ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Exit polls: Why Clinton won Ohio

Posted: Wednesday, March 05, 2008 12:49 AM by Domenico Montanaro

From MSNBC's Norah O'Donnell and Adam Verdugo
Hillary Clinton's win in Ohio was shouldered on the strength of her core constituencies: women, whites, labor, seniors, and she narrowed the gap in groups that had been strong for Barack Obama.

Let's take a closer look at the white vote. Overall, she won a solid victory among whites. Clinton took 65% of the vote to Obama's 33%.

As in other contests Obama won the black vote by a wide margin (86%-14%). But remember, blacks make up only 19% of the Democratic electorate, so the white vote was key for Clinton.

The generation gap among whites starts at a younger point than we've seen elsewhere. Only the under-30 groups broke for Obama (49%-46%). And as you can see, it was a far narrower gap than we have seen in other contests. All of the other age groups among whites went for Clinton (ages 30-44, 62%-38%; ages 45-64, 68%-29%; ages 65+, 74%-23%).

There was more of a split among whites by education. Those without college educations going overwhelmingly for Clinton with 71% of the vote. The numbers were closer for those with a college education -- where Clinton won by 54% to Obama's 43%.

Clinton regained her lead among the "white working class" -- those who make less than $50,000 (69%-28%). She also won among whites, who make more than $50,000 (61%-37%).

Clinton also showed her strength in other areas: She won the late deciders; she won among union households; she was seen as best qualified to be Commander-In-Chief, and she was seen as the candidate with the best chance of winning in the fall.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

It is time Barack Obama stopped playing nice and let loose the dogs of war.
Either that or submit, groveling on bended knee to the Bull Connor party of the Clinton's.
HILLARY!!!!!!!!!
I'M A INDEPENDENT TEXAN,AND I VOTED FOR YOU TODAY BECAUSE I BELIEVE YOU'RE THE BEST QUALIFY TO WIN IN NOVEMBER.
20% of Ohio voters went against Barack Obama because he is a Black Man. This is the new legacy of the Clintons. Hillary will have to do quite a lot of apologizing to the black voter base she no longer has to be on any kind of ticket with Barack. A campaign based on racist fears is not the way this was headed. It seems to be all she knows how to do now. I'm also getting the message that the GOP feels she won't raise as much money as Obama. There's a split party who won't contribute to her like they would have to him. Which is true. And there's the thirsty wolf effect - the Rush folk who just want to trounce her. So they can't wait to get to her. Meanwhile, the defecting democrats will let them do it, feeling she would be getting her comeuppance.
Okay, you're right.  Toothless white folk pull for Hillary.  In Ohio.  But it's a fifty state process.  'White' did not seem to disserve Obama much in Iowa, Wiscconsin, Virginia, MD, etc.  Look for other identifiers, Mr. Slice and Dice.

Let's see where things stand in the morning...after the Texas primary votes are distributed by district, after Ohio votes receive same treatment, after a third of TX caucus votes are given (60% to Obama per present numbers).  Suspect Obama will have fended off a very, very negative (and desperate) challenge and that the remaining chances for Clinton will be all that much smaller.  Must she really put all the rest of us through this, and possibly endanger November success?
OBama still needs to answer all the questions that  the media are afraid to ask him.......

Rezco

Racist all black church who praises Farrakhan

Racist Pastor who praises Farrakhan and gives him award

William Ayers, OBama's terrorist friend

Nafta/Canada lies and flip flop
She won because 9 out of 10 black racist voters cannot stop her - we don't need your vote

Clinton '08
Shut up FR! She won because she successfully played race and fear to trickle a fearful and racist Ohio. If she remains in the race by the end of this month, I will pledge to vote for McWar -- she is much more polarizing than him for me and they both voted for the Iraq war.
Funny how the exit polls all of the sudden have changed...! This whole thing was a scam! The election was rigged! And the media shows a blind eye to this! What a shame! Watch me tune out if Hillary somehow manages to steal this! Explain this to me; Why does Obama have the high turnout, while Hillary doesn't? And wins with 15-18% while the polls showed a tie ON ELECTION DAY!
This whole thing is a fairy tale!
Shame on you MSM! You have NO BACKBONE MSNBC! No integrity!
DUMBAMA is losing in Texas delegates right now with 75 percent voting - the caucuses will back Hillary Clinton because she won the state.

NEXT!!!

Clinton '08
Hillary ROCKS! If you dont vote for her you're an idiot! :p
Congrats to Billary McCain on her victory in Texas and Ohio...  Wait till your White House experience starts to come up in the next few weeks... We don't need another Senate trial.  Who is financing your new found wealth...
Please leave race and gender out of your analyses. Senator Clinton didn't win because she's a Caucasian woman. She won because she's the best candidate for our country's next CIC.
Poor, poor losers.  Those who wrote in support of Obama sound like twins to the description of the Clinton supporters they gave.  Did anyone ever think of giving credit where credit is due?  
It's ok, because pretty soon we'll see who will be in the Black House.
Regarding Ohio, what does it mean if Clinton wins 54-43 among whites with college educations and 61-37 among whites earning more than $50K?  Which group is turning out more: Uneducated whites earning more than $50K; or, Educated whites earning less than $50K?  Furthermore, which group is larger in Ohio: the uneducated wealthy or the educated poor?  
Hillary won because if it's ok for blacks to vote in goose step for Obama then We old throw away women will do the same for her. If Chris and Rachel and Keith slimed Obama the they just did Hillary, Jessee and Al would demand they get fired Ain't it great to live in America. God bless you all
I can not believe what a racist country we have. Blacks are voting for Obama 91%. MSNBC is the most bias new organization out there. Worse than FOX.They do not give Hillary a break or credit for anything. Today is the last day I watch them. Tomorrow I sell my GE stock that I have held for 17 years. This company must have a terrible managment structure to allow their reporters to report only personal opinions and prefrences. They are just trashy people on that network
Barack has a simple choice:

Drop out tomorrow or be ready to get nasty.  America (at least Texans and Ohioans) today proved that nasty deceptive campaigning works.

If Barack wants to play Mr. Nice Guy from here on out, that's fine.  We'll remember him twenty years from now as we remember Bill Bradley now; great ideas, good ideas, a looser in the Presidential campaign.
Wow, simply amazing all the screaming that is going on in these tag boards.  Personally I am all for Hillary.  I am sorry, I haven't seen any of this so called "Racism" that Hillary supposedly produced out here in OH.  If anything it was more like she completely disappeared off the maps!  All that was seen out here was Obama, Obama, Obama...rarely has Clinton even been MENTIONED in the news.  For which I think it is a shame and shows that the so called "impartiality" of the news really is not so.  So anyone who is going on about Hillary feeding on racist fears out here in OH, trust me, it really isn't so.  Guess you are going to find another reason to create for the reason that she won!
Oh Grow Up.  Neither Clinton is racist, their records on diversity are clear, and neither owe anyone an apology on this issue. For Bill to point out the obvious -- that a majority of blacks are voting for Obama (what is it, +85%) -- does not make him a racist!  He was just stating a fact!  Blacks are supporting Obama, Hispanics are supporting Hillary -- how does the mere stating of those facts make someone racist??  
We have two excellent Democratic candidates, and one will win.  The supporters should stop bashing each other -- these candidates are alike on 97% of their beliefs, so bashing one is the same as bashing the other.  Play by the rules, and may the best man (or woman) win.
BIG MONEY WAS EXCHANGED... TOO MANY RICH PEOPLE HAVE BACKED HILLARY... 60'S TYPE... SUPERDELEGATES WERE BOUGHT... JUST TO ENSURE CERTAIN PEOPLE SEE A LADY BECOME PRESIDENT... POLITICAL CORRECTNESS IS AS EVIL AS FACISM!!!!!!
Not at all surprised. I was born and raised in Ohio and I visit my family there regularly.  It must be said that it is the  most racially biggoted place I have lived out of 14 states. I know it seems strange (I am caucasian) to imagine... but no where have I ever seen an area so blatantly embrace and encourage discriminatory words and behavior.  The Ohio Valley in particular is uneducated and very behind the times in this area. People don't go see movies with blacks in them, they certainly aren't going to elect a black man president of the US!!  Sad, but true.  Not to mention Hillary has every major union in her back pocket and this is the heart of union country.  And you heard this from a conservative!
Doesn't matter what happened in Ohio and TX...just delaying the inevitable nomination of Senator Obama.
Not long ago there was an african american man who said how he would love to see an african american as President of the United States, but not Barrack Obama.....that has stuck in my mind ever since.  I too have had an uncomfortable feeling about Senator Obama's rushed careerand the overwhelming support the media seemed to be giving him over the other canidates and after reading for days about his 17 year affiliation with orginized crime in Chicago through his relationship with Mr. Rezko it all makes sense.  When asked about his relationship with Mr. Rezko Senator Obama's comments were to lead us to believe that he did not really know Mr. Rezko and had indeed only met the man on 2 occasions...........then why was this man the one he called to help him with his delema in securing the purchase of his mansion?  Perhaps Ohio and Texas voters read the papers or watch the news and their votes reflect that.....not everyone votes from a cult like dream state, a lot of folks vote after careful consideration of the facts they can glean from the media.  Good job Ohio and Texas!
I am so upset about your coverage I can hardly control my temper.  I have been ill for the last 18 months. I got sick 7 weeks after I lost my son to suicide so I have had lots of time to watch MSNBC while being acutely aware of the unfairness of the world.  If you treated Obama the way you treat Clinton you all would be on the radio with Don Imus.  Chris Matthews told John Edwards in an interview that his candidacy was meaningless because he was just another white, Protestant male runnning for president. Hillary didn't respond quickly enough for Chris regarding Obama's religion.  It's not an objective answer.  John McCain said he was an Episcopalian for years but now he says he's been a baptist for 20 years.  Someone could go to church every Sunday and not be Catholic.  Of course if it came out 6 months from now that Obama does have some Muslim beliefs or is a closet Muslim it would be that Hillary Clinton said he was a Christian so she showed poor judgement.  What do you think would happen if you said Obama should back out if he was in the exact position Clinton is in right now.  Oh my God.  It would be the end of civil rights and the free world as we know it.  Tonight Howard Fineman said Obama called Hillary tonight because he is basically a class act and has tried to hold himself above Clinton's campaign tactics.  Ran a response ad within 6 hours of that unvelievable hateful ad.  Fineman said Hillary didn't even mention Obama in speech.  Wrong.  Never corrected his misstatement when he returned from commercial.  Just now you showed a clip of Clinton's speech and left that out.  I like Obama.  He doesn't inspire me but I think he's a decent person.  He is not a saint who has temporarily descended to right this country.  He is a well programmed, talented politician with no experience as a leader.  Sound familiar?  Let it go.  
Many votes for Obama were protest votes against Hillary, or "the Clintons".  Obama might not get those votes in the fall, yet Hillary certainly won't either.
Chris Matthews is so blatantly biased against Hillary Clinton that he does not belong on the air.  Commentators are supposed to be objective unless it is stated otherwise.  Matthews takes every possible opportunity to diss Clinton, whether it's blunt or subtle.  If he isn't blunted, MSNBC will be the big loser in this election.
How come it's okay for black voters to support Sen Obama just because he's black but if white voters support Sen Clinton because she looks most like them it's consider racism? My personal opinion is that people should pick someone who they feel can best lead this country.
Why is it when Hilary wins she has played the race card, what makes you think she needs to do that to win? She is a strong well educated woman... Obama needs to answer many questions . Whats the truth about Nafa- his association with a known
criminal. Maybe the press needs to start asking him all kinds of questions like they do Hilary.
Another slap on MSBC`s face for being so anti-Clintons specially to Chris Matthews. If they are on air considering themselves analyst, MSNBC should start covering both campaigns with fair and equal manner. I am pretty sure MSNBC has tapes and records of their shows particularly HARDBALL with Chris M..., almost all your commentators gang up on the Clintons, distorts whatever HILARY or BILL stated but when it comes to ALMIGHTY OBAMA all praises and brushing ups on his lack of experience and knowledge to the matters of a presidential campaign. HILARY IS THE BEST QUALIFIED AMONGST THOSE TWO, MSNBC GROW UP AND BE MORE RESPONSIBLE>
The Clintons, like the United States have always used African Americans when they needed them, now that the so-called Latinos are a large minority group, they Clintons have began to use them as well, playing the race card. It was the African Americans who got Bill Clinton elected, and now they are running after the Latinos to satisfy their plans. Watch out, Latinos, they will drop you when they no longer need you, that is what the Clintons do. Obama is the only clear chioce, even when he does not win, he speaks of grace and hope and bring out the good spirits of the Americans folk, that is what a leader does in even when things are not going well. When the Clintons are feeling the heat, they blame everyone else, complain, and play the fear card, shame on her. I was for her when this who contst began, but I will rather vote for Mccain than Hillary now. She has showed herself to be a cheat, either win the delegate race fairly, or I am voting Repulican.
Good job Democrats.  Instead of wrapping up the nomination like McCain and preserving any sense of dignity, this bloodbath will go on and further damage either of their chances.

I am an Obama supporter, but if things get even more ugly between these 2, I may very well go for McCain.
I agree with many here. Forget who won or lost yesterday, Chris Matthews and the rest of the panel need to chill out on their Hillary hate. It is disgusting and aggravating that the biased media is picking our nominee.
How many times did we see the clip of Hillary being interrogated on whether Barack is Muslim? She answered NO, of course not FIVE TIMES. Then when she tries to change her answer to avoid sounding like a robot, Chris  makes a huge deal of NOTHING.
Sadly, I was an MSNBC junkie, but I have been getting my news from elsewhere, which is still anti-Hillary but less so.
I really think management needs to step in and stop this woman hating behavior so proudly exhibited. Who would have thought Joe Scarborough would be the most balanced of all?
And a reality check to everyone, including the biased media- Barack can't win the nomination without super delegates EITHER.
The message on your programs is that you don't want Hillary to win. Your coverage has been biased from day one. Chris, if Hillary was prettier, you would fawn over that but a smart woman none of you seem to be able to stomach. Racism in this country is on the way out,thank God. Sexism however is alive and well.
There are still women who simply are parrots to their male counterparts and they will simmpley repeat what they are tought. It is these women who should be ashamed and so should many black women who are voting for Obama simpley because of his Race. That seems to be OK. Someone voting for Hillary simpley because she is a woman. "OH MY GOSH" that must be wrong. They are both good Candidates but Hillary is BETTER! Take that from a female Florida Idependent!
Why? Why is anyone surprised? Mrs. Clinton is a fighter and why shouldn't she be? All the experts say she give it up for the party, why? She has as much right as anyone to pursue her dream, if viable, and by all accounts her campaign and her message is viable. All "The Experts" are simply speculators taking their own biases putting their own spin on things. Chris Matthews, "Shame on you!" You stated yesterday on national tv that you heard that there may be riots or uprisings if Obama was denied this opportunity (not an exact quote) - why? First, that comment only sets up the conditions; second, no one is "taking away" something that he didn't possess to begin with. Both he and Clinton are minorities in their own right; he being an African-American and she a Woman. I don't expect Obama to give up any more than Clinton and America needs to chill and let things run its own course without "false, misleading and irresponsible" reporting or speculating - Americans can decide for themselves who they want.
Clinton's not a racist.  The racists is America today are the majority of Hispanic voters.  It's been a little known fact that most Latino's don't care for African-Americans and definately wouldn't vote for Barak Obama.  This racist attitude is much more prominent in older Latino's.  As a white voter, it's sad that the future of America is being decided by race rather than competence to lead.
kravitz, you claim she ran a racist campaign when it has been shown that 90% of blacks support him because he is black that it self is racist to vote for your canadate just because hes black. every tv station and pundit have brought up this point that blacks are voting for him and not her this is not because she is a clinton and a woman but because she is white. also they have gone after her at every turn while the glden boy has been left untouched. this is the hieght of ignorance to have a man so untested in battle that we would bestow on him the presidency just because he is a well spoken black man. I have seen nothing negative in hillarys recent ads its a legitamate question as to who will answer the red phone at three a.m. I certainly want it to be someone who has experience and the brass to back it up. and you are forgetting his lies and under handed land deals have news for you if this was you or I that had done the shady land deal we would be in jail. He is not the return of MLK, JFK , or the messiah he is a man who puts his pants on the same way the rest of us do. quit wimpering and yelling racism when it does not exist where hillary is concerned and realize his mesage is starting to where thin and people are realizing that they need to support the canadate who is a solution finder and not a change monger.
I was born in Ohio, glad as hell to be FROM Ohio, because I know that the ploughboys and inbreds there were just too damn stupid to know where their own economic self-interests lay.  In some hyper-ambitious, richer-than-God woman who really doesn't give a rat's ass about their slide into Third World-style poverty?  Did her hubby do much to stop that slide while HE was in charge?  A better choice would have been someone who gives a damn about the poor and who wants to retool the whole economic factory in ways no one has ever thought of before.  Hope you like being progressively poorer than you are even now, you bunch of ignorant clowns!!
We'll you all did it congratulations. You have secured an unrealistic feeling of accomplishment. You see if Hillary was to win the nomination, even though she has less popular vote, delegates and states, McCain would beat her mercilessly. Really, the reason she won last night is because many republicans voted against Obama. Reason being that they know Obama can beat him. But the polls for Hillary suggest otherwise. So celebrate as long as you can because it's either Obama or McCain who will seal the deal. The Clinton machine is a thing of the past.
Intelligence is not a prerequisite for voting.  You can be dumber than a stump or smarter than a whip.  The simple fact of the matter that you voted shows your smarts.  If you don't vote you have no business complaining.  Primary voter participation this year must be setting some kind of record for number of voters.  This is good for the country.  
TO the person who claimed that ohio is the most racist part of the country she knows. Who are you to speak for me I am white go to see movies with blacks in them and everything you act if we are senseless backward neanderthals when in truth we are a very diverse group of people who made informed decison and the rest of you are being Obamas crybabies pulling the race card to justify the loss f three states and her wins in key states. and she spoke the truth when she said that no president has been seated in a long time unless they can win ohio. So yell race all you want and scream injustice but because of all this racism aganist anyone who does not vote for him now I will actively campaign aganist him for john mccain if hegets the nod. I not doing this because hes black but because you yourself are. thanks for ensuring he will never have my vote .
Congratulations, Hillary and Hillraisers everywhere. You've proved that the harder the media tries to elect the nominee with its selective reporting, the harder the voters will push back!  How can the DNC deny the winner of 6 of the 7 big states needed to beat McCain and put a Democrat in the White House?  I can't wait to see Puerto Rico, the last primary, put the cherry on this cake!  
Hi eveRy one, lets call a spade a spade. The end justifies the means right. Put in REzco, whether true or not...include nafta and the canadian goverment, add fear about islamic roots....win the primaries.
What about the youth in Hilars campaign..if Hilary is their role model.....what good traits have they learned from her.....the power of lying, the power of being divisive, the power of doing whatever you can to win....I worry for chelsea and the values she has picked from her parents. I worry for the young in the campaign..as for the old...you cannot teach an old dog new tricks.........that is how they are...but the young...i guess that is what they wil become.
Hi eveRy one, lets call a spade a spade. The end justifies the means right. Put in REzco, whether true or not...include nafta and the canadian goverment, add fear about islamic roots....win the primaries.
What about the youth in Hilars campaign..if Hilary is their role model.....what good traits have they learned from her.....the power of lying, the power of being divisive, the power of doing whatever you can to win....I worry for chelsea and the values she has picked from her parents. I worry for the young in the campaign..as for the old...you cannot teach an old dog new tricks.........that is how they are...but the young...i guess that is what they wil become.
Clinton's negative campaign hurt Obama. She doesn't know how to win any other way. I am just upset that the American public allow themselves to be puppets on the Clinton string. The only time she has won is when she plays super dirty last minute political games. This just proves she can't be trusted. Even all of the "breaking news" stories regarding Sen. Obama have been PROVEN FALSE.

Of course, the Clintons can play these games all the way to the convention but she will still have fewer  delegates than Sen. Obama and he will be the next president.

President Obama!!!!!
You are right.  I always enjoyed Chris Matthews program, but no more. After this election, no matter who wins I will no longer listen to Hardball.  He is so biased that he reminds me of Rush!!!!! What scares him about a woman President.?He must have insecurities.
I am suprised even Americans fear change. Obama inspires Hope and I don't see why people should be afraid of him, especially as a President whose judgemnet you can  safely trust to safeguard the interests of the nation and its wellbeing!
Oh My...it didn't take long for the niceness veneer to come off the obamamites...the calls of racism are funny...if it is racist for 60% of whites to vote for a white than what is it when 90% of blacks vote for a black?
Looks like Senator Clinton is well on her way to win the nomination.  If she wins the nomination we (Democrats) will loose in November.  A Clinton candidacy will galvanize the fundamentalist right wing of the Repugnicants .... like roaches they will come out of the cracks and flood the voting booths on election day.  Again we Democrats know how to screw things up.  Obama should have gone on the offensive and dished out the dirt as Clinton did.  Senator Clinton will not unite America.  Should she win the presidency (doubtful) it will be another period polarization is America.  Eventhough I like Bill, it will be a divided nation.
Can someone please explain to me why it is not racism when the vast majority of African-Americans vote for Barack, but it is racism if whites vote for Clinton?  I'm a white voter should get to cast my vote for someone I like without the fear of being called a racist.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=731424

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google