ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Clinton says she'll abide by pledge

Posted: Tuesday, January 22, 2008 1:14 PM by Domenico Montanaro

From NBC/NJ's Athena Jones
WASHINGTON, D.C. -- In a 20-minute press conference Tuesday morning, Hillary Clinton again called on President Bush to do something to help the economy immediately and said she plans to abide by the DNC pledge not to campaign in Florida, despite a national Obama cable ad buy, which happens to run in some Florida markets and her campaign took issue with yesterday. 

In response to a series of questions about her husband's role in her campaign, the senator said his strong advocacy for her was to be expected and that the party would unite behind whomever is the nominee.

Clinton said Obama had decided to change his strategy after losses in New Hampshire and Nevada and he had come to the Myrtle Beach debate looking for a fight.

On Bill Clinton, she said, "I think on both sides, our surrogates are obviously out there advocating for each of us. But this is between us. This is who's on the ballot. This is who's presenting our case to the public."

The senator said this race was about the candidates as individuals and about drawing contrasts among the candidates on the issues:

"I just think that there's a lot of commentary about this that is really missing the point. You know, we are presenting ourselves as individuals, not as categories, not as fulfilling certain kinds of expectations. We are individuals and we come with our life histories, our experiences and I think that is exciting and that doesn't mean that we're going to step back and not criticize each other."

On campaigning outside South Carolina this week and whether it means she's giving up on the state, Clinton said, "For those of you who covered me in Nevada, you know that we were always present in Nevada. Either I was there (sic) my husband was there, my daughter was there. All of us were there. That's exactly what we're doing in South Carolina. I have a couple of obligations that I have to meet today and tomorrow, but my husband and my daughter are in South Carolina and we are waging a very vigorous campaign in South Carolina. We are obviously on the ground pushing hard. We have advertising running and I will be spending, you know, the last part of the week there." 

On campaigning in Florida after Obama's decision to run ads on cable there, in what the Clinton campaign says is a violation of the DNC four-state pledge: "You'll have to ask them (the Obama campaign) what they are doing in Florida. I intend to abide by the pledge and follow the pledge and that's what we are, you know, planning to do."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Funny how all of those naive little Obama supporters said that Hillary was going to be the one campaigning in Florida first. Let me guess, since Barack Obama did it, and not Hillary, it's a completely fine move on his part right? Yeah, that would pretty much be the definition of hypocrisy.
You know, the whole "pledge" argument is baloney seeing as all the campaign ads are played on the news and online all the time. Florida is not another planet.
No disrespect First Read, but coverage appears to be pretty slanted today.
Hillary is damned if she does and damnded if she doesn't.The republicans did an excellent job on the Clintons for years.Their poop sticks when they throw it unk=like the ppedophiles,child molesters,treasons behavir of the plame outing,lying about the war and economy,etc.The neocons are too slippery for anything to stick to them even the truth.
Come to fla Hillary! We love you and will campaign for you!!
Of course she'll abide by the pledge.  She's winning in FL.  When things are good, we see statesmanlike Hillary.   It's easy to be gracious when the sun is shining.  People's true colors emerge when it gets cloudy.  And man did we see some nasty things after Iowa; the old Clinton/Rove playbook got dusted off and America got more of the same.
Keep up the good work, Hillary.  I have already voted for you.  GO HILLARY
She wasn't too worried about her pledge not to run in Michigan, where she was the only top democrat to appear on the ballot... She wasn't too worried about her pledge not to campaign in Florida to stop fundraising in Florida.

It's literally impossible to buy a national ad, and NOT have it run in every state.  It's implausable to buy 100,000 local ad buys for every major metropolitan and suburban area across the United States.
Hmmm... what about Hillary keeping her name on the ballot in Michigan!!!!

WHAT A HYPOCRITE!

Hillary whines about Obama ads reaching some markets in Florida, but she didn't say anything when she "won" Michigan!
This woman is really turning a whole lot of people off, but I am sure that is the part of the strategy...that is, kill all the enthusiasm of the people who have never been involved in politics with same old, same old….the same old Rovian strategy.

I am sure the republicans are thanking their fortune as we speak as it looks more and more that Mrs Clinton will likely be their opponent this fall and with her coming with less than 40% enthusiastic Democratic supporters even makes it more good news for them.

The horror film of who had what (and who gave what)in the Oval office will come back into the television near all of us this fall, which is why I think the entire news media is rooting for her because the viewership will increase because of the replay of the junk news of the 90s.
OBAMA, lets be honest with the American people. OBAMA surfaces in FEDERAL CORRUPTION case.If you feel as I do, pass it along. http://www.chicagosuntimes.com
she said, "I think on both sides, our surrogates are obviously out there advocating for each of us. But this is between us. This is who's on the ballot. This is who's presenting our case to the public."

If that's true, THEN WHY DID YOU IMPLY CREDIT FOR THE ECONOMIC HEALTH OF THE 90'S, in last night's debate, when you had ABSOLUTELY NOTHING to do with creating it!!

Hillary cannot have it both ways!!

Either she is running strictly as "FEMALE BILL CLINTON", or as Hillary Rodham Clinton....

pick one!
Yeah, Right it is between her and Obama.   I can see that statement as being untrue, as soon as it left her lips.   Obama has to campaign against Bill.   Bill has shown that he thinks he is the candidate.   Hillary really is not, no matter how she protest.

Why all of the nasty attacks?   She used a personal attack during the debates, even though none were thrown at her.   Yet people see them as viable.  I hope the electorate wakes up as to whether they really want to see Bill Clinton back in the White House for a 3rd, possibly 4th term.  His being a spouse to help his wife is totally different from Michelle and Elizabeth.   It is a little like Goliath and David, don't you think?
I wouldnt take her word on any pledge she takes how about Lobysist not runining or taking position within your campaign or if elected your office....Dont give me the reponse you gave Obama well they may the best suited for the position and by that you mean there money that you and bill seem to be taking.....
How can anyone believe what Sen. Clinton says anymore?  She left her name on the Michigan ballot when Sen. Obama and John Edwards pledged not to.
Why is wrong for Obama to run national media which happens to also include Flordia.  Shouldn't then all candidates not speak to national media because it will be broadcast in Flordia.  Also, what happened in Michigan where the Clintons were the only Democrates who did not take their name off of the ballot.
Clinton's are now engaged in typical dirty pool. I am so disappointed in the former President, and Hillary for their distortions, and flat out lies regarding a member of their own party. I am starting to see that Hillary can't stick to talking about what she will do or has done, cause she really hasn't done much at all. So much for bringing the party together...Hillary/Bill keep this up and win the nomination, many dems, and most indies will vote republican (if the nominee is Huckabee or McCain), or just stay home.

By the way, in Illinois, a "present" vote means perhaps with a few changes, I can support this. It gives the participants an idea as to whether a particular bill is on the right track or dead in the water.

Finally, Barack said that RR was a transformative president (Conservative Movement...TRUE), and the repub. party was SEEN as the party of ideas (NOT BETTER IDEAS HILLARY!!). Which was the friggin truth...thus 12 years of repub white house.

Keep this crap up, and we'll be repub in the white house for 4 more years.
After watching last night’s debate, does anyone really want the Clinton’s back in the White House?  Hill or Bill it doesn’t matter because it’s all the same, yesterday’s news.   She will do and say anything to be president, just as Bill will do and say anything to get back into the White House.  I for one will be voting for Barack Obama in the primary.   Should the Clinton’s win the primaries then I’ll be voting ABC.  "Anybody but Clinton"
Oh yea sure, Hillary is turning people off huh? Well then how come her poll numbers continue to go up and Obamas are going down in critical states. Hillary is kicking butt and shes tough and thats one of the things we need in our next leader. Obama can barely look at her during the debates-he's sooo intimidated by her and his own wife.
you know hillary said in one of her comments and said obama is a african american and she ia a women we know she is a women she didn't want to say she was a white american women because even a white american women has more and is reconize above african american man and womens and hispanic male and female white american womens might be in the minorities as womens but they are on a standard higher than minorites women and mens
Florida will be voting for President. Last I heard it was a swing state and did not lose it's electoral votes. Jeez...grow up. Run on your record...your ideas...your vision...not by bashing the other guy.
So she says it's important to be judged as an individual, it's "who's on the ballot" that counts...but I'm going to go raise money in California and Arizona while my husband(an ex-president) campaigns for me in South Carolina???
Did Clinton abide by the pledge in Michigan? She was the only Dem candidate to put her name on the Michigan ballot. I do not recall that Clinton made an announcement regarding the MI pledge before the MI primary.

OBAMA WON THE SC DEBATE BECAUSE HE BROUGHT UP RELEVANT ISSUES OF INTEGRITY. OBAMA DID THE NATION A SERVICE BY ASKING THE QUESTION ABOUT THE NAME OF THE ACTUAL CLINTON CANDIDATE.

BILL IS RUNNING FOR A THIRD TERM AND THE CLINTONS ARE SHREDDING THE U.S.CONSTITUTION.

OBAMA SEES THE BILL ISSUE BETTER THAN A LOT OF US BECAUSE HE IS A PROFESSOR OF U.S. CONSTITUTIONAL LAW AT THE UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO.

THANK YOU OBAMA FOR YOUR COURAGE TO SPEAK OUT ON THE CLINTONS' LATEST CONSTITUTIONAL SUBVERSON TRICK. THE LAST TIME THEY WERE IN OFFICE DURING BILL'S ESCAPADES.

FORTUNATELY, THIS TIME THEY HAVE NOT MADE IT BACK. HOPEFULLY, THE NATION WILL NOT HAVE TO FACE THAT PROSPECT AGAIN.

GO HOME CLINTONS AND LEAVE US IN PEACE!!

THANK YOU.
She wasn't too worried about her pledge not to run in Michigan, where she was the only top democrat to appear on the ballot... She wasn't too worried about her pledge not to campaign in Florida to stop fundraising in Florida.

It's literally impossible to buy a national ad, and NOT have it run in every state.  It's implausable to buy 100,000 local ad buys for every major metropolitan and suburban area across the United States.

Ron, TX (Sent Tuesday, January 22, 2008 1:55 PM)


What a pathetic apologist and what a limp defense. What if it was Clinton? A hypocrite like you would be harping on it for WEEKS. Your guy is a wimp and your defense of his running ads A FREAKING WEEK after planting stories about how Clinton was going to violate the pledge is just more proof that Obama people are hypocritical and turn a blind eye to every misstatement, flip-flop and outright lie coming out of his campaign. Thank goodness we'll only have to put up with this crap for another couple of weeks...


"Is Hillary Clinton breaking her pledge not to campaign in Florida? Democratic rival Barack Obama raised the question - even though he insists Florida's vote won't matter - one day after a poll showed him 21 points behind in the state. An Obama campaign memo Tuesday pointed to "signs . . . that she may be planning to campaign in the state, inquiring about large venues and increased organizing activity."

http://www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=view_all&address=132x4085316


Campaign 2008 PDF Print E-mail
Obama camp suggests Clinton will break no-Florida pledge
By Sam Youngman
Posted: 01/15/08 06:18 PM [ET]

A spokesman for Sen. Barack Obama’s (D-Ill.) presidential campaign sent out a memo Tuesday afternoon suggesting that rival Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton (N.Y.) might violate her pledge not to campaign in Florida ahead of its Jan. 29 primary."

http://thehill.com/campaign-2008/obama-camp-suggests-clinton-will-break-no-florida-pledge-2008-01-15.html

and just for good measure...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eAkIidChxic
Depends on what the meaning of "is" is.
It is hard to believe that any union would be stupid enough to vote for Hillary Clinton after all the time she spent on the board of Wal-Mart.  My team is just frothing at the mouth just waiting for her to discuss union issues.

Considering she is not really a union woman makes the idea of union's supporting Hillary more sillier.
Saint Hillary has spoken and now we all must fall in line and believe her every word.  Nothing comes out of this women's mouth that is not measured or calculated.  It is impossible to buy National advertising and not include Florida, but that is not the point.  The point is that the Clintons are the Carl Rove of the Democratics and it will be a better day when we are rid of them and they are off doing all their good privately so we do not have to listen to them pat themselves on their backs.
"This woman is really turning a whole lot of people off, but I am sure that is the part of the strategy...that is, kill all the enthusiasm of the people who have never been involved in politics with same old, same old….the same old Rovian strategy."
  I think you got a great point here although I wouldn't use the "This woman" quote to make the statement.  I think we need some civility in the process.  Having said that, I think that the strategy her camp is playing here is "winning at any cost".  Now to some that might sound good but I would imagine the gridlock would continue and people would continue to be turned off.
Good luck USA. This is what we have to look forward to after all the acrimony during Bill's years; the lack of leadership from the Bush cronies and now more. Just be prepared to read everyday in your papers how Bill or Hill got mad at either a Congressman, the media, or somebody else who didn't agree with them (sound like a current President?) and everyone is wrong or out to get them and the Republicans are the devil incarnate (although some may actually be). This is the noise of division, power, greed. If anyone thinks this is the politics that will get us a majority in Congress, I got a bridge to sell you in Arizona. And the poor will get poorer and the environment will become diritier and will have more soldiers killed because we couldn't get anything done. And Bill and Hill can sit in the White House talking about how it wasn't their fault.
Enough with the childish antics and get on with what is at stake here America
The problem for Hillary is that Obama has so much material to draw from that he can make fairly mild and legitimate jabs both at Hillary's own voting record and her husband's less successful policies, but when she chooses to pick at Obama's mistakes, there isn't a there there. Obama had a glittering overall record in Illinois, and has been enough in the limelight since coming to Washington that he's known to keep his nose meticulously clean. It's not productive to challenge his record, so Hillary comes off looking disingenuous. It's a no-win strategy.

That Hillary seems not to even perceive of another way, one that consistently takes the high road of receiving criticism in good grace and promising to deliver the fruits of learned experience, is what troubles me most greatly about her campaign. For all her wonkish detail about economic policies, her interactions consistently lower the quality of debate, and often insult my intelligence.

Mistakes will happen, but all the candidates and their spouses need to consistently strive for a high level of discourse, and that's not happening right now. As John Edwards noted last night, this is about so much more than the candidates, and we need to always keep that in mind.
Funny.

I was in Iowa and heard Obama's stump speech, read his "Blueprint for Change" and heard his policies. What I hear now is the same as I heard then, with the exception of the Clinton Machine spin.

I am so glad he finally stood up and called her on the floor for the dirty tactics. It is difficult for him to stay a complete gentleman among the political barbs.  It is kind of like trying to remember the man in the lake is trying to stop a leak while surrounded by alligators.
The way I see Hill as president is this: as usual with the Clintons, some huge controversy will come up, they will spend a lot of time denying said controversy, then, at a later time, will admit to a "little bit" of said controversy, and as usual, none of the important stuff will be done because they have spent so much time denying.  CONTROVERSY, DENIAL, AND A LITTLE BIT OF ADMISSION.  Is this what you want for four years.  Not me,  Go OBAMA and I am a republican.  Hill is not the right woman for president.
I am so glad to see a woman running.  Men have had over 200 years.  We have the greatest country but our economy is in deep trouble, and this war needs to stop.  The president could put a freeze on gas prices.  It has been done in the past, but our president is becoming richer every day.I am voting for Hillary.  May God be with her.
A press conference call just to attack Obama.  Dispicable, and shows that although the press won't admit it, Obama trounced her in the debate.  This Florida thing is ridiculous, but its clear to me why she is bringing it up.  She doesn't want Obama running national ads which are geared towards Feb 5th states (not Florida which doesn't even count).  That's because she is counting on uneducated and uniformed voters in those states voting for her based on name recognition.  Heaven forbid, they would actually get to know who this Obama gut is before they cast their vote.  The Clintons are a disgusting embarrassment.  
The way I see Hill as president is this: as usual with the Clintons, some huge controversy will come up, they will spend a lot of time denying said controversy, then, at a later time, will admit to a "little bit" of said controversy, and as usual, none of the important stuff will be done because they have spent so much time denying.  CONTROVERSY, DENIAL, AND A LITTLE BIT OF ADMISSION.  Is this what you want for four years.  Not me,  Go OBAMA and I am a republican.  Hill is not the right woman for president.
Frankly, I'm ready for a change!!! If Hillary is elected it's like Bill having a third/fourth bite at the apple. I think it's time for a new direction!! Hillary is too political for me. I think every word that proceeds from her mouth has been calulated to fit in her career path. I have never trusted the woman. Good Luck to Obama and Edwards!!  
First Read, I see a double standard in your reporting, Im white but something has bother me for a while, SC,50%AA,NH,98%white,Nevada lge population of latinos, If HRC dosen't when in SC it's because of the 50%AA votes,I guess you devalue their votes,NH that's fine they're white. RACISM IS ALIVE AND WELL IN THE WHITE MEDIA!!!!!!!!!  If i were the AA and HRC won the nomination i was mobilze and not vote at all
Give me a break!  We cannot as a nation let the Clintons back in the White House.  It just seems so wrong.  Haven't we seen this movie?
Its too funny. Clinton gets caught scheduling a large speaking venue in Miami. Obama places an ad buy on cable networks, which happen to show in Florida as well as everywhere else that gets those stations. And Clinton criticizes Obama on breaking the pledge.

Its jaw droppingly shameless.

Its like Clinton criticizing Obama for Rezko when she has far worse fundraising baggage. That's what the Clintons do. They just ignore the obvious and make loudmouthed attacks that are absolutely insulting to voters' intelligence.

Maybe enough Democrats will pretend not to notice so as to nominate her. But who here thinks independents would do the same?
The debate put me solidly behind Barack Obama for two reasons.
1. Clinton had repeatedly attacked Obama for considering 1 trillion dollar tax on "hard working Americans" to fund Social Security.  Apparently, Clinton is opposed to “raising the cap” on Social Security payroll tax on wages over $97,000 (about 6% of the population makes over that amount). Hillary apparently thinks that the middle class can fund SS from 100% of their wages while those that make more, can fund SS on just 50%, 20% or .5% of their total income and still be eligible for full benefits. She thinks the burden should stay on the middle class.
2. Also, Hillary wants to mandate (or force) everyone to pay for health care. The thinking is that will drive the price down. What incentive is there for insurance companies to lower the price is everyone is force to buy it? Further, Obama would have kids going to college stay on their parent’s health care. Hillary would have kids after they turn age 18 (whether in college or not) buy their own. Their parents would still likely have to continue to pay for a family plan, but insurance companies would benefit with another paying customer at age 18.
For all her talk about how families are struggling with gas, education, heating, and food costs, she wants to increase the financial burden by adding a mandatory health cost too.  
Some would call Hillary's attacks on Obama's stance on these issues as a way to deflect the real impact her own policies would have on the American people as politically artful. I'd call it a con job.
The debate put me solidly behind Barack Obama for two reasons.
1. Clinton had repeatedly attacked Obama for considering 1 trillion dollar tax on "hard working Americans" to fund Social Security.  Apparently, Clinton is opposed to “raising the cap” on Social Security payroll tax on wages over $97,000 (about 6% of the population makes over that amount). Hillary apparently thinks that the middle class can fund SS from 100% of their wages while those that make more, can fund SS on just 50%, 20% or .5% of their total income and still be eligible for full benefits. She thinks the burden should stay on the middle class.
2. Also, Hillary wants to mandate (or force) everyone to pay for health care. The thinking is that will drive the price down. What incentive is there for insurance companies to lower the price is everyone is force to buy it? Further, Obama would have kids going to college stay on their parent’s health care. Hillary would have kids after they turn age 18 (whether in college or not) buy their own. Their parents would still likely have to continue to pay for a family plan, but insurance companies would benefit with another paying customer at age 18.
For all her talk about how families are struggling with gas, education, heating, and food costs, she wants to increase the financial burden by adding a mandatory health cost too.  
Some would call Hillary's attacks on Obama's stance on these issues as a way to deflect the real impact her own policies would have on the American people as politically artful. I'd call it a con job.
Mrs Clinton was a senator from NYS a few years ago... having lived there at the time,I noticed that she NEVER appeared there unless it was warm weather, never in the winter time, when we have our massive snow storms.I cannot remember ONE thing that she did for New York State, she will hopefully lose NYS in the upcoming election.  We need some one who cares for us.  
while she was serviing as  THE New York State Senator....Will she be a "no show"  if she becomes the US President, never being in the country.
The sanctity of Whithouse/country is at stake. We do not want Bill Clinton back there operating with a remote control. Support Obama
Hillary revealed to the nation what an amateur Obama truly is on the national stage.  He's not ready - he's not tested.  And if he thinks the Clintons are ganging up on him - he's gonna get steamrolled by the Republicans in the fall.
There was NO personal attack by Hillary against Obama at the debate! He struck the first blow with his crack about the Walmart Board. Hillary mentioned Rezko the slumlord because Obama DID have a business relationship with him and even bought adjoining property with Rezko's wife! It's on the record, so HOW is that a personal attack??? Rezko was a campaign fundraiser for Obama, and even donated money to his campaign while some of Rezko's inner city tenants suffered with NO heat! The fact that Obama went back on his word about Florida does not bode well for the future either, if he can't even be honest about campaign ads! Also, all of his whining protests about Big Bad Bill Clinton are becoming QUITE pathetic...All Bill's done is talk about his RECORD! What does he think the GOP will do, play footsies??? Hillary For President!!!
I remember Elizabeth Edwards taking a very active role on behalf of her husband, as well as Michelle Obama. Now, I ask you, why can't Bill Clinton do the same on behalf of his wife? Oh, I see, Obama supporters think this is not fair.
Also, Obama can question votes made by Clinton and Edwards, but takes exception when they do the same? Why does Obama seek a double standard? If that was coming from either Clinton or Edwards, this would be deemed racist. Come on, people. Wake up. You have to be thick-skinned to run for the Presidency of the United States. What do you think the Republicans will be firing at Obama if he wins the nomination?
Obama is clearly not ready yet, although with some seasoning he will be, but not at this time in history. Clinton is the best choice for President!
The Billarys are turning off even core Dems with their nasty campaign tactics. They will do anything, including fracture the Democratic party just to win the nomination but then what...create too much bad blood within the Dems and see if people come out and actually vote if the Billary's get the nomination. I may just sit out this election because I've come to despise Hillary in the past 2 weeks.
Crucial question for HRC that, unfortunately, has to be buried all the way down here...How does she plan to continue courting the popular support of Hispanics, particularly in the SW, but not support an "amnesty" approach to the issue of immigration?  Whether it's right or not is open for debate, but I think anything that so much as hints at amnesty is very, very unpopular with the broader American public right now.  She can't have it both ways come general election time, so she'd probably be better served to settle this issue now rather than later.
Obama didn't lose. They each have 9 NH delagates and he has more delegates than her from Nevada. So.......

XXXXXXXXIT! Try Agian Hillary.

What Obama and many others are sick of , is your BOLD FACED LIES!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=598847

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google