ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Clinton economic speech echoes trail

Posted: Thursday, January 24, 2008 3:42 PM by Domenico Montanaro

From NBC/NJ's Athena Jones   
GREENVILLE, S.C. -- It was billed as a major economic speech on what needs to be done immediately to help jumpstart the U.S. economy and avoid recession, but Hillary Clinton's address here Thursday was really a continuation of her recent attacks on Pres. Bush for not doing enough to help and a restatement of the economic stimulus plan she announced earlier this month.

The difference was that she gave it here in this early primary state in a week when global markets have been rocked by uncertainty and at a time when the economy is tops on voters minds.

Much of the language in the address echoed speeches the senator has given in places like Compton, CA, Las Vegas, NV and Hackensack, NJ in recent days, with an emphasis on dealing with the mortgage crisis, providing tax rebates for working and middle class families, helping people pay their energy bills and creating millions of green collar jobs.

She said Pres. Bush had failed to act to help the economy.

"Instead he has stayed at a comfortable cruising altitude, well above the realities of people's lives, delegating responsibilities to his advisers, hoping the buck would stop somewhere else," Clinton told the audience at Furman University.         "This administration has delivered a foreclosure notice on the American dream."

She noted African-American families had been particularly hard hit by the sub-prime mortgage crisis. Blacks make up about half of primary voters in this first-in-the-South primary and polls show rival Barack Obama has opened up a wide lead among them.

Over the longer-term, Clinton said a focus on clean energy and rebuilding America's infrastructure would help shore up the economy, ideas she's been talking about for months on the trail in Iowa and New Hampshire. She talked about making college more affordable, helping people save for retirement, changing the tax structure and fiscal responsibility.

The senator said America needed a "hands-on" president, a subtle criticism of both Bush and the kind of management style Obama suggested he might have in a recent debate.

"The presidency matters more now than ever. We need a president who will run the government and manage the economy. The American people don't hire a president to talk about our problems but to solve them, to set a vision for the future and then to roll up our sleeves and get about fulfilling it. It's time we had a president who believes that leading an economic comeback is a full-time, hand on job," she said.

And she touched on the theme of unity.

"The way we bring our country together is by acting on our values. True unity can only be achieved by finding real solutions for the American people and then delivering them. Without real solutions, division and disappointment, not unity will be the result. We've been there before. Pres. Bush promised to be a uniter not a divider and we know how well that turned out," she said.

During the question and answer session, when Clinton was asked about helping the Latino community, she cited her work for the Children's Defense Fund.

"During the course of my work on behalf of the Children's Defense Fund and many of the other positions and jobs that I've had, I have worked closely with practically every community in America. I don't know any that I haven't worked with. Obviously, I have deep roots and very strong relationships in the African-American community and in the Latino community, because I think it's important that we see ourselves as the United States of America, that we see ourselves that we are all part of the American community. But different communities have different needs."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

not surprising, a negatively slant from FR against HRC.  The bias is almost comical at this point.  Obama has been giving the same speech for months, including the story about the woman who inspired the fired up ready to go mantra, yet FR has nothing to say about that.  the media can continue to say whatever it wishes about the campaign and the candidates themselves, but it's clear the real loser the cycle is the media itself.  Everything from predictions based on polls (NH) to blatant candidate favoritism (Obama) has ensured that!
A candidate of "competence", Hillary Clinton. Please come visit and learn more.. hillaryclinton.com .
Can somebody point out that Senator Clinton's plan on capping mortgage rates is VOLUNTARY (and therefore no different from what President Bush has already put in place).  She's trying to get credit for something that can't be done (contracts are already in place).  Nowhere on her website or in any of her speeches does "voluntary" come up.  Somebody has got to call her on the latest in this cynical game
HILLARY WANT TO GIVE ANYONE THAT HAS NEVER WORKED 3000 DOLLARS, AND THOSE WORKING A JOB 300  TO JUMP START  THE ECONOMY, OR THE DRUG BUSINESS
Actually, her 'work' for the Children's Defense Fund was to create the state-level alliance, The Arkansas Advocates for Children and Family, which is a public policy not-for-profit that does NOT deal directly with the families and children and communities.  They merely raise a ton of money, none of which is funneled down to the actual children and families in need and crises.  They lobby for laws.  
Anyway, I just don't find this "First Read" newsworthy.  Can you tell me why this is considered newsworthy?
HILLARY ROCKS ! ROCK ON HILLARY ! hillaryclinton.com
It is great to have Hillary back in SC! Many thought that SC did not belong in the US anymore... Hillary came so excited--filled with old slogans and nothing new. Only someone who has experienced being part of a minority can understand and heal the needs of the minorities. Hillary doesn't have that experience.
Alex. California (Sent Thursday, January 24, 2008 4:06 PM, Laura Gee (Sent Thursday, January 24, 2008 3:58 PM, DAVID ANDERS , PHARR, TX and FactCheck (Sent Thursday, January 24, 2008 3:57 PM)

I bet you all voted for Bush.  It takes more than hope to change things and run this country.  Just Ask Dr. King, He understood that.  




Alex. California (Sent Thursday, January 24, 2008 4:06 PM, Laura Gee (Sent Thursday, January 24, 2008 3:58 PM, DAVID ANDERS , PHARR, TX and FactCheck (Sent Thursday, January 24, 2008 3:57 PM)

I bet you all voted for Bush.  It takes more than hope to change things and run this country.  Just Ask Dr. King, He understood that.  




A woman doesn't know what it feels like to be in the minority ???  Interesting ...
Looks like Hillary is already into reruns.
I'm just tired of the talk about fixing the economy focusing on telling us that Bush did a bad job.  I've been alive for the last seven years, I've seen what happened.  Don't tell me what I already know, tell me what you are going to do about it, I'm sick of slam jobs by the left and right, Hilary and Obama, Cheney and Rove.  Slam jobs don't fix the problems, they just make those that believe in the person you are hitting angry.  Is it any wonder that this country has become so polarized that we barely even listen to each other anymore.
" because I think it's important that we see ourselves as the United States of America, that we see ourselves that we are all part of the American community. " -HRC

Really?  Now, let me see; where have I heard that before?  Who has talked about seeing each other as one people, as the United States of America since about 2004 around DNC time?  Boy, words must mean something or she wouldn't be trying so hard to steal them.  What was she saying at the last rally in Iowa, "Well, I am fired up and ready to go."  Shameless doesn't really begin to capture it.
Handing out money taken from tax payers, to people who don't pay taxes is just plain wrong. To argue that poor people will spend it faster is lame. Give it to the people you overtaxed in the first place. They darn sure would have spent it if you had let them keep it. They did not give it to this inept congress because they thought congress would manage it better.
Going to need stimulus package to pay for taco-Nancy.
ALL OF THIS IS FAST BECOMING INCONSEQUENTIAL. NOTHING ELSE IS GOING TO MATTER, BECAUSE AT THIS RATE WE ARE GOING TO LOSE THE WHITEHOUSE.  O'BAMA IS DIVIDING OUR PARTY HORRIBLY. YESTERDAY, CLINTON AND EDWARDS SAID THEY WOULD (AND WOULD ENCOURAGE THEIR SUPPORTERS) TO COME TOGETHER AND STAND STRONGLY BEHIND WHICHEVER CANDIDATE WINS THE NOMINATION.  O'BAMA INSINUATED THAT IN AN ALMOST THREAT, THAT SHE WOULDN'T GET THE VOTES FROM HIS SUPPORTERS.  THAT WAS A DEVASTATING THING TO HEAR FROM A FELLOW DEMOCRAT.  COMMENTS GET TWISTED IN POLITICS ON ALL SIDES, THERE'S ALWAYS MUDSLINGING, BUT STATEMENTS LIKE THAT ONE WILL DIVIDE OUR PARTY AND WE'LL MOST DEFINITELY LOSE THE NATIONAL ELECTION BECAUSE OF IT.  THE REPUBLICANS ARE LAUGHING THEIR @$$ES OFF AT US, KNOWING IT'S LOOKING MORE AND MORE LIKE THEY'LL WIN --AGAIN--WHEN THEY NEVER SHOULD.
"THE MOST IMPORTANT THING IS GETTING ANOTHER DEMOCRAT IN THE WHITEHOUSE!" IT'S MORE IMPORTANT THAN YOUR EGO, MR. O'BAMA.  PLEASE SAY THAT'S NOT WHAT YOU MEANT AND THAT YOU, TOO, WILL URGE YOUR SUPPORTERS TO BACK WHICHEVER CANDIDATE IS NOMINATED. DON'T COST OUR COUNTRY ANOTHER 4 YEARS OF WAR AND REPUBLICAN RULE!!
ALL OF THIS IS FAST BECOMING INCONSEQUENTIAL. NOTHING ELSE IS GOING TO MATTER, BECAUSE AT THIS RATE WE ARE GOING TO LOSE THE WHITEHOUSE.  O'BAMA IS DIVIDING OUR PARTY HORRIBLY. YESTERDAY, CLINTON AND EDWARDS SAID THEY WOULD (AND WOULD ENCOURAGE THEIR SUPPORTERS) TO COME TOGETHER AND STAND STRONGLY BEHIND WHICHEVER CANDIDATE WINS THE NOMINATION.  O'BAMA INSINUATED THAT IN AN ALMOST THREAT, THAT SHE WOULDN'T GET THE VOTES FROM HIS SUPPORTERS.  THAT WAS A DEVASTATING THING TO HEAR FROM A FELLOW DEMOCRAT.  COMMENTS GET TWISTED IN POLITICS ON ALL SIDES, THERE'S ALWAYS MUDSLINGING, BUT STATEMENTS LIKE THAT ONE WILL DIVIDE OUR PARTY AND WE'LL MOST DEFINITELY LOSE THE NATIONAL ELECTION BECAUSE OF IT.  THE REPUBLICANS ARE LAUGHING THEIR @$$ES OFF AT US, KNOWING IT'S LOOKING MORE AND MORE LIKE THEY'LL WIN --AGAIN--WHEN THEY NEVER SHOULD.
"THE MOST IMPORTANT THING IS GETTING ANOTHER DEMOCRAT IN THE WHITEHOUSE!" IT'S MORE IMPORTANT THAN YOUR EGO, MR. O'BAMA.  PLEASE SAY THAT'S NOT WHAT YOU MEANT AND THAT YOU, TOO, WILL URGE YOUR SUPPORTERS TO BACK WHICHEVER CANDIDATE IS NOMINATED. DON'T COST OUR COUNTRY ANOTHER 4 YEARS OF WAR AND REPUBLICAN RULE!!
Dear Senator Obama, Go cry me a river, you spoiled little brat, You won't support the nominee if you don't get picked because you thought you had it all sewed up, your supporters are childish runny nosed parrots who cannot think for themselves if they were payed and you suck at debating, McCain is ahead of you if you are the pick and we don't need that, go home and decorate your big house and visit your buddy Rezco when he goes to jail, oh yeah do some work in the senate for a change you lazy secret republican sleaze ball rat bastard. AHHHH that feels good!
Hillary!!!

You go girl!!!!

So waht if MSBC and Chris Matthews thinks that being consistent with your economic speeches is a baaad thing?

As long as you keep on coming up with GOOD DEMOCRATIC IDEAS, we will support you.

Well Hillary tell me how your going to fix the economy when you  and all your collegues life time politicians supported 9200 Pork barrell spending bill and no one standing up outside of the president to say enough is enough...Once again our elected offical are rapeing the American People.... So I suggest you give the American people a free pass on the bridge to no where and a ride on the 60 million dollar ferry to 2 desolet roads, and a free diet meal at the capital building, while i struggle to pay my bills, take care of my family, worry about keeping my job, sending all of manufacturing jobs over seas, cutting back on feeding my family so i can get Health care for my family and you give your self a raise, Have the best Health Care in the country and letting the lobysist make American decesion by the amount of money they give you....All this will stimulate the econmy in the out house where we are now....Thank you washington for taking care of me
I just want to reiterate the wise statement from "ANYBODY BUT THE BOY MESSIAH "I've been saying for a long time Obama is a CON ARTIST. He knows how to make pretty speeches, which he has long prepared, but when it comes time to make responces at debates he flounders..not able to think on his feet. It really makes one feel comfortable doesn't it?        


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=605658

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google