ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Oh, Canada

Posted: Monday, March 03, 2008 3:20 PM by Domenico Montanaro

From NBC’s Domenico Montanaro
Obama campaign manager David Plouffe dismissed the Canada-NAFTA story today, calling it “way overblown” and part of the Clinton campaign's "kitchen sink" strategy

Plouffe said Austan Goolsbee, a senior adviser and professor at the University of Chicago, met with Canadian officials unofficially during a walking tour he gave them at his university. 

“This is being reported as an official meeting of an Obama representative,” Plouffe said. “They were having a casual conversation, and the report on that conversation is just not accurate.”

The report he was referring to was a memo by the Canadian government, released to the AP, which characterizes the meeting this way, “Noting anxiety among many U.S. domestic audiences about the U.S. economic outlook, Goolsbee candidly acknowledged the protectionist sentiment that has emerged, particularly in the Midwest, during the primary campaign. He cautioned that this messaging should not be taken out of context and should be viewed as more about political positioning than a clear articulation of policy plans."

But Plouffe had told reporters days earlier in another conference call that Goolsbee did not meet with Canadian officials. When asked about it today, he said it was “not a formal conversation. This is something that was done in context of his university. So, again this is being way overblown. This is part of the kitchen sink campaign.”

The Canadian Embassy also released a statement on the matter, and it was circulated by the Obama campaign. “In the recent report produced by the Consulate General in Chicago, there was no intention to convey, in any way, that Senator Obama and his campaign team were taking a different position in public from views expressed in private, including about NAFTA,” the statement said. “We deeply regret any inference that may have been drawn to that effect.”

It went on to highlight something that has bubbled over in Canadian Parliament today: “The people of the United States are in the process of choosing a new President and are fortunate to have strong and impressive candidates from both political parties. Canada will not interfere in this electoral process."

*** UPDATE *** At a hectic-sounding press conference, Obama took questions on the issue and said, per NBC/NJ's Aswini Anburajan, "As I said just understand the context. Nobody reached out to the Canadians to try to reassure them. They reached out, unbeknownst to the rest of us, they reached out to Mr. Goolsbee who provided them with a tangible conversation and repeated what we've said on the campaign trail, which is that we belive in trade with Canada.

"We believe in trade with Mexico; we think the terms of NAFTA have to be altered, so that the labor standards and the environmental standards are enforceable. But there's nothing more there. I have said repeatedly that I believe that NAFTA should be rengotiated. This is not a new posititon; it dates back many years. During my U.S. Senate campaign, I was criticized for taking this position. It's been well reported; it hasn't altered, which stands in contrast to Sen. Clinton's position, which has altered substantially. "

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Dear Mrs. Clinton,

Thank you for your continued support of Mr. Obama's campaign. The more mud you throw the less the Republican's have to use in the general election. Once again, your sleaze doesn't stick. An entire foreign governmen is in an uproar because of your Canadian/NAFTA snafu. Nothing says loser like making up stuff and having member's of Canadian parliament denounce your claims on international television.

Thank you for being so incompetent in your campaign that you cannot even run an effective negative message. Seriously, you can just pick the silver platter you would like to serve your concession upon now.

This campaign is not about Senator Obama or any other candidate, but rather, about that which Senator Obama represents.  If the central theme of Senator Clinton's campaign HAD BEEN (from the beginnig) the same as his, the nominating process for the Democrats would have ended with the February 5th results.  If the campaign HAD BEEN about EXPERIENCE sufficient enough to be President, then why (as Senator Clinton & some Others claim), did not Senator Clinton (THE EXPERIENCED ONE) "close the deal" as of February 5th; i.e., Senator Obama's qualifications for the Office of President have not changed since starting the campaign...and yet, he's more strongly in the race now than at the start.

The bottom line to these continuing arguments is classic:  There are many who fuel them for the sake of "milking" as much money out of OUR ignorance as possible; i.e., hundreds of millions in advertising dollars, TV ratings, and patronage of other media.  This is all being done while the economy is adversely impacting those who are keeping the campaign going with strife and contention - the ones who are impacted the most by the problems in housing, health, gas and food prices.  The real winners?  THE MEDIA AND THEIR ADVERTISERS!!!!! - NOT JOHN Q PUBLIC CITIZEN - NOT MAIN STREET, BUT WALLSTREET.  

There's a time to speak, and there's a time to shut up and take action (which might include not voting at all).  Otherwise, you present yourself as the proverbial hypocrite that you so vehemently denounce. Say what you mean and mean what you say by taking action accordingly!!...and then, follow your leader, your AMERICAN President, whomever he or she happens to be.  For the present, this also includes President George W. Bush.
Did Clinton staffers create and "leak" these allegations?  The timing seems very convenient.  Or, given that the allegations are false, and the Canadians in parliament are expressing that they are false vehemently, does the Hillary campaign have an updated response, based on ALL of this NEW information?  I'd consider voting for her if she made the honorable and honest choice by condemning these false reports.  
obamas BIG MISTAKE.  One should not lie to the American public !!!  Maybe you should exit gracefully.


Go Hilliary
It all boils down to: Obama is not who he says he is
MSNBC - needs to update the story... Get the facts.
MSNBC - Update the story - you are doing a disservice to the American Public and Barack Obama.
I strongly believe the Obama people said exactly what was stated.  They are overly confident and when one is overly confident mistakes are made.  Now, I am waiting to hear the usual rhetoric, thats not what I meant.  Let the fun begin!  
THINK WHERE WE(USA/WORLD) COULD BE 4 YRS. FROM NOW! OBAMA or CLINTON(S).......

YES WE CAN!
The truth is coming out...beware of OBAMA.....think before you vote....his innocent talk(lies) will take you nowhere....as it says "The sin shouts from the
roof of the sinner’s house"......
I think that you people in Ohio have the IQ of the number letters in your states name. So that is why you would vote for HRC. I don't think most of you are smart enough to vote.
For those Hillary supporters who keep referring to Obama and his "cult supporters".  Remember, if, God forbid, Hillary wins this nomination, she will need these "cult supporters"  to put her in the White House.  If I were you, I would be careful about who I alienate at this preliminary stage.
It is amazing that this story can be debunked by everyone, including the Canadians and the HRC camp still continues to spread it. Some people just will not allow themselves to be confused by the facts.
I TOLD YOU SO..........
O B A M A  IS THE BIGGEST JOKE OF THE CENTURY.....
MR..FLIP FLAP......
HE'S RUNNING AS A "CHANGE" BUT IT'S ALL A BIG LIE..
VOTERS BEWARE ABOUT HIS HIDDEN AGENDA.....
how good it is that oboma, is at the pick of his life,he's what being the president of the united states,cos he gat all the quality,i urge americans, to get a new, taste of leadership,then u can compare and contrast, it is not how long u have being there, its how well did u make use of the office.there is one thing that is constant in life, that is change,it has come to american political grounds,and it must make its impact,there is no illisit comments that can stop it.but i will ask Americans to embrace it with all their heart and work with it,its for there good.
VOTE HILLARY 2008 - THE CANDIDATE OF SUBSTANCE.

SORRY OBAMA.  YOU CAN'T HAVE IT BOTH WAYS.  YOUR NO SUBSTANCE DOUBLE TALK IS FINALLY COMING BACK TO KICK YOU IN THE BUTT.  YOU WERE SAFE WHILE YOU GOT AWAY WITH TALKING ABOUT NOTHING, NOTHING, NOTHING.  BUT WHEN HILLARY AND THE PEOPLE PUT YOU ON THE SPOT TO START TALKING ABOUT SOMETHING WITH SUBSTANCE (AS HILLARY HAS DONE ALL ALONG), YOU GOT STUMPED FIRST TRY FROM CANADA ON YOUR NAFTA DOUBLE TALK!!  THE ONLY REASON YOU CAN SAY YOU NEVER CHANGED A POSITION IS BECAUSE YOU NEVER TALK ABOUT ANYTHING REAL. YOUR ENTIRE CAMPAIGN IS NOT FOCUSED ON ISSUES TO HELP OUR COUNTRY, BUT ON HOW BEST TO PLAY ON THE EMOTIONS OF THE PEOPLE -- TO INSTIGATE THEM -- WITHOUT EVER SAYING ANYTHING THAT YOU CAN BE HELD TO.  ITS EASY NOT TO BE CAUGHT SAYING ANYTHING WRONG WHEN YOU HAVE NO RECORD OF SAYING ANYTHING MEANINGFUL.  WELL, YOU ARE FINALLY STARING TO BUILD A RECORD, AND YOU WON'T ALWAYS BE ABLE TO TALK, TALK, TALK YOUR WAY OUT OF THINGS.

VOTE HILLARY 2008  -  WE KNOW HER RECORD, WE KNOW EVERYTHING ABOUT THE CLINTONS.  WHAT DO WE REALLY KNOW ABOUT OBAMA?
Here is more about Osama Hussein dishonesty and sleazy
politics.  Go to www.savagepolitics.com and learned
about what he is done to make sure he secures the
Puerto Rico vote.  He wrote a letter to the Governor
who is up for re-election and offer his support in
exchange for a primary that will show him as a winner
of that Hispanic vote, an amount of $3,000.000 was
offered`to assists with the primary.  He play the race
card assuring this man that we will the candidate that
will better serve their people, and mocking Hillary as a white woman who did not have the color of his
skin.  Puerto Ricans are black and brown and are not
able to vote but they do participate and they are
mostly democrats who have supported Clinton in the
past.  Please do your research before electing this
dirty clown.
I’m thoroughly convinced that Obama haters are ignorant of the world around them.
They only see what they want to see and they hear what they want to hear say whatever sounds plausible!
I understand how people of old could believe in witches.
Every lie becomes the truth to weak-minded people.
We have a once in a lifetime opportunity to positively redirect this country and her we are engaging in tit for tat semantics and none substantive accusations.
I work for Hillary then flew the coop for good reason. You fill in the blanks!
Vote Obama and get to work on rebuilding this great nation
I understand how people of old could believe in witches.
Every lie becomes the truth to weak-minded people.
We have a once in a lifetime opportunity to positively redirect this country and her we are engaging in tit for tat semantics and none substantive accusations.
I work for Hillary then flew the coop for good reason. You fill in the blanks!
Vote Obama and get to work on rebuilding this great nation
Oh, Obama supporters.  Who's whining now?
Okay, I've had it.  This is a non-event.  Someone started this story at this time in the campaign to damage Sen. Obama - whether it was Clinton or the Canadians' doing - it is old dirty tricks again - to enhance someone's agenda.  Are we not yet sophisticated enough, smart enough to recognize garbage when we see it and read it.  If it should alter the race in favor of Clinton, she will be elected for the wrong reasons and we will damage our democratic process.  I would hope at some point (sooner rather than later - preferably  before stories go public) that the press ask the right questions - who gains from this information, why now, how did happen?  It would be more useful to the public than rushing to carry water for those who use such tactics.
History will be filled with facts regarding how the Clintons, news media and  pundits destroyed the democratic party because of a candidates color, and Billary's win at all costs campaign. It is amazing that people who claim to love this country would destroy it to protect white only institutions. Is the USA the new South Africa of old? When you read betweeen the lines, MSNBC, CNN, ABC,NBC aand CBS are saying lets stop the black guy. We have always know where Fox and rightwing talk show hosts were on the issue of race. However, given the possibility of a black man being seriously considered for the presidency, they ( with the exception of Keith Olberman)seem to have morphed into a lynch mob as ruthless as in the Jim Crow days. Notice how they all are instructive on how Hillary can beat Obama. This country will never change because of  its fear of change. Black men and women have fought in every war.  Even when the forces were segregated, Blacks did the right thing because of love of country. No other race has had to fight beside whites in conflict and return home to fight the same folk for the right to simply have the same rights as others. The Clintons are beginning to personify the greatest evils in America-racism and bigotry. Hillary has finally shown her true colors and will never be elected to the Whitehouse. If she wins the nomination, you can bet that she will have destroyed the party to the extent that McCain will easily win and republicans will again rule both houses of congress. Can you imagine 50 years of republican rule? Just look back over the previous 7 years to get some idea...
History will be filled with facts regarding how the Clintons, news media and  pundits destroyed the democratic party because of a candidates color, and Billary's win at all costs campaign. It is amazing that people who claim to love this country would destroy it to protect white only institutions. Is the USA the new South Africa of old? When you read betweeen the lines, MSNBC, CNN, ABC,NBC aand CBS are saying lets stop the black guy. We have always know where Fox and rightwing talk show hosts were on the issue of race. However, given the possibility of a black man being seriously considered for the presidency, they ( with the exception of Keith Olberman)seem to have morphed into a lynch mob as ruthless as in the Jim Crow days. Notice how they all are instructive on how Hillary can beat Obama. This country will never change because of  its fear of change. Black men and women have fought in every war.  Even when the forces were segregated, Blacks did the right thing because of love of country. No other race has had to fight beside whites in conflict and return home to fight the same folk for the right to simply have the same rights as others. The Clintons are beginning to personify the greatest evils in America-racism and bigotry. Hillary has finally shown her true colors and will never be elected to the Whitehouse. If she wins the nomination, you can bet that she will have destroyed the party to the extent that McCain will easily win and republicans will again rule both houses of congress. Can you imagine 50 years of republican rule? Just look back over the previous 7 years to get some idea...


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=725654

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google