ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Clinton's NAFTA-gate?

Posted: Thursday, March 06, 2008 3:37 PM by Domenico Montanaro

From NBC’s Domenico Montanaro
Per the Toronto Globe and Mail, in a story that was the lead on the paper’s front page today, that call to the Canadian embassy was actually from the Clinton campaign, not Obama’s:

“Mr. [Ian] Brodie, [PM Harper’s chief of staff], during the media lockup for the Feb. 26 budget, stopped to chat with several journalists, and was surrounded by a group from CTV. The conversation turned to the pledges to renegotiate the North American free-trade agreement made by the two Democratic contenders, Mr. Obama and New York Senator Hillary Clinton.

“Mr. Brodie, apparently seeking to play down the potential impact on Canada, told the reporters the threat was not serious, and that someone from Ms. Clinton's campaign had even contacted Canadian diplomats to tell them not to worry because the NAFTA threats were mostly political posturing. The Canadian Press cited an unnamed source last night as saying that several people overheard the remark.

“The news agency quoted that source as saying that Mr. Brodie said that someone from Ms. Clinton's campaign called and was ‘telling the embassy to take it with a grain of salt.’

“The story was followed by CTV's Washington bureau chief, Tom Clark, who reported that the Obama campaign, not the Clinton's, had reassured Canadian diplomats.

“Mr. Clark cited unnamed Canadian sources in his initial report. There was no explanation last night for why Mr. Brodie was said to have referred to the Clinton campaign but the news report was about the Obama campaign.”

*** UPDATE *** The Clinton campaign responds: "Unlike the Obama campaign, we can and do flatly deny this report and urge the Canadian government to reveal the name of anyone they think they heard from. The Obama campaign has given a variety of misleading answers to the press and the public about its top economic adviser’s contacts with the Canadian government and should come clean about why they did so," writes campaign spokespman Phil Singer.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

When did this story break, last week?  Ooops wrong campaign?  Please.  Obama admitted that a meeting took place.

Next story please!
So, are there any Clinton supporters who are starting to see that the Clinton play book is, tell a lie, deny, deny, deny.

Seriously folks, give up the nostalgia, do we really need another president with so little regard for the American people?
First, when asked about if Obama's campaign ever spoke with Canadian Government about NAFTA PRIOR to the debate, Obama said NO (twice - he was asked this question, and TWICE he denied it):

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/03/04/us/politics/04nafta.html?em&ex=1204866000&en=d8d9fdd9c4b944d5&ei=5087%0A


ONLY to change his story a week later to "Yes, we did meet however it was at the request of the Canadians."

Sure sounds like "Change" I can believe in!
I bet the people in OHIO are going balistic over this NEWS.This needs to be front page NEWS.Please get this out there.
"I would ask you to look at this story, substitute my name for Senator Obama's,......"

wow, this makes that quote from Hillary oh-so-much-more hilarious

and sad.. truly sad...
This should be on the MSNBC front page the way the inaccurate story about Obama was. How many more Clinton skeletons are there to come tumbling out of Canada between Giustra's uranium deals and donations and Belinda Stronach's "friendship." So far, the biggest exports from Canada are $$$, sex and smear.
Hillary lost my vote a long time ago.  She lost my respect shortly thereafter.  But now, I can understand why Republicans dislike the Clintons so much.  

People love to call Clinton-haters irrational... well, you know what, it can't be very much more rational than the past two weeks of disgusting onslaughts by the Clinton campaign against Obama.  Lies, fabrications, peddling unverified stories like this just to assassinate his character.  Unbelievable.  She needs to resign from the race for this NAFTA stunt.
Talk about buyer's remorse!  Sorry TX and OH. You got duped by the Clintons. Are we going to see this come up on Hardball and Morning Joe? I think MSNBC and the rest of the media owes a big apology to the Obama Camp.
the major U.S. TV Media needs the biggest spanking in world history. they simply SUCK at what they do.
I've never been one to complain about the media. I believe they have a job to do and the follow the best story.

But this is a disgrace. No matter if you're a Clinton supporter, McCain Supporter, or an Obama supporter. How are we supposed to NOT be outraged by this.

MSNBC, NYT, CNN, every last one of you dropeed the ball on this. Perhaps a pubic apology is in order.
I've never been one to complain about the media. I believe they have a job to do and the follow the best story.

But this is a disgrace. No matter if you're a Clinton supporter, McCain Supporter, or an Obama supporter. How are we supposed to NOT be outraged by this.

MSNBC, NYT, CNN, every last one of you dropeed the ball on this. Perhaps a pubic apology is in order.
What I do not understand is how the media fell for this.  I'm wondering how much of this was a political tactic on behalf of Hillary Clinton by the media.  Those journalists have been reporting politics for a very long time.  How could they make such an amateur mistake like this?  When I first heard this story, I blogged the fact that it did not make any sense and it was a set up by the CLINTONS!
Thanks Chuck.  Front page please!  The people in Ohio need to know this.  The people in ALL states need to know this.
Hillary Clinton is a disgrace to the Democratic Party. She can't be on the ticket in either capacity come the general election. She has no integrity.
Come on Clintonians, where are your responses!
Lying whiny heifer.
Unbelievable!  That just potentally cost Obama Ohio.  Whats next?  Can anybody believe anything that comes out of that womens moutH?  Oh, yeah, my fellow Ohioans believe everything she says.  I hope this is all over the news today.
Anyone from the Clinton Campaign want to talk about NAFTA now?  Anyone?  Anyone?  Bueller?

Remember, this is the "fun" part of campaigning, Hillary!

RELEASE THE HOUNDS!!!!!

(...and the tax records)
Poor people in Ohio were duped.  This is the perfect example of why we don't need the Clintons back in the White House.  And a perfect example of the media jumping blindly on the Clinton bandwagon.
SEE, this is what you are going to keep getting with the clinton's.   Her campaign is, yes we can, lie, cheat, steal, do anything, say anything to win.   If she steals this, I'm voting for the old man.  
Thank you for getting to the bottom of this matter---now get the truth out to voters so they can see how they were defrauded by the Clinton-machine.  Give this FRONT PAGE COVERAGE or put it on the national news!
Yes, thank you Chuck.
The question remains though, why none of the television media have seen fit to cover this. The information coming from Clinton was actually just the beginning and the Canadian government now intends to conduct a high level investigation into what the PM characterizes as grossly unfair to Barack Obama (regarding the entire incident). If the Canadian television networks see this as a big deal as the latest report from CTV indicates, why not the American networks? Especially as it gravely impacted not only Barack Obama but the voters in Ohio and Texas who were mislead. Please try and get you network to pay some attention to this. CNN has known about this for days and chosen not to cover it. I don't know about Fox or CBS or ABC.
Shame on you Hillary!  Shame!

If it were not bad enough that you lied.  It's worse that you bore false whitness and accused Obama of this.

I'm sure voters in Ohio and Texas will have buyers remorse.
Why isn't this on the frontpage Newsweek and CNN and Time and the NY Times? It is disgusting that Clinton pulls something like this.
Ouch!  Buyers remorse in Ohio?  Clintons are just up to their usual dirty tricks.  I actually feel sorry for that Barack dude.

Go McCain 08!  
MSM SHOULD BE ALL OVER THIS! COME ON!!

clinton will say or do anything to steal an election.
No way does Olberman ignore this tonight...he will be all over it!
One fact that should not be lost on anyone: Ian Brodie is the Canadian equivilent to Josh Bolton. What comes out of his mouth should be taken as fact. If he says a call (from the Clinton campaign) was made. A call was made.
I have been waiting to see this come out.  This will be trumpeted by the Obama campaign and Hillary's house of cards will come crashing down.

By the way, let's compare results:

Maine caucus:  Obama +6 delegates
Ohio/VT/RI/Texas primaries where Clinton had "big wins":  Clinton +6 delegates.

Clinton is toast.  She should drop out now because if they have revotes in Michigan and Florida she's not going to gain much ground and this whole race will turn ugly and nasty and will make it more likely that McCain will be President.  I already have Independent voter friends who are giving McCain a second look and saying they're fed up with the Clinton/Obama fights.
New Flash MSNBC/Obama Network

*** UPDATE *** The Clinton campaign responds: "Unlike the Obama campaign, we can and do flatly deny this report and urge the Canadian government to reveal the name of anyone they think they heard from. The Obama campaign has given a variety of misleading answers to the press and the public about its top economic adviser’s contacts with the Canadian government and should come clean about why they did so," writes campaign spokespman Phil Singer.

Oh, but the Clinton camp says it isn't true, so I'm assuming the MSM will take her at her word and drop it now.
Please report this on your front page.

Hillary's campaign is as negative and spiteful as any that I have ever seen.  It would be nice for her campaign to be revealed as being willing to do anything, moral or not, to take power.  That is not the leadership we deserve.
The strange thing about this story is that it was the Obama economic advisor that met with the Canadian officials in Canada. If you recall, Obama denied the meeting and had to later fess up. You Obamasheep will believe anything. Why do you always bash Hillary as opposed to stating what your Obama brings to the table. You have a campaign of hate and fear. Don't you realize that chuck Todd is a republican operative who is trying to stir the pot? Don't you realize that MSNBC is owned by GE. A big corporate conglomerate who is interested in repulican domination. Talk about gullable and ignorant!!
Don't quit now, Billary. Your punishment must continue under the klieg lights of public exposure for all to see. This is only the beginning.

To paraphrase what someone else said here about Senator Obama a few days ago, "Call him what you will Billary, but get used to calling him Mr. President". President Obama will change America and the world. Yes, We Can.
MSNBC - stop hiding news. Put this on the font page instead of that useless non news.
Given that the spin around this affected the vote in Ohio and perhaps elsewhere, and given that it was against a colleague of the same party, isn't it time for Mrs. Clinton to bow out graciously while she still has some dignity?
The strange thing about this story is that it was the Obama economic advisor that met with the Canadian officials in Canada. If you recall, Obama denied the meeting and had to later fess up. You Obamasheep will believe anything. Why do you always bash Hillary as opposed to stating what your Obama brings to the table. You have a campaign of hate and fear. Don't you realize that chuck Todd is a republican operative who is trying to stir the pot? Don't you realize that MSNBC is owned by GE. A big corporate conglomerate who is interested in repulican domination. Talk about gullable and ignorant!!
The strange thing about this story is that it was the Obama economic advisor that met with the Canadian officials in Canada. If you recall, Obama denied the meeting and had to later fess up. You Obamasheep will believe anything. Why do you always bash Hillary as opposed to stating what your Obama brings to the table. You have a campaign of hate and fear. Don't you realize that chuck Todd is a republican operative who is trying to stir the pot? Don't you realize that MSNBC is owned by GE. A big corporate conglomerate who is interested in repulican domination. Talk about gullable and ignorant!!
Could this story get some airtime please. Don't try to bury it in FR. This is speaks to Hillary's character, and is very important for the voters to know what she's all about. How can we believe any promises she make.
when is msnbc going to get off their dead asses and start going back and ask tough questions to howie wolfson, mark penn, fast eddie rendell, terry mccauliffe, etc? you guys, especially matthews, and scarbourough - talk about a couple guys in love with their own celebrity - have lost your guts to go after the latest clinton dirty tricks, the past clinton schemes, totally lost in the schuffle. nothing has been learned from florida 2000, or diebold ohio, 2004.
The Clinton campaign gave the Canadian Government "blanket immunity" to release the name of anyone that supposedly spoke with them. No name has been released! If this is true, lets see the hard facts and evidence, not conjecture. We have a memo clearly implicating Goolsbee so far. Where is the proof?
This needs to be Front Page news- when it was suggestive of the Obama campaign it was Front Page.. come on guys, though I thank you for running the story- how about running it equal to the initial story- which has been now proven to be false.  Come on Share it all over the media the way you're so fond of doing when it's FOR Clinton.  All that we Obama supporters want is the FACTS & the Truth, not Clinton spin and regurgitation! Please.
WHAT?? Are you trying to say that a Clinton would LIE, be UNFAITHFUL, 'wag the dog,' or try to HIDE their inolvement in shady (if not illegal) activities?  This is just a humor piece, right?  
A more indepth analysis at how dillusional all of those Clinton supporters are for thinking that a cheetah (or is that cheater) can change their spots?
OHhhh unlike Obama... blah blah.
Her CAMPAIGN IS PATHETIC!!!!
Is Carl Rove the man behind the curtain???
This has gone past negative...
this is REPUBLICAN campaigning!

RELEASE YOUR 2006 TAX RETURNS
~wink~
~wink~

liar
CHUCK I HOPE YOU DO NOT LET THIS BECOME JUST A BLOG STORY.  IT NEEDS TO BE ON THE MAIN PAGE, ON MORNING JOE, ON NBC EVENING NEWS, ON HARDBALL WITH CHRIS MATHEWS, ON EVERY MEDIA NEWS OUTLET YOU ARE ON ! ! !
Howard Wolfson and the Clintons are hurting America - and I defended the Clintons strongly during his presidency. It is time to move on.
Why is this not being reported on the TV news?  It should be THE LEAD STORY!!!
I agree with GW. WHY IS THIS NOT YOUR LEAD STORY?
Keith O. on MSNBC reported this fairly, and he seemed to be disgusted with what the Clinton campaign has done. Do not be surprised that this is not being widely reported. Media bias for sure. I have stopped watching a lot of journalists because they obviously have hidden agendas in supporting Republicans. News is being filtered to favor and protect certain candidates. You have to get on the Internet to find the truth for yourself.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=738264

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google