ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Clinton campaign manager steps aside

Posted: Sunday, February 10, 2008 4:07 PM by Domenico Montanaro



From NBC's Chuck Todd and NBC/NJ's Athena Jones
Patti Solis Doyle has stepped aside as Clinton campaign manager. Maggie Williams assumes the role of campaign manager. Dole remains as a senior adviser.

"Patti Solis Doyle has done an extraordinary job in getting us to this point -- within reach of the nomination," Hillary Clinton said in a statement released by her campaign, "and I am enormously grateful for her friendship and her outstanding work. And, as Patti has said, this already has been the longest presidential campaign in history and one that has required enormous sacrifices of everyone and our families. I look forward to her continued advice in the months ahead. Patti and I have worked with Maggie Williams for more than a decade. I am lucky to have Maggie on board, and I know she will lead our campaign with great skill towards the nomination."

Williams served as Hillary Clinton's chief of staff in the White House.

Speculation there could be a shakeup in the campaign began weeks ago and hit a peak just before the New Hampshire primary. Recent reports that Solis Doyle overspent in Iowa -- helping put the campaign in a precarious financial position that required a $5 million loan from the New York senator -- added to the speculation among the chattering class that a change was coming.

Doyle sent the following letter to campaign staff this afternon:

Over a year ago Hillary launched her campaign for President.

Her announcement began a historic effort that has inspired millions and brought hundreds of thousands to their feet all across this nation.

I have been proud to manage this campaign, and prouder still to call Hillary my friend for more than sixteen years.  I know that she will make a great President.

This has already been the longest Presidential campaign in the history of our nation, and one that has required enormous sacrifices from all of us and our families.

During the last month I have been working closely with my longtime friend, Maggie Williams.

This week Maggie will begin to assume the duties of campaign manager.  I will serve as a senior adviser to Hillary and the campaign and travel with Hillary from time to time on the road.  Maggie is a remarkable person and I am confident that she will do a fabulous job.

Although I will continue to see you all at headquarters, I would be remiss if I didn’t thank each of you for your dedication, excellence, and passion over the last year.

You are the best campaign staff in the history of Presidential politics and I am grateful to each of you for your hard work and friendship.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Changing staff, changing direction, changing money issues,... is this what the Clintons mean by "change"?  They never used the word "change" when she first started running, now that Obama has started winning against Hillary she uses the word in all her speeches.
People are outraged at MSNBC for trying to guide this election. They did it in 2000 & 2004. They put the idiot in (Matthews called Blacks & Senior citizens stupid in 2000) and now they are trying to destroy Clinton. If Blacks believe the rhetoric of what they are saying (God help them). The bogouise they have running - wait until he gets the nomination and watch Chuck, Tim and gang help destroy him.
Will, you are so right. Everytime something is screwed up with Hillary, the next day they attack.

She hired a $4million strategist.

He told her to change her slogan to "Yes We Can", and that Change should be the main issue.

I would not be surprised to see her sporting an afro tomorrow.
I don't think the Hillary campaign is evil/underhanded in changing their message and shuffling their staff and redistributing Bill for different purposes every week.  What it does is play right into Obama's argument: it's not enough to be ready on Day One; you have to be right on Day One.

Obama has stayed the course since the beginning of his campaign.  Hillary has floundered and flip-flopped and course-corrected so many times, tested so many different messages, it's no wonder Obama is finally gaining traction.

You can't manage the White House with this kind of constant reinvention.  And you certainly can't manage a successful White House with the kind of disorganization that the Clinton campaign has shown.  A poor grassroots showing has squandered the caucus states, even where the demographics are favorable to her.  She has squandered her enormous monetary advantage.  She has squandered double digit leads in the polls over Obama.

If she can't put away this upstart, first-term senator from Illinois with the enormous Clinton machine at her back, how is she going to get anything done in the White House?  Scratch that, how is she going to defeat a scrappy fighter like John McCain?  He's even more of a surging underdog than Obama (though he's got his own problems within his party at the moment).
get this: be still, The Lord wil do something new, a never-before-seen in this country. just as the young David came from nowhere to Israel to the peak, so will be the one i can't say the name, just be very very carefull when God's waves are on their way.  peace out!!!!!!!
Hillary is up to some kind of no good antics. Is Maggie Williams an African American? Is she trying to pit the Latinos against the African Americans? This is all very strange.
Rocco said: "she is waiting for the big states with the most delegates and superdelegates."

Yeah, sure.  That approach worked SO well for Giuliani, didn't it?

Put a fork in her.  The Billary lies after Iowa killed the campaign.  Karma is sweet sometimes.
Oh, does this mean Hillary can claim to be the cantidate of "Change".  ;-)
Jennifer....I went to the Freedomsenemies website as it was suggested by another blogger.  

The website does a poor job of misquoting the words Barrack Obama wrote in his book "Dreams of my Father".  There are numerous errors on the website and I have a hard time anyone actually takes it seriously.  Then I realize that Bush was able to convince 70% of the American public that Saddam Hussein had a hand in Septemeber 11th and I am not so surprised just sad.   Before you take that website as gospel; read the book and compare what he wrote and what they said he wrote, or the conclusions the website draws that are so far from the intent that there is no doubt that it is written for shock value instead of accuracy.  

They seem intent on convincing people that Barrack Obama is a Muslim.  This is wrong on many levels.  First and foremost he isn't a muslim.  Second if he was exposed to Muslims during childhood is that really a bad thing?  Are all muslims our enemies?  Do you want to allow that website to use your fear and anger against radical terrorists to make you so predjudiced that you would perpetuate a hate campaign to smear Barrack Obama because some of his family in Kenya are Muslims even though he never even met them until he was an adult.  Are we as American's going to allow the same tactics that GWB used...fear and ignorance to trump, truth.  Please support which ever candidate you believe in but do not allow yourself to be used in a way that will one day bring you shame.  And please don't try to pass that ignorance onto others.
Firing a campaign manager in midst of playoffs points to extraodinary circumstances. It is VERY BAD. Don't blame Obama for that. Hilary's mighty machine is showing signs of disrepair. On the other hand, the inexperienced Obama campaign machine is maching in step and sync with its charismatic helmsnan. So, whos is ready to "LEAD AMERICA FROM DAY ONE"? One who messed up with her finances, or one whose bank account is as inflated as the Goodyear blimp?  
Firing a campaign manager in midst of playoffs points to extraodinary circumstances. It is VERY BAD. Don't blame Obama for that. Hilary's mighty machine is showing signs of disrepair. On the other hand, the inexperienced Obama campaign machine is marching in step and sync with its charismatic helmsnan. So, who is ready to "LEAD AMERICA FROM DAY ONE"? One who messed up with her finances, or one whose bank account is as inflated as the Goodyear blimp?

I rest my case. This one is a no brainer.
Stay Strong Hillary!!!  The media is SLANTED toward the male candidates.  Many people follow the medias nasty comments or their school budies for advice on who to choose.  The smart ones don't, they choose you!  Hang in there.  This is tough but we need you.  Stay Strong.
Campaign trouble for Hillary should be good news for the Democrats. No Republican, no matter how disaffected with Bush and/or McCain (and there are a lot of them), will EVER vote for Hillary. They might send a signal to the Republican party by voting for Obama however.
I am glad to see the end of Ms. Doyle.  I wish we could see the end of Mr. Penn, too.  After New Hampshire, Hillary started taking more control of her campaign but the damage that was done has been difficult to overcome.  It cost her the advantage.  I still don't think we should be too quick to count her out.  She has a knack for pulling a rabbit out of a hat.  
How can Hillary manage our government, when she cannot employ the right people to manage her campaign. To be President, you don't have to know how to do everthing yourself; but you surely need to know someone who does.Hillary can't seem to be able to hire the quality and excellent staff that Obama has.I truly believe Hillary uses people, and she has this sense of "Entitlement". She was already in the White House for eight years, now she and Bill wants eight more? Greed, Vanity, Selfish, and of course DIVISIVE!!!!
Now let me see, 1st she fired someone on her campaign committe after the Iowa, New Hampshire caucaus, then yesterday she caused a reporter to get suspended, (of which I don't condone what he did it was wrong) but I think she has carried it to far, now another person on her campaign staff is asked to step back in the background.  What a sad situation.  I am a democrat and if Obama does not get the nomination I'm afraid I won't vote.  If you vote for Hillary then it's a vote for McCain and if you vote for McCain it's a vote for Hillary, sounds like a no win situation to me.

Go Obama!
If Hillary had a sun over a meadow as her symbol of our flag, the media would have been all over it.   What about all those people who worked so hard for our freedom and who worked so hard to protect our flag.  Oh you may not print my last blog, becuase it was for Hillary and the media is so slanted is mind blowing.,, Oh well the "O" with the sun over the meadow is so much more inspirational than the FLAG.
I believe it's all rigged anyway.We, the working  population of America will continue to see our freedom erode our food supply become more tainted and our incomes swallowed up by more price increases no matter who sits in the White House padding the pockets of their powerful friends.
Thus it was and thus it ever will be.
You are acting like vultures, looking for anything to hang your hat on that might indicate your misguided following of an unqualified candidate is the right thing. Half of you need to just grow up and the other half need to read a book or a newspaper.
Bye, Bye Billary!

I am sure the ethnic heritage of her new campaign manager had nothing to do with it!
Bye, Bye Billary!

I am sure the ethnic heritage of her new campaign manager had nothing to do with it!
Reporter to voter outside of polling center; Can you give me one word to describe Hillary Clinton?

Voter: mean, vindictive, irrelevant, devious, saltimbanque, destructive, meandering, obscure, sanguineous, and now a loser!
This one is for HILLARY.  YOU WILL WIN!!!!!!!
Watch, the media wont print this one.  They are so bias is icky.  
Go HILLARY!!!  '08
...and, of course, I suppose it's pure coincidence that we're now "changing" from a Hispanic campaign manager to an African-American campaign manager!

Maybe you need that vote after all?

Now, I'm not saying she's done, but this campaign is a LONG way from where they expected to be after Super Tuesday.  This thing was supposed to be over and done for Billary...they were supposed to at the very least have a lead that would be too difficult to overcome but now they have to wage a real campaign...

...one that appears to be more and more like the Obama campaign.
The first display of a bad leader, and a bad administration,,,oh then their's Big Bill, bet he can't wait to get his hands on new blood in the White House. Can't wait to see it...

Bill and his all female staff...25 and under...
I am a democrat yet I would rather vote for McCain than to vote for Obama.  The blacks have made this race about color and that is the ONLY reason Obama is ahead.  The fact that 90% of the blacks voted for Obama in Georgia proves the fact.  Clinton is much more prepared to run this country.  She is more experienced and she can bring positive change.  Everyone acts like Obama can do no wrong.  Let us remember that Obama has a tainted past involving drugs and alcohol.  But as usual, the blacks will make excuses for thier own and excuse unexceptable behavior just like they did with OJ and like they did with Michael Vick.  As long as one of their own gets in that is all they care about.  If only whites were allowed to say what they really feel, the blacks would be surprised how sick most whites are of playing the politically correct racial game of kissing thier rear ends.
Wow....so many mysogynists and homophobes spouting off here against Hillary!  

Pretty insecure bunch for sure....read a book....learn to read!  Do something that will improve your minds, PLEASE!
The first display of a bad leader, and a bad administration,,,oh then their's Big Bill, bet he can't wait to get his hands on new blood in the White House. Can't wait to see it...

Bill and his all female staff...25 and under...
I know she will not bow out, however she may be building up more steam of negativity. I can only pray Obama's campaign is ready for the release! She is a dirty politician and a sore loser... both together are a dangerous pair.
All you Obama hypsters--especially the biased knuckle heads at MSNBC--will be singing a different tune if Obama is the nominee. He will be vaporized by the Republican spin machine because he has potential but no experience. "Yes we can"--ever notice he doesn't tell you WHAT that means...?

There's a reason why MSNBC consistently under-represents the Clinton lead in delegates: It doens't support their narrative of Obama as the now "inevitable" nominee.

Chuck and the gang: Recuse yourselves of the Obama bias or admit that you are the leftist version of Fox. You're pathetic.
Obama is the bobble-head cheerleader; Hillary is the real player that will get the job done.
Hmmmm...didn't Mr. McCain shake up his staff??? That was quite the failure, eh? Go Hillary!!!!!
if she can't take care of her money. what do you think she would do with your money?  
On more than one occasion the media has sent Obamas message stating “I have no doubt that I can get the people who vote for Senator Clinton, .. It’s not clear that Senator Clinton can get all the people I’m getting.  In other words, if Clinton loses, the majority of her supporters will vote for me but if I lose, my supporters will not vote for her. This is such a telling comment from the great "uniter."  With so much in common, as Democrats, other than Senators Clintons experience and willing to stand up to protect our nation, I can hardly tell the difference between the two.  So this statement seems racist or sexist and definitely wrong.  Possibly even arrogant.  He says he is for unity.  Is it only if it is Obamas Unity?   I have spoken to many of people who voted for Obama who say they will definitely choose Hillary when she is the nominee.  Those people were on the fence for Obama and Hillary.  Some voted for Obama, because they didn’t know who to vote for and found themselves being guided by the media or their school buddies.   (A media that is slanted for Obama, a media that guides people with statements like the one Obama is using above.)  When these people are asked about Obama’s plan or views, many didn’t know or their information was inaccurate.  Some of them never found an answer.  Many people (men and women, many races) I talked to, easily changed to support Hillary.  

There are whole bunch of other people out there.  A LOT that I have spoken to, MANY who say “if Senator Clinton is not the Democratic choice then they will choose the Republican candidate”.  They refer to National Security and feeling safe with knowing more about the candidate.  Senator Clinton is not shy about protecting America, and she sends a positive message to the world as well as a protective message.

It is bewildering that the media just doesn’t seem to present this information.  I thought maybe the media hasn’t heard.  That’s why I’m writing.  To share with the media, that there are many people that support either Senator Clinton first or McCain second.  This is not American Idol or Hollywood, this is the REAL world, this is America’s next President. In a very volatile time.  These people feel that the next President has to have a plan, and needs to be able to stand with strength to protect and serve our Nation.  I hope the media will share the information that there are many people who are on the fence, and the fence has Hillary as a first choice and McCain as a second choice.  Both are very different, but many people feel both are a safer choice because they know what the person’s real agenda is.  This may not be what the media wants to hear or share but it is real.  If it’s not Hillary as the nominee, there go many Democratic votes for Republican.  Maybe that’s what they want.    
AMERICA wake up.. all this stuff is silly...

The best to run the white house in the democratic side is Hillary.. As Cher said recently have we forgotten CARTER....

It's sad to say history may repeat itself where we have the first black american make a mpckery of the democratic party followed by 12 years of republicans in the white house.
Interesting to see the hate between rival Democratic factions. Hmm, could all this dissention be a vast right-wing conspiracy? I bet that evilJohn McCain is behind it all!! Face it people, all these people running on both sides of the fence are the same- they are tools of powers greater than they can know. Can you say multinational corporations?
Hillary cannot remake herself into a silk purse from being a sow's ear.

Hillary throws one more out of the life raft.


Did she step aside, or run away?
I am glad to see the end of Ms. Doyle.  I wish we could see the end of Mr. Penn, too.

-----------

And we're all looking forward to the end of Ms. Hillary Rodham Clinton.
Patti is a good person, she did not deserve this, she gave her life to Hillary put he family and everything on hold and this is the thanks she gets.   Hillary re-think what you are doing, it was Bill that did this to you not Patti.
You would think that after all the campaign experience she (they) have, they could better manage those who manage her campaign...and she wants to be President based on "experience"?
I am so sick of this absolute b.s. I read.  Obama supporters are not an all boys club.  My daughter and I both support Obama.  My mother supporter clinton in the Nevada caucus but has since found some things out that made her regret her decison.  That is three generations of female democrats that are now all behind Obama.  how dare any other woman try to speak for me.  I support Obama because he is the best person for the job.  As far as this person resining to me its another sign that there are problems in the clinton campaign.  I also am sick of the hypocracy.  how many posts on internet sites have I read where clinton supporters say rude things about Obama and his supporters.  One case in point just from this series of posts is calling Obama supporters sheep.  I am not a sheep.  I have a mind of my own and will stand up for myself and my candidate of choice.  Overall many clinton supporters and in some ways the clintons themselves have bee the most polarizing force in this election.  Lastly it doesn't look good when a candidate chooses to use the rhetoric of the other campaign such as yes we can.  It only makes her look desperate.  She can't come up with good campaign slogans on her own.  Give me a break.  
Hey Natalie

I think you are repeating what Bill said to Monica. Cant wait till the PA Primary.
GO OBAMAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
Hmmm.  Best girl friend managing campaign, mixing business with friendship, replaced by new long-time girlfriend.  Will we have an all-girl cabinet too? I am for a woman in office, but one who is mature enough to know you don't mix friendship with business.  Obama is a better choice in 2008.  Go Obama!  
Got the Latino early vote to win California, but now that she can't run from Obama's campaign I guess she decided NOW (instead of after Iowa) is a good time to get rid of her Latino campaign manager. I guess she must have a different strategy now for Texas that doesn't involve Latino voters. Now I go vote for Obama.
Hillary the two faced thug is desperate...but now will be more dangerous.  The Clintons will do or say anything to win.  Frankly I hope she gets the Dem's nomination so McCain destroys her in November.  I'm afraid Osama could beat McCain.......Go Hillary!!
Natalie,how does one determine which of the 37 personalities of "Sybil" Hillary Clinton one dislikes the most?
This is just another sign that she is just like Bill.  I will vote for anyone NOT associated with a Clinton and I am a female babyboomer.  She doesn't have all of our votes.
MSNBC is the most Biased gossip channel there is. They not only play favorites but then they don't even report the story as it really is. They should all go down like Dave Shuster.
We don't need that ape Obama leading the party. It is as simple as that. He has no experience and will get zzero done. Better to go with a proven, experienced leader like Hillary than a showboat like Obama. His wife is a first class bitch who will be so out-of-place in the White House. Contrast her with Bill who has already been there longer than anyone alive today.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=653470

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google