ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Clinton camp overhaul

Posted: Monday, February 11, 2008 9:20 AM by Domenico Montanaro

Yesterday afternoon, the Clinton campaign announced that manager Patti Solis Doyle is stepping down and former Hillary Clinton chief of staff Maggie Williams has taken over the reins.

NBC’s Andrea Mitchell reports that, per the Clinton campaign, there was no good time to do this shakeup. But you can’t have two people trying to make the big decisions about advertising and budgeting for Texas and Ohio now "there is no margin of error.” According to the campaign, they have to win those states and Pennsylvania to keep their hopes alive.

The Washington Post: "The change at the top of the Clinton campaign has been talked about since last month's Iowa caucuses, in which the senator from New York placed third and immediately lost her front-runner status. Still, it came as a surprise to even some senior advisers." Why the change? It appears that this long campaign is getting to the campaign that's slowly falling behind. "One senior official, who spoke on the condition of anonymity to speak freely about the campaign's inner workings, said, ‘The dissatisfaction -- to the extent there has been -- has not been about money.’ Asked what the source of dissatisfaction was, this adviser replied, ‘There is a sense that this is a fatiguing campaign and some new energy primarily was useful.’”

The paper also hints at tension between Williams and Solis Doyle. Williams had come in temporarily after New Hampshire to help out. “By one account, Williams decided early last week to return to her consulting firm, her temporary assignment over. By another, she announced that she was leaving to send a signal to Clinton that the dual management structure was untenable."

The New York Times: "The replacement of Ms. Doyle was in part a signal to donors and other supporters that the campaign was regrouping and was poised to right itself, even as Mrs. Clinton faces uncertain prospects Tuesday in contests in Virginia, Maryland and the District of Columbia."

More: "The campaign had braced for a shake-up ever since Mrs. Clinton lost Iowa, but it was delayed because she unexpectedly won New Hampshire. At that point, Ms. Williams, a longtime friend of Mrs. Clinton’s, had been worked into the organization along with Ms. Doyle, and over time ‘it just became untenable for both of them to be essentially sharing the same job,’ as one campaign ally put it.”

The Los Angeles Times: "An overhaul of Clinton's senior staff had been rumored for months as her national lead shrank and she struggled to keep pace with Obama's prodigious fundraising." More: "Power in the Clinton camp is divided among a handful of top aides: Terry McAuliffe and Jonathan Mantz head fundraising; Mandy Grunwald handles campaign advertising; Howard Wolfson runs communications; Mark Penn is responsible for polling and strategy; and Harold Ickes oversees political matters. Bill Clinton acts as chief surrogate with the standing to weigh in whenever he chooses. As campaign manager, Patti Solis Doyle was atop the pyramid, responsible for directing the staff, making final decisions on budgets and hiring, and consulting with the candidate. In ‘Hillaryland’ -- the nickname for Clinton's staff that dates to her White House years -- Solis Doyle, 42, could boast of a rapport with the candidate that few matched. The two teamed up in 1991 when Bill Clinton first ran for president. She later became Hillary Clinton's scheduler in the White House."

The New York Daily News: “The overhaul signaled growing anxiety inside Camp Clinton. … Clinton's campaign has sunk into a post-Super Tuesday funk, with little to crow about except a spike in fund-raising.” More: A “source and others have complained for weeks that Solis Doyle hasn't been able to corral the towering egos of Hillary's chief consultants, notably pollster Mark Penn and consultant Howard Wolfson. On the staff level, the knives have been out for Solis Doyle since Obama won Iowa Jan. 3 and shattered the campaign's sense of inevitability, the source added.”

Get to know Maggie Williams. "Among Billaryland's inner circle, Maggie Williams is renowned as the ultimate Hillary loyalist, fierce and unwavering in her devotion for nearly 25 years."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Changing horses in the middle of the stream is always a good idea. What could go wrong?

Hillary fans should get a kick out of this young, idealistic Obama supporter trying to defend his candidate’s policy positions when confronted on the street by a hostile interviewer.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kica8hmSdAM
Hillary is clearly the best choice to be The Democratic nominee, and thusly President of The United States.
Obama is an extremeist, non-patriot, fast-talking used car salesman who'll embarrass our party against McCain in tha fall.
I hope it's not going to take another beating in another general election for The Democratic Party to wake up and understand that "mainstreamers" count.

HILLARY FOR PRESIDENT 2008!
This is ready to lead on Day 1?  She can't even get through a primary in which she was supposedly the "inevitable candidate" without axing her right-hand woman?
reshuffle of the deck chairs on the titanic...clinton is toast and she knows it...time for a graceful exit and put the looming democratic defeat this fall on obamamania...there's always '12 against president huckabee
On ABC's This Week MD Governor O'Malley demonstrated that he passed his course in Clintonspeak; he barely avoided any opportunity to say anything truthful. However, he let this little revelation slip out: "Senator Clinton is doing the very best she can." That's some triumphant endorsement and a sober dose of truth.
Yikes!  Beware of the Junior Leaguers Gone Wild!
Shall we say the end of an era!!! This is the end of Clinton's machine
Shaking up the staff won't help. Voters are suffering "Hillary burn-out". People like to be talked "to", not "at".
DOES THE PRESS HAVE AMNESIA? I just watched all morning TV talk and scanned net blogs about the Clinton campaign shake-up and noone is bringing up the  notion that Maggie Williams is the Rosemary Woods of the Clinton Aministration. Could someone please recall that documents relating to the Whitewater investigation lent to the Hillary's office in the East Wing by the DOJ went missing. In the ensuing investigation a Secret Service agent testified that he saw Williams leaving with them on the weekend in question. Later, she, while breaking down sobbing, denied in front of a Senate Committee that she had anything to do with the papers dissapperance?  C'mon guys, wake up! Don't you think it's legitimate to remind viewers and bloggers this is the same old crowd of hacks and loyalists and the same old stuff we lived thrrough in the 90s?
Excuses, excuses, excuses! Bill says Caucuses benefit Barack because working people can't attend them (Newsflash, working people can't attend a primary either), Other's say Barack is Winning because of AA votes, Hillary No doubt stayed with Solis Doyle to get the Latino vote in California.Here we are 2 months into the voting process & Hillary's still NOT ready as she claims to be.
Here's an excuse for the Clinton campaign to ponder, America is Sick & Tired of Dynasty's, that's why you're Losing & that's why you're gonna continue to lose.America is sick & tired of Politics as usual( nothing getting done)
We the People are gonna take back Our Government from the entrenched lobbyist, who care Nothing for US.
We don't care about your TEARS, Hillary ( buy stock in KLeenex), We don't care that Bill want's to be back in the Whitehouse again to try & make thing's right.
IT'S OUR WHITHOUSE & WE DON'T WANT EITHER OF YOU BACK IN IT!  GOT THAT!

Barack Obama for President!!!!
The Clinton's don't like to lose. Get ready for the slime to flow and the political earth to be scorched.
This will be more than a drill for Novemeber for Obama. "That which does not kill us makes us stronger"

Yes We most certainly Can!
ok, even the HRC hard core supporters has to admit that changing your staff in the middle of a tight race is a bone head move. they report she step down but we all know she was asked to leave. makeing a major staff change this close to the texas primeary, a state you need to win, is just poor judgement.
You guys don't see this, or you are not allow to say it on national television. She replaced Mrs. Doyle with a black lady.
From now until Auust, Hillary would try to gain some African-American votes.
It has to be hard for them. They never prepared to lose. They thought Obam would be out of the race after Super Tuesday - and that did not happen. That's why they are short on Money and wins!

She may win Virginia - but 1 in 7 is sort of pathetic if you are suppose to be the presumptive nominee? How many times can you kep comingfrom behind without dammage to that front runner image?

And what if they don't win Texas and Ohio automatically? I think this has to be troubling for them.
NBC’s Andrea Mitchell reports that, per the Clinton campaign, there was no good time to do this shakeup. But you can’t have two people trying to make the big decisions about advertising and budgeting for Texas and Ohio now "there is no margin of error.” According to the campaign, they have to win those states and Pennsylvania to keep their hopes alive.

What has that got to do with anything????
The Clinton's had better hope they got rid of the right girl....

"The replacement of Ms. Doyle was in part a signal to donors and other supporters that the campaign was regrouping and was poised to right itself, even as Mrs. Clinton faces uncertain prospects Tuesday in contests in Virginia, Maryland and the District of Columbia."

So, in order to get their house in order, they have to get rid of one person....
She must be one POWERFUL person if they had to get rid of her LOL.....
Patty needs to go over to the winning team; Obama's.

"An overhaul of Clinton's senior staff had been rumored for months as her national lead shrank and she struggled to keep pace with Obama's prodigious fundraising."

Oh Yeah Clinton's, I almost forgot....
We only have 5 or 6 chinese eateries here in Corpus Christi....
So the chances of you picking up any money for our Chinese dishwashers is pretty slim...

What are they going to do next in terms of fundraising; send letters out to people promising them an I.R.S. audit if they don't kick in?????

A “source and others have complained for weeks that Solis Doyle hasn't been able to corral the towering egos of Hillary's chief consultants, notably pollster Mark Penn and consultant Howard Wolfson.

While you are in town Clinton's
Stop by the King Ranch shop....
I'm sure they have the right size bullwhip you two will need to control the towering ego's of your staff.

Among Billaryland's inner circle, Maggie Williams is renowned as the ultimate Hillary loyalist, fierce and unwavering in her devotion for nearly 25 years."

LOL!!!!!
Isn't that what got patty fired?????
God riddance, Patty.  If you ever again run a national campaign, you might want to take care in your attitude toward, and treatment of, campaign volunteers.  "Please" and "thank you" go a LONG way.  Every vote counts.  
" ...send a signal to Clinton that the dual management structure was untenable."
--To be honest, I do not doubt that if politically expedient, Hillary Clinton could reign Bill Clinton in.  She would be in charge as I see it.


"Bill Clinton acts as chief surrogate with the standing to weigh in whenever he chooses."
--On the other hand, having a prominent member of her possible future administration, Bill Clinton, roaming about with nothing to do ...  Honestly, he is going to be a figure and will be guiding policy, but as somebody without an official role, he will not be subject to the checks and balances--and that is concerning.  The lack of oversight of this Bush administration is one of its greatest failures in my opinion.
Clinton's have nothing new, its all of the same Washington self serving paper hanging masked double talk! Change is not to mask, but a over haul of wrong! Point being, Clinton's yuk it up like they have all the answers. Far be that from reality, their self serving hidden agenda is just that!

Nothing to address the real issues, only to sweep those hard to solve problems under a rug, or paint a new face on them. America can not continue present path and the Clinton's are a major problem!

changing, only more of the double talk. They have shown irresponsible control during this run, they were irresponsible while in the White House and brought more shame and dishonor, immoral conduct, lies,constant scandal, now this is their track record!! So  to expect WHAT?

Conduct unbecoming of a President!

Both Liar's!

Both coat tail hangers!

America does not need this curse upon it again!
Sounds like another ploy for public pity to me. If it is true, how dare she claim to be more experienced. They are not organized.
Maggie Williams would need some time to get settled into running Hillary campaign.  This does not bode well for her performance in states where primaries are to be held.
Yeah right, J. Merle, mainstreaner's are  2 outta 7 in the previous cycles, not a gr8 performance.Maybe You so-called mainstreamer's need to get out a little more& actually see what;s going on the Real America.

Mainstreamer's don't Win without lotsa Help.

You call Barack a Non Patriot. That's what the GOP called ANYONE who did'nt support this debacle in IRAQ. Showing your True color's are ya J. Merle?

MAINSTREAMER, MY ASS. SORE LOSER IS MORE LIKE IT!
Wonder why she waited till AFTER Super Tuesday to switch campaign managers? To coin a popular phrase.."its the Latino vote stupid!" Despite the fact Patti was mishandling funds HRC needed to ensure that LATINA vote for Super Tuesday. Now that CA, AZ, and NM are behind her, she can put her on the back burner and bring back Maggie Williams in hopes of getting back some of the black vote that helped take BILL to victory which she has bled like a sieve since SC.

AA know this because they used to be the Clinton's pocket vote. Now the Latinos get their turn to get played. Viva Hillary? As for Texas, HRC is hopeful the Latinos are sufficiently fooled to keep their vote.  If not, she'll rely on the under 50K of non-hispanics.  Aint politics grand?
J. Merle Stanley-
You should leave yourself room to adjust.
You could be wrong.
Don't underestimate or undervalue the power of a "movement candidate" or more importantly a movement.
This is not about Obama anymore, it is about the movement of many people of varied beliefs in a single direction.
You can quible with the minute policy differences between Senator Clinton and Senator Obama but at the end of the day, the leader who can inspire best leads best.
No more name calling. You are a good person who believes strongly in his candidate. That is a virtue, but at the end of the day, if Obama is the nominee I hope you can support him. You are needed.

Whose payrole is Bill on?  Where did Hillary get the 5 million?  Where are the tax returns?  Nuff said..Obama for president.
Another example of typical Clinton triangulation.  They are in trouble with the black vote and are doing very very well with the Latino vote.  Therefore, lets get rid of the top Latino running the campaign, blame the trouble of the campaign on her ineffective management and appoint a black woman to take her place.  Brilliant!!  Bring the 90's back!
Hillary, Rove, Bush, Cheney,

It's over!

Barack '08!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
HILLARY CLAIMED TO BE A HANDS ON PERSON.SHE STATED YOU HAVE TO BE HANDS ON WITH EVERY LITTLE THING THAT COMES ACROSS YOUR DESK.I DONT THINK SHE CAN NOW GET AWAY WITH NOT BEING AWARE OF THE THINGS HER STAFF,HER HUSBAND,FRIENDS AND WHERE THE MONEY WAS GOING WHILE SHE WAS NOT LOOKING!
Sounds like another ploy for public pity to me. If it is true, how dare she claim to be more experienced. They are not organized.
loris bay (Sent Monday, February 11, 2008 11:16 AM)

Agreed!! If you have "35 years experience" and you are "ready on day 1" - why are you changing campaign managers and running out of money?? If you are someone who looks to how someone runs their campaign....I have a hard time believing she is ready to run the country. If the Campaign was not planned well how does that bode for all these programs she wants to get going? Not well I'd say.....
[[The Clinton's had better hope they got rid of the right girl....]]


They didn't. Hillary is still there.
"Obama is an extremeist, non-patriot, fast-talking used car salesman who'll embarrass our party against McCain in tha fall".

WOW! And the Clintons didn't embarrass the party????
Where were you living those 8 years?
Hillary CAN NOT beat John Mccain! The GOP has way too much ammunition ready and waitng for Hillary!
If Hillary gets the nomination,John Mccain will be the next President Of these United States!
"You guys don't see this, or you are not allow to say it on national television. She replaced Mrs. Doyle with a black lady.
From now until Auust, Hillary would try to gain some African-American votes".

LOL! Yep! Patti helped her with the Latino votes in California....
I think it'ssafe to say the Clintos can "kiss" the majority of black voters good-bye! LOL!LOL!
"Another example of typical Clinton triangulation.  They are in trouble with the black vote and are doing very very well with the Latino vote.  Therefore, lets get rid of the top Latino running the campaign, blame the trouble of the campaign on her ineffective management and appoint a black woman to take her place.  Brilliant!!  Bring the 90's back"!

LOL!LOL! If Bill couldn't get her the Black vore....Maggie sure doesn't stand a chance. LOL!LOL!
Ok, McCain fired most of his staff last summer - mostly because he couldn't pay any of them.  He's now the nominee.
John Kerry had the same problems, including staff shakeup and lending money to the campaign.  He also won the nomination, if not the election.

Re Primaries v. Caucuses, [See above:  Excuses, excuses, excuses! Bill says Caucuses benefit Barack because working people can't attend them (Newsflash, working people can't attend a primary either),]
Every state I know of has polls open (and many, many, more polling places than caucus places) from 6am to 8 or 9pm.  I don't know about you, but I don't have too many working friends who routinely put in 15hr days.
It is refreshing to see that many informed Americans are willing to express themselves and say they are tired of the same old politics. American people are trying to take back there country and their voice by voting for change and for policy. As we have heard the Republicans refer to being the President as running a corporation, Than apparently Mr. Obama has demonstrated that he can organize as well as lead individuals to a common cause. Now lets take a look at how Mr.Romney invested Millions and got nothing out of it but knew when to cut his loses (Not a bad business decision but flip flopping doesn't bold well as a leader). Mrs. Clinton making a change within her organization after assuming she would do well without actually listening to her subordinates (Typical managerial skills when profit is the main focus but not showing appreciation. Main reason why coporate america is failing). J Merle Stanley your comment is typical of those who are too narrow minded to notice when something is broken and need to be fixed but again when you are part of the establishment change isn't something you would want it cuts into your beliefs that certain people need to stay in their place. I will give you credit for one thing your blatant comment to refer to Mr. Obama as a non-patriot and used car salesman shows you are the typical listen and believe what you are told *basically a follower & not a leader). For AntiRestorationDemocrat you are absolutely correct that the media has a responsibility to inform people about the roles individuals played during the Clinton era which was full of scandal but telling the truth is hard when they are in bed with the Clinton's. We have to be the voices and remind people what this country was founded on and who pay their SALARIES!!!

Reagan+Bush+Clinton+Bush=Bankruptcy & Corruption
Ditto, Loris Bay.  So much for experience, huh

LOL!    
J Merle:

This is going to be interesting with your girl coming to my fair city on Wednesday......

i have not seen ONE Hillary or Bill sign in this town yet....

I have not seen ONE Hillary or Bill bumper sticker around town (except for the "Vote for Monica's ex boyfriend's wife for president" Sticker).....

I have not heard or seen anything in this twon as it concerns The Clinton's....

Obama on the other hand.....

There are signs in people's yards...
Bumper stickers on cars....
even had a couple of folks stop by to talk to me about why I would vote for a republican...
Took care of their Hillary talk in record time....
All I had to say was Marcellio Celis....Nuff said...
J Merle:

Obama is one lonely black man.....
The Clinton's are a tag team combination......

Nuff said....

When your girl talks, she does it in High School gyms
Obama is speaking at arenas seating 20,000 and filling them.

Game, set, and match to Obama....

If your girl is so popular......
Why doesn't she rent madison Square garden for a few hours and see if she can bring in 20,000 folks....
As usual, the Billary's can't get out of their own way.  

Mr. Shear, well said.
so what about the stories about Obama in 1989, in the back of a car with a gay male and smoking crack AND receiving a BJ. Come on! Bill and Hillary went through the meatgrinder every single day and are still going through it. Just wait til the repubs get ahold of THAT story..and I'm sure there are others too. Mr Perfect is a huge fraud!
Hillary, you need an u-haul truck to overhaul your campaign. A campaign that constantly udnergoes change is one in which a candidates is going to become an indecisive, stubborn one whomismanages the exective branch.
If you are still not convinced about Obama, I urge you to read the excellent article in the December issue of Atlantic Monthly entitled "Goodbye To All That: Why Obama Matters" (can be found on line).  You will find there solid answers to the question Why Obama?, some you may not have thought of.
Obama stands on the stump and acts like he is selling tonic to rid the world of the common cold. Maybe even throwing in a good rain dance. I can't believe so many people are falling for such a scam. He has no ideal what it will take to run this country. You were dumb enough to put Bush in office, will you repeat? Vote for Hillary and get us out of your last mistake.

Hillary fans should get a kick out of this young, idealistic Obama supporter trying to defend his candidate’s policy positions when confronted on the street by a hostile interviewer.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kica8hmSdAM

jaycee, Ventura, California (Sent Monday, February 11, 2008 9:27 AM)

Jaycee - Thanks for that link!  It just goes to show you that all black people don't support Obama because of his skin color.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=654856

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google