bla Clintons, bla bla bla Obama, bla bla bla political rhetoric......

Ask yourself..... who speaks to your heart... who makes you feel that they know what's the right thing to do....

Ask yourself who's running on the Constitution and not on how to play the game of politics.....

then vote.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=595961

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

More First Read

Recent Posts:


Archives:


Topics:

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google