ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Oh-eight (D): The Populist Manifesto?

Posted: Monday, February 18, 2008 9:19 AM by Mark Murray
Filed Under:

CLINTON: The Clinton campaign has a new way of circulating its views on the economy. "Clinton's campaign released a 13-page blueprint for fixing the economy Monday, detailing the former first lady's plans to achieve universal health care, address the home foreclosure crisis and develop jobs for the middle class. The pamphlet, which will be distributed to voters at campaign events and posted online, outlines many of the ideas she talks about on the campaign trail each day. But by pulling them together, the document resembles a populist manifesto - with Clinton championing the needs of working-class voters over corporate and business interests.”

“‘Over the past seven years, big corporations and special interests have been given a free pass to profit, often at the expense of the American worker. As President, Hillary will make it a priority to scale back special benefits and subsidies to these corporations and put those resources to work for our economy again,’ the pamphlet declares. Among other things, the document stresses Clinton's plan to freeze home foreclosures and subprime adjustable rate mortgages - a plan some economists believe would raise interest rates on other consumers.”

Bill Clinton's outbursts yesterday, which we detailed, were probably not that bad -- despite the heavy Drudge play. There was a passion to it that didn't seem out of place. 

OBAMA: "Obama has launched a newly aggressive strategy to undermine two pillars of support for rival Hillary Rodham Clinton: Latinos and working-class white voters. In Ohio, Obama backers are courting local union leaders and members with promises that the Illinois senator will change U.S. trade policies enacted by Clinton's husband, and which the unions blame for severe job losses. In Texas, Obama has launched a new effort to introduce himself to Latino voters as someone who understands their challenges, thanks to his background of attending college on a scholarship and working with churches as a community organizer."

Of the two big March 4 states, it appears Texas is the state Obama's campaign is more fired up about. "Obama has one other advantage in Texas: The state's complicated system of voting, involving both a primary and a caucus, awards convention delegates based in part on past voter turnout in state Senate districts. Because blacks in cities such as Houston and Dallas have voted at a higher rate than Latinos in the valley -- and blacks are expected to go heavily for Obama -- those black voters will have outsized influence over the final delegate count." 

USA Today: “Democratic presidential hopeful Hillary Rodham Clinton's campaign hammered rival Barack Obama on Sunday for refusing to reaffirm his commitment to accept public financing in the general election, a development a top aide criticized as ‘a pretty big flip-flop’ and an opening for Republican attack.”

The similarities between speeches given by Obama and given by his ally, Mass. Gov. Deval Patrick, is back in the news again.  A Wisconsin Obama speech and one given by Patrick two years ago were strikingly similar. The Obama campaign said he and Patrick often trade speaking ideas. “‘They often riff off one another. They share a world view,’ Mr. Axelrod said. ‘Both of them are effective speakers whose words tend to get requoted and arguments tend to be embraced widely.’”

Reports that Barack Obama used language from Gov. Deval Patrick of Massachusetts isn't surprising, NBC/NJ’s Aswini Anburajan reports. The two politicians are close, sharing similar upbringings and a penchant towards eloquence. But Patrick has also helped Obama with several of his speeches on the campaign trail, including the critical Jefferson-Jackson Dinner speech in Iowa that served as a turning point for Obama's campaign and was highly praised by the media. 
 
Patrick confirmed this to NBC News/National Journal in late December when he was on the road with Obama in Iowa. He added that they shared ideas and spoke frequently.  When Obama and Patrick were on the road together, he used lines from Patrick and joked with the crowd, "I'm stealing some lines from Deval because he stole a bunch of mine when he was running for governor."

That email which accuses Obama of being bad for Israel is making the rounds again and the New York Post has picked up on it.

The New York Daily News on Obama followers: “Scoffing bloggers write of ‘the blind frenzy of a mob clamoring to touch the hem of his garment’ and ask, ‘What next? Obama raises the dead?’ Even some Democrats who back Obama are leery. ‘Many of the Obama people not only have partaken of the Kool Aid, but they drank it undiluted,’ one Obama voter wrote in an online discussion titled: ‘Barack Obama Is Not Jesus.’”

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Looks like the Clinton propaganda machine worked the weekend. My bet it wasn't too hard on them, they probably just tweaked the same one they put out in '91.
It's obviously clear that Hillary Clinton is a leader with ideas and the experience to make them work positively for this country; while Barrack Obama is a cheer-leader with little experience and nothing to back up the beer-hall-orator-like speeches that so hypnotize the sheeple who follow him.
Obama's health care theory leaves millions of Americans without coverage, and he didn't even start to address the home forclosure problem until he heard Mrs Clinton doing it.
And what of post-war Iraq?...Obama has NO plan whatsoever! (...other than to remove one division per month).
But, what does he propose to do about diplomatic relations with Iraq, and how is he going to secure the embassies and consulates?
He doesn't tell you, because he doesn't know.
Hillary is absolutely correct about Barrack Obama. He is all show and no go, all talk and no action.
But, there's something else that ocurred to me recently.
Why did he bother to run for the Senate? Was it to serve the people of Illinois, or was it to give himeself a platform from which to catapault towards The White House?
The fact that he didn't even finish one term before running for the Presidency is pretty much all the answer you need. It's terrible for him to have run for the Senate under the guise that he was going to serve the people of Illinois, then run out on them in this fashion. It's shameful, and there's no excuse for it.
This proves that it's all about him, and not the people he serves.
Hillary could have run for the Presidency in 2004.
But, she completed a full term in the U.S. Senate before she announced her plans to run. This proves her committment to the people she serves, above and beyond her own personal desires.
I urge everyone to vote for this wonderful woman, who loves this country and the people in it, and who puts and will continue to put us, The American People FIRST.

Vote for Hillary 2008!
Putting Americans FIRST is her priority.
“Democratic presidential hopeful Hillary Rodham Clinton's campaign hammered rival Barack Obama on Sunday for refusing to reaffirm his commitment to accept public financing in the general election, a development a top aide criticized as ‘a pretty big flip-flop’ and an opening for Republican attack.”

Hillary,"I promise the people of New York that I will not use my service as their senator as a stepping stone to the presidency" FLIP

Hillary, "My vote for the war was not what I thought."  FLOP

Hillary,has had her share of flip-flops that have a far more serious impact on Americans. She lied to the voters of New York and to the people of the America. Her flip and flops have cost us in real dollars and real lives.
It is so funny to see how quickly the media goes from decrying voter apathy to reminding us that Senator Obama is not Jesus. What a joke.

Senator Obama is a political candidate, and a very good one. Many people have decided to support him based on his policies and the idea that people can work together regardless of ideology for the common good. Sorry if this concept is so heretical and scary for some - it's really not that difficult to understand.

But hey, if 8 more years of backbiting, backroom deals, and scandal are more your style, you are free to make a different choice. That's why they call it America.

P.S. What does "Bill Clinton's outbursts yesterday, which we detailed, were probably not that bad" mean? I'm confused by the need to write this sentence.
Now we have Bill Clinton doing a "V8" moment with people.  This guy really needs to go back and start making money money grabbing deals in Russia and wherever.  The Clinton's are finished.

The Clinton's economic manifesto is nothing but a bunch of bad ideas rolled into a slick presentation.  If she does get a freeze on mortgages, people will look at other things to raise rates on and people will really feel the hurt then and blame the Clinton's...
Obama supporter please read the New York Daily News link. It expresses exactly what you look like to others. It is a scary the intensity if your anger and devotion to a man. He is a man, not a demigod, a man. I do not usually use quotes but this one struck me. "If Hillary walked on water, she would be criticized for not swimming," Lehane said. "And if Obama swam, he would be lauded for being able to do what Hillary could not do."

I do not hate Obama, he is some guy who can apparently give a good speech, but he is not the second coming. Please if you want to support him fine but when you talk to me about him be able to tell me something other than "he will bring change" and "he is about hope". Seriously it is sad to see all these college grads who are completely unaware of the issues or misinformed.
Nashville_fan

They said that because they realized this was not news, it was some lunatic who wanted his 15 minutes a fame. And keep it real, if someone had done that at an Obama event, they would have been physically assaulted. I had to college graduates call me out of my name because I said state senate experience (parttime) does not equate US Senate experience. These are normally well spoken people who reverted to 4th grade tactics because Obama inspired them with his message of change. I originally would have supported whoever the Democratic nominee was but Obama lack of depth AND his supporters "you are with us or against us" tone remind me too much of the republicans "you are for the war or you are unamerican" crap over the last few years.
the root cause of stagnant wages, loss of pensions, loss of insurance, the general decline in living standards for working americans, and the  disappearance of the middle class is because of one document, nafta. then president clinton signed it into law knowing it was designed to lower the standard of living of working class people while increasing corporate profits, nafta was the beginning of the end of the middle class and the elitists major victory in the pursuit of a 2 class america, the clintons are proud architects of the decline in the u.s.a. we see today, does anyone really think that the clintons are going to turn their backs on the same corporate interests that have made them powerful and wealthy, and are bankrolling their current attempt to regain the thrown? spare me
I am still concerned that Vince Foster committed suicide in the 90s while been investigated as Hilary's partner in the whitewater case. Obama does not even whisper of this and many other funny dealings including in countries as far spread as Ukraine. I am also concerned with the Tyra Banks interview that cast Bill's fphilandering as the one case with Lewinsky where Hillary claimed she was dissapointed and thought what was best to do for her (as if it were a one case rather than a twenty year event with Jones, Lesinsky, Willy, Flowers. I do not care much that Bill did those things and I supported him then - it is their personal business (although I wish they didnt). It is my responsibility to teach my children it is not ok.
HILLARY HAS NO RIGHT TO CALL A FLIP FLOPPER.HILLARY WAS FOR NAFTA BEFORE SHE WAS AGAINST IT.SHE WAS FOR THE WAR BEFORE SHE WAS AGAINST IT.SHE FOR THE CREDIT CARD COMPANIES BEFORE SHE WAS AGAINST IT.SHE FOR LOBBYIST AND WALL STREET BEFORE SHE WAS AGAINST THEM.MCCAIN WAS AGAINST WATER BOARDING BEFORE HE WAS FOR IT.HILLARY AND MCCAIN DO NOT LIKE OBAMA BECAUSE HE HAS NOT PAID HIS DUES TO ALMIGHTY,S IN WASHINGTON.
Bob W Mendon, NY, wrote..."Hillary,"I promise the people of New York that I will not use my service as their senator as a stepping stone to the presidency"..."

Ah Bob, I guess you forgot that Hillary actually served a full term in the Senate before declaring her candidacy for President.
Obama served less than two years of a six year term before announcing his run for The White House.
If anybody sold out their constituency for a shot at being President, it was OBAMA, Not Hillary.
Hey jerry....how'd that Romney or Giuliani thing work work out? Not so good, eh...
Guess what jerry? They're both GONE, and Hillary's still standing.
How's that make you feel?
Happy PRESIDENT's DAY jerry....how's it feel knowing "Gigolo Rudy 'G'" and "Mitty-Boy" will NEVER be one.
J. Merle Stanley, Westchester, NY I couldn't agree with you more.
She run for a 2nd term in the Senate, debated her opponent and won her seat. She could have made a go of it in her first term but did not.

Finding out about Obama's voting record (133 times 'present') really made me wince. For someone preaching change, that does not sound like someone with guts who will fight for his ideas. That looked more like someone playing it safe. Rove made it known if he gets the nomination, they would go after his voting record and his 3 years in the Senate spent mostly campaigning for Presidency.

This woman dealt with just about every mud sling thrown her way. Yet she's out there standing still. Campaigning for her cause. Coming up with ideas and fine tuning solutions. Keep focusing on the issues Hilary. At the end of the day, that's what matters.

I realize that msnbc and firstread have declared an anything goes war on the clintons but what does surprise me is that so many have fallen for it.The snarky Mika whose father and brother are campaigning for Obama has no credibility left when twisting her words around anything about Hillary.Obamanoid hecklers are free to provoke and get in peoples faces and then brag about it.People who are attacked tend to attack back---Obama has already claimed he did not know the guy that heckled Bill Clinton.If you obamanoids expect Obama to thank you for acting like thugs,he will not.I do not care whose speeches he plagarizes I still will not support him.
HILLARY HAS NO RIGHT TO CALL OBAMA A FLIP FLOPPER ON ANYTHING.HILLARY WAS FOR NAFTA BEFORE SHE WAS AGAINST IT.SHE WAS FOR THE WAR BEFORE SHE WAS AGAINST IT.SHE FOR THE CREDIT CARD COMPANIES BEFORE SHE WAS AGAINST THEM.SHE WAS FOR THE LOBBYIST AND WALL STREET BEFORE SHE WAS AGAINST THEM.AS FOR McCAIN HE WAS AGAINST WATER BOARDING BEFORE HE WAS FOR IT.HILLARY AND McCAIN BOTH DO NOT LIKE OBAMA BECAUSE HE HAS NOT PAID HIS DUES TO THE WASHINGTON DC ALMIGHTY,S!
Only the Clintons know how to fix our economy and bring prosperity back to the working and middle class. After all they have DONE IT BEFORE.

How about Obama - NOPE.

Vote for your economic future. Hilliary 08
Having whipped J Merle in debate after debate on here, one would imagine he would have given up the ship.  But I see there are still some things he does not see in his one vision mind of The Clinton's...

Here we go:

Obama's health care theory leaves millions of Americans without coverage, and he didn't even start to address the home forclosure problem until he heard Mrs Clinton doing it.

The Clinton's health care plan will garnish wages out of the pockets of hard working American's, leaving them less and less to buy the basics (food, power, gasoline for the cars etc).  The Clinton's plan to freeze Mortgages will mean it will be harder then it is now for anybody wanting to buy a new home.

And what of post-war Iraq?...Obama has NO plan whatsoever! (...other than to remove one division per month).
The Clinton's will stay in Iraq until at least 2012

But, what does he propose to do about diplomatic relations with Iraq, and how is he going to secure the embassies and consulates?
He doesn't tell you, because he doesn't know.

How interesting....
neither do The Clinton's........

Why did he bother to run for the Senate? Was it to serve the people of Illinois, or was it to give himeself a platform from which to catapault towards The White House?

The same could be said of The Clinton's Merle.  Illinois is Hillary's home state.  Why did she not run for her home state rather then need New York so she could hang out her shingle and run for the Senate.  Her record as a Senator from New York (in baseball terms) is rookie league, compared to Obama's.

Or was the real reason was that she could beat Barock Obama in Illinois????

The fact that he didn't even finish one term before running for the Presidency is pretty much all the answer you need. It's terrible for him to have run for the Senate under the guise that he was going to serve the people of Illinois, then run out on them in this fashion. It's shameful, and there's no excuse for it.
This proves that it's all about him, and not the people he serves.

The same could be said for The Clinton's.....
Just put "Hillary" in place of "Obama" in your paragraph and you have picked them to a "T"

Hillary could have run for the Presidency in 2004.
But, she completed a full term in the U.S. Senate before she announced her plans to run. This proves her committment to the people she serves, above and beyond her own personal desires.

The only thing this proves is that she needed an address so she could run for President.  Once again, her record is not very good as A Senator from new York State.

Merle; so far half of the democratic party has seen The Clinton's for what they are, a couple of snake oil salesmen who could care nothing about the country, just their own power.

What is MSNBC going soft on the "evil empire" of B. & H Clinton?  It just adds to the evidence that Bill has gone bat s*** crazy.  THis is a story.
Obama is not Jesus and it's about time that someone said it.  As a black American it's amazing that people in my community regard him as the second coming.  But none of them can tell me his policies or his senete record. The media never comments that Obama comes up with his policies after he tries and fails to explain them when pressed. And that when he does, they are amazingly similar to Hillary's.  Why not drop the copy and elect the original.  Hillary Clinton for president.
Johnny from LV

Good thing one does not have to take an IQ test to post a comment. If that was the case we would never hear from you.

Clintons = Middle Class Success
All you nuts out there need to get a life and quit  letting Bill consume you. It is really bad for your health to be so vendictive. If you are are so worried about him and have nothing better to do, go do some charity work and get off your butts. You Obama supporters are the nastiest people I have ever seen. I thought the right wing nuts where bad but you all are unbeleivable, and you all call yourself Democrats, THAT REALLY SCARY
WHAT??????
** Man files Federal Lawsuit against Obama regarding GAY sexual act and drug use claims **

A man named Larry Sinclair posted a video to YouTube claiming to have used cocaine and engaged in a gay sexual act with Obama when Obama was a state legislator in 1999.

In the video, Sinclair claims he and Obama met on two separate occasions, that Obama used crack cocaine and that Sinclair performed an oral sexual act on Obama both evenings.

Now Obama and company are quickly trying to quiet this man, but Sinclair has filed a federal lawsuit. Sinclair filed suit against Obama and his campaign guru David Axelrod and DNC chair Howard Dean in Minnesota district court for allegedly attempting to abridge Sinclair's right to free speech, and for waging an intimidation campaign against him.

check out the video on youtube for yourself:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sVeFVtcdSYY

This has also been covered by The Smoking Gun but no one else.

America wants to know: where's the media coverage on this???? We deserve to hear the truth!

http://www.worldnetdaily.com/index.php?fa=PAGE.view&pageId=56626 is the latest website covering the story.
Hey jerry....how'd that Romney or Giuliani thing work work out? Not so good, eh...
Guess what jerry? They're both GONE, and Hillary's still standing.
How's that make you feel?
Happy PRESIDENT's DAY jerry....how's it feel knowing "Gigolo Rudy 'G'" and "Mitty-Boy" will NEVER be one.

J. Merle Stanley, Westchester, NY (Sent Monday, February 18, 2008 10:58 AM)


At Least they never slapped Obama supporters like The Clinton's did the other day.....

Personally I would have filed charges against Bill....
But then again, I would have probably ended up like Vince Foster....

Happy President's day to you Merle....
too bad Hillary will never know the feeling of being one.....
Why do the Clinton's think freezing the interest rate is a good idea?  I saved my money for a down payment.  I work hard to pay my mortgage on time.  Why should I be penalized because some people bought more house then they could afford?  Are we children?  Are we no longer expected to read contracts and live by budgets.  Banks and Corporations should not be protected, and homeowners who bought property they couldn't afford need to find a new place to live.  People all over bought and flipped houses with upside down loans.  They took the risk and many reaped great rewards.   I feel horrible that there are people in foreclosure.  But it isn't the governments job to remove all risk and pain. The Republicans will rightly eat her alive on this issue.  
How vitrolic can these posts get?  I support Senator Obama because I made an informed decision not because I am a "kool-aid" drinking, "lemming," of a "cult-follower" who is a "sheeple."

If I said that about Senator Clinton's followers -- who often behave with the intelligence of bigoted, uncivil, ignorant (how about the "it is Senator Clinton's time to rule" comments I read over and over again) Americans who I sincerely hope are being paid to post their garbage and do not represent the opinion of any American alive today and certainly not the opinions of a person as capable as Senator Clinton.

As for an Obama supporter making that inane statement -- he must be a shill for somebody else.  I have walked for, called for and rallied for Senator Obama in California (the state other states call the land of the "fruits and nuts," home to a myriad of REAL-live cults) and gee whiz, I didn't see any such behavior from my fellow Senator Obama supporters.  If it was going to appear anywhere, I daresay it would appear here in Southern California.

What I did see from the young supporters especially, was a sense of irrepressible joy.  Now, if joy is something that some of you must label negatively to feel good because you personally aren't experiencing it, I have real problems with your point of view.  

I admit I am too old and too jaded to go out and feel that sort of joy simply because I have decided to participate in something, but that certainly does not equate to demeaning those who are still innocent enough to feel it by labelling them a bunch of "sheeple."  

The young people I have met are all intelligent kids who thought through their decision to support Senator Obama -- they just are extremely happy that they made the decision and decided to ACT on it.

Get a life people and stop knocking the joy of the young.  

Yes we can!  Obama '08.

It's amazing to see people say that Barack Obama is only a good speech maker and has no specifics about how he will bring about change but Hillary Clinton does.  All you have to do is go to his we site and read.  By continuing to say this, you are only showing your own stupidity.

135 'present' votes out of OVER 4000 votes is less than 3%.  Some of those votes were actually done for startegic reasons to get something done.  To say that 'not committing' to a position on less than 3% of the votes someone made is, again, just showing either your own ignorance or that you have to grasp at straws to validate your decision.

Vince Foster?!?! Are you kidding me?  Missing furniture from the White House?!?!?  Are you nuts?!?!  People, all of these incidents have been either fully investigated or been disproven as lies circulated by the neocons.

There are two downsides that prevent me from supporting Hillary for the nomination: 1) The way a Clinton candidate will unite and motivate Republicans and many independents to vote against her in addition to some Democrats to not vote, and 2) the 'Clinton Political Machine' and her attacks that truly represent the old way of politics.  Their tactics are very divisive and the debts she would owe to her biggest donors (oil companies, drug companies, stock brokers and large Wall Street investors and financial heavy hitters) would lock us into at least another 4 more years of the status quo in the federal government.  If she is the nominee, I will definitely support her but not as enthusiastically as I support Obama.
*waves to Chaunda,Indianapolis*

I do not condone anyone heckling at a public political rally. That said, I am equally offended that now that the tide is turning in Senator Obama's favor, suddenly all of his supporters are misguided, naive "koolaid drinkers".

I too have SERIOUS misgivings about supporting Senator Clinton should she win the nomination because of the many things that have happened over the course of this campaign (including voter fraud). However, my feelings about the Iraq War trump all the pettiness from the campaign trail, and so I will support Senator Clinton should she win the nomination because I don't think our troops should have to pay the ultimate price simply because Senator Clinton does not know how to campaign FOR herself as well as she campaigns AGAINST Senator Obama.

Obama '08
When I consider the campaign that each candidate is runnng as a metaphor for how they would govern the country, this is what I see.  Candidate A is having cost over runs and disarray at the top, underestimated the opponent, changes "message" frequently, considers small states insignificant, and has all sorts of excuses for losses.  Candidate B has remained within budget, respects the opponent, has stability at the top, has had the same message, and considers all states (and delegates) as significant.  Which one would you prefer to assume management of the country?
I love all the overthinking in here!

Obama is a far better candidate - period.

Hillary has a 49% negative rating - and that's her ceiling! Just another 51 - 49 defeat to McCain if she's the nominee. Not interested in the bridge back to the 20th century.

Obama '08
Hillarys plan sounds wonderful, well thought out...oh yea.. maybe if we yell "yes we can" and "we want change" loud enough, that can be a plan too!!!!DOH, I'm just a plain old stupid American, and proud to be.
Yes we can what? Nobody seems to know. How scarey.
Folks, listen up! They are all politicians and will have to play the ballgame of Washington.  What we need is to change the system to nominate and as long as it is left to the states, we will have what we are all experiencing now.  When 1000 people decide the state's  delegates or the DNC could not resolve a date for Mich and Fla, I say, we are in a mess.  Come on Democrats, get with it or Mc Cain will be the next pres.
I really don't know what "cultish" Obama supporters you're talking about, other than a few crazies on Internet message boards. There are a lot of them. Just look at how far Ron Paul got.

When I campaigned in Nevada for Obama, all I met were thoughtful, intelligent people, most of them highly informed, that were excited to be working for a great candidate whom they supported for reasons that usually had nothing to do with his charisma.

But whatever. Keep pushing that meme. Destroy the career of a brilliant man and incredibly successful politician. Give the Millennial Generation the finger. Just understand that your party will likely have to wait another 40 years before the youth sees it as a valid mode for political expression again. I'll certainly be taking my vote, and my activism, elsewhere.
I, too, would like some coverage on Larry Sinclair. I'd also like some coverage on Michelle Obama's statement that this is the first time she's really been proud of her country. Great thing for a potential First Lady to be saying.  If Bill Clinton would have said that, it would be in capital letters by Mr. Todd!  Again, unfair coverage. What's good for the goose is good for the gander. In this case, that would vice versa.
2 words...Larry Sinclair!  Look it up on YOUTUBE.  Not that I'm saying it's true....but...the swiftboating from the right is starting.  A guy is claiming that Obama did drugs with him in Illinois and then... Well you get the picture.  Yikes right?  Do we want to take a chance with Obama...with the repubs insisting they want to go against Hillary (reverse psychology).

Look what they did to Al Gore...and John Kerry.  Can we afford to take the chance with Obama???  Who the heck is he anyway??? He's lied about his past in his books...and doesn't even write his own "inspirational" speeches.

Come on folks!!!!  We can't afford to have McCain and the repubs in power AGAIN!!!!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=676722

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google