ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Clinton's NAFTA-gate?

Posted: Thursday, March 06, 2008 3:37 PM by Domenico Montanaro

From NBC’s Domenico Montanaro
Per the Toronto Globe and Mail, in a story that was the lead on the paper’s front page today, that call to the Canadian embassy was actually from the Clinton campaign, not Obama’s:

“Mr. [Ian] Brodie, [PM Harper’s chief of staff], during the media lockup for the Feb. 26 budget, stopped to chat with several journalists, and was surrounded by a group from CTV. The conversation turned to the pledges to renegotiate the North American free-trade agreement made by the two Democratic contenders, Mr. Obama and New York Senator Hillary Clinton.

“Mr. Brodie, apparently seeking to play down the potential impact on Canada, told the reporters the threat was not serious, and that someone from Ms. Clinton's campaign had even contacted Canadian diplomats to tell them not to worry because the NAFTA threats were mostly political posturing. The Canadian Press cited an unnamed source last night as saying that several people overheard the remark.

“The news agency quoted that source as saying that Mr. Brodie said that someone from Ms. Clinton's campaign called and was ‘telling the embassy to take it with a grain of salt.’

“The story was followed by CTV's Washington bureau chief, Tom Clark, who reported that the Obama campaign, not the Clinton's, had reassured Canadian diplomats.

“Mr. Clark cited unnamed Canadian sources in his initial report. There was no explanation last night for why Mr. Brodie was said to have referred to the Clinton campaign but the news report was about the Obama campaign.”

*** UPDATE *** The Clinton campaign responds: "Unlike the Obama campaign, we can and do flatly deny this report and urge the Canadian government to reveal the name of anyone they think they heard from. The Obama campaign has given a variety of misleading answers to the press and the public about its top economic adviser’s contacts with the Canadian government and should come clean about why they did so," writes campaign spokespman Phil Singer.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

The Truth finally comes out!!!!!!
YES!!!  Thank you MSNBC!!  Now we need to get this info out on the nightly news tonight!!
WHY IS THIS NOT ON YOUR LEAD PAGE?????
Thanks, Chuck, for putting this up.

Now what I want to know is: where is the memo detailing the Clinton aide's contact? If they memorialized a conversation at the low level that Goolsbee had -- they's CERTAINLY have memo-ized an official contact from the Clinton side.

So the Clinton campaign are pathetic liars.  What were people expecting.  The people of Ohio were duped by the lying Clinton machine.  What will people say when they realize that Clinton has been lying about providing universal health care, pulling troops from Iraq and other positions.  Hillary Clinton is a disgusting, pathetic, miserable humanoid.
Hillary, SHAME ON YOU, you lying sack of _ _ _ t.
IT NEVER MADE SENSE FOR OBAMA TO HAVE DONE THIS.

He did not have the foriegn government connection or "experience" to need to reassure Canada.

Now this report makes sense it was Bill Clinton that pushed and signed NAFTA and Hillary is the one that has been on camera in the past supporting it.

Sorry Ohio and Texas. At least folks from Florida can get their vote back. Enough of this corrupt couple from the past.

Here's hoping the national news media gives her as hard a time on this one as they gave to Sen. Obama.
the truth!!! what a scheme. the clinton machinery must be stopped for the good of america.
I'll tell you why the news reports were that it was from the Obama camp - because the Clinton camp said so!  The media has totally abandoned its responsibilites in this race, and now only parrots what Howard Wolfson, Maggie Williams, and Mark Penn tell them to say.  I don't know if it is fear, laziness, or corruption (I would guess it is a mixture of the first two), but the media needs to start calling things independent of what the Clinton camp asserts is the truth.
Well, I hope the press redeems itself and tells us the truth about this NAFTA nonsense. Talk about shoddy reporting! Nearly everything first reported was untrue, and you let Clinton get away with it. Shame on you.
Too bad this came out so late.  Good news, regardless.  Please, Hillary, quit now, keep whatever is left of your dignity and let the Democrats concentrate on McCain.  Your lies bully ways only make matters worse.
This is getting all interesting...Let it all come out now...No More Games!!!
The technical work for that inside the Clinton campaign is: "sh#t"
Wow.

Explain THAT Wolfson, Penn, Clinton.  This was not the press' mistake--you KNEW better.  You (Mrs. Clinton) have actively defrauded (via your ads) the voters of Ohio, especially...not to mention 'the country' by means of the gullible (if not lazy) press---yes, this includes our friends at MSNBC if they reported this 'as news.'  Do your job, journalists. Please.
THIS STORY BELONG ON THE MSNBC FRONT PAGE, AFTER THE FLACK OBAMA CAUGHT FOR IT.  I love First Read, but this has to go mainstream!!!!!!!!
Thank you First Read! I knew we could count on you to get this out and will follow up to see if the facts bear out this story. I'm sad that Senator Obama had to lose voters because of Senator Clinton's claims. I hope if this is true, she will apologize to the American people.
This really just shows that the whole NAFTA issue should have been a non-starter as it really was a wash.  No body really knows who said what when...and neither candidate (as far as I can tell) expressed any political posturing.

This shows exactly how the littlest thing can get blown right up and potentially sway an electorate.

Welcome to the political process America.
Way to steal votes...
Are you guys going to report this, along with a big FAT apology to Obama?  If the MSM would do its job and research this stuff, Ohio would've been alot closer.  So do we want a President who got there because she lied (about NAFTA, etc.), did the same thing she accused her opponent of doing (plagiarizing John Edwards "It's personal" and "We're going to be OK" and Bill Richardson "We need an Apollo project for energy independence," and who will cheat by trying to seat delegates in a state where her name was the only one on the ballot?  Do we really want someone who lies, cheats and steals to get to the Oval Office?  I don't.
Undoubtedly Bill used some of his pull in Canada.
Do we really want another 4 years of this.  Please , voters wake up.  I would love to see a woman in the White House .   But I cannot support this woman.
I'm a naturalized American citizen (from Canada) and I'm ashamed that they got pulled into this.
Where is the apology to the Obama Campaign?  I just know the Clintonistas will be gracious enough to give one.  (Sarcasm intended)
So is it a coincidence that in the same month Hillary raises the most in a month to this date, a "slip up" of this magnitude happens?

Kinda makes you wonder what else will see the light of day?

I saddens me that these are the irrelevant issues that can deeply fracture the party pre-November. I hope we can straighten this out and have a clear choice next go around
Looks like another part of the Clinton dirty tricks campaign like the photo they put on Drudge.  They really have no shame.
Remember that Bill Clinton had/has a young friend who is a conservative Canadian pol,, Belinda Stronach.  he was squiring her around NYC a few years ago. She might have arranged the leak!
I HOPE this is covered on Hardball, Nightly News, Abrams, and 360 tonight!  I am so sick of the lies. It really sad. Some of us new this was a bogus story all along and it pained me to see the Clinton smear a fellow democrat.  so PLEASE PLEASE cover this...for democracy's sake!
This information comes out after the damage has been done, costing the Obama campaign an unknown percentage of votes in the industrial Ohio demographics.

For the "correction" to be buried in First Read is a shame.  Much like "Hillary Wins Texas" was banner front page and "Obama actually wins Texas" will be small print when the Texas votes are all finally in.  
Oops - how did this get out - must be Ken Starr
I've been waiting all day for this to end up on an MSM page - please PUSH THIS TO THE FRONT PAGE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
What took MSNBC so long? Brodie started this off when he mentioned that the Clinton campaign approached the Canadian embassy. Lemme fill in the blanks: Bill called his old friend Micheal Wilson. No teletype. Nothing written down. No muss. No fuss. One has to wonder if he didn't make a request for ol' times sake to have a certain document leak out. Would anyone put it past him?
By the way, why is the Canadian government still using teletyped communication? They haven't heard of virtual private networks?
I'm sure a lot of people in Ohio are going to feel cheated when they learn this. They should have known better.

And shame on the media. You guys never vetted or reported this story properly. Sadly, SNL will be unable to make fun of you guys for doing a hit job like this on Obama for the Clinton campaign. But I guess it didn't hurt MSNBC's ratings to keep the fight going, did it? Was that the media agenda with that story?
Lisa from New Britain, CT:

Well said.
ELECTION 2008
Clintons to face fraud trial
Judge setting date, testimony to include ex-president, senator
Posted: February 19, 2008
11:27 pm Eastern

© 2008 WorldNetDaily


Peter Paul and President Clinton (Courtesy Hillcap.org)

While Hillary Clinton battles Barack Obama on the campaign trail, a judge in Los Angeles is quietly preparing to set a trial date in a $17 million fraud suit that aims to expose an alleged culture of widespread corruption by the Clintons and the Democratic Party.

At the conclusion of a hearing tomorrow morning before California Superior Court Judge Aurelio N. Munoz, lawyers for Hollywood mogul Peter F. Paul will begin seeking sworn testimony from all three Clintons – Bill, Hillary and Chelsea – along with top Democratic Party leaders and A-list celebrities, including Barbra Streisand, John Travolta, Brad Pitt and Cher.

Paul's team hopes for a trial in October. The Clintons' longtime lawyer David Kendall, who will attend the hearing, has declined comment on the suit.

The Clintons have tried to dismiss the case, but the California Supreme Court, in 2004, upheld a lower-court decision to deny the motion.
*wonders where Patty from SD is now?*
Are you going to follow up on this and "drive" it home on "Hardball" and "Meet the Press" and whatever other show MSNBC doesas much as you did the fabricated story version about Obama?  The trumped up version could very well have determined the outcome in Ohio.....  But then again, mayber you wanted it that way!
All I can say to the Obama team is use some of the $55 million that we donated to drive the point home to the American people that what they get with their vote for a Clinton is 4 to 8 more years of lies, half-truths and unethical behavior.

Show them you can be as tough defending yourself as you will be defending America!!!
I knew that this story smelled fishy from the beginning.  MSNBC owes Senator Obama an apology and also needs to give this story front-headline treatment to show that they still have some journalistic integrity.
The Media seem afraid of the Clinton Machine. Thats why you havent reported on this earlier. You All have known this for a week already.

I dont blame you for being afraid though. Some people had died going against the Clintons.

Some went to jail.

They are dangerous.

But know this Our young people are not afraid of the Clinton Machine
NAFTAGATE.....shame on you Hillary Clinton, Shame on you with your attacks and your negative campaigning.  Enough with the speeches, and the rallies.  Meet Obama in Pennsylvania and lets have a real debate about your tactics.
is msnbc going to make this a front line story in the same way they helped crucify obama and cost him votes and possibly the primaries in ohio and texas. how about it msnbc, are you going to do the right thing or continue to be scared of howard wolfson?
" ...someone from Ms. Clinton's campaign called and was ‘telling the embassy to take it with a grain of salt.’"
--Neither the Canadian government nor the Canadian press has a lot of standing with relation to our Democratic candidates.  One thing is for sure, the Obama campaign did NOT contact the Canadian government over this issue as previously reported.  They were instead approached, and in an informal matter--no direct contact w/ the campaign.  I refuse to speculate on Clinton's involvment at this time as it wouldn't be appropriate.

The Clinton party is over. But the trashing of America has just begun.  God help us.

We have heard that Obama is trying to win on math alone...  Obama HAS won.  

That is the reality any intelligent person would perceive, even if that reality is a great disappointment.

It is over... how she could destroy the party and its chances in November with a campaign based on mudslinging and character assassination, a campaign doomed to fail unless Obama quits or is otherwise disabled...

Is she hoping he will fall down the stairs?  Wow.

She has gone over the top, but not in delegates.

Many are questioning her present state of mind and for good reason.

The media do a disservice if they do not, at least, shine a light on what is happening and what the mentality into which the Clinton campaign has morphed.

Thank you Newsweek and Jonathon Alter.

Say it louder and clearer, Chuck.  Your nation needs you to be brave. No kidding.

You know very well of what I speak, I suspect.


Can we have a do-over in Ohio and Texas now?
Well, isn't that interesting. I doubt anyone is really surprised by this. Of course Clinton supporters wont see anything wrong with it. How could anyone trust and support such a lying hypocrite is beyond me. This is like falsely accussing someone of a crime that you yourself committed. I'm sure she set the whole thing up. Probably had that Canadian guy contact the guy from Obama'a camp and mischaracterized his statements. Character and Principles do matter.
OH MY GOD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
The picture of that woman standing at the podium waving that "memo" in the air is the most incredible vision of HYPOCRISY I have ever heard.  This should be the #1 story on the news today...
THANK YOU FIRST READ!  Finally, the truth is revealed!

This needs to get on the front page!  America must hear the truth!
MSNBC please feature this story tonight during your election coverage.  I count on you to share the facts.
I have been watching MSNBC on the internet for over a year now.  I thought that you would report the truth!!!  I don't care if you are siding with Obama... at Least he isn't going to make the LIAR OF THE YEAR AWARD!!!!  It also really boils my blood that our Governor of Ohio would support someone who was partly responsible for Ohioians losing their jobs through NAFTA!!!!  What does he want the rest of us on Food Stamps and living on the streets???  That is what Hillary wants... her middle class isn't making 30 to 50,000.... It is over 100,000.  I now agree with the lady who asked McCain... "How do we get rid of the B!"
OMG...Thank You First Read...

Don't count on this being reporting on the NYT Blog
REMEMBER BUSH, ITS ALLWAYS AFTER THE ELECTION YOU FIND OUT THE REAL VILLIAN IS.  PEOPLE WAKE UP!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=738264

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google