ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Obama camp responds to Ferraro

Posted: Tuesday, March 11, 2008 2:58 PM by Domenico Montanaro

From NBC’s Domenico Montanaro
The Obama campaign called for Geraldine Ferraro to step down as a member of the Clinton campaign’s finance committee for comments she made suggesting Obama’s race is why he’s a leading presidential candidate.

"If Obama was a white man, he would not be in this position," Ferraro told Torrance CA’s Daily Breeze Friday as we and others reported this morning. "And if he was a woman (of any color) he would not be in this position. He happens to be very lucky to be who he is. And the country is caught up in the concept."

The Clinton campaign had this response: "We disagree with her," Spokesman Howard Wolfson told Politico.

Rep. Jan Schakowsky (D-IL), called Ferraro a “good friend” and credits her with “clearing a path” for women, but added that “In the heat of the campaign though things get said that shouldn’t. It’s disappointing that Clinton supporters have tried to diminish” Obama. “To suggest that he’s getting preferential treatment” because of his race, she sad, “is out of line. I urge Sen. Clinton to call on advisers and supporters to change the tone of their campaign.”

Axelrod said the Clinton campaign’s response was not enough and that “she ought to be removed” from any responsibilities she has on the campaign’s finance committee or in any other way related to the campaign.

“Ferraro should be denounced and censured by the campaign,” Axelrod said. “Samantha [Power] resigned, because it was not consistent with the kind of campaign we want to run. We want a candidate and president who will live by their words.”

The Clinton campaign called for Obama foreign policy adviser Samantha Power to step down after it was revealed that she had told a Scottish newspaper that she felt Sen. Clinton was “a monster.”

Susan Rice, an Obama foreign policy adviser, this morning on MSNBC said that Ferraro’s comments were worse than Power’s. Axelrod declined to rank the two, but called Ferraro’s comments “part of an insidious pattern” by the campaign. Axelrod cited comments by Bill Shaheen, Bob Johnson and Clinton’s comments on 60 Minutes, in which Axelrod said she did not strongly attest to Obama’s Christianity -- even though the two senators had been to Christian prayer together.

“They need to set a tone and do what we’ve done,” Axelrod said, adding later, “When you wink and nod, you are telling your supporters that anything goes.”

'A real inflation of credentials'
The campaign also attacked Clinton’s foreign policy credentials again. They have recently called into question her role in bringing peace to Northern Ireland and her claim that she “negotiated open borders to let fleeing refugees into safety from Kosovo.”

“There’s a real inflation of credentials over there,” Axelrod said.

*** UPDATE *** On Ferraro's comments, Clinton said, "I do not agree with that. It is regrettable that any of our supporters on both sides, because we’ve both had that experience, say things that kind of veer off into the personal. We ought to keep this on the issues. There are differences between us. There are differences between our approaches on health care, on energy, on our experience, on our results that we’ve produced for people. That’s what this campaign should be about.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Confirmed: Obama Did Gain Delegates From California Vote Count
By Eric Kleefeld - March 11, 2008, 12:23PM
We've just confirmed with the California Democratic Party that reports in the blogosphere, which said that Barack Obama picked up additional delegates from the vote count in California, are correct.

Election Central spoke to Bob Mulholland, campaign adviser to the California Dems, and he confirmed that the delegate estimates for the California primary have been revised from the initial media estimates.

To put this in perspective, over one-million votes were yet to be counted when the media estimates were first made. Those estimates had Hillary at 207 delegates to Obama's 163. The new projection: A small alteration to Hillary 203, Obama 167, which Mulholland said is not expected to change when the election is officially certified this Saturday


Chuck is this reflected in your current numbers? Thanks
If EVER there was a pot calling a kettle black, it's Gerrie Ferraro, who was picked as a VP candidate solely because of her gender. The original case of stunt casting.
The Clinton camp called for Powers' removal from the Obama team. The Obama camp has every right to call for Ferraros' removal from the Clinton team. On the other hand I could see where Hillary might have been more harmed by those comments from Powers (Hillary is a monster). After all, the truth does sometimes hurt more.
Gerry ought to join Monster-Calling-Woman in the dumpster.  What's good for the goose is good for the gander.
Not only are Ferraro's comments grossly offensive, they are patently untrue.  Ferraro claims that if Obama was a woman of any color, he wouldn't be where he is right now.  Ferraro must not realize whose campaign she works for.  Hillary Clinton is a woman... and she's done quite well, even though first place has slipped from her grasp, largely because America is sick of this disgusting type of politics.

Obama is who he is not because of the color of his skin, but because his life experiences have crafted a person of extraordinary judgment and ability to lead this nation forward.

Obama '08!
McCain and Obama have publicly rejected and denounced supporters that have made statements that go against the spirit and ideals of their respective Campaigns.


Hillary, on the other hand, has Not. Not in the Ferraro case, nor in the case of her Major Campaign supporter in Texas that said "i will not vote for Obama because he is Black".


This sends a message to all Americans and indeed the world.  


Make no doubt about it, she is a fighter.  But only fights for personal glory rather than Integrity and Honor.


She is the antithisis of everything our kids, our community and our country needs.

Check the 3rd paragraph. I think you have wolfson speaking fro the wrong campaign
Ferraro is right.  If Obama wants to pressure black superdelegates through surrogates to support Obama because he's black, and if he is always presumed to win states that have a large black Democratic presence, then admit that he would not have these preferences if he were white.  Just ask John Edwards.B.Graye
Hillary and her campaign are so two-faced.  Unfortunately, Hillary's supporters admire her for it.  The same people who bitched and moaned about how Republicans have campaigned over the past two decades are loving them some Hillary for doing the same damn thing.

As a Democrat, it is sickening.
"The Obama campaign had this response: 'We disagree with her, Spokesman Howard Wolfson told Politico."

The CLINTON campaign had that response Chuck and company, not the Obama campaign. Another error in reporting.

Is it too much to ask to get pro-Clinton journalists to at least report accurate information?

Please get it together.

p.s. Newsflash to MSM and those who love to Obama bash: He's still winning and those of us paying attention know that the real crime is a MSM that parrots Clinton talking points and conduct ... like acting like Mississippi is meaningless and not part of the United States.

There is an election going on there today.
Bravo Geraldine!  Finally someone has the guts to say that Emperor Obama has no clothes.  
Ferraro's comment PALES to the race baiting waged by Obama and supporters throughout this primary.

On 60 Minutes - Hillary said Obama was not a Muslim.
But that answer wasn't good enough for the media and Obamabots.

http://www.talkleft.com/story/2008/3/11/143928/278

Obama will do and say anything to win - even telling Mississippi audiences the Clinton camp distributed the pic of Obama in African garb.
But just last week - Obama said she had nothing to do with it.
Desperate Oblahma!! using links from Drudge to bash opponent.
Pitiful.


Since when do we start denouncing people for the truth!  Face the facts, if Obama wasn't Black he wouldn't have won half the preimaries he did.  Let's get over making political correctness a priority over the truth.
If you care to get the drift of this primary contest, check out Chuck Todd's video clip from Morning Joe.

Chuck is the man these days!

Knows his stuff, and unlike so many suck-up journalists, he is not afraid to layer the story so's you get the inside if you listen.

Listen to him.

Another example of the Clinton Campaign's do as I say, not as I do policy. When Powers made her comment, the Clinton Campaign asked for her head on a platter. Ferrero has said something that is more spiteful and awful and the Clinton Campaign is just stating they do not "agree" with her comments.

Why are the Clintons' held to a different standard? Why does the MSM bow down to the Clinton attack machine? Why are the Clintons' allowed to say or do anything and everything they want without retribution? Is it because this is EXACTLY what the Clintons' represent and no one in the MSM has the guts to stand up to it? How far does the Clinton arm really reach? Why is the MSM so afraid of them? Is this really who we want to run this country?? What would it say about America to elect a president half the country can't stand and whom rules with an iron fist, threatening and shouting at anyone who imposes her? This is the Politics of fear at least half of America has had enough of.

Time to turn the page.

OBAMA '08
Honestly - how is that bad?  She didn't say he is lucky to be 'where' he is; she said he is lucky to be who he is.  So let me ask you this?

Why is Obama the only one who can talk about race?  He is soliciting support from the black community in huge numbers - is that not racist?

The candidate himself made some controversial comments during his speech after the Texas primary - which not many people seemed to pick up on.  To paraphrase - his father came to America, got an education and married a white girl?  How is that not racist?

They are just looking for revenge for the monster comment.
Chuck,

You incorrectly associate Wolfson with the Obama campaign: "The Obama campaign had this response: "We disagree with her," Spokesman Howard Wolfson told Politico. Wolfson is evil and therefore meets the Clinton's campaign credentials.
Holding my breath, waiting for Hills to admonish someone, anyone from her gutter campaign
Ferraro comments are worst than Powers, Powers "monster" comments hint at a character flaw, something that can be changed,characterizing Clinton's actions, but when they speak of race that is something that can not be changed. It was very offensive.
I think there are a lot od\f Sour grapes at Obama HQ. What a bunch of whiny sissy girlie-men...lol
Mrs. Ferraro was correct in her statement. The only reason Mr. Obama's camp is upset about Hillary's foreign credentials, is Obama has none at all...
Obama camp= Pathetic whiners
Six weeks from now there won't be anybody left in either campaign from all the 'resignations'  That's how we'll pick the winner.   Last one left with any staff gets the nomination.
I cannot resist this pun: Ms. Ferraro's accusation is the proverbial pot calling the kettle "black". You see, the question is so hypothetical. No one knows for sure if Obama would be there if he were white, red, yellow, brown, black -- or any other combination thereof.

However, the same cannot be said of Hillary's being a female. She would not be in this position if she were not Ex-Pres Bill's wife. (Thereby having to be a female unless Bill were gay. And there is sadly way too much evidence that he is not gay. It is, sadly enough, found in all sorts of Congressional records!) It has become obvious to me that sadly, so many women support Hillary because they think she is entitled. Yes, as undemocratic as it sounds, entitled. They think she is entitled, perhaps because of the marriage. But I am more inclined to believe they think she is entitled because she stood by him during the impeachment process. Or worse, because she put up with so much from him. That seems so un-feministic to me! (And I too am a feminist who kept my maiden name and use the title "Ms.")
But would she be there if she had been a man? Certainly not. She would have been just a junior senator -- and maybe not even that.


We all as one nation cried and moaned about the Presidential Bush bid. He cheated his way in to settle past wars of his father. The senators of some of our states let this happen by allowing the war and now we as a nation is mourning our lost due to this VOTE!!
I say that to say this if we let a person who was for the vote in the beginning into office who's to say that our percious LAND OF LINCOLN isnt finished fighting with this presidential bid. So we have to look at it in our prespective "IS CHANGE WHAT WE WANT"

Obama 08
I expect nothing less from a person a person who lives in a glass house. Thank god she is a small person and her rocks are even smaller. After he brief run for V.P. she all but dissapeared from the scene. I expect she will now go the way of the Dodo. Good riddance.
Again - Clintons change the rules to match what they want.  They allow Splitz to continue to be a national Co-Chair of their campaign, they allow this type of words from others on their campaign, the Clintons continue to attack....
The Clintons are setting it up for bringing down the party so they can say if I would have been the nominee I would have won.
Shame on the Clintons
hopefully she'll let this ride and it blows up in her face.  It will give something else Obama can bring up in his stump speeches.
now howard wolfson is obama's spokesman?
So  what else is new.....everyone knows that Obama has gotten preferential treatment because he is black.

The press has bent over backwards for him, afraid to say or ask him anything beacuse they will be called racist.

But the true racist are Obama and his  wife who says America is mean and she hasn't been really proud to be American untill her black husband ran for president.

Obama belongs to an all black racist church in Chicago who preaches racism.  Obama's Pastor        ( Wright) is a confirmed racist who praises Farrakhan; the leader of Nation Islam who hates whites and Jews.

The truth does hurt doesn't it?


OBAMA is playing the race card. FERRARO is right.
Is Barack Obama the whiniest candidate we've ever had running for President or what?  

Ex-Senator Bill Bradley, the guy who called Vice President Al Gore a liar in 2000, called Hillary Cinton a liar yesterday.

Maybe Barack Obama should work at keeping his own supporters civil, instead of coming out and crying about everyone else.
Please correct your typo:

The >Obama< campaign had this response: "We disagree with her," Spokesman Howard Wolfson told Politico.

Wolfson is with the Clinton Campaign, where he fits right in.
Wolfson is with the Clinton campaign, not the Obama campaign.
Shame on you for your sloppiness.
As an Edwards supporter - it's been clear throughout this primary that the media and Obamabots perpetuated false accusations of racism against the Clintons.

Obama surrogates and bots even accused the Edwardses of racism!!  Whatever it takes to win....

We saw it in Iowa and SC - and to date.

Obamabots are even accusing Hillary of racism over her VP comments - claiming it's code for "get to the back of the bus, Obama!"

When they decide the nominee, hopefully, the superdelegates will consider the damages that will occur with a race-baiting president and his followers.

Most people don't want to walk on eggshells for 4 years.

Wow, what a monster... OOPS!
That woman loves Hillary because she loves divisive politics and polarizing leaders like Hillary. Hence her own divisive and stupid race baiting.
These two women are trying to be role models for women and trying to present women as polarizing and highly negative, which is not the case.
Hillary's campaign is certainly stuffed with monsters.....
Wow, Does the Clinton Campaign Reject or Denounce or both?  Probably not.  What a double standard.  You know they will not ask Geraldine Ferraro to quit because this how the Clintons conduct themselves in real life.  Last time I checked, did Geraldine Ferraro help carry ONE STATE in the National Vote?!?  Nice for Hillary to keep that kind of advice around in her "Big State" model for winning in November.
Geraldine Ferraro's comments are true in that if Obama were a white man, he would not be getting the OVERWHELMING majority of the black vote, which has been a determining factor in many of his victories, particularly in the South.  What is wrong with pointing out such an obvious fact?  
Does this mean that according to the Clinton camp that the Mayor of Philly only got to where he is because of his race? As he has already come out in support of Hillary he may want to think about that for a bit and reconsider exactly who and what it is he is supporting here.

That may be a question that Obama can pose to the Clinton camp during his campaign in PA. He may want to ask the Clinton camp if they believe it is also true that the mayor of Philly only got to where he is because he is a Black male, or the soon to be Governor of NY, or any other elected Black male in Pennsylvania, New York and anywhere else in the US. the question. e
We as Americans should look at the candidates for their policies, votes in the past, their staff choices, how their deal with their staff's mistakes and plans for the future.  Comments talking about this person getting this far because of ethnic, gender, religious or other background should be down played as much as possible.  I would hope that we as Americans can try to make the best possible guess when we vote.  Electing a person is like making a guess in the stock market; the past is not necessarily a guarantee that you will get what you want.  
Gee, I guess everything is off limits when it comes to the Community Organizer from Chicago.  Please don't hurt his feelings by telling the truth.
I don't care enough to call for her ouster. The Clinton camp isn't worth that much consideration.
Ferraro's comments don't bother me as much as her intentions. It would be like say Hillary doesn't deserver to still be in the race because she get the woman vote. Facts are facts, but how you paint them speaks to truth. Why doesn't she mention that if Obama was white, Hillary would have lost Ohio & Texas?
Yes, Ferraro's should resign immediately.  Her comments are an insult to everyone 'half' or 'whole' person of color and needs to be repudiated.  It is sickening how the Clinton campaign's surrogates have one after another made disparaging sometimes racist comments about Obama and pretty much given a 'pass' by the media.  Clinton's 'silence' shows she agrees with Ferraro.  
Sounds like Ferrarro and Farrakahn are two peas in a pod. One's already been denounced and rejected. It still remains to be seen how the other will be handled.
I'm willing to assume this reflects the views of Hillary, as well as her most strident supporters. What possible evidence is there that would make me feel otherwise? Her word?
I'd be far more receptive to the idea that Hillary called in a favor from a friend to say what she couldn't.
It's an old political trick. If it was a gaffe, Ms. Ferraro would have already resigned. Contrary to the perception of fair minded people, this stuff works where it appeals to a carefully selected target audience. Expect a response lag on Hillary and Geraldene's part. The campaign needs time to get this message to get out to Pennsabama.
You know what, part of what she said is probably true.  There probably have been voters who have supported him because he's black.

HOWEVER, the precise same thing could be said of her.  If she were not a woman and a Clinton, she wouldn't be in this at all.  
These attitudes start from the top

The Clintons are running a dirty, mean spirited campaign....
Race baiting, cocaine allegations, Muslim accuasations, you name.....

This all reflects Hillary's character
Politics as 'Blood Sport'
The 'Politics of Personal Destruction'
'Now, the fun part starts'

What a pathetic, disgusting family the Clintons are
Adultery, rape, infidelity, corruption, scandals, impeachment.....

Just a caravan of scandals.......

TURN THE PAGE
(on Hillary Rotten Clinton)
Let's all wait a bit and see -- after that bit of time, if Hillary has not asked for Ferraro's resignation or fired her outright, we'll know exactly what kind of character, morals, integrity Hillary has.  My money is on the none of the above!

Ferraro needs to leave now!
Bottom line for me is that the name-callers should just be ignored.  Neither the 'monster' nor the 'Ferraro' comments are a very big deal, and certainly not worth crowding real news, evaluations, and issues out of the way.  The Clintons certainly are bawl-babies, and cheap shot artists to boot (e.g., the 'wink and nod'), but Obama need not 'retaliate in kind', even if the press does beg for it as showing 'toughness.'  It's whininess.
It's time for PA to prove they aren't the racists their Governor Rendell thinks they are. 20% of Ohioans admit in polls that they would not, in any case, vote for an African American for President.

While this is nowhere near the built-in negative of over 40% of Americans who say they would not vote for Hillary, in any case, for President, it is still disturbing. What's up, PA?


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=755677

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google