ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Reporter stands by work

Posted: Friday, March 07, 2008 5:32 PM by Domenico Montanaro

From MSNBC's Adam Verdugo
The reporter who set off a political firestorm that led to the resignation of an Obama senior advisor today is standing by her reporting.

"Of course, I'm saddened from a personal point of view, because she's actually a very intelligent, articulate woman and her heart seems to be in the right place," Gerri Peev said today in an interview on MSNBC with Norah O'Donnell. "I don't know of any journalist worth their salt who would have pulled her remark. We're not in the business to self-censor or to censor ourselves."

According to Peev, the interview with Samantha Power was initially arranged to publicize a recent book authored by the Obama advisor. During the interview, Power received a phone call from another "special advisor" to the campaign.

"I fiddled around with the tape recorder, and she kindly waited for me to switch it back on," Peev said. "So she knew it was going to be recorded."

Peev continued the interview with Power and notes that she, "described a little bit of the context of the phone call and that things hadn't gone so well in Ohio for the campaign that day." Power told Peev "We f***** up in Ohio," referring to the campaign.

When pressed about why she published a quote, which Power had called off-the record, Peev responded: "I don't know what the convention is in American journalism, but in Britain here we have very firm rules about the fact that generally, you establish whether a conversation or interview is on or off the record before it actually happens.

"She made some off-the-cuff remarks which were on the record. She even waited for the tape to start recording and then I think once she noticed that they were quite controversial she tried to withdraw just that very remark about Hillary allegedly being a monster."

Peev said that she had received an "unofficial clarification phone call" from the Obama campaign, but of course, that conversation was "off-the-record."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

If she said it was off the record then it was.  I think the reporter was highly unethical and I hope he has terrible trouble getting interviews in the future and I am not an Obama fan
I've said it before and I'll say it again....Ms. Peev is an opportunist who saw her 15 minutes of fame.  Her own comments confirm it.  I forget the exact quote, but Ms. Peev said something to the effect that Ms. Power seemed to be making more "candid" comments that had been heard from the Obama camp previously and that it should be reported.  She also siad that Ms. Power was tired, jet-lagged, and distracted by a phone call from the Obama campaign about the results in Ohio.  Ms Peev clearly took advantage of someone who was not at their best and made anill-advised personal attack against Sen. Clinton.  The comment was inappropriate, and Ms. Power realized that the instant she said it by stating that the remark was off-the-record.  OK...she paid the price and the Obama campaign responded immediately and appropriately.  Move on!

For Sen. Clinto to comment that this calls into question the behind the scenes intent of the entire Obama campaign is at best, disingenuous.  What about Mr. Wolfson's comment comparing Sen. Obama with Ken Starr???

What is truly disturbing about this issue is how all of a sudden NO ONE from the media is commenting on the bigger story:  the Clinton campaign's involvement in the NAFTAGate scandal!
Ooo, the Ohio remark was a lot more interesting than the "monster" comment.  I hope we hear more about that!  
I know both camps have so-called policies of not attacking the opponent, but is this a ploy to show that Obama definitely will not tolerate these harsh words against Hillary Clinton (for real), because he HAS treated Hillary in a condescending manner as if she is a "know-nothing". I would hate to think he thinks nothing of her because she is a mere woman.
I hope Miss Peev realizes that her chances of ever getting an interview with anyone from America ever again (or whoever she writes for) is slim and none.  Oh, and by the way, as a journalist, yes, you should self censor!!!!!!!!!
I know both camps have so-called policies of not attacking the opponent, but is this a ploy to show that Obama definitely will not tolerate these harsh words against Hillary Clinton (for real), because he HAS treated Hillary in a condescending manner as if she is a "know-nothing". I would hate to think he thinks nothing of her because she is a mere woman.
Last 30 years, I wanted a women, a black or anybody but a middle age white man to be our President. So I was very happy to see Hillary Clinton and Obama are our candidates. But seeing Obama side is flashing money. Every day the head lines are "Obama raise 54 Milions" or so on. Sorry dirty games and money can not buy the White House residence.
She CLEARLY stated that it was off the record.

This idiot was desperate to have a story. So much for journalism. I'll see who talks to him again.
Too bad she quit or was fired or resigned, she was telling it like it is and how the other side is playing extreme hardball and ugly. Hillary will stop at nothing to get her power seat in the oval office! But also have anyone ever thought that may be a plant? I mean she is not stupid, maybe they wanted the word to get out that Hillary is a monster?
Maybe this story should be added to "Obama Canmp: 'Different Standard' for HRC".

It is too bad that Obama HAS been the one held to a looser standard... but Britain prints EVERYTHING... there is nothing sacrosanct about gender OR race!

Clinton/Obama '08, Obama/Clinton '12.
If the shoe fits, wear it !
http://twocanpete.blogspot.com
Nothing to be sorry for. The last thing Obama needs is a loose cannon running around. He'll have enough trouble keeping Jesse Jackson, Al Sharpton, Louie Farakahn and his wife quiet between now and November.
Those on this blog trying to push the notion that the media is pro- Hillary need to stop the foolishness. I thought Matthews, Olberman and Russert were going to cry Tuesday night when Hill took 3 of 4. Give me a break. Nobody's buying it. The press has been Obama's cheerleader, shield and attack dog for months.
Thanks to SNL for bringing this bias to light in a hilarious fashion.
Hillary has done an excellent job as senator for NY. She  will make an excellent president.
I was very sadden for the policeman who had an accident while on Ms. Clinton's detail in Texas.  The bodies are starting to fall just like in Ex-president Clinton's regime.  I really pray that Obama get out of the race before something dreadful happen to him
she is a monster and WILL do anthing to win. what is the big deal ?
I'm sad that you are writing about this. I'm even more disappointed that your network is reporting this story over and over again.  Americans look like fools to the international community.  This is what we call politics.  Is it to much to ask you to do your job.  If you only reported real news facts, you would have a lot more viewers.  You would not suffer for rating, but you are on a treadmill now.  I hope you will get out of the race and report facts. This  election is to important for you to way in   I'm hoping that you will report real news facts on both Democrat candidates as well as McCain.

Sick of Silliness from Adults
Good for her (the reporter) she got her big breaking news strory of the year. she'll be on every talk show now.  Fame, 15 minutes is all it takes..
According Powers interview with a scottish reporter, Baracks immediatly withdrawl of troops from Iraq is just an empty campaign slogan. Kind of like when his economic advisor went to Canada and said don't believe the campaign rhetoric, it will be didderent if he is elected.

What do we conclude from this? Obama has poor judgment and is a liar. He is very clumsy with foriegn reporters. He is not a "knew kind of politition". He is slick and inexperianced. His people and him are stepping all over themselves.

Wake up Obamasheep!!
This is a no story.  Samantha Power is a decent, intelligent person who has dared to do work that many others would never dream to do. It is a shame that the journalist felt the need to try and hurt her. But I guess that's the way life goes everywhere--always trying to tear others down.  Ms. Power, you should be commended for your work on behalf of the people of Darfur and elsewhere.  No one can take that away from you.  Not even a silly little word like monster.
According Powers interview with a scottish reporter, Baracks immediatly withdrawl of troops from Iraq is just an empty campaign slogan. Kind of like when his economic advisor went to Canada and said don't believe the campaign rhetoric, it will be didderent if he is elected.

What do we conclude from this? Obama has poor judgment and is a liar. He is very clumsy with foriegn reporters. He is not a "knew kind of politition". He is slick and inexperianced. His people and him are stepping all over themselves.

Wake up Obamasheep!!
Obama has had a magic carpet ride by the Republicans, Media, and the DNC thus far. Lets see if he can stand the kitchen when things get warm! This is nothing compared to what the media will do to him if he actually win the nomenation. Hiliary can take it, she has been taking it for years on end!
Hillary is a monster! She is putting herself before the Democratic party and at this point...the country! Maybe she could campaign SOME MORE for John McCain telling us that she and McCain are ready with their lifetimes of experience. Experience doing what exactly Mrs. Clinton? What bills have you sponsored with your wealth of experience? As a life long Democrat let me state this clearly..you are a monster, you dare accuse Senator Obama of using the Rove playbook...looks to me as though you took copiius notes during the "vast right wing conspiracy" and have become a co-author with Mr. Rove! P.S. I used to be a monthly contributor to the DNC...when you backed Bush on the war, I called and cancelled it,but you are worse than I thought!
Well, if the fangs and horns fit . . . . . . .

LOL!  I wish both candidates would just start talking about the issues that matter again.  This constant bickering is disheartening.
Here is a direct quote from today's Ben Smith report in plitico.com regarding Samantha Power on Obama's Iraq plan.  Quote: "For all the chatter about Obama adviser Samantha Power's calling Clinton a "monster," another set of remarks made on her book tour in the United Kingdom may be equally threatening to the Obama campaign: Comments in a BBC interview that express a lack of confidence that Obama will be able to carry through his plan to withdraw troops from Iraq within 16 months.

"He [Obama] will, of course, not rely on some plan that he’s crafted as a presidential candidate or a U.S. Senator," she said at one point in the interview.-End Qoute.

to read the whole story see the link:http://www.politico.com/blogs/bensmith/0308/Power_on_Obamas_Iraq_plan_best_case_scenario.html

How come The First Page is not reporting about this???

She is a monster. It's so sad that this country has engineered a gutless society totally unwilling to tell the truth, for so-called political correctness. Power lost her power in her retraction. There is no backbone there for a 3 a.m. call, nor in the other camp either. Who cares about Ken Starr, Clinton's residual guilt from hubby's follies came out of the closet with a snarl. We are not ignorant of these petty games and this display of gutlessness.
She is a monster. It's so sad that this country has engineered a gutless society totally unwilling to tell the truth, for so-called political correctness. Power lost her power in her retraction. There is no backbone there for a 3 a.m. call, nor in the other camp either. Who cares about Ken Starr, Clinton's residual guilt from hubby's follies came out of the closet with a snarl. We are not ignorant of these petty games and this display of gutlessness.
Obama's senior advisor has made a tremendous mistake and it will certainly cost Obama a valuable asset.   But let's not sidetrack the candidates from the issues of our country, the voters can decide if she is a monster or not!  Enough said and it should be from Obama too!  Let's try not to allow Hillary to lead us all the way to the next Republican President!  =)

That so called "reporter" looks and talks just like a feminist Clinton supporter.  Just like those female dogs from SNL.    
Well what's done is done. Hillary is a monster. She is vile and deceptive. Her tactics are Nixonian. I find them offensive. I will never vote for this person. Oh and by the way I won't apologize for calling Hillary a monster. It's the truth.
Well, I'm not a fan of all hardball politics.  But, the way Clinton has run her campaign,and if I'm Obama, I play that final hard tactic.. walk up to the superdelegates and tell them if I have the elected delegates, popular vote, and most states, and I don't get the superdelegates, I walk from the party and run as an independent. Thus destroying the party forever, and possibly still winning the election.  CHECKMATE.  He will then get his superdelegates.
Joe America, Philadelphia, PA (Sent Friday, March 07, 2008 10:54 AM

Joe America, that is Exactly what he'll do & with his already Impressive ground assault in each state, he could very well pull that off. I for one am willing & i'm sure gazillion's of other's are also ready to field an Independent candidate who has the American People at the forefront. He has already shown that he can bring in the $$$ to pull this off.As you can see by the poster's on here, Barack Obama would be a Formiddable Independent candidate.Hillary's supporter's can Whine all they want to, the Common sense American voter is Not gonna let her & Bill anywhere near Our House again.She has shown that she cares Nothing for the Real Democratic Party, only the title of POTUS.Bill promised it to her, but he can't Deliver good on that promise.Yet she hang's on because Bill said so.

We  supporter's of Barack Obama will Not look back as the Democratic Party we have been member's of & Loved for so long, Implodes from within on a Promise, Bill made to Hillary.

Barack Obama the next POTUS!!!
The real reason that Ms. Power resigned was not because of her remarks about Sen. Clinton but rather her honest assessment of Sen. Obama's plan for Iraq - In the best case scenario, we hope that it may

Sen. Clinton is talking about the economy, healthcare and national security.

Sen Obama is asking about Sen. Clinton's taxes?


True journalism...I don't see a journalist like her ever working for CNN...where it is business as usual
Journalists are such self righteous bastards. This tabloid article has now pedestaled her career. The world would be a much better place without religion and journalists.
If she was in Clinton's camp there wont be resignation.
I also  wonder why are you not reporting or talking about the canadian NAFTA connection? that a call was made from Clintons people   it was big enough news when she acused Obama when did it become less important?
Clintons Network News and you are not doing your jobs SHAME SHAME
?
Poor Hillary! Someone called her a monster... how will she survive?

This is a lame story that plays right into the
Clinton's death by 100 nicks strategy and you guys are eating it up.

Why no coverage of the fraud trial that is about to open regarding HRC's 2000 fundraising?

www.peterfpaul.com

Seriously guys, I know she called you out for being too hard on her but this is really silly.
Hard to blame the reporter when the media industry creates the expectation of this kind of hot reporting. She had to go with it or possibly get scooped by the competition. Sad days when something like this goes from just interesting to creating a firestorm.
She has nothing to be ashamed of. Both the Clintons are monsters. None of the rules apply to them. Hillary can pick a favorable state to call "home", purely for political reasons, and become a Jr Senator for a state she's never lived in. Can you think of one other presidential candidate EVER who pulled that off? Now, she is pushing for a re-vote in Florida. Rules, regulations, laws just don't apply if your name is Clinton. It is sick, and sad that our country is saddled with the caliber of candidates we have to choose from. Hillary is clearly the worst.
I feel badly for Power. She didn't deserve to be abused so badly by the British/e'en worse Scottish/ press.  Off the record means off the record.  I've given dozens/hundreds of backgrounders, and I'll negotiate for myself or my boss (e.g., an ambassador) about what's on the record and can be attributed.  Peev dinna understand the ground rules, not Power.  She should have allowed renegotiation during the interview.
That said, don't say anything off the record that you don't want quoted. And that said, an ethical reporter who had any decency or competency would have kept the quote but attributed it to a "senior Obama campaign official."  Well, Sam, that's how we learn...  I'm confident you'll be back as the U/S for G or A/S for DRL - at minimum - in an Obama administration. I'm obviously a fan -- and a huge one for "A Problem from Hell" -- and hope to work with you in '09.
Over the last century the average voter elected two democrats to the presidency; Jimmy Carter and Bill Clinton. Jimmy was one of the worse, while Bill was considered a good one. How is this possible?  Before 1968 we had many fewer primaries held for the nomination process of a Democrat candidate.  Most of them JFK, FDR, Wilson, Truman, and Johnson were chosen to be the candidate by the party bosses after just few primaries. The party bosses chose the nominee that would be the most electable in the general election.  Judging their list, they have chosen better than the recent average voter. Look at who the average voter has elected: Mondale, Dukakis, Kerry, none of which were able to win.

After the 1968 convention, and after letting the average voter elect Carter through country wide primaries in 1976, the DNC had reforms which created the superdelegates. This year we held many primaries which we haven’t held since 1976 and look what it brought us. It proves the average voter does a poor job picking a candidate, as they generally steer toward likability, inspiring promises, and a pretty oratory. This is what lead American to Carter and it is happening again with Obama.

Obama-- like Carter--is not ready at this time to be president; he will have more experience, knowledge, and insight in about 8 years. Currently, we need a tough, decisive, president who is a fighter, and a democrat. Obama has my vote in 2012 but not in 2008; Hillary has it now.
Her most damaging comment, which I suspect got her fired was about Iraq, i.e. not to expect Obama to rely on plans formulated during the campaign. The second was calling Ohioans essentially dumb. This are what got her fired... Not the monster comment. Focus on the substance, not trivia like the Obama spokesman Olbermann, the Bill'O of the left.
Obama should have surrounded himself with a bunch of yes men robots, just like the Bushes and Clintons. Sure, it ends up in a poorly run country, since anyone with an opinon of their own is ignored, but at least most of the screwups are their own.
Sounds like Peev was taking advange of this woman on technicality.  However Power has learned a big lesson, don't answer your cell phone while talking journalist.
This is by no means an isolated incident.Their campaign, has done "numerous" dirty tricks.In Texas their supporters went around polling places and homes,and distroyed Hillary Clinton signs and banners. This is an act of a desperate campaign.America is getting tired of your campaign slogan, I was against the war from the start,but was not in a position to vote on it. And have voted to fund the war ever since.If this is the criteria to be President, well I spoke out against the war to, so maybe I should be President. Maybe not, there is a candidate running named Hillary Clinton with 35 years of experience and a whole hellof a lot smarter that I.
Is there anyone in the world we can trust?  We can't trust Democrats, Republicans, Democratic Leaders, Democratic National Convention, BUSHS', CLINTONS, MCCAIN....SOUNDS LIKE EVERYONE SHOULD BE ON THE CROOKS AND LIARS PAGE.  MAYBE ALL THE NEW SHOULD JUST BE BLOGGED ON THAT PAGE.  WOULD MAKE IT SIMPLE FOR MOST AMERICANS.

What is the big deal? The newscasters never did mention when Hillary Clinton had to reassign or let go three of her staff because of the bad things said about Obama. Keith and Chris, Why do you two hate Hillary so much? I thought you were better than that.
The lady was RIGHT.....Clinton is a monster.    Clinton would sell her soul to the devil to get the nomination.........
Obama has to understand that Democratic voters love scoundrels.  They loved Bill Clinton despite his scandalous behavior and lying under oath and extra-marital affairs with countless women.  Obama cannot win if he tries to maintain the high ground in this campaign.  That may appeal very well to Republican and Independent voters --- but not with Democratic voters.  They want ‘down & dirty, gutter’ politics.  They want lying and gross mischaracterizations.  They want DIRTY TRICKS.   Obama is going to have to take off the white gloves and revert to Chicago-style ward politics if he wants to win this nomination.  Anything less the Democratic voters will not support.   Decent politicians finish last in Democratic politics.    
I've worked in political campaigns and in the press office of political campaigns. NOTHING is off the record with a reporter. They are not your friends, they have a job to do. If you've established a working relationship you may ask for something to be off the record, as background, and if granted then yes, it should be. But all campaign people, especially volunteers, need to be told that EVERY WORD WITH A REPORTER IS ON THE RECORD.

It was a silly amateur mistake but she's also a Harvard professor and should have known better, and not assumed a Scottish paper was safe. I don't think the Obama campaign should have trouble over it, but Power should definitely have resigned, her credibility is gone.
Why should she have to resign for being right?
Whatever happened to the politics of hope?

Oh, not working?

Obama, gain some substance and you wouldn't have to (wink wink) unknowingly have surrogates do your dirty work.

Enjoy your best shot which is the VP slate if Hillary is forgiving of your present votes and utter lack of experience and horrendous debate abilities.

Also, Senator Obama, tell your surrogate Keith Olbermann I said hello.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=744307

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google