ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Hillary brings out the heavy gloves

Posted: Friday, February 15, 2008 4:02 PM by Domenico Montanaro

From NBC/NJ's Athena Jones
WARREN, Ohio -- Clinton has her boxing gloves on. The senator launched her campaign Thursday in this must-win state with a series of blistering attacks on Obama, who now leads her in the race for delegates, unlike any heard on the trail up until now.

She used several harsh, new turns of phrase to hammer home a point she began to make in the lead-up to the New Hampshire primary, arguing her opponent, known for his great oratory, is all talk and little action.

Those who wondered whether the New York senator would begin hitting her rival from Illinois hard to try to stop his momentum, seemed to get their answer here during a speech at a General Motors plant.

"Over the years you've heard plenty of promises from plenty of people in plenty of speeches and some of those speeches were probably pretty good, but speeches don't put food on the table. Speeches don't fill up your tank. Speeches don't fill your prescriptions or do anything about that stack of bills that keeps you up at night. That's the difference between me and my Democratic opponent: my opponent makes speeches. I offer solutions," she said to applause. "It is one thing to get people excited. I want to empower you. This is not about me. This is about you."

She said he promised to stand up to the special interests, but instead let the nuclear industry water down legislation he had proposed to regulate it, noting that the bill never passed -- a reference to Exelon, which has donated to Obama's political campaigns. She also hit him for voting for "Dick Cheney's energy bill."

She went on to knock Obama's healthcare plan for not covering everyone and said the union at a Maytag plant in Illinois that Obama often mentions supports her over him, because he failed to help save jobs there and said his economic policy speech yesterday showed he had copied many of her proposals, including goals for green-collar jobs and investment in infrastructure.

"Now if he would only copy my healthcare plan and provide coverage for every single American instead of standing in the way," she said. "There's a big difference between us: Speeches versus solutions, talk versus action. You know, some people may think words are change, but you and I know better. Words are cheap."

Clinton talked about being the co-founder and co-chair of the bipartisan Senate manufacturing caucus, saying she managed her life "not by applause or headlines, but by whether I'm helping people."
 
The speech was an appeal to the working-class voters that have been among the senator's strongest supporters. It followed a haphazard, poorly organized tour of GM's Lordstown plant and was billed as a "town hall" although she did not take questions after her remarks. Her camp said the event had been misnamed and that it had been intended to be just a speech.

A focus on Ohio
The senator was joined by Rep. Stephanie Tubbs Jones (D-OH) and Ohio Gov. Ted Strickland. "We are unique among all the states in our diversity,” Strickland said in his introduction. “North, South, East and West, Ohio has racial, ethical (sic), cultural, religious, economic diversity like no other state. We have great manufacturing plants, large cities, small towns, wonderful agricultural areas. Ohio is a microcosm of America and because of that, when Ohio speaks on March the 4th, America will listen to what Ohio says.

“We hear a lot of talk about hope and hope is important, but I want to tell you what's even more important, having a hopeful plan for Ohio and for America and Sen. Clinton has the plans."

Clinton, whose voice sounded strained at times and who interrupted her speech at one point to cough repeatedly, echoed Strickland's words and used the occasion to mention recent endorser John Glenn.

"Ohio is the heart of it all,” Clinton said. “Ohio is where we saw the first airplane actually race the skies, where we had astronauts who explored the heavens, including my friend Sen. John Glenn. You know, it was the steel from the mills in Ohio that armed America through two world wards, put cars in our garages and built our cities and Ohio is once again at the center of it all."

She said she wanted the area, often called the Rust Belt, to become an "Opportunity Belt" that would circle Ohio and America. "I see a middle class comeback that starts right here, right now in Lordstown," she said.          

While she used the last half of her remarks to slam Obama, Clinton initially focused on the economy, bashing Bush, for whom she said every day was Valentine's Day for the special interests, and talking about the importance of manufacturing jobs.

"Essentially President Bush has signed a sub-prime mortgage on America's economy," she said. "Now I know here at GM, you've had some serious challenges, but I don't think we can ever, ever in America give up on our manufacturers and our manufacturing jobs."

GM announced a new round of buyouts this week for 74,000 U.S. hourly workers after posting a nearly $39 billion loss in 2007.

The senator ticked through her policy proposals, talking about clean energy, cutting costs in the healthcare industry, taking on credit card companies, Wall Street and student loan companies and making the tax code fair.

"It is outrageous that a teacher, a nurse, an assembly line worker, a truck driver here in Ohio making $50,000 a year pays a higher tax rate than some Wall St. investment manager making $50 million a year," she said, adjusting a common line to make it a local.     

When put together, the long list of whom she would take on had the ring of former rival John Edwards' populist message. Both Obama and Clinton are courting Edwards' endorsement.

She got the biggest applause for promising not to reward companies that ship jobs overseas and for promising to support labor and ran down the list of unions that have endorsed her.

"I am proud to be a pro-labor, pro-Union candidate," she said. "So when my opponent in the primary puts out a mailer, which some of you may have gotten, with all sorts of false claims about my position on NAFTA, I'm going to count on working men and women to know the truth."

Clinton repeated her call for a time out on trade agreements to determine if they work for America and said that while Obama didn't "have much experience creating jobs," she did and that she would pick up "those boxing gloves" to fight for the American people.

McCain wasn't left out. "When Sen. McCain tells you that business as usual on trade is fine and tells neighboring Michigan workers we can't bring your manufacturing jobs back to the United States, they're sending a clear message aren't they?” she said. “They do not believe America needs a strong manufacturing base. I believe a strong America cannot remain strong without a strong manufacturing base, and I intend to fight for that as your president."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Sen. Obama is not qualified to be President, he's unelectable in the general election. Hillary wins big in the big states that are must wins for the Dems in November. It's that simple. AS Ohio goes, so goes the nation. No Presidential candidate can win without Ohio, and Ohio LOVES HIllary! Even more importantly, Hillary polls well against MCcain in Ohio, while obama  loses in Ohio. VOTE SMART OR DONT VOTE AT ALL.  EMOTIONS HAVE NO PLACE IN POLITICS. A vote for Obama is a vote for McCain in the General Elections.
It's about time that Senator Obama gets called out on his record (or lack of it) and his rhetoric (inspirational?  Maybe, but it takes more to being a President than rhetoric).  And now he's afraid to debate?  Why?  Because he knows that in a debate one-on-one with Senator Clinton he can't rely on posturing alone.  He'll run to Tehran to talk to Ahmadinijad.  He'll negotiate a health care deal on C-SPAN (like that will work).  But he's afraid to debate.  The harsh truth is, he can't be taken seriously.  The sad truth is, too many people continue to do so.
You should all try to be informed voters. Unforunately you're not going to get any candidates position in a 30 second soundbite you see on the news nor are victory speeches usually the place where candidates expouse their positions. If you haven't been able to figure out Mr. Obama's positions from the 20 previous debates, why don't you try going to his website? Took me less than a minute to find a rather detailed list of all his positions. Try that before spouting of the empty "Obama has no positions" rhetoric you heard the other candidates say.
I would rather have a president who can make optimistic, infectious speeches to the Republicans in Congress than one who has, does and will antagonize that legislative body.
And, oh yea, let's call Putin "soulless" to launch our new foreign policy. Another round of cold war anyone?
Obama people whining again. Get over it, this is an election and if he can't take it TUFF. She should have done it a long time ago, and buried his butt.You all think he is the best thing since sliced bread. He is nothing but a racist like Al Sharpton and Jesse Jackson.  I hope Jackson and Sharpton keep running their mouths, that sure to turn some of you off.
HILLARY or McCain
Always right (wong), what did Hillary do?

Nothing--so get under it.

Dan, OHIO (Sent Friday, February 15, 2008 4:21 PM)

__________________

Your Rhetoric is just like your candidate.... A whole lot of verbiage but not a lot of substance.
okay.. i do not understand how when clinton criticizes someone for where they stand on an issue, it is an "attack".  yet when obama criticizes someones position it is "a call for change"... i have seen people attack someone else, and it involves much more then questioning someones stance on an issue.. My vote won't be a gamble.  Clinton '08
Clinton and McCain share a trait that keeps me from suporting either one. Both were too callus or too stupid to see that there spouses had serious problems right in front of their faces, Clinton with sex and McCain with drugs. I think this inability to see the truth disqualifies them from the oval office
Negativity  = Desperation

Same old Clinton trash talking. What a shame.
I'm begging MSNBC to print this. This election is much too important to once again be deceived.

"9. Honor the life and legacy of Alexander Hamilton on the bicentennial of his death.
10. Congratulate the Syracuse Univ. Orange Men's Lacrosse Team on winning the championship.
"11. Congratulate the Le Moyne College Dolphins Men's Lacrosse Team on winning the championship.
12. Establish the 225th Anniversary of the American Revolution Commemorative Program.
13. Name post office after Sergeant Riayan A. Tejeda."

...And the like, Andre Kaz, you call this achievement? Any public official can do exactly that. My town mayor has done more of the above acts. This is exactly how Obama present himself. Lots of stats. But please SCRUTINIZE what they are!

You know what counts to us ordinary Citizens? What I would expect from a Senator? Taking a stand on issues that affect and will affect our children's future. VOTING PRESENT 133 TIMES is cowardly. That alone should erase any "congratulatory speeches" he's ever done.

Note that Hilary gained her Masters in services from Harvard in her 20's so she CAN make a change. Long before Obama (6 months ago) started chanting it.

Even though Obama found a new position to not take Lobbyist money, ONLY during his Presidential campaign…and yet has raised over 85K from Lobbyists, at least Hillary doesn't allow those Lobbyists or Corporate donors to influence her VOTE LIKE OBAMA DOES.

Obama voted for the Cheney Energy Bill in 2005, Hillary did not.

Obama voted NO to cap interest rates to financial institutions to protect citizens from loaners in gouging and predatory lending. HILLARY VOTED YES to Cap interest rates.

Obama is in favor of Nuclear Plants, and was one of the first to sign on to Liebermans Nuke Bill, besides the obvious upthread Energy Bill he supported (Exelon, 6th largest Nuclear plant has contributed over 250K to Obama)

AND

Obama tried TWICE to push a Lobbyist Back Liquified Coal Bill that would have used MILLIONS of tax payer dollars to fund this programs that would have added so much Global Warming Pollution, environmentalists were screaming for 6 months for him to pull it, until it lost support in June 2007.

So Obama, who walks the talk?

'..a reference to Exelon, which has donated to Obama's political campaigns...'

How Clintonesque....

From Huff Post:

Mark Penn Tied To Controversial Nuclear Firm
February 14, 2008 03:46 PM


'...Even as Sen. Hillary Clinton's presidential
campaign was blasting Sen. Barack Obama for his ties
to the Exelon Corporation, the firm of Mark Penn,
Clinton's chief strategist, was earning hundreds of
thousands of dollars from the very same nuclear energy giant...'

;...Nine days later, Penn's firm, Burson Marsteller,
received $230,627.05 from Exelon'... '...-- for work
deemed "Public Affairs....'

A real 'public service' !!
Getting a crooked Billary elected President !!

'...the Clinton campaign pressed the notion that Obama had succumbed to pressure from his donors, even though Clinton had supported the bill...'

HOW MANY Times have you seen Clinton cultists mention
Exelon ?
Turns out, Hillary's in bed with them ....

She's also TAKEN DONATIONS FROM REZKO !!
and appears in a picture with TWO CROOKS, Rezko and Bill Clinton
Once again Hillary will say or do anything to get elected. This woman can't be trusted. If you want 4 more years of corruption and the president selling us down the river so they can retire billionaires then vote for the witch.

This woman is becoming so disgusting and annoying every time I see her on TV. She is the female version of George Bush. She thinks she is entitled to be the next president.

No more Clinton or Bush presidency.  Please retire and go count your millions for speaking across the country and the kick backs from companies you made back door deals with. You and your crooked husband are starting really look pathetic.
Sen Clinton's promises of jobs in Ohio is reminiscent of her promise to create 200,000 jobs in upstate NY when she ran for the Senate - It didn't happen.
To Scott in Seattle, WA -

There is a difference between sponsoring a bill and writing one yourself.  Anyone can 'sponsor' a bill that was written by someone else.  So even though those numbers seem large compared to Clinton's numbers, I think you are missing the point and/or really don't know what you are talking about!
Let's see now ... Hillary makes a speech about speeches in which she states that speeches don't really do much for anybody and she campaigns in states where she really doesn't expect to win but that really doesn't matter because she wants Ohio and Texas.  Can't wait to hear the "SPIN" from Hill on March 5th because even if she wins in Ohio & Texas, the margins will be so close that she'll still be spinning in the wind.  I really expect her to pull a Huckabee long after her hopes are dashed simply out of a spirit of meanness and vindictiveness.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=669523

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google