ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC Political Researcher



Hillary surrogate invokes MLK

Posted: Tuesday, January 29, 2008 7:00 PM by Mark Murray

From NBC/NJ's Carrie Dann
HIGHLAND HILLS, OH -- In the wake of criticism that his involvement in the presidential race has hurt his wife's campaign, President Bill Clinton campaigned in Ohio tonight with a message refocused on his wife's decision-making experience. Although the back-and-forth between Hillary Clinton and her main rival did not creep into the former president's remarks, the issue of race came up before Clinton even took the stage. He was introduced by Clinton endorser and popular local black representative Stephanie Tubbs Jones, who told a cheering and racially diverse crowd that Martin Luther King would have been proud of Clinton's candidacy.

"I am supporting Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton, and I owe Martin Luther King Jr. too," said Tubbs Jones, a African-American congresswoman popular in her Cleveland-area district here. "Martin Luther King said  'Judge, you, by the content of your character, and not by the color of your skin.' And if he was here, and if he was here, he would say 'I'm happy that there's a woman running for president too.'"

She went on to take a swipe at Obama's focus on hope as the centerpiece of his candidacy. "You need to know hope did not begin in 2008," she said. "Hope began in 2002 when the man from Hope, Arkansas, ran for president and made a difference in the United States of America." (She meant 1992, when Clinton first began his presidential bid. The slip, perhaps, provides some evidence of the fieriness of her comments.)

When the time came for his own remarks, Clinton stayed away from the contentious issues that have dominated chatter about the race since the run up to South Carolina. Outlining his wife's strategies to tackle education, the economy, and trade, Clinton emphasized she has "the broadest, deepest record" of the three candidates still in the race.

(RNC oppo types may salivate over a few of Clinton's lines that point towards possible short-term tax hikes for long-term hikes. He said that his wife will "spend whatever it takes to put 100-mile-a-gallon cars in your reach quickly." And on her plan to repair the impending housing crisis by giving states and cities extra cash to negotiate with mortgage companies, he admitted "That will cost you some money, probably about 30 billion dollars," he said. But he emphasized that such an early bailout would save billions of dollars and thousands of families' homes.)

Clinton's visit to Ohio, an important Super Tuesday state, comes days after his wife's defeat in South Carolina. In her introduction, Tubbs Jones downplayed Obama's win in the Palmetto State Carolina, where his overwhelming support from African-Americans was largely credited for his victory. "I congratulate Senator Obama for winning south Carolina, but we got 22 other states to make. And we're gonna take this election right on to the people and win the rest of them."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Tubbs is going to be in big trouble in her Cleveland district. She's so pitiful and bought and paid for!
Why does Bill need to continue to attack Barack Obama when his surrogates can do it for him? The Clintons have no shame.
So now if any Clinton surrogate, support or either Clinton utters the name of MLK it becomes news????? Are you guys all crazy???? What are you trying to do???? I just am astonished, amazed and quite frankly saddened if this is what we have come to.
I don't think Hillary is going to be able to take away the MLK mantle from a BLACK man. It's silly to try. Just look at how the nation's "first black president" did on the campaign trail in the Palmetto state: he turned people off and cemented Obama's win there. http://nationalscold.blogspot.com
No you are not MlK
LOL!!  MLK would never have endorsed or 'been proud of' anyone who has a past like she does. google Clinton Chronicles and watch the video... MLK would not endorse criminals.
Hope started in 2002?!?!?!  Even if she mispoke and meant 1992 she's wayyyyy off base here!  Hope is what Abolitionist, suffragettes and Freedom Fighters have used as motivation for over a hundred years before there was ever a Bill Clinton!  This woman needs to check her history books!  
What's the implication of your headline--that there's something inappropriate about a black congresswoman who supports Sen. Clinton refererring to Martin Luther King?  Are you suggesting that only supporters of Sen. Obama can properly invoke Martin Luther King?  I'll tell you this much: Sen. Clinton has much more in common with Dr. King than Sen. Obama has with President Kennedy.  Your faux alarmist headline is stupid.
It is good to see Mr. first 'laddy to be'  do what he does best, talk issues.
Oh no, this is going to get the 'little tea pot' steamed, you go sierra and spew your hot water now.

I am a proud troll for Hillary, we trolls are individuals, who think on our own and wear the troll badge with courage and honor, and we are not afraid to use our real names, unlike some!
The Clintons think that people are stupid and buy this crap.  Just another way to keep you down so you can be nice and submissive and do whatever they say.
Everyone is invoking Martin Luther King, Jr.  However it was Martin Luther King, III, himself, who sent John Edwards a letter on MLK's birthday that stated "my father would be proud" of your camapaign and to "ignore the pundits" and stay in the race.  Typcial of the Clinton camapaign to steal Edwards' thunder, and typical of the media to make it a headliner.
I guess the polls are right. Hillary is doing much better with the uneducated. How much seed money did they pay this black surrogate? And how unintelligent does she sound stating hope started in 1992 with Bill Clinton. Hope started long before that Stephanie Tubbs Jones. Why don't you tell the relatives of all blacks, Indians, and Jewish people that they didn't have hope while they were being tortured and murdered? What a dope!
Shame on you MSNBC for not reporting live results of Florida democratic primary. Your anti-Clinton MSNBC mafia became the only electronic media to do so. Now you officially proved your bias policy. This is disgusting.
Enough of the Clintons!! Just enough!! People are tired of these two egotistical morons. These little staged events they have are so, so fake. Any other person that behaved like Bill Clinton did last week would have lost their job, been thrown out of their political party,and buried under by the media. The Clintons are nothing short of racists. Their behavior in SC was pure and simple -- to marginalize the black guy. Anyone that believes otherwise is fooling themselves. I'm embarrassed for my state that they pulled this nonsense in front of my peers.

Enough of the Clintons!!! They need to go away!!
Ohio is not, as you claim in your last paragraph, a Super Tuesday state. If anything, this visit by Clinton signifies that they may be looking past February 5th in a long drawn out delegate battle.
This is exactly why most people are turned off by politics.

Hillary '08
Yeah right, why don't you try selling that 1992 hope speech to the people of Rwanda? I'm sure they wished Bill's interested in their survival equaled the interested he had for Monica Lewinsky.

What an asinine statement to make!
Ohio isn't a Super Tuesday state.
Ohio is not a Super Tuesday state, it's on March 4.
according to the clinton chronicles the man from hope will go down as the worst president ever
carrie dann, please refrain from trying to race-bait every piece of news.  you are only appealing to a small majority of people and are offending the intelligence of the rest of us.
Invokes?  What an interesting choice of words for someone mentioning the name of a civil rights leader.  Good ol MSNBC anything to keep the race card alive and well.  It makes it sound like someone has just pulled a secret weapon out of their pocket.
The republicans will eat Mr. Obama alive.  Oprah can't help that.
Looking for Constructive Change in America (Sent Tuesday, January 29, 2008 6:59 PM)

Kinda like the Clinton campaign has, huh?

The Clinton trolls are out in full force . Gotta love it when Maxine water's endorse Hillary, But When Oprah's name is mentioned, they go into Fright mode. It's the woman vote he's after(more of it). He's already even with White male voter's. the Clinton's screwed themselves with the AA vote, it's not coming back anytime soon.

I guess in a couple hour's, Hillary's Uneducated legion will Demand a concession speech from Barack & John. Here it is, Stop trying to Cheat B-T-. Even the uneducated can fill in the Blank's.

You can always tell when someone's scared, Lies grow larger & & the s_ _ t starts flying.

Barack Obama for President!!!!!!!!!!!
An Ohio resident responding to Congresswoman Stephanie Tubbs Jones:

I read your introduction of Bill Clinton today and I must say, your statement that hope started in 1992 with Bill Clinton is the most asinine statement I've heard anyone make. We all have our opinions on and right to support/endorse any candidate, but is it necessary for you to take a swipe at other candidates instead of promoting your own?  Did you even consider that just maybe you were belittling millions of innocent men, women and children of all racial injustices who "hoped" for something better long before Clinton and Obama? I'm sure the innocent people in Rwanda that were slaughtered in the 90's hoped America would intervene. I'm sure the survivors of that travesty hoped that Bill Clinton would have explained why his interest in 19 year old interns was unmatched during the affliction their country suffered.

I'll bet you that right now, young girls and boys throughout your district that look up to you, HOPE that you can see through this charade the Clintons have injected you into. You don't find it peculiar that you're on a long list of black representatives that have endorsed the Clintons today?  Could it be a political tactic to offset the white endorsements that Obama is receiving?  Or even more sinister, could it be they’re (The Clintons) trying to make up for attempting to marginalize Obama’s South Carolina win?

I hope for the sake of your constitutes that, you’re not that ignorant. But I fear for America that you are!
I wish the former president Clinton would stay out of the public eye, it looks to me that he is the one running, and will do anything to get back into the white house, even at his wife's expense. Thank you.
Listen to Robert Kennedy Jr,
Kathleen Kennedy Townsend, and Kerry Kennedy

"We have worked with Hillary Clinton for 15 years (and in Kathleen's case, 25 years) and witnessed the power and depth of her convictions firsthand. We've seen her formidable work ethic, courage in the face of adversity and her dignity and clear head in crisis. We've also seen her two-fisted willingness to enter the brawl when America's principles are challenged. Her measured rhetoric, political savvy and pragmatism shield the heart of our nation's most determined and most democratic warrior."....

http://www.latimes.com/news/opinion/la-oe-kennedy29jan29,0,1618955.story
Please, please MSNBC people or anyone else.  Explain your obvious hatred of Hillary Clinton.  You won't show results of our vote in FL. (basically saying a million of us don't matter at all to you) all of you put O'bama on a pedistal and smear her at every opportunity. It's in black and white (here on first read for a week, I can find maybe 1 completely positive Hillary post compared to hundreds for O'bama) and on video. You even conflict each other.  It's getting sickening. I used love MSNBC as you seemed a place we could go to see both sides of things fairly represented. Why are you shoving this man down our throat.  So far, all I hear from him are lofty words and no substance.  All of us out here that don't have your cushy jobs and secure lifestyles need to know the SUBSTANCE of what BOTH candidates plan to do.  O'bama won't talk about the details, you won't ask him about the details and we're going to be the victims if you get him elected with all your praise and nothing gets accomplished because he's looking like just another puppet.
I like the pretty talk, just like everybody else, but that doesn't mean the man can do the job and get things accomplished.  You're playing with our lives, MSNBC. Do you even think about that?  You have power that should be used carefully and such one-sided reporting can do a great deal of harm. Us regular folk go to bed at night worried about how we will pay for checkups our kids need that we can't afford, or whether to pay our house payment or put food on the table for the month.  I've been on the fence, but the only candidate that has shown any kind of substance and true in-depth knowledge of their own plans is Hillary Clinton.  If he has substance under the pretty words, please talk about that, ask him detail questions about that.  That's what we need from you.  I'm almost begging.  I have a feeling if the obvious bias continues you will be losing me and a lot of other viewers.
Please, please MSNBC people or anyone else.  Explain your obvious hatred of Hillary Clinton.

--------------

That's easy. She's a liar, a cheat, and will throw anyone who gets in her way under the bus. Hillary is a racist (note SC primary behavior between her and her husband.). As I write this Hillary is on the TV celebrating her "win" in Flordia. Florida was uncontested. She won a race with no opposition. She is a terrible and self centered person with an ego that is only rivaled by her husbands. She cares only about herself and no one else. Her and husband just need to go away. The (political) world would be better off without her.

I hope this helps.
Since the soon to be retiring baby boomers, like to continue living high on the hog, they may replace the hopes and dreams of the blacks with the illegals......wait too late....they already did United Patriots is the new third party. We will get the black vote. We will be in the Oval office.
Is it the people who are so stupid, this article is so slanted it reeks of MSNBC being bought off. This race for the President has turned into crawling in the gutter!

America sees again the Clinton manner to slander any one in their way. The people have been lied to and this some how must be show in the vote!

To ""Judge"" all I see is scandal and past failed excuses! More of the race card and hammering of hollow experience!

One ""NO"" vote for fact!
Hey Fair is Fair - why don't you just switch over to CNN - the Clinton News Network. They've only shoved Hillary down our throats for two years now.

By the way, MSNBC has shown the results on the Democratic side, they're just spending more time on the Republican side because its A BIGGER NEWS STORY as the contest that's actually awardign delegates.
There is nothing that I can fathom in MLK Jr.'s 39 years that suggests to me that he would have approved of the use of the southern strategy. This is particularly so for those who would be expected to know better.

I would suggest that he would have been appalled by their crass self-absorption. Their behaviour has been detestable. Besides, Sen. Clinton, given her own description of what the president should do, is, at best, a manager NOT a leader.
no, it doesn't help, jenna...you're just spouting more of the garbage.  it's politics, I check facts and O'bama has been "distorting" and outright lying just as often as anyone.  if you think he's not a true politician, look at some of the impartial fact checking sites and his voting record.  Stop drinking the koolaid and talk about the ISSUES that need indept coverage!
MLK's name was mentioned because, apparently, the candidates thought it was a magic name or, more likely, MLK is so important in terms of fighting for justice and equality, so the media will report whenever an influential figure in U.S. history has his/her name uttered by a political candidate. So what's wrong with that?
"no, it doesn't help, jenna..."

Then don't ask. You care about Obama's lying, but not Hillary's? You're nothing but another screamer.
Obama run TV ads (the only one), had 2 (!!!!!) fundraisers, had a grassroots support team from Chicago working here for one month (google it)!
It's too late, Obamanites! The party is over for you! ha-ha!!!!
Salute to Madame President!

Please, Kool-Aid drinkers, refrain from hollering bias because the fl results weren't posted. They don't matter! The Fl dem party screwed up, and rules should be followed. So there are no delegaters coming from Fl. Give it up, move on to the next state that matters. In which case you can look for more meaningless things to complain about.
To "fair is fair" - you would seem a lot more credible if you would lose the apostrophe in Obama's name - what's that all about, anyway?
Stephanie Tubbs Jones represents her district and is well thought for her endless time supporting people's issues.  To think Obama supporters can be so hateful, makes me sad.  If he is the candidate that is pulling people together, he is FAILING TERRIBLY. A black women can't support someone other than Obama. It's not about race or is it just about HATRED.
People are not turned off by politics but they are turned off by the tendency to make the reality of a nation in search of experienced and positive leadership into another reality TV show.  It's understandable but disturbing to see good people become the dancing bears of the media.

Is it now off limits for anyone in the Clinton camp to make any mention of that great person that was assasinated in Memphis?  Would the same hold true for another camp to try to associate itself with that other great person that was assasinated in Dallas?
 
There is no franchise.....  

Both individuals were men....and flawed men at that...but were men that stood up for the things they held dear and we should all take pride and inspiration from both.  Who would they endorse in this election?  I have no idea but I'd bet it would be the person that best would help them achieve their personal end.  That's politics.... and in case you can't or aren't old enough to remember, both were masterful politicians.

The one thing wrong with this race (and politics in general) is all the comments that are thrown around. They are masked to be these wonderfully poetic uplifting words in support of their candidate, but in reality they are infused with little snipes against the opponent. Why are these politicians so worried about the other candidates, all it proves is that they are intimidated and scared. They need to understand that people are more responsive to an honest campaign that focuses on the issues. I thought Hillary was running that kind of camp until as of late. Hopefully she'll get back on track and not just GIVE this election away.
Fair is Fair:
You claim Obama is disorting facts. Please post your sources (not biased bloggers and Hillary supporters, but reliable sources like www.factcheck.org.
Yeah, I have caught him saying a couple of inaccurate things, but the overwhelming majority of the lies are coming out of Bill and Hillary Clinton's mouths.
So, just don't claim to be fact checking Obama or Hillary without honest sources or actually checking.
We have to be a responsible, honest, and informed -- not misled -- citizenry.
Jimmy:
I like your point. Some voters are just looking for "meaningless" things to complain about and level baseless accusations of bias out of hunger for Hillary to win. John Edwards and Obama made the right choice by not breaking DNC rules they agreed to, because the FL Dem party is utterly at fault.
To Fair is fair, Don't blame MNSBC. Florida isn't suppose to count unless a candidate cheats. Hillary is hated because she would divide and destroy our country for her own self interests (more money,more power). It shows in her refusal to release her White House records, it shows in her willingness to divide the Democrats, it shows in her attempts to stir up racial tension and she lies. She votes with Bush on the war as Bill and George Sr are good buddies (Bush-Clinton-Bush-Clinton). She is endorsed by Robert Hugo Chavez Kennedy. She is named 2007 Most Corrupt Politician in Judicial Watch, she manipulates the legal system and thinks Americans are stupid. We are stupid only if we vote her in.
what happened?  Did all of the right wing republicans switch party affilliations to become right wing demo's?Obama certainly attracts the foam at the mouthers, makes me want to call animal control. I agree, if you are so proud of your contribution, put your name and state on your comment.
There is so much hatred coming from the Obama camp, I don't know how they think they are ever going to win the general election.  Bill Clinton said nothing about
Obama and look at these hateful posts.  I would rather vote Republican than vote for Obama.
Obama trolls: Please, please don't call Hillary supporters uneducated and then screw up using apostrophes. It's embarrasing for all of us. I'm sure if you look up "apostrophe" in wikipedia you'll get a lot of great "fact's."

For all the Hillary shriekers, I think you're facing the fact that Obama "sells papers." Obama is getting three times the searchers on major web searches. Don't think they don't pay attention to what the people want to see. Like it or no, but that's the for-profit system. It also doesn't hurt that the Clintons never miss a chance to kick a reporter. Obama listens to their question and answers them directly. He's given them some real juicy quotes because he speaks his mind. Whether he eschews scripted and focus-grouped sound bites is inexperience or authenticity is a judgement call. The fact is he treats them with a bit of respect, something they don't get from the Clintons.


i don't just "claim" anything.  jeez, all I was doing was asking for some help because I dont like things slanted so much.  Is this how all obama people "reach out" in support?  

here's just a few examples and thier "reliable sources".  all I'm saying is that everyone plays politics, all of them lie, distort and try to work everything to their advantage.  so get to the issues.


SEN. OBAMA FALSELY CLAIMED HILLARY SAID NAFTA WAS A 'BOON' TO THE ECONOMY LAST YEAR. At the last debate, Sen. Obama said "And it is absolutely true that NAFTA was a mistake. I know that Hillary on occasion has said -- just last year said this was a boon to the economy." Sen. Obama and his campaign have made the claim repeatedly, even though it is well established that she never said it. [Fact Hub]
THE OBAMA CAMPAIGN FALSELY CLAIMED THAT BILL CLINTON GAVE A PAID SPEECH ABROAD ON THE ANNIVERSARY OF 9/11. Actually, he was attending a 9/11 memorial service in New Jersey. [TPM Election Central]
SEN. OBAMA FALSELY CLAIMS HE 'NEVER SAID THAT WE SHOULD TRY TO GO AHEAD AND GET SINGLE PAYER' HEALTH CARE. There is video from a campaign appearance in 2003 that shows him doing just that. [WSJ; Fact Hub]
THE OBAMA CAMPAIGN FALSELY CLAIMED HILLARY HAD A 20 YEAR PLAN TO BECOME PRESIDENT. This is a widely discredited claim from an anti-Hillary book. [TPM Election Central]
SEN. OBAMA FALSELY CLAIMED THAT HE DOESN'T TAKE MONEY FROM SPECIAL INTERESTS. Obama told the Culinary Workers, "The time has come to tell all the fat cats and the special interests in Washington that their money and their influence don't speak louder than our collective voices. They don't own our government. We do, and we're here to take it back. Those special interests they didn't fund my campaign they will not run my White House and they will not drown out the voices of the American people, working people when I'm President of the United States of America." In fact, Sen. Obama has taken hundreds of thousands of dollars from insurance industry, the banking industry, and others. [CNN, 1/12/08; opensecrets.com]
OBAMA FALSELY CLAIMED THAT HILLARY SAID 'TOUGH AND DIRECT DIPLOMACY' WAS 'NAÏVE AND IRRESPONSIBLE.' Actually, Hillary said that she would not pre-commit to personal meetings with the leaders of Iran, Syria, Venezuela, Cuba and North Korea in the first year of her presidency. She also explicitly promised "a very vigorous diplomatic effort" with all nations, including Iraq. [Union Leader, 10/11/07; CNN/YouTube Debate, 7/23/07]
OBAMA CLAIMS 'NO ONE HAD AN INKLING' THAT REZKO HAD LEGAL AND ETHICAL TROUBLES DURING THE COURSE OF THEIR RELATIONSHIP. Actually, prior to his controversial land deals, prior to land deal, news reports clearly indicated Rezko's troubles, including involvement in kickback scheme. [Fact Hub]
SEN. OBAMA FALSELY CLAIMED THAT HILLARY AND BILL CLINTON SAID HE 'WASN'T OPPOSED TO THE WAR FROM THE START.' Neither Hillary or Bill Clinton has ever said that. They have noted his quotes and record after his speech opposing the war in 2002. [Fact Hub]
SEN. OBAMA CLAIMS HE HAS A 'UNIVERSAL' HEALTH CARE PLAN. Top health care experts agree that his plan leaves 15 million people out. [Fact Hub]
SEN. OBAMA DENIED THAT THE CO-CHAIR OF HIS NEW HAMPSHIRE CAMPAIGN WAS A PHARMACEUTICAL LOBBYIST. His New Hampshire co-chair, Jim Demers, was a pharmaceutical lobbyist. [The Page]
SEN. OBAMA FALSELY CLAIMED THAT HILLARY COULD ORDER THE RELEASE OF ALL HER WHITE HOUSE RECORDS. The process is actually controlled by the National Archives. [Fact Hub]
SEN. OBAMA FALSELY CLAIMED HE HAD NEVER DONE ANY FAVORS FOR REZKO. As a state senator, Barack Obama wrote letters to city and state officials supporting his political patron Tony Rezko's successful bid to get more than $14 million from taxpayers to build apartments for senior citizens. [Chicago Sun Times, 6/13/07]
MSNBC's bias is so transparent you should be embarrassed.  Seriously.  You're starting to rival Faux News levels of shamelessness in your efforts to prop up Obama and disparage Clinton.  And then to basically pretend the FL Democratic Primary wasn't happening until it became clear other networks were reporting on it was a joke.  Really, if you think people aren't on to you, you're kidding yourselves.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=619627

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google