ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Oh-eight (D): 'They call him (her) flipper'

Posted: Monday, February 25, 2008 9:09 AM by Domenico Montanaro
Filed Under:

Who's a flip-flopper? The Washington Post notes that both Clinton and Obama have been flip-floppers. "A review of the two candidates' records shows that both senators have shifted positions on numerous issues as the competition for votes has become more intense. In some cases, the shifts have been subtle, a change of emphasis rather than an obvious reversal. But on other issues, both candidates are saying things that are quite different from their previous positions.” 

In fact, here are each candidate’s top-five flip-flops. For Obama: special interest money (he's now happy to get labor support); public financing; Cuba; illegal immigration and decriminalization of marijuana. For Clinton: NAFTA, No Child Left Behind, Iraq, driver's licenses for illegal immigrants and the FL/MI delegate debacle.

The Boston Globe: “While political analysts said that Nader is unlikely to repeat his performance in the 2000 election, in which he won nearly 3 million votes, his presence on the ballot could still have an impact if the contest is close. In 2004, Nader won about half a million votes, including nearly 33,000 in Florida.”

CLINTON: The Los Angeles Times looks at Clinton's shifting tactics. "With her White House prospects in jeopardy, Hillary Rodham Clinton has shifted from one tactic to another in trying to overtake rival Barack Obama. She tried TV ads saying he ducked debates. She accused him of plagiarism. She disparaged his huge crowds. She called his attacks on her shameful and dishonest. On Sunday, Clinton turned to ridicule. ‘Now I can stand up here and say: Let's just get everybody together, let's get unified, the sky will open, the light will come down, celestial choirs will be singing, and everyone will know we should do the right thing, and the world will be perfect,’ Clinton told supporters here at Rhode Island College.”

“‘Maybe I just lived a little long. But I have no illusions about how hard this is going to be,’ Clinton continued. ‘You are not going to wave a magic wand and have the special interests disappear.’”

The Washington Post writes about Clinton's more populist tone, noting that she's sounding more like John Edwards these days. "Eager to recapture the white, working-class voters who favored her in some of the early primaries but who have since shifted to Sen. Barack Obama, Clinton traded her usual wonky style this weekend for a fiery, populist tone in speeches in Ohio, Texas and Rhode Island. Instead of giving precise policy details, she repeatedly pointed her finger skyward, declared that Americans ‘got shafted under President Bush’ and cast herself as a fighter, as Edwards often described himself, promising to help most Americans, not just the ‘wealthy and the connected.’” 

Apparently, Clinton was reassuring donors over the weekend that she was in good shape for March 4.

And in case you missed it, over the weekend, Clinton apologized for the comments her husband made that were seen by some as racially charged.

OBAMA: The New York Times does the Obama safety story. "There is a hushed worry on the minds of many supporters of Senator Barack Obama, echoing in conversations from state to state, rally to rally: Will he be safe?"

For what it's worth, we've found this to be a generational thing; Folks old enough to remember the assassinations of the '60s are the most worried; those under 50, not so much.

This is one of handful of conservative columns we've seen of late that hits Obama on his ego. It seems one of the talking points that could become louder over the next few months. Here's NYT's Kristol's shot: "So we don’t have to work to improve our souls. Our broken souls can be fixed -- by our voting for Barack Obama. We don’t have to fight or sacrifice to help our country. Our uninvolved and uninformed lives can be changed -- by our choosing Barack Obama. America can become a nation to be proud of -- by letting ourselves be led by Barack Obama."

The Los Angeles Times’ Z. Barabak looks at Obama's success at wooing Republicans. "Many are skeptical that Republicans will stick with Obama until November. They point out that many of his proposals -- including a timetable for ending the war in Iraq, repealing Bush's tax cuts for the wealthy, expanding the government's role in healthcare and supporting gay rights and gun control -- cut too much against GOP orthodoxy."

At some point, Obama has to deal with this increased criticism as penned by Roll Call's Stu Rothenberg: "Maybe if Obama wraps up the Democratic nomination in the next few weeks, he’ll give all of us a better idea of what he’d really like to do as president. We can only hope so. Another eight months of soaring but empty rhetoric about bringing people together and bringing about change will leave most of America brain-dead."

Here's an endorsement Obama could have done without: Louis Farrakhan. "In his first major public address since a cancer crisis, Nation of Islam Minister Louis Farrakhan said Sunday that presidential candidate Barack Obama is the ‘hope of the entire world’ that the U.S. will change for the better. The 74-year-old Farrakhan, addressing an estimated crowd of 20,000 people at the annual Saviours' Day celebration, never outrightly endorsed Obama but spent most of the nearly two-hour speech praising the Illinois senator."

Said Obama campaign spokesman Bill Burton: "Sen. Obama has been clear in his objections to Minister Farrakhan's past pronouncements and has not solicited the minister's support."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Why can't anybody make comparisons to JFK?  JFK was a womanizing son of bootlegger.  The silver spoon in him and his brother's mouth was bought with dirty money.  He MAY have been a party to the murder of the America's first pop icon.

Since the advent of video media (starting with JKF's run incidently)Presidential elections have been mostly a popularity contest.  So why all the venom when the candidate you like doesn't look as good or speak as well as the "popular guy".  If JFK hadn't been made "US royalty" by the media and a martyr by a bullet you wouldn't be able to be so hypocritical. Obama's no god.  JFK was no saint.

As far as the Obama mocking and "delusional" supporters:
I bet Hillary woulsn't have a problem if the "heaven's opened up" when she spoke.  Unfortunatley the only thing that happens when she does is people go to sleep or think she's fake or she looks like a crazy person.

Not good, girl. And if all that crap was really out there about Obama- trust me the Clintons would have already used it.  Contrary to her pronouncements the Clintons play politics just as dirty as the Republicans.  Why do you think they hate each other so?
Sen. Clinton ranting and raving about Sen Obama's mailers finally we see her true side emerge daying that "All Democrats should be outraged".  Well Sen. Clinton I am outraged that you have the nerve to tell me as a Democrat at what I should be.  Facts are fair in a campaign and if you can not handle the truth then perhaps you are in the wrong field of play.  If you want to be upset or mad is one thing but we are intelligent Americans and we do not need you to tell us what we should be.  I think it would be best if she looses in either Ohio or Texas so that we can move on I am so tired of hearing Sen Clinton picking arguments with words andcheap shots it is truly ridiculous and childish.  Sen. Clinton only does what is satisfies her and when it doesn't she gets angry.  If she is like this now imagine if she makes it into the White House it will be sparring matches every day.  TIME FOR CHANGE!!!!!
I will vote for Obama in the primary just to take a vote away from Clinton. I don't want Billy in power again. Hillary should have dumped him from the get-go. I have no respect for her for standing by him.  I don't care much for McCain either, so am not sure whether I'll go Rep or Dem in Presidential vote.
That's what is wrong with the country now, we have so many pepole with so much HATE in them.Try for once in your life to be more positive about the words you use when attacking other people.
That's what is wrong with the country now, we have so many pepole with so much HATE in them.Try for once in your life to be more positive about the words you use when attacking other people.
Christians, are willing to take a leap of faith with this man: we will be united, the world will be ready to accept us as friends again, and Americans will benefit! And SHAME on Hillary for mocking us!!

GO OBAMA!

Irish Mom for Obama! Virgina (Sent Monday, February 25, 2008 10:07
-------------Seems you will believe any one who passes by singing gospel.  Mock this , OBAMA LIES he is a phony and so are you! You trolls make me sick with with your pasted rhetoric spread on these blogs.  Shame on you!
Clinton has proved that she is mentally unstable. She is done in TEXAS.
BUSH was a christian when he was running for President...remember?    
Watch for the Republican's to talk about the lord again.  
Obama's middle name keeps being brought up by the republicans.  Hussein wouldn't have menat anything 10 years ago.  The Republicans recite Obama's middle name, Hussein, like he had something to do with 911.  Or do the republicans still believe we went to war in IRAQ of 911??  Anyway...do you think Obama had anthing to do with the "name" he was given the day he was born??  No different than any of us being named some dumb name our parents gave us.  What is in a name??  
 If your name is anthony or joseph you must be affiliated with the mob?  If your name is billy or bobby, you must be a "hick"?  
Politicians really BELIEVE we are still BRAIN DEAD.  The giant has awakened...the american people!  tricks, tactics, FEAR MONGORING and dirty politics won't work anymore!  
Hillary's campaigns latest dirty trick, with the pic of obama in african garb (just like she covered her head while visiting a Muslim country, so she must be a muslim in hiding!!)) is gonna backfire big time.  The VOTERS won't fall for her pathetic last ditch effort!!  
You ought to be ASHAMED OF YOURSELF HILLARY CLINTON!!!  
Mrunpc-
Actually, several members of the congregation where I worship are converted Muslims.  I am friends with many other current Muslims, and they are wonderful people.  Barack Obama is not a Muslim, he is a Christian, and you can read his conversion experience in Dreams of My Father and read his feelings on his faith in The Audacity of Hope...that is, assuming you can read.
I gave him money and I am not a Muslim.

don't you have a Klan meeting to get to?
GIVE HIM HELL HILLIARY.  

Hey Marv - FACE IT. Your obama canidate is nothing more than a junior want to be.He has never accomplished anything important and he never will.

The only credible and winable canidate is Hilliary
To mrunpc: ridiculing his name and saying if he believed what he said  he'd change it to a Christian one is a strange argument as if that "proves" he is a secretly a muslim, he says in his biography that he did take an American sounding family name when he started at college and came to believe that rejecting the name his mother had given him was inauthentic. It only adds to his transparency for him to honor and relate to all of his legacy just as all Americans in this melting pot should be proud of. Cassius Clay took a tremendous amount of ridicule for changing his name to Mohammed Ali, interesting you turn that on its head. It is silly season. By the way I think it is pathetic that in a country that stands on the constitutional concept of separation of church and state that if a candidate was muslim that should be held against him. But obviously we haven't traveled far enough from Kennedy being feared because he was a Catholic. see Romney and the mormon controversy that swirled up. It is doubly ironic that he is both being criticized for supposedly not being Christian enough  and supposedly modeling his rhetoric on being messianic. like previous criticisms he has humorously mentioned. He is not enough black/he is the African American "boy" candidate. he has no substance/but he earlier was criticized for being a wonk and a snoozer. He sweeps people off their feet with his soaring rhetoric/and now Clinton accuses him of being a plagaristic hack while not acknowledging her own speechmaker's repeated lifting of his, Edwards, her husband, etc. any other speech motif they think at the moment might wangle another vote. Like I said, silly season
Let the FOOLS rush in for Obama.

You ought to be a shamed of yourselves to, you look like a bunch of drones. Maybe you need to grow up and get lifes.
It's about POWER, people.  This is the most powerful position to hold in the world.  The Question is:  Who do we want to have that power?  Do we want a leader that can unite us and the world through inspiring words?  Or, do we want a leader to unite us with tears and sympathy?  Maybe niether.
Clinton did not apologize for her hubby's remarks. She said she regretted that/if anyone was offended. I regret everyday murder, but saying so is not a personal apology
I say that an ego isn't such a bad thing when one is right as frequently as Obama, or just all-around better than anybody else.  I speak from experience.

Anyway, he should be confident in himself, his abilities and his judgement--otherwise, why would he run.  He should also recognize his weaknesses (wait, wasn't he recently chastized for that?).
Obama says one thing does the other: Example - He said he would aggressively pursue public financing system during election, but when he sees the big advantage of his current fund raising he changed his tone; In December in Iowa, Sen. Obama criticized spending by independent groups as a "major loophole in campaign finance reform.” But yesterday in Ohio, Sen. Obama refused to criticize a significant, last-minute outside expenditure organized on his behalf.

The point: I'm not saying Clinton is better than Obama, just wake up to see Obama is just another politician who has been painted by media & everyone as someone he's not!

Farrakhan hails Obama as 'hope of entire world'. How funny it is! I have no problem for anyone to praise him in any reasonable ways, but "hope of entire world"? Give me a break! If he is the hope of the world, I'd say there are potentially many politicians that can be seen this way as long as Oprah, Kennedy family, and the either media and press play the same role as they did for Obama in this election. OMG, give me a break, don't make me laugh out all my teeth over this! Media created an "Obama" that he's not even yet! Wake up everyone! This is the major reason that I can't bear looking at him or hear his voice no matter how good and capable he is in general as a person. Because of that I will not vote for him in general election regardless of his good ideas or plans! Please no more nightmares.
well I see nothing has changed on this site---just more spitting and hissing.The democrats have not had a president representing them for over 7 years and it looks like we will be without one for at least 5 more years.Damn--why do the republicans always outsmart us in the primaries?Because they cross parties and vote for who they want to run against---the weakest.they are laughing at us all the way to the oval office.
Well here we go!  The main-stream-media, and a lot of ill-informed and anti-Obama voters are so predictable.  Sen. Obama is now leading in the polls so EVERY LIE, EVERY INNUENDO, EVERY BIGOT, and EVERY EXAGGERATION will be FLOODING the airways and blogospheres from now on.  Most educated, well-informed/intelligent voters will see this for what it is- rhetoric and propaganda. But it's the buffoons/idiots/bigots like some of the ones who are blogging here who are advancing this mess because they know that there will be other ignorant people who will succumb to believe and want to believe these nasty/vile and sinister smears. Compared to the other candidates (McCain and Clinton), Obama is an angel and you know it. I could post EVERY nasty smear/scandal/corruption that I've heard and read about Clinton and McCain, but what's the point???  I have nothing to fear because I know that my candidate represents honor and dignity, and most Americans reflect the same decency, so I don't have to stoop to this level. But, what you fail to realize is that MOST Americans are a helluva lot smarter than you people give us credit for so we can see right through this, and we are the ones who will bring about CHANGE in spite of your vile agendas and vindictiveness.

OBAMA, 2008!
Here is a wake up call to all the Democrats and Independants. Those in white America who support McCain and Clinton will not support Obama in the general election. As sad as it is, whites dont dont support him now wont in November. The suppport he has now is the only support he will have against McCain. He won mostly small causus style primary runs and alot of red states. It is very deceptive when you look at the big picture. He wont win the southern republican states verse McCain. Plus there is so much against him now. The Nation of Islam, Tony Rezko, Larry Sinclair and the gay sex thing, Michelle Obama and her unpatriotic statement and all of Obama's anti-American actions. I am a political analyst in a "RED" state. This is the buzz under the table and McCain expects an easy victory against Obama once everything is out on the table. I am not telling you who to vote for, but do some research and weigh in all the factors before you make you decision.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=699405

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google