ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Spitzer fallout

Posted: Wednesday, March 12, 2008 9:05 AM by Domenico Montanaro

The New York Times’ lead: “State government remained paralyzed on Tuesday as Gov. Eliot Spitzer, reeling from revelations that he had been a client of a prostitution ring, was engaged in an intense legal and family debate about whether to resign or, as aides said his wife was urging, to stay on. Mr. Spitzer did not emerge from his apartment at Fifth Avenue and 79th Street in Manhattan as Albany remained roiled and riveted by the deepening crisis.”

The Times’ editorial page says Spitzer “has now twice violated his obligations to the people of New York. He violated their trust when, according to law enforcement officials, he patronized a prostitution ring. He compounded that violation Tuesday by hiding in his Fifth Avenue apartment and refusing to explain his actions or his future plans. To put it bluntly, Mr. Spitzer must either resign immediately or explain why he deserves to continue in office. It is almost impossible for us to imagine how he can survive this scandal and provide the credible leadership that his state needs.” 

VIDEO: When will New York’s governor, Eliot Spitzer -- caught up in a prostitution scandal -- resign? TODAY’s Natalie Morales reports.

The Washington Post's Baker wonders if Spitzer's troubles will hurt Clinton. "Now, his apparent involvement with a prostitution ring has not only distracted attention from her efforts to take down the front-runner, Sen. Barack Obama (D-Ill.), it has also brought back unhelpful memories of her own husband's dalliances in office. There on cable television again were pictures of Bill Clinton hugging Monica S. Lewinsky. And the image of Spitzer's wife standing painfully by his side while he acknowledged unspecified wrongdoing could not help but remind some of Hillary Clinton's own stand-by-her-man moment."

The Boston Globe: “As New York Governor Eliot Spitzer weighs his political future after being accused of patronizing a high-priced prostitute, Democratic candidate Hillary Clinton is faced with an awkward choice: Call for the resignation of a fellow Empire State Democrat and raise comparisons with her own husband's behavior as president, or keep quiet and risk the appearance of condoning Spitzer's alleged offense.”

The New York Daily News: “It was a double whammy of a day for Hillary Clinton, who got pounded at the polls in Mississippi as Gov. Spitzer's mushrooming sex scandal brought ugly headlines reminiscent of her husband's philandering.”

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Spitzer should stay on as governor and fight the charges. Who cares if has sex out of his marraige? Spitzer is someone that has done, and will do, a lot of good in the world, he needs to stay in office. His private life issues are just, private. Good liberal Democrats like Eliot Spitzer are difficult to find. The man is a national treasure, not a criminal.
Whats new? Hillary is a woman and fair game for all.Obama lied to make race an issue in beginning to consolidate and built his whole campaign on S. Carolina when he did it. Obama is the raceist and yes Blacks are raceist too. I never would have believed it in todays world but he has proven it.People will see it before Nov.by than it will be too late. Women are upset cause Hillary did things right and is being punished.Being a woman its fair game to dump on her. Well I think all women should gather round her now like Obama had the blacks do. Mississippi was given him because of blacks.He did it and rolls in it ever since.Than these people are so revolting we will lose in Nov.I will never vote Obama.He had to ruin this landmark election with no experience just race.Pathetic Than he has the nerve to whine about race or fear if anyone DARES to question.Makes me want to throw up
Is paying for and having sex with a prostitute illegal? Can a John be arrested? Is it illegal to move tax payers money around to hide what its used for? If I were guilty of these things, could I just quit my job and not be convicted?
Spitzer made a lot of enemies with the work he did. I think this is more to do with that than anything else.Hillary will catch fall out because he was a super delegate so she will lose one. Obama of course and his minions will smear her face in it. I think all these peoiple that smear her so he can keep his hands clean should be thrown off these sights. I hope Hillary doesnt distance herself from anyone till the people on here are delt with. There pathetic personal attacks are an obimination .This double standard of dont dare ask or attack me is the grossest thing going.You are a racist or fear monger if you dare to ask or question the great Bomba. Well guess what he is a nothing but self centered problem to this country.The swift boaters will have such a field day with him and wont care a bit about his whines or wimpers.God help this country.The polls showed if its Obama he will not get Hillarys support.Wont get mine for sure!!He can hide and lie all he wants wont do any good in long haul.You people can call names,smear,lie,talk your points you've been given and in November you'll be talking to an empty hall.
Right on Mox. 9 out of 10 blacks vote for Obama. Don't tell me their not just voting for him because he is black. Blacks never turned out like this before.
To Claire Brunner, do you not understand what the word "criminal" means?  It means someone who has broken the law, which Governor Spitzer has alledgedly done.  Whether you agree with the law or not, having broken it, he is by definition, a criminal.  To make matters worse, he has broken the same laws that he, himself, has prosecuted others for breaking.  He should be held to the same standard to which he holds others, don't you think?
A curious misread on my part: instead of reading "Fifth Avenue apartment", I at first read "Fifth Amendment apartment".
It is unbelievable that his wife is urging hime to stay on. She should have Pulled Lorena Bobbit by now if she had any sense at all. This jerk is suipposed to be the top law enforcement official for the state and he is involved in an iollegal activity. he shold be 1. impeached 2. prosecuted 3.disbarred.
If this lowlife escapes prosecution and Roger Clemens, Barry Bonds,et al do jail time then you know that this country has finally fallen ovwer the proverbial cliff.
This is another case where liberals like the poster named Claire Brunner, think it is just about sex. The problem is not the sex but the breaking the law, violating public trust, being the target of potential blackmail, interfering in federal rackateering cases, and finally the lies to cover it all up.

Perhaps, the liberal threshold for virtue is so low that anyone no matter their character will due. But, I think America deserves better than that.

On a side note, Ms. Brunner should realize that damage that this scandal caused Mr. Spitzer's wife and family. You would think a woman would be more sensative than that. But as she states, a liberal Democrat trumps all including crime.
memo to Governor Spitzer, also known as the "LOVE GOV": YOU'VE THROWN YOUR WIFE, YOUR CHILDREN, AND ALL OF YOUR CONSTITUENTS UNDER THE BUS.   Now that's where we want you to be.          
He didn't just have an affair, he broke the law.  Huge difference.
mox:  I feel nauseated after wasting my time reading your "comment"..
Who cares if he had sex outside of marriage?  I'll just go out on a limb here and guess.....his wife?  If it were merely an affair, that'd be one thing; immoral, but not illegal.  At the moment, prostitution IS illegal.

So because Spitzer is the governor, he shouldn't face the same consequences any other citizen would get?  And it wasn't even one time; he's been at it for 10 years.
For you liberal idiots out there, I have one challenge for you.....

Why don't you liberal guys go hire a $1000 hooker for a night in the sack....

And then tell your wife the next morning......

James Carville made it sound like he was jealous that it wasn't him with the hooker instead of Spitzer....

Why don't you get a woman, take her to bed and then tell Mary in the morning boy!
For you liberal idiots out there, I have one challenge for you.....

Why don't you liberal guys go hire a $1000 hooker for a night in the sack....

And then tell your wife the next morning......

James Carville made it sound like he was jealous that it wasn't him with the hooker instead of Spitzer....

Why don't you get a woman, take her to bed and then tell Mary in the morning boy!
Spitzer is trying to do what he would never grant any who got into his cross hairs - a deal with the prosecutor.  I like these people who say this is no big deal.  Had this been a high profile Republican caught in a similar situation, the call for a summary execution would be made. Spitzer is accused of breaking the Mann Act, a relic of a law that should be abolished, but it is still the law.  Also, leaders are successful when they have proven to be honest and moral in their dealings in office and in their private lives. How can Spitzer provide leadership after 1) flaunting the law and 2) spending a forturne on hookers while many of his constituents have trouble heating their homes and feeding their families and 3) what creep puts his family through the embarrasement of this sordid affair.  Leno and others are having a field day with this. As far as I am concerned, he can stay if he can arrange it. That way he can be a living, breathing example of the arrogance of the Democrat Party.  I'm sure Hillary is going to love his Super Delegate vote, if he lasts long enough to cast it.
Broken down, the Mississippi vote had an unmistakable racial descant — and unmistakable limits for Obama. Exit polls revealed once again an emerging racial divide that has opened in the Democratic party between whites who tend by healthy margins to favor Clinton and blacks who and blacks who overwhelmingly favor Obama. African Americans comprised nearly half of the Democratic vote in Mississippi — and 90% of those voters, according to exit polls, pulled the lever for Obama, his strongest showing yet among African Americans.
Claire, it's not about the sex. It's about engaging in illegal activities, conflict of interests, integrity and possible mis-use of funds etc.
What about Kwame Kilpatrick Detroit Mayor who cheated on his wife, caught using city property for inappropriate and illegal purposes, is being investigated for $ "mishaps," and being involved with a stripper's death?? Why doesn't the national news report on this idiot?

Why hasn't he been pushed to resign?? This just went down last month. He is a terrible leader, he is not a leader at all!

Report on Kwame and put the pressure on him to resign...or IMPEACH! Does anyone outside of Detroit care about Detroit, or does the world only care about New York??
This whole sordid affair will do nothing but remind the nation that the 3:00am phone call was coming from Monica.  Spitzer has to resign, but Bill gets to go back to the White House???


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=759704

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google