ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Exit polls: Why Obama won

Posted: Tuesday, February 19, 2008 10:26 PM by Domenico Montanaro
Filed Under:

From MSNBC's Norah O'Donnell and Adam Verdugo
Obama chalked up his ninth straight victory and won in this predominantly white state with a strong showing across a broad spectrum of voters and by eating into Hillary Clinton's base of support. He nearly tied her among women, won on all of the issues and won every income level. He also won the white vote under-60.
 
First, the independents: One-in-four voters call themselves independents in this open primary and tonight, Obama took nearly two-thirds.
 
Second, white voters: He did very well among white men with 62% of their vote to Clinton's 36%. Remember those Edwards voters? At least among white men, it looks like at least some of them are going for Obama. Clinton, though, still took a plurality of white women (53%-45%).
 
Obama also made inroads with one core constituency of Clinton's: white working-class voters (households making under $50k/yr). Clinton still edged him out 51% to 48%, but Obama had a strong showing. He won white households making more than $50k/yr -- 56% to 48%.

Electability has been something both campaigns have been touting. Tonight, Obama beat Clinton soundly -- 63%- 37% -- when voters were asked who would be most likely to beat the Republican candidate in the fall.
 
One other note regarding the negative attacks this past week: Wisconsin Democrats took notice. When we asked if either of these candidates attacked the other unfairly, 53% said that Clinton was unfair, while only 33% said the same about Obama.
 
Not all is lost, however, for Clinton. She still took the senior vote, those with less than a college education and Catholics, but it was not enough to overtake Obama.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Obama promises everything to everyone.  How he will pay for it nobody knows.  God help this country if he get in. Terrorists will love him.
Goodbye Sam.  Don't let the door hit you on the way out.
Dynastic politics doesn't work in Anerica; never has, never will.
Hillary and Bill ran the country once that's enough
It's time to step aside and let someone else step up
to the plate. It appears Obama is gonna be that person. It's for sure he can't do any worse than the
present administration. We can all agree that a change is way overdue.
I switched to Democrat but will return to my Republican beliefs if Obama is the nominee. I live in Kansas that has always been republican. In its infancy it began as a republican state. So I will go with the tide here. I know it is the only way to protect my husband's job future.
A narrow voting segment of older, under-educated, white women won't be able to beat McCain in the general.  HRC is losing because she simply isn't appealing.  She's smart.  She's tough. But she can't lead her way out of a paper bag.  Vote Obama.
Despite the sickening "pro Obama" coverage of NBC/MSNBC, Millions of Americans will not let the media tell us who to vote for or who to support. Hillary will win TX, OH and PA...and NBC.MSNBC will be left humiliated yet again.

Sam is a moron! "Racist scare tactics", what country do you live in? How can a black man use racist scare tactics, the backlash would be monumental. Then we you try to play the plagiarism card it comes off as desperate. She's plagiarize Bill's presidency.Get with the program! The old way are not working. It's time for something new dude! I'm former military, Field Artllery 4th Infantry Division, and I'm tired of my friends being over there, bring them home. It was the wrong fight to begin with and oil prices spike every week! Lower energy costs and the economy will boom. Clinton=Patriots...Hillary Bellicheck has been out played and is played out
if Obama win most of my frinds goning voteto vote for  mccaine innovimber of2008
I thank God for Obama.May God give him strength and
keep him and his family in good health.There is a time
for everything. This is the time to bring this kind
of change to United States of America and more blessings to this land of opportunity.
I think that ,yes it will take money to change things, but what Obama defines as the answer, and what people are responding to, is the proposal of everyone joining together working together to transform not only our government, but our lives, our countries direction. It may be words, but it's the spirit behind the words, our spirit that will make it happen. Also  it takes WORDS to define the problem, and WORDS and ACTION from ALL to define the solution, and make it happen... GObama!
Your reporting needs to be more thorough. Exit polls posted prior to this post show that Obama
- won among anyone who didn't graduate college right through postgraduate
See here: (go to p2 of the polls): http://www.cnn.com/ELECTION/2008/primaries/results/epolls/#WIDEM
see ya sam
Is God is backing Obama? Not only does he win the church-going vote, but the weather once again is terrible on primary day. One suspects this aids Obama, as his supporters are portrayed as more dedicated, but I have nothing except anecdotal evidence to support this.

Maybe older voters don't like the cold? Or don't feel like falling on ice and breaking their arm a la Defense Secretary Robert Gates?

Obama continues to eat away at key Clinton demographics, winning flat-out those without a college education. I have no idea why Clinton didn't fight here, as the demographics would seem to indicate she could've been competitive.

It maybe good in the long run if the front-runner status forces the media to turn on Obama, but more likely than not, the Clinton campaign will die the same death by 1,000 cuts that finished off that other New York politician. You know, the 9/11 guy. You can't lose every primary for a month and hope a firewall saves you, especially in this race.

As for momentum, Obama is climbing in Texas and Ohio in the polls. Is a 52%/48% win in those two states going to net the delegates needed for Clinton to hold on? Not likely, as Obama is going to win the delegate count in Texas either way because of its wacky primary/caucus system.

Clinton needed to look competitive in the Badger state, but instead she looks like she got owned.

More insipid analysis: http://www.nationalscold.com
If the 'Commander in Chief' line is the best Hillary Clinton can offer, it is too bad, because John McCain will crush either Clinton or Obama on national security issues in a general election.  The countering strength is to ask Americans to be courageous rather than afraid, and that is the essence of Obama's message.  Clinton will not outcompete the Republicans in fear mongering.
I voted for Obama in the VA primaries. I will vote for him in the general election. He will win, and he will become the first minority president in the history of the United States of America. I can’t stand Hillary Clinton especially after her crying episode after she lost in Iowa. She is a liar, a cheater, and lacks any of the qualities our president should have. Obama all the way.
So much vitriole for Hillary Clinton!  Why?  This undeserved perception of her undying obsession with power has spawned such disproportionate contempt!  I may have voted for Obama, but that doesn't detract from the validity of Clinton's campaign or the admiration I have for her as a person.
First and foremost I am a Hillary supporter.  However, I just don't understand why she doesn't pin him to the mat on just exactly how he plans to evoke all this "change" he speaks of.  I would take his laundry list item for item, and demand his response on each and every issue.
congrats to Obama, hopefully this country can move past racial sterotypes. People are tired (at least people under 55) of same old stale mate tactics demonstrated by the clinton war machine.
Vote for McCain in a general election and vote for a supreme court that will overturn Roe vs Wade.
Jim Conley

And we'd like to hear how Hillay plans to evoke all of her plans.

Hillary does the same thing she talks about her programs but no information as to how she will do this .
Psst....hey dan...in the general election you don't need to change your political party to vote for the other guy.

On another issue, Clinton's disregard of her WI loss is typical. Did she thank her supporters? Nope. Did she praise her campaign staff there? Nope. Just push on to the next state. The Clinton Machine only cares about delegates and not the American public; victory and not the country. Win at all costs? Who needs that in the White House...if people would think carefully, that's pretty much been the mantra of the current administration....but that's just my observation. Clinton ought to drop out, endorse Obama and allow the Democrats to organize a strong campaign for November.
it is unfair for democrats to switch party becuase Obama is a blackman. For christ sake Obama is a citizen of America. IF you didn't like him you should'nt have voted for him in the primaries. All those who switch party's because of colour of people are racist.They are not party faithfuls and they should b3e ignored
It is difficult to understand how people can say that Obama has no substantive ideas.  His platform is spelled out very clearly on his website and his speeches routinely reference his policies and distinctions between himself and Senators Clinton and McCain. The empty attacks on Senator Obama are disheartening to me and, if Senator Clinton gets the nomination, I will be voting for a republican for the first time in my life.
It is time for the media to stop expressing their views.  It is terrible that Hillary was in the middle of her speech when MSNBC & CNN switched over to Obama.  They aren't even fair to her.
I really hope that people won't vote for Obama. This man has no experience. Can't anybody see this? He is going to bring nothing good for the United States.
People talk of the lack of experience that Obama has. If I read correctly in school there were a few other people that had never governed a country  before,brought people together with words of hope and change. Led only by the ideals of prosperity for all. OUR FOUNDING FATHERS did a pretty good job. This is like an AMERICAN REVOLUTION and will go down in history as such. Its time for a new way of thinking....I'll give Obama a chance...The "old experienced" people had there chance and led us to the brink of destruction.
John McCain is apparently the best republicans have to offer, which ain't much. He is Bush, Bush is him. McCain touts himself on national security please realize the system is already setup, and McCain will only attempt to go further than Bush if that's possible. McCain is pandering so hard to evangelicals his "straight talk express" has derailed and actually fallen off the trestle. McCain does not have the temperment to be president. I am a capitol hill retiree and I know McCain's reputation. I have watched and heard him speak and his temper is always just under the radar especially when challenged. He is not the kind of president I want. Like Bush McCain will be no asset to this country.
Hillary keeps touting her 35 years of experience. Experience in what exactly?
the people of this great country has said they need a change from the oLD politics of the past. Hillary has 35 years of the past in her. I can't beleive that the people of this country can forget about all of the past that went on it the white house when the Clinton's were there. Don't you remember someone killing himself because he knew he would be a exscape goat for the Clinton's. Obama is a good person. Lets give him a try. If you don't like him after 4 years, vote him out.
I don't get it.  Obama doesn't have any meat to his message or ever describes how he is going to deliver on all his promises.  He doesn't have a voting record to defend because he avoids voting on controversial or politically unsafe legislation by voting present or not showing up to vote.  He is an inspiring speaker, but does he really have more to offer?  Being a magnetic personality certainly helps in the popularity polls, but how will he fair in one-on-one discussions with world leaders?  How is he going to get the economy back on track?  He speaks about it, but has not laid out a clear plan or even much more of a vision.  He has managed to avoid defining himself and his issues.  What really frightens me is that many of the individuals voting right now in the primaries for Obama, such as the college students, typically will not show up for election day, feeling like their vote doesn't count.  Will they be there then to support the democratic nominee they put up when we need their vote?  Republican's have the most powerful "get out to vote" machine and historically do great at getting people to the polls.  Furthermore, McCain will appeal to as many independents as Obama will in a general election.  And I hate to bring this up, but Obama's feel good, play good politics won't work in the general election.  527's will be attacking and if he doesn't attack back and can't show some toughness he'll be Swift boated just like Kerry, who seemed weak in the eyes of the overall population and lost in the general election.

Let's at least nominate someone that knows how to fight off these attacks, has some real plans for her vision and honestly has among the best people in place for the Cabinet positions, who are more important that the President.  If anything, vote for the team...Clinton can put together the best team to run this country, despite how you feel about her personally.  This isn't a popularity contest...it is who are the best people for the job.
it is unfair for democrats to switch party becuase Obama is a blackman. For christ sake Obama is a citizen of America. IF you didn't like him you should'nt have voted for him in the primaries. All those who switch party's because of colour of people are racist.They are not party faithfuls and they should b3e ignored
White male; 50; Ohioan; voting for Obama.
No, doubt Obama is the next President.  People will do and say things to convince or sway a vote just because,  but no matter what others say...deep down in our hearts anyone that really cares about the state of this Country and it's future.  Know's that the only really choice for positive change is Barack Obama.
For what it's worth I could not be happier with the candidates available in this cycle. I believe John McCain to be an honest, honorable man. If I were to vote republican, hands down, my pick would be Mr. McCain. If Hillary were to win the nod, I think we would have a fine representative in government, able to address the issues we are facing.

But, alas, there is a mobilization. A movement. A force that is tuning into the despaired, the dejected, and the despondent. There is a calling for involvement. A plea for activism. A promise that we, together, can move mountains. A belief, that if all the people of this great nation come to the table with open minds, and willingness to compromise, WE can move passed this current state of failed government. A belief that if the people of this United States of America desire, inspire, roll up our sleeves, and demand change that we WILL make the changes we seek. If the people DEMAND it the politicians will finally be released from this gridlock, in fear of their JOBS! This is what Mr. Obama brings to the campaign. Not just promises, but requests of service. Not just words, but motivation. Not just motivation, but, more importantly, mobilization. The American People are stepping up. We are taking OUR government back. The politics of old are being discarded, and once again a great beast is being awakened. Oh, I can't wait.

LOVE THY NEIGHBOR!!
As they say let the better man or women in this race win, When all the mud settles down AMERICA meet the new person in charge. And no matter who it is there will be people that will be unhappy and there will be those that will be happy and there will be those that just don't care but no matter the feelling we will deal with it for four years and put up the changes and etc, So America as we say in the military Suck it up and deal with it what ever the outcome.
Sen. Obama reminds me of another historical candidate with about the same amount of experience in the Senate, ye who went on to become one of the greatest thinking Presidents of all time - JFK.  We don't need to pass the Presidential torch back and forth between the hands of the Bush and Clinton dynasties any longer.  It really IS time for a change!
Why Obama won Wisconsin in one word:

Momentum.

But this isn't passive momentum, where a candidate expects that voters will simply copycat the results of previous contests because, as the saying goes, everyone loves a winner. That's what everyone thought was going to happen in NH, but since it fell short, momentum seemed to drop out of the equation. The problem is that we were talking about the wrong kind of momentum.

What Obama has is active momentum. After generating excitement with a win in Iowa and many others since, the Obama campaign was able to translate that excitement into huge fundraising, huge crowds, huge word-of-mouth, and huge enthusiasm from legions of volunteers. The bit of genius comes in how they were able to use the internet to explode that activity.

In my opinion, the campaign's phone banking efforts have been the best (and perhaps most effective) example. In the run-up to last night's voting, online supporters from everywhere in the country made over 200,000 calls to voters in Wisconsin and other upcoming states. Similar numbers happened for the Potomac primaries and Maine (over 100,000 calls for Maine alone). That's the kind of momentum that's important in this campaign. Once you get that many people involved and invested in a campaign, then give them a way to casually volunteer from their own home, as well as donate, discuss, learn, and share, you can roll over a traditional campaign machine like the Clintons' with relative ease.

Obama's momentum was only in its infancy in the early hours of the morning on January 4th. Right now, it's fully matured, and we're seeing just how difficult that's making life for Clintons at the moment. If this continues -- and it looks like he's got tons of enthusiasm in Texas and Ohio -- he'll have the nomination wrapped up in a few news cycles after March 4th.
What's all the flap about experience? The only experience that Hillary has is, she lived in the White House for 8 years as the spouse of the president.  Which is a non decision making role concerning problems facing this country.  Look,I like the Clintons very much and Bill did a wonderful job as president, but they've had their time in office and its now time to move on to someone else.
Also, on the issue of of National Security and other war issues: Why is McCain touting that he is the best candidate?  Is its because he was a POW? Mr. McCain we appreciate and thank you for your service to this country.(and yes, I am a veteran) But, in todays time and your age, it is also time for you to step aside also.   GO BARRACK OBAMA

 
Mrs. Clinton is continually bragging about her experience and attending meetings with Bill, when she was in the White House. No one, not even the media, will ask her what security clearance she had.
First and foremost I am a Hillary supporter.  However, I just don't understand why she doesn't pin him to the mat on just exactly how he plans to evoke all this "change" he speaks of.  I would take his laundry list item for item, and demand his response on each and every issue.
jim conley lexington ky (Sent Tuesday, February 19, 2008 11:27 PM)

obama should ask hillary the same question, actually obama's plans are more precise than hillary's, most of hillary's so called plans are purposely vague so she can change them latter, the argument that obama does not have specific plans on how to pay for his programs is false, that is probably why clinton doesn't push the issue, but the next debate will probably clear that up and mrs. clinton and her followers will have to come up with a new farce to claim against obama, but at this point it's irrelevant, she's lost.
I see we have some really bright Democrats here.  If they don't get the candidate they want (either Clinton or Obama) they'll show us -- they'll vote for McCain.  Talk about shooting yourself in the foot!  You'll forgo getting a Democrat in the White House and vote for Good Ole Bush Lite for President.  You are the living embodiment of the phrase, "cutting off your nose to spite your face".  No wonder the Dams have so much trouble regaining the Presidency.  What nerds you all are!  As for me, I'm supporting the Cemocratic nominee, whoever it is.  Let's calm down, people.  We're all Democrats here, aren't we?
Dredbear from Texas
I'm a staunch Republican. However McCain's politics don't seem to stand out.

Obama has an inspiring message, whilst it is idealistic I think that is part of what makes American so great. I will ALWAYS be a Republican but I actually see myself voting for Obama over McCain.
It cracks me up that all you Obamaniacs are crucifying Chris for FINALLY being somewhat objective in his treatment of the two dem candidates..  if your crying about this wait until the repubs get ahold of him.  All your whining about about how evil the clinton campaign has been is pitiful.  She's handled him with kid gloves compared to what the RNC has in store for him.  He and his supporters better toughen up unless you want another repub in the white house.  Its not a threat, or just a nasty comment.. but this dem is seriously thinking about going to the other side for the first time other.  Most of you beleive the "best show on TV".  I dont.  he needs to show me something other pretty words and the "promises" of a career politician.  And im pretty sure im not alone in this thought.  That should have the DNC a little worried.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=683081

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google