ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Oh, Canada

Posted: Monday, March 03, 2008 3:20 PM by Domenico Montanaro

From NBC’s Domenico Montanaro
Obama campaign manager David Plouffe dismissed the Canada-NAFTA story today, calling it “way overblown” and part of the Clinton campaign's "kitchen sink" strategy

Plouffe said Austan Goolsbee, a senior adviser and professor at the University of Chicago, met with Canadian officials unofficially during a walking tour he gave them at his university. 

“This is being reported as an official meeting of an Obama representative,” Plouffe said. “They were having a casual conversation, and the report on that conversation is just not accurate.”

The report he was referring to was a memo by the Canadian government, released to the AP, which characterizes the meeting this way, “Noting anxiety among many U.S. domestic audiences about the U.S. economic outlook, Goolsbee candidly acknowledged the protectionist sentiment that has emerged, particularly in the Midwest, during the primary campaign. He cautioned that this messaging should not be taken out of context and should be viewed as more about political positioning than a clear articulation of policy plans."

But Plouffe had told reporters days earlier in another conference call that Goolsbee did not meet with Canadian officials. When asked about it today, he said it was “not a formal conversation. This is something that was done in context of his university. So, again this is being way overblown. This is part of the kitchen sink campaign.”

The Canadian Embassy also released a statement on the matter, and it was circulated by the Obama campaign. “In the recent report produced by the Consulate General in Chicago, there was no intention to convey, in any way, that Senator Obama and his campaign team were taking a different position in public from views expressed in private, including about NAFTA,” the statement said. “We deeply regret any inference that may have been drawn to that effect.”

It went on to highlight something that has bubbled over in Canadian Parliament today: “The people of the United States are in the process of choosing a new President and are fortunate to have strong and impressive candidates from both political parties. Canada will not interfere in this electoral process."

*** UPDATE *** At a hectic-sounding press conference, Obama took questions on the issue and said, per NBC/NJ's Aswini Anburajan, "As I said just understand the context. Nobody reached out to the Canadians to try to reassure them. They reached out, unbeknownst to the rest of us, they reached out to Mr. Goolsbee who provided them with a tangible conversation and repeated what we've said on the campaign trail, which is that we belive in trade with Canada.

"We believe in trade with Mexico; we think the terms of NAFTA have to be altered, so that the labor standards and the environmental standards are enforceable. But there's nothing more there. I have said repeatedly that I believe that NAFTA should be rengotiated. This is not a new posititon; it dates back many years. During my U.S. Senate campaign, I was criticized for taking this position. It's been well reported; it hasn't altered, which stands in contrast to Sen. Clinton's position, which has altered substantially. "

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Does anybody know why the Canadian officials were visiting there?
Obama's new slogan should be "Change to the same."
Yeah who would ever believe a democrat would do anything to put our oil supply in jeopardy?
Politico is reporting that Canada has apologized for the misunderstanding and clarified its "leak."
FLIP FLOP OBAMA, TALK ABOUT TALKING OUT OF BOTH SIDES OF HIS MOUTH. P.S. IN THE LAST 48 HRS. THERE HAS BEEN A "SIGNIFICIANT SHIFT" TO HILLARY CLINTON IN BOTH TEXAS AND OHIO. THE HILLARY EXPRESS IS PICKING UP SPEED ,AND NOT LOOKING BACK. HISTORY IS GOING TO BE MADE THIS TUESDAY,PUT THAT ON YOUR CALANDER.
I do not trust Obama. Obama is telling lies in Ohio about NAFTA (I have received his lie filled mailers). Obama states he is against NAFTA all the while telling Canada he's FOR NAFTA and that he's just pandering to Ohio voters. Shame on Obama.

Obama is unqualified to be President of the U.S. and is unelectable.

I refer you to Ambassador Joseph Wilson's thoughtful piece printed in the Huffington Post today. Read it and VOTE SMART, VOTE FOR HILLARY! Hillary is the most qualified to be President and the most electable.

Ohio LOVES Hillary and if you can't win Ohio you can't win the Presidency. HIllary has already proven she can win big in the big states that are the must wins for the Dems in November. Hillary's credentials are unmatched.

The Dems are foolishly gambling on Obama, who has questionable character and judgment.

For example, REZKO, his friend of 17 years who is starting his trial on federal criminal charges today in Chicago.

For example, PASTOR WRIGHT, the man who Obama calls his MENTOR, is an avowed anti-semitic, anti-white, pro-Louis Farakaan black supremecy supporter. YIKES! Why does Obama call THIS man his mentor?

For example, BILL AYERS, an admitted participant in the bomb plannings of New York and the Pentagon and other AMerican targets. This radical terrorist along with his wife Bernadine Dorhn would likely be serving life sentences for their federal crimes if the FBI had not bungled their cases. INstead, they hang around Chicago with Obama in Hyde Park, contributing to his campaign and working together in radical community groups in Chicago. YIKES!

Why does Obama hang with such an unsavory crowd?

WHO IS BARACK OBAMA?

What I know of him, I do not trust.

I TRUST HILLARY CLINTON IMPLICITLY WITH OUR NATIONAL SECURITY AND OUR DOMESTIC POLICIES.

Hillary must remain in this race through the convention. By then, Obama will be exposed for the fraud that he is and he will be so OVER.

VOTE SMART!  VOTE HILLARY!
Will you guys give this the same press coverage as you did the UNSUBSTANTIATED ERRONEOUS version of the story?  Please.
I, too, dismiss that memo as not representing Obama's actual position on the NAFTA.  The meeting was a low key meeting and does not necessarily reflect Obama's policy positions. The only time he will have the power to make policy pescriptions is when he is elected.
I don't think that if Obama is pro-NAFTA, the nation's largest labor federation, Change to Win, won't be endorsing him after carefully reviewing his positions.
canadian parliament just on msnbc---they want to fire their member for meeting with obama about nafta.
cho cho cho !!! The Hillary Express is movin' down the track. And there is no one going to stop it. hillaryclinton.com .
Yea, and I know a guy who said Obama is really a muslim! Maybe Clinton should bring him up as a reliable source for her next attempt to smear Obama with bad information.

I mean seriously, a memo with faulty information circulating in another country is what Hillary is using to try and attack Obama on now?

I can't wait for this to be over so the Democrats can start focusing on the real opponent, John McCain and the Republicans.
Can we get Joan Crawford Clinton, her Mommie Dearest pitbulls (Penn & Wolfson) and their sleaze politicop act out of the way so we can get on the with the business of people who care about this country? Or don't people get that sooner or later all the venom spewed by these pack of self-serving scropions will eventually turn around and sting them as well.?
Obama tells the people of Ohio tha NAFTA was the reason that they lost their jobs and if they elected him he woud force Canada and Mexico to renegoiateits terms.  He at the same time tells the canadians that he is just saying this for political consuption.  Translated that means he is saying it just to get elected.  Now that is that change we can beleive in.  Wake up Ohio and Texas, Obama is one of those old style politicians that will say anything to get elected.  Luckily there is still time to stop him.
I thought Canada wanted out of NAFTA from what i hear from my Canadian friends whom i do ALLOT of buisness with.. most of Canda thinks NAFTA did not deliver on the promises and wants a withdrawl or re-configure

ALSO for the Canadian government to come out to clarify that the Obama campaign did not make that statemen; clarifying a story made in the heat of an election in a primary proccess in anther country.. seems REALLY odd...

I think the Clintons (and the Patty from SD) should be very carefull about pushing this story it may be a plant and come back to embarass them very badly.

I doubt very seriously the OBama campaign would be so stupid as to do somthing like that.. and that the Canadian government would ever bother to "negotiate" with a poltical canidate in a PRIMARY ELECTION.. no way ..

just too much does not add up here..
Well I just watched your report and they were fighting about it in the Canadian Parliamnet and basically both sides said the story was false!! SO WHERE IS THE OUTRAGE in another falsehood circulated by Howard Wolfson on your tv show??!! Come on MSNBC, challenge these people when they say this stuff that you know isn't true!! Just because you're treading backwards so Hillary doesn't get mad at you again, you don't have to be the HRC news outlet!!
Obama and his cult members are starting to show their true colors arent they. McCain will make mincemeat out of the youngster.
Go to cnn right now on line and check out Hillary clinton. 3:45 p.m. e.s.t. or go to hillary clinton.com tonight at 6:30 p.m. c.s.t for her town hall meeting.
The Obama banwagon people talk a lot about change, however if Obama get's the nomination for the general election, they might wake up in the early morning of November 5, 2008 with a change they don't like, a change with McCain in Pensylvania Ave which is in reality not a change because McCain will implement and follow the same policies and strategies like Bush.
The word "change" become meaningless when we scrutnize the votes that Obama casted on the floor of the senate, most of the time he voted with the Republicans on issues like Funding the War, Class Action Reform, Credit Card Reform, Limiting Non-Economic Damages, Mining Law of 1872, Energy Policy....etc.....
Obama is not an agent of change simply because his record shows that most of the time he capitulated to the Republicans, and we can not trust someone who about NAFTA says something to the American people and says the opposite to the Canadians.
Now we still have a chance in Texas, Ohio, Rhode Island and Vermont to vote for Hillary and  secure her nomination for the general election, she's the real agent of change, she has a clear vision and a detailed plan how to change our country for the better and she's most likely the one who can beat McCain in the general election and bring security and prosperity back to the American people.      
Have you seen the blow-up going on right now in the Canadian Parliament...both sides are saying the meeting...or reports from and of the meeting are false and they want whoever is involved in the Canadian Goverenment with this report the Clinton campaign is pushing be fired.
Clinton supporters DO NOT READ!

If you do, you will subject to facts that minimize the affects of your ill-informed arguments.
The Canadian Embassy also released a statement on the matter, and it was circulated by the Obama campaign. “In the recent report produced by the Consulate General in Chicago, there was no intention to convey, in any way, that Senator Obama and his campaign team were taking a different position in public from views expressed in private, including about NAFTA,” the statement said. “We deeply regret any inference that may have been drawn to that effect.”

OK, so end of story.

How is an AP story released by the Canadian government Hillary's fault???  Typical Obama smokescreen.  Blame Hillary!!
Canadian officials,
I cannot believe you people released that  inaccurate memo! As an ex Canadian citizen, I am  ashamed of your actions and I asking you to please stay out of our election,thank you!
It is what it is.  Even a dumb ol' school Dem like me knows how to read.

Buckeyes take note.  You've being punked by Obama.
If Canada doesn't wish to interfere, why did it release the memo and only later issue a retraction of sorts that confirm David Plouffe's assertion that this is way overblown and that Goolsbee was meeting with Canadian officials in his university role and not that of the campaign?
Mr. Plouffe is correct that this is yet another deparate attempt by the Clinton camp to throw everything they can at Senator Obama to see what can stick, whether it is true or not.  This, along with the "...he's not a Muslim, as far as I know...." and the constant barrage against his experience (Senator Obama has actually held elective office longer than Senator Clinton, and the landmarks of both of their legislative careers are similar in length), come from a candidate who in 2007 vowed not to run a negative campaign.
Now, of course, her ads and attacks in speeches (yes, Senator Clinton gives speeches too; so does Senator McCain.  Every candidate gives speeches), are called "drawing contrasts."
I wonder what Senator Clinton would tell a delegation from Canada about NAFTA, given her response to questions posed during the last debate?
According to the latest Zogby poll, Obama has a slight lead over Clinton in Ohio and Texas. This is just another attempt by HRC and MSM to knock him off message one day before "JR. Super Tuesday." It will fail, like all the others.
So what is it Obama are you for NAFTA or are you aginst NAFTA or is it you were for being aginst nafta
or is it now you are aginst being aginst NAFTA.
Or is it that once you are elected then you will be for NAFTA even though you told labor you are aginst NAFTA.
Now you say we should not be afraid of free trade. Your positions seem to blow with the wind like Kerry's sailboat !!
That picture of you with the white flag of surrender does not make you  look like a muslim it makes you look week.
If you can not stand up for the homeland's middleclass citizens now.What can we expect if elected? You wont have the Hilster to refer to. If you have to refer to the Hillster then why even bother running why not just refer to Senator Clinton and make her president ?
Why don't you just say its onesided agreements and cutthroat wages that wreck free trade STAND UP FOR THE HOMELAND
Countries like Mexico are our trade enemies countries tthat provide good wages to workers are our friends.
And yet, despite the overwhelming evidence that this story is a NON-STORY, Hillary and Howard Wolfson keep on spewing out the insinuations. What about the fact that the original story put out by CTV also indicted the Clinton campaign??? She denies that but somehow can't find the requisite sense of fairness (and truthfulness) to acknowledge what the Canadian government actually said on the matter. Hmmm. Did you see her on 60 Minutes last night? It's business as usual in smearville.
By the way, that ad about the phone ringing at 3AM could have been made by John McCain. Does this mean there's no real distinction between the two??? Will she reallly pull troops out of Iraq or is she just saying that to get elected?
Thank you Sen. Clinton.  You have made my candidate grow even stronger after climbing through the endless slime that you and your agents have thrown at him.  I guess it's like Nietschke's quote "Whatever doesn't kill me makes me stronger..."  If anyone can say that he hasn't been properly vetted after the amount of untruthful attacks that Sen. Clinton has hurled, then they must live in a fantasy world.

This apology needs to be spread far and wide by these perpetrators.  I pray that the people in the March 4th contests will end Sen. Clinton's dishonorable campaign and that Sen. Obama will now be allowed to focus on the upcoming general election.  I would hope that Hillary will bow out while she still has some dignity left.  However, I cringe at the thought that she has one kamikaze attack left to inflict.  Deep down I know that she won't stop until she destroys the Party.
Will the press do it's job and say this story was false or will it continue to print Clinton campaign spin as fact?

It seems that all Hillary had to do was bark and whine at the press and now they've become her surrogate, repeating every unsubstantiated claim as if it were carved in stone.
Oh come on.  So this official Canadian memo was written up and passed out all because of a college tour?  They really expect us to believe this.  And now it has been disproved because an official from Chicago "says so."  MSNBC please do your job and investigate. We are talking about filling the most important position in the world and we have people talking out both sides of their mouths and people turning a blind eye.  
As a Canadian, I hope that this doesn't result into too many changes for NAFTA. If Clinton / Obama want to revisit the agreement and makes changes that are favorable to Americans, then maybe we should look at the oil we send to down south.  It works both ways, if you want to satisfy the needs of a couple of states, then maybe punishing the whole country with tariffs on oil would be appropriate.

I am tired of this posturing, if you say you are going to do something, then do it, if not then don't say anything on the subject at all.
Hillary Rodham Clinton will be our next president. It is written in the stars. It will be.
How can we let Hillary Clinton repeat this erroneous story for the next two days? She must know by now that the story was a false story and who in the world even knows who wrote the memo!! OBAMA SUPPORTERS: Write this station and others to let them know that we won't tolerate false news articles being presented by the reporters (like Candy someone on CNN) and the candidates as real stories!!!
My daughter lives in Canada and she said the Canadian Government is very unhappy about regarding the lie about Obama and them having a conversation, in fact they are trying to find the person in Canada who may have said this and are going to FIRE them.  Clinton and her campaign are not to be TRUSTED!  How can you vote for a person like her!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Smart Americans stand-up.  The smear tactics are beginning to bloom. The media and others thinks the average American is to stupid to see through their BS.  SO they will try to interpret anything that seems dirty to make it dirty just to slander Barak Obama.  People of OLD are scared that we are going to have someone of color in the white house, but not only that someone that will do what others have not been able to do.  BE A PRESIDENT FOR THE PEOPLE BY THE PEOPLE and not for the ELITES and the BIG COOPERATION.  Stay Strong Barak Obama, we are with you.
It's disgusting how the Hillzilla campaign makes up stuff from 'Obama may be a Muslim' to 'He is a Canadian Spy'.

I rather believe that Hillary is a man than the crap her campaign is shooting out.
I don't believe this was any big deal..This is just another attempt to throw out as much dirt as she can in hopes that simple minded people will fall for it. Hillary is the queen of dirty politics and will try to win by any means neccessary. As far as Rezko, the Clintons have plenty of associations with people they are trying to keep voters from finding out about, some, have been revealed. All politicians have skeletons in their closet, but the Clinton's have a whole cemetary.
"Does anybody know why the Canadian officials were visiting there?'
oknOK:
I believe they have a consulate in Chicago as well as NY and LA.
Ohio would be making a HUUUUUGE mistake if they vote for Hillary. Hello, half your state is unemployed as a direct result of the Clintons. It's called NAFTA. It was the major thing that Clinton trumpeted in his re-election bid and was a hallmark legislation/treaty of his administration. It has cost the state dearly and you all would be STUPID to give her any sort of prize for it.
Another "intelligent well-informed" rant of insanity from Ms. Red Phone at 3:00 a.m. and her band of followers blown wide open. LOL!!! Is this the "experience" with world leaders Mrs. C is hanging her claws on? How many ways can you spell pathetic?
NEWS ALERT.... IT'S FINALLY HAPPENING. AMERICA IS SEEING THE "LIGHT". THE MOMENTUM TO HILLARY IS MOVING VERY STRONG AND FAST.THE DEMOCRATIC RACE IS IN FOR A NEW BEGINNING THIS TUESDAY. STAY TUNED FOR MORE DETAILS OR GO TO hillaryclinton.com.
I ask the people in Ohio and Texas to vote for Barack Obama. He projects the views of Americans that things are bad with the war in Iraq and the failing economy BUT sees the future with HOPE. And that things will get better if we, as Americans, work together to make it better. Listen to his speeches where he always mentions "we." Hillary is a smart person who knows policy well but she is also a very devisive figure. Her speeches are full of "me" and "you" and "them." Her negatives run about 50% across the nation. THAT is not a UNITED States of America. We are in a time of crisis, you could say the Depression or WWII of our time and WE will need the involvement of ALL Americans, not just half of us, to make us great again. And Barack Obama is the President who can lead US in that direction.
"cho cho cho !!! The Hillary Express is movin' down the track. And there is no one going to stop it. hillaryclinton.com ."
Chelse;
Except for the reality that that bridge ahead that goes back to the 1990's is out.
I bet you one thing, this mischaracterization from the Clinton campaign is really not building a trusting relationship if she is elected.
As a supporter of Senator Obama I used to be surprised when Senator Clinton's supporters attacked not only the candidate I support, but also insulted me directly.  I am used to the insults now, but still find the tactic an extremely odd one.

I do not think Senator Clinton's ever-changing message has much chance of winning, although Rush Limbaugh is giving it the college try and asking Republicans to go out there, vote against their consciences and put her over the top against Senator Obama.  

Nonetheless, I would like to ask all of you who constantly insult me, all of the States that voted overwhelmingly for Senator Obama, the millions of voters who voted for, donated to and volunteer for Senator Obama, how do you think this is helpful?  Do you think you can insult us yesterday, today and tomorrow and somehow we will all suddenly realize we are masochists who enjoy the insult so much the "sky will open" and we will suddenly realize Senator Clinton's cynicsm is the right course?  

Next time you decide to create an argument for why Senator Clinton should win this, try telling us what you like about her.  Don't tell us we are delusional cultists for supporting Senator Obama.  It makes you sound like you are demented and only aggravates the other side of the argument.  Do try to have a discussion without being disagreeable.  Instead, tell us something about Senator Clinton that you like.  Your support seems rather vehement, surely you could find ONE positive argument?  It would be a welcome change.
Another negative strategy by the Clinton Campaign. I am praying so hard that God will help us all to see the truth, to help all the people in Texas, Ohio Vermont and Rhode Island to see the true color of the Clintons. If they'll win because of this "kitchen sink" strategy, I honestly believe we will no longer get involve to make America a place to be proud of.
It is really amazing the lengths the Clintons will go to attack their opponents. For those of you that believe that there was an official meeting please read the statement by the Canadian government…oh but I forgot, the Canadian government, like everyone else is out to get Hillary and treat her unfairly like the media, the pundits, the Republicans etc. etc.

Forgive me for thinking that her campaign went from inevitable to “dying on the vine” because of arrogance and lack of preparation. I wish for once Hillary would simply stick to why she should vote FOR HER rather than vote AGAINST OBAMA, but she can't because her nature is too attack and be negative and that would not change if she became president. As a democrat I am appalled by the tactics the Clinton's have used from trying to make Obama the "Black Candidate" in South Carolina to alleging plagiarism when Hillary's best "genuine moment" and the end of the second to last debate was lifted from speeches her husband and John Edwards had given. She in essence has said you should not vote fro him because he is black, shallow, corrupt, incompetent and worse of all another George Bush. Obama, on the other hand, has said that Clinton would make a good president — certainly better than George Bush — but that he thinks he could do better which I think is fair.

I am a lifelong democrat and began as a Clinton supporter and if she wins I will vote for McCain because she is truly a shining example of divisiveness and the politics of personal destruction.
Are some of the commenters reading the same article as me? The article clearly states that the Obama campaign had nothing to do with the reports and that the Canadian government condemned the false reports about Obama's staff member. I guess reason cannot triumph over ignorance.

obamavets.com
This is the story I missed:

Clinton donations from troubled firmPosted: Friday, February 29, 2008 5:47 PM by Domenico Montanaro
Filed Under: 2008, Clinton
From NBC's Lisa Myers and Jim Popkin
Sen. Hillary Clinton has declined to return $170,000 in campaign contributions from individuals at a company accused of widespread sexual harassment, and whose CEO is a disbarred lawyer with a criminal record, federal campaign records show.

The federal government has accused the Illinois management consulting firm, International Profit Associates, or IPA, of a brazen pattern of sexual harassment including "sexual assaults," "degrading anti-female language" and "obscene suggestions."

In a 2001 lawsuit full of lurid details, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission claims that 103 women employees at IPA were victimized for years. The civil case is ongoing, and IPA vigorously denies the allegations.

"This is by far, hands down, the worst case I've ever experienced," said Diane Smason, one of the EEOC lawyers handling the lawsuit. "Every woman there experienced sex harassment, they were part of a hostile work environment of sex harassment. And this occurred from the top down."

Sen. Clinton's spokesman, Howard Wolfson, told NBC News in a statement that the senator decided to keep the funds because the lawsuit is "ongoing" and because none of the sexual harassment allegations has been proven in court.

"With regard to the pending harassment suit, as a general matter, the campaign assesses findings of fact in deciding whether to return contributions," Wolfson said.



SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=725654

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google