ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



On the trail with Chelsea Clinton

Posted: Thursday, February 14, 2008 12:15 PM by Domenico Montanaro

From NBC/NJ's Mike Memoli
DAYTON, Ohio -- Don't be mistaken: Chelsea Clinton hopes her mother returns to the White House. She just thinks she's too old to live with her parents again.

"Sometimes people ask me if I want to move back to my old room," Chelsea playfully told an audience at Sinclair Community College in Dayton yesterday. "One, I don't see past March 4th. I don't take anything for granted. … And two, I'm 27. I love my parents a lot. But I don't want to move back in with them."

Chelsea had been asked about the challenges of once again being involved in the presidential campaign of one of her parents. Earlier, she had mentioned that she did have a private life working and living in New York. "At least did until about five weeks ago," she said. "Yet I do believe this is the most important election of my lifetime. And I believe so strongly in my mom. Not only is there anyone that I love and respect more, but I've seen her work on these issues my whole life, and that's why I'm here."

Rarely, if ever, does she mention Obama's name, instead focusing almost exclusively on her mother's record. Countless times, she has begun a sentence with, "I'm so proud that my mom …," before wonkishly detailing something her mother has done as senator, First Lady or in private life. When any of her comments have been met with a hint of applause, she would stop and prod the crowd: "Yeah, you can applaud for that."

At several points, however, she did slyly dig at Obama on an area of policy disagreement. Discussing health care in Delaware, she said she was proud her mother stood up for universal health care before it was en vogue, adding that, without promising fully universal care at the outset, it would be unlikely that Republicans would allow any worthwhile plan. And in Dayton, when asked about the current administration's "cowboy" diplomacy, Chelsea said her mother would offer a more cooperative approach. "She doesn't support the president dropping into Tehran on January 21, 2009," she added, hinting at a dispute between Clinton and Obama last summer over whether the president should personally engage adversaries in their first year.

Though she was addressing mainly college-age Ohioans all day, most of her answers stuck to the same message one would hear listening to her mother or father. She offered few introductory remarks at each stop, immediately taking questions from the crowd. (By the end of the day, she had taken nearly 50.)

Only occasionally did she put things in personal terms, as she did while discussing health care at Ohio State University. A male student talked about his girlfriend, who had a bone disease, and asked about Hillary's health care proposal. Chelsea talked about the merits of offering a range of health care options instead of just one single-payer system. "What your girlfriend needs is different than what I may need, is different than what I would need when I make my mother happy and give her grandchildren, is different than what my grandmother needs," she said.

What she did repeatedly ask voters to do was to consider the candidates by considering the issues that matter most to them. "I do believe that if people really think about the issues, whatever those issues are, … that people will realize that my mom is the stronger candidate," she said in Dayton. Asked at Ohio Wesleyan University about the chance of going from Bush to Clinton to Bush to Clinton again, Chelsea said voters should consider her on her own merits. "I would hope that you would vote for my mom because of my mom and not because of my dad," she said. "I also hope you don't vote against my mom because of my dad."

Chelsea shows her love for the Buckeye State again today, Valentine's Day, with two more schedule stops. Her schedule then tentatively calls for a weekend trip to the Aloha State, ahead of Hawaii's Feb. 19 primary.

See, campaign life does offer the occasional perk.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Chelsea pulls down a solid six figures at the hedge fund where she works, but she knows the big money is in politics and in the Clinton family "business". Smart girl that Chelsea.
Chelsea for President!

It must be expensive to the Clinton campaign to have to give the 5 star treatment to Hillary, Bill, and Chelsea. That's why Hillary needs her supporters to send in their money right away, even if they have to step down from bologna to mac and cheese.
Cheslea was in the White House with Hillary and Bill, we should assume she's just as qualified as Hillary to be president... until all those white house papers are released by Bill at least... what?  Maybe 10 years from now?  Maybe more, he might be shreading them for all we know.

No, actually, I feel bad for Cheslea, she's being used as a pawn by her parents, who are threatening to lash any press officials that question her newfound role of "Hillary Replacement" on the stump.

What are Hillary's "solutions" again?  I don't think I've seen any headlines detailing them yet...
The media is relentless. For weeks, months, everyone was like where is chelsea, why doesnt she speak? So now we know why, she obviously isnt comfortable speaking publically, and is not very articulate. So now what do you do, MAKE FUN OF THE GIRL. New lows daily.

Also, the perk you refer to is for you guys, who get to go to Hawaii and make some more fun of Chelsea.
ASK YOUR SELF THIS QUESTION. WHY HAS SENATOR OBAMA REFUSED TO ATTEND A "PLANNED DEBATE" WITH SENATOR CLINTON IN WISCONSIN ?  DO YOU THINK IT MAY BE TIME SOMEONE PRESSED HIM TO LAY OUT THE "DETAILS" OF HIS PLANS? OR JUST LET HIM GIVE SOME "FANCY SPEECH" OR PHOTO OPS ?
Hillary's Health Care Plan will encourage companies to drop Health Benefits forcing you to buy second rate HMO insurance.

Her policy was written by the Insurane Lobbyists and would only serve to tighten their grip on the American Public.

Fact is, Hillary's campaign is paid for by lobbyists. She takes the second most money from Washington Lobbyists, second only to George W Bush.

If you ever want this country to change, you have to start right now by not rewarding her corrupt behaviour with your vote.

Republicans in Texas, we need your help, help us remove the Clinton Cancer from American politics ONCE AND FOR ALL.
Alert: R.I.'s Chafee backs Obama

Former Republican U.S. Sen. Lincoln Chafee today endorsed Democrat Barack Obama for president, citing the Illinois senator’s longstanding opposition to the war in Iraq.

Chafee, who lost a run for reelection in 2006, was the only Republican in the Senate to vote against giving President Bush the authority to attack Iraq. Chafee left the Republican Party last year and changed his registration to unaffiliated.

Chafee hinted several days ago that he was considering a vote for Obama. In his upcoming book, Chafee criticizes Democrats who supported the resolution to authorize the war, saying a vote for the war should be a career-ending lapse of judgment. In backing Obama, the former senator said the nation cannot afford another presidential election with two candidates who supported the war.
DEBATE SENATOR CLINTON,IN WISCONSIN SENATOR OBAMA,AS PROMISED !
Nice young woman, but I'm for Obama!
I still can't stop laughing over "pimped out" comment, say what you will that was pretty funny!! I didn't think he deserved to be suspended, women on THE VIEW, say things all the time, it is not like he called her a name or something, what ever happened to "FREEDOM OF SPEECH"
No need to worry about that room Chelsea, it's being Reserved for 2 little girl's who are'nt being Used by their Parent's for Political gain.
You can still visit with dad in harlem or mom in georgetown.


Barack Obama for President!!!!!!!!!!
I CAN'T BELIEVE MY EYES. MSNBC FINALLY WROTE A NICE ARTICLE ABOUT A CLINTON. I THINK I'LL GO LIE DOWN A PUT A COOL CLOTH ON MY HEAD. On a serious note, I think it says a lot about a person's character the relationship she has with her daughter and what an (apparently) fine young woman she has turned into. That didn't happen by chance. Someone was a positive influence in this young woman's life.
Since Hillary has stated that she is a mother first and politician second, does that mean if elected and Chelsea is kidnapped by terrorists or whatever she will turn over the country to the kidnapper's?????  As hard as it may be I would rather have someone who puts the country ahead of all else!!!
Whether you like the Clintons or not, whether you are a Dem or Repub, we all should be proud to have a youngster like Chelsea Clinton - she is a class act and I am almost her mother's age.

It's a stretch to ask voters to consider Hillary as president absent of her Bill Clinton's time in office.  How is that possible when half of the 35 years which Hillary harps as "experience" is based moreso on her husbands governership and presidency?

I just don't see the separation.
Look at MSNBC trying to get Chelsea slam Obama. Shameless. You are the worst for sure.

This is a young lady with grace and dignaty. More than you could ever have.
Chelsea is a charming woman. It's comendable she's working on her parent's behalf so much.
Hey Chelsea, where are the bills to help generate the 200,000 jobs your mommy promised to upstate NY to help our failing economy? Oh yeah, the GOP has halted her at every turn. Of course its easy to halt actions that are never taken.

Yeah, you can applaud that.
Chelsea is undoubtedly a good person but what experience does she have with real American’s and their problems?  She lived in the Governor’s mansion in Arkansas and the White House in Washington DC and went to one of the most elite schools in the Country in Stanford.  She has probably had some sort of security protection her entire life and we know her parents have gone to great measure to protect her privacy at all costs (as all good parents would do).  I suspect Obama’s 5 year old has more real life experience than Chelsea, certainly his 9 year old.
I think Chelsea wil be a great politician someday!!! She is doing an amazing job supporting her mom. Maybe she should be the first woman president. But for now....... Obama in  08!!!
As david Shuster says PIMPIN OUT THEIR DAUGHTER,SCOUNDRELS
Chelsea Clinton is so refreshing – a poised, smart and gracious young woman that every American should be proud of – especially after the troubled Bush and Reagan offspring.  

The GOP loves to talk about family values – but Bill and Hillary Clinton have demonstrated their family values by raising such a wonderfully well-adjusted daughter.  Kudos to the Clintons.

Don't Let them 'pimp you out', Chelsea !!
To:  Alan in NJ,

I have taken the liberty of reposting your comments from 9:57 AM today because you are spot on.  I have posted several comments over the last several days regarding the exact same issue, Obama’s Health PLAN.  Like you, I have taken exact quotes from Obama’s website, and have taken exact quotes from the transcript from the CNN debate on January 31, in California that Mr. Obama has made in reference to his Health PLAN.

All of the Obama supporters are good at making comments about what the Clinton’s or anyone else they take the liberty of mentioning has done wrong or that they don’t agree with.  Obama’s supporter are quick to tell everyone that his plan does have substance and they go as far as to TELL everyone to go to his website and see for yourself.

Like you, I too went to his website.  Not only did his website provide the source of my information, but it also allowed for the discovery of the enourmous holes in not only his Health PLAN, but many others. As a result I will continue to post the comments that I have assembled that take exact quotes from Mr. Obama’s website and other verifable sorces that refute and call into question the validity of his claims since knowone else seems to want to discuss these very important topics that Mr. Obama is misleading his followers and attempting to mislead the rest of our country about.

Finally, just as with my posted comments, for all of Mr. Obama’s followers ability to make hate filled brash comments, they have yet to refute the comments posted by you or I, instead they just move on by and continue to make more useless comments that show them for the people that they are.

Here is the comment from Alan in NJ as posted earlier today.

Jaycee, here are the specifics of the plan that has so many holes in it.  This is from the BO website.  

This is why I think there shoulbe a debate (or even a speech to answer these points)

Obama will make available a new national health plan to all Americans, including the self-employed and small businesses, to buy affordable health coverage that is similar to the plan available to members of Congress.  

Is this a goverment program?  If so will this not encorage businesses to drop health insurance as now the goverment is offering a subsidized program?

Employer Contribution: Employers that do not offer or make a meaningful contribution to the cost of quality health coverage for their employees will be required to contribute a percentage of payroll toward the costs of the national plan. Small employers that meet
certain revenue thresholds will be exempt.  

No details?

Mandatory Coverage of Children: Obama will require that all children have health care coverage. Obama will expand the number of options for young adults to get coverage, including allowing young people up to age 25 to continue coverage through their parents'
plans.  

How will this mandate be enforced?


Subsidies. Individuals and families who do not qualify for Medicaid or SCHIP but still need financial assistance will receive an income-related federal subsidy to buy into the new public plan or purchase a private health care plan.  

At what income levels would this subsidy be available?  Would it be regional due to the higher cost of living in certain areas?  Would this subsidy cover employer based insurance?

Guaranteed eligibility. No American will be turned away from any insurance plan because of illness or pre-existing conditions.  

Would this mandate to insurance companaies not raise costs?  If so, how does this encourage an increase in competition that is also mentioned in your plan?

Simplified paperwork and reined in health costs.  

Has anybody in your campaign done a study of the effort required by consumers, providors and payors that support such a goal?  From my personal experience payers are all for electronic systems as it would reduce their costs but providors have no incentive to install such systems as the ROI cannot justify it for thousands of individual medical offices.  Do you plan to offer incentives or subsudies to providors?  

Tackle disparities in health care. Obama will tackle the root causes of health disparities by addressing differences in access to health coverage and promoting prevention and public health, both of which play a major role in addressing disparities. He will also challenge the medical system to eliminate inequities in health care through quality measurement and reporting, implementation of effective interventions such as patient navigation programs, and diversification of the health workforce.  
Require full transparency about quality and costs. Obama will require hospitals and providers to collect and publicly report measures of health care costs and quality, including data on preventable medical errors, nurse staffing ratios, hospital-acquired
infections, and disparities in care. Health plans will also be required to disclose the percentage of premiums that go to patient care as opposed to administrative costs.  

Two different points in the plan that will require collection and processing by providors to meet goverment reporting requirements.  Will these new requirements not add to costs?  How many nurses, nursing assistants etc. will be tied up with reporting requirements rather performing patient care?  Speak to any nurse and find out how much of their time is already taken up due state reporting requirements.  

These are just a few of the points from his healthcare program.  In my opinion it doesn't add up.  

Also, regarding the comment by BO that people who become ill and are only required to pay back premiums makes no sense. (This can be found on the CNN debate transcript)

1) How far back must they pay their premiums? (a month, a year, since the system starts?)
2) If they cannot pay are they refused treatment?
3) Why buy insurance at all?  It would make more sense to the individual to put the premiums in a savings account, and if you get ill there's no penalty.  If you don't get ill as BO puts it "you have gamed the system".

Point 3 is also the crucial one when talking about lowering costs.  How can you lower the costs of a premium based system when fewer people are paying?  The point about everybody being mandated into the system immediately increases the number of premiums and the cost of premiums to all go down.

BTW I personally believe that a single payer system with no insurance companies is the way to go.
Alan, NJ (Sent Thursday, February 14, 2008 9:57 AM)

We love you Chelsea. And it's obvious your parents did a wonderful job raising you. Your mother will make a fantastic president.
If someone referred to your daughter as prostitute, im sure you wouldnt like it either. Some of you disgust me.
And Alan that comment is idiotic
It´s fine if a child is supporting his mother.

BUT REMEMBER: Chelsea is currently employed at the hedge funds "Avenue Capital" at Wall Street with an estimated salary of serveral hundred thousand Dollar per year (for those who dont believe google "Chelsea Clinton Avenue"). Therefore Chelsea should also be considered as a true lobbyist.

And is it really a good idea to give hedge funds direct access to the President or does anyone expect more control of one of the worst form of companies in the free economy.
Why should Ohio get their votes counted, ours were not. (1.7 million Democratic votes cast.)
Maybe someone can explain to me how someone with no business background in college suddenly vaults in front of MBA graduates to land a plum job with a Hedge fund.  If she wants to help the country, lobby her parents to lobby for the full disclosure of her "fund's" activities.
HOW DO YOU THINK CHELSEA FEELS WHEN HER MOTHER JUST ANNOUNCED THAT IF RE ELECTED BILL WOULD NOT EMBARASS THE WHITEHOUSE AGAIN, IN ESSENCE THIS MEANS HE WONT MOLEST ANY INTERNS WITH CIGARS, OR WOMEN VISTORS.  WHAT A SICK BUNCH OF DEMOCRATS WOULD VOTE FOR SOME ONE WITH THIS CRITERIA  DISGUSTING I FEEL SORRY FOR CHELESEA  RIDE ON YOU PERVERTED DEMOCRATS
she's got more than her hands on that sluch fund...she was probably sitting under the desk with a cell phone cam for more than one of Bubba's close encounters!!!....way to go Chelsea,..you go girl
You people who slam Hillary as doing nothing but "lived at the white house while her husband was president", need to read what she has done to help people. She has gotten the laws changed on abusing children, helped the military men,  the laws on getting schools to make a way to teach disabled students, totally turned around the schools in Arkansa. Helped, supported  and stood by the black and latino communities.      What has Obama ever done except vote present in Illinois on the hard issues?  Get the facts people.
I am amazed at the meaness in this country. I can not believe the amount of men that hate women in this country. some of these comments are just plain nasty. Do you treat your wife's or mothers like this?
I have voted for a long time in my life and if obama and mccain are the nominees I will not vote in this year election.shame on you all for the nasty remarks and comments. i am glad I don't know any of you. If these are the kind of people obama attracts, he can have you all. why don't you read about obama get educated and maybe you might change your mind. Barack Huasian Obama??? for a american president...
Maybe someone can explain to me how someone with no business background in college suddenly vaults in front of MBA graduates to land a plum job with a Hedge fund. Shawn, Somerville, NJ

Shawn – Like most Clinton haters, you are woefully misinformed.  Chelsea was a named a National Merit Scholarship finalist in 1997 (meaning she outscored 96% of the nation on her SAT scores) graduated with honors from Stanford University and has a Masters Degree form Oxford.

Those sound like some heavy duty credentials to me –  what percentage of the nation did you outscore on your SATs?
You people who slam Hillary as doing nothing but "lived at the white house while her husband was president", need to read what she has done to help people. She has gotten the laws changed on abusing children, helped the military men,  the laws on getting schools to make a way to teach disabled students, totally turned around the schools in Arkansa. Helped, supported  and stood by the black and latino communities.      What has Obama ever done except vote present in Illinois on the hard issues?  Get the facts people.

John Doe (Sent Thursday, February 14, 2008 2:33 PM)


And where was your candidate when the Repubs in South Dakota tried to outlaw all abortion?  BO at least contributed money to fight it.  HRC was MIA.  All you supporters of women's rights explain that one!!!!
I am a woman and democrat. But I will not vote for BARAK HUSSEIN OBAMA. You guys are crazy. His father was raised a Muslim. Obama knows he cannot be elected if he even gives a whisper of his past.

Come on grow up. If he is nominated, I know he will not win. We will hand over the white house to the Repubs again. I agree I will not vote.
She is so hard on the eyes...
Adan, NYC;

Thank you.  You have provided the details of Mr. Obama's health plan that he is afraid to talk about in public.  Sadly, far too many of Mr. Obama's supporters haven't bothered to educate themselves regarding his positions.  Also, it is curious that he seems to be adopting more of John Edwards (and Hillary Clinton's) positions since his own lack depth.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=664818

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google