ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Bill heckled again

Posted: Wednesday, March 12, 2008 3:28 PM by Domenico Montanaro

From NBC/NJ's Mike Memoli
ERIE, Pa. -- Bill Clinton has gotten used to this by now.

Early on in an event in Northwest Pennsylvania, Clinton was beginning a regular line in his speech comparing the state of the nation now to when he was president in the 1990s. A young man then started shouting at the former president, repeating "1991 Bilderberg." After a moment or two, Clinton stopped trying to speak over him and acknowledged the heckler.

"Look, this is the deal, folks," he said. "All these people that are paranoid about the world come and scream at me everywhere."

The man said that if Clinton heard him out, he'd leave, so Clinton did so. But as he shouted about Bilderberg, NAFTA and the Trans-Texas Corridor, the crowd drowned him out with boos.

Eventually, Clinton rather calmly addressed the remarks of the heckler. "You said you would go if I answered the question," Clinton said. "All right, here's the answer."

He said he did attend the 1991 conference of global players at the invitation of Vernon Jordan. "To the best of my knowledge, NAFTA was not discussed by anybody in my presence," he said. "I was talking to people who happen to be from Europe who did not give a rip about NAFTA."

Clinton then gave a general defense of his role in NAFTA, saying he tried to get labor and environmental standards into that agreement, "but I couldn't because it was already negotiated when I got there." He also said that as president, he enforced trade laws more than the current Bush administration has.

"I had a very good time talking to those Europeans about European affairs and what was gonna happen to Russia, but I was not somehow polluted by it into sacrificing Americas economic interest," he said. "America did a lot better when I was president than they have in this decade and that is the truth. Now goodbye."

And with that, he waved him off.

Clinton enjoyed an otherwise rousing welcome in Erie during the visit, which he said brought back memories of a trip during his '92 campaign.

"When we started our bus tour we pulled into Erie at about a quarter to two in the morning and there were still 5,000 people waiting for us," he told the nearly 2,000 who waited about 45 minutes for him at East High School today. "I thought to myself we are gonna change this country and now we need to change this country again."

He then referred to the current race, acknowledging record turnouts and financial contributions. "We got almost two million new donors, many of them of very modest means who give over the Internet. People wanting to have a piece of their country's future."

He did not refer to last night's contest in Mississippi.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Who cares?
Would the psychotic hecklers yell out something relevant like "Who Donated To Your Presidential Library?" and "Where are your 2000-2006 tax returns?". Then we would get some real value for the nuttiness.

Remember the Rick Lazio 2000 campaign when HRC's lapdog Wolfson dressed up as Uncle Sam and yelled at Lazio for hiding his tax returns?
Would the psychotic hecklers yell out something relevant like "Who Donated To Your Presidential Library?" and "Where are your 2000-2006 tax returns?". Then we would get some real value for the nuttiness.

Remember the Rick Lazio 2000 campaign when HRC's lapdog Wolfson dressed up as Uncle Sam and yelled at Lazio for hiding his tax returns?
A previous post said that it was uncivil to heckle people at rallies.   Frankly, a heckler shouting:  NAFTA! is hardly "uncivil."   If returning to a more civil time means going back to 1967, when Sec. Defense Robert MacNamara had bags of urine thrown at him while speaking at Berkley, or LBJ being shouting down with the political rallying cry of F**K YOU!!!, then I'd rather stick with the current political climate, thank you!
Here is the truth....

We know Bill Clinton (when he is truly Bill Clinton) and Hillary, you are no Bill Clinton.

Bill Clinton wishes he were married to someone else  so he wouldn't have to campaign for Hillary. He is doing so only out of guilt and thinks he owes her something.

Bill Clinton secretly identifies more with Obama, sees some of himself in Obama, and internally supports Obama and thinks (as well as knows) that Obama would make a much better President then Hillary. And that is a fact, Jack.
Just had an entire segment on Fox News concerning Reverend Wright. All you people are familiar with Reverend Wright aren't you?
Well here is a brief summary of his sermon;
Omama is the man who can lead the country because he is the best to work with a country that has been run by "Whites". Hillary Clinton can't because she's never been called a Nig--r. He went on to tell his congregation that Bill Clinton says he has done so much for the Blacks, well, he went on to say, No he hasn't! He did to the Blacks what Monica Did To Him.
Well the crowd cheered and ranted and raved about the whites..Isn't that grand....Keep up the good work Obama followers now that I saw Obama not condemn or deny Wrights comments. He says that it's like when a family member says something you don't agree with. WHAT?
Now all you double standard voters picture Hillary Clintons Reverend saying those things about Barack Obama.
Did you really think that both he and Michelle are not racists? Do you really think he is a man of change. Change for who? You and me? No, I am thinking that Reverend Wright, Farrakhan and Sharpton's lives will be greatly improved after hearing comments from all three concerning Obama. Way to go, keep voting for him. Now I am not spreading rumors if you would like to verify the Reverends comments read the Transcript of Fox News Brian Hume's show today. See for yourself what racists these people are. And really he is talking about all the white voters as well....I am just so proud of all the Obama supporters.
I will be checking back Firstread to make sure you are a fair and equal blog site. Thanks
It is very hard to make a decision on these 2 people for president. I know the media has the power to destroy or build up anyone it chooses with half truths and garbage which get's people's attention. Their are qualities in both Hillary and Obama which I like.  I do not like the fact that  Hillary allowed her campaign to become negative. But Obama needed her attacks  to know how to deal with that sort of stuff , because if he is elected the candidate you can bet that John McCain will come for him with everthing including the lack of experience stuff. Just remember this ..
How many out there think that the Clintons are hiding huge income from Bill's speaking engagements to companies that most benefited from NAFTA?

Both Clinton and McCain think that the best plan for America is to flatten its wealth in favor of a world economy, the only difference being that Clinton thinks that America should consign itself to a world federation tied to new age concepts, while McCain wants to give it all away to big business, as long as he ends up being the world police chief. Meanwhile both these two are loading up their own pockets. If this isn’t pimping on an international scale, I don’t know what is.

Obama is the only hope for a free America, we need to take care of our neighborhoods before we can help other countries, and the days of America being police to the world are too dangerous today. Yes, he is Young, and Black-get over it!-
I am so irritated with the Democrats! I have been a life long Democrat (a long time!) and I am so frustrated. We have a wonderful choice. Now one candidate is clearly preferred. It is not about race or gender. It is about the hard working American public being disgusted with business as usual and looking for a "different way of doing business in Washington." So Hillary should step aside and join the parade supporting Obama and his choice for VP. Enough fighting and sliming. Get on with the business of beating the dastardly Republicans and winnning the White House and Congress. Then we can get on with the business of restoring America, ending the war, rebuilding our infrastructure, schools, health care and integrity in government. We're going to shoot ourselves in the foot again and give the election back to the crooked, money mongering Republicans. Yes, Bill was great! But now is the time for him and Hillary to play a different role in our history. Sorry a woman didn't make it. Maybe next time. Enough already of giving the Republicans the mud to sling back at us!
It's a shame a heckler has to be the one to shine a light on the Trans Texas Corridor.  If you own property in this country you need to investigate what they are planning to do in Texas.  I am not a conspiracy theorist, I just "follow the money" to arrive at my conclusions.  I urge people to search the web for information on the Trans Texas Corridor and you will see that this is not some hair-brained hoax.  Look at the Texas DOT official web-site for a start.
I do not understand why we are so preoccupied with Race.  When did we become a nation where one can not make a statement without fear of being labeled sexist or racist?  I see nothing wrong with Ferraro's statement.  It could be true or it may not be true, but she does have the right to say it.   We, all, need to stop reacting negatively to everything that is written or spoken. Where is the dialogue?  Let's not attack every word that a person makes.  Has the American People gone crazy or is it just politics as usually?  
Reading all the comments make me weep.  I'm so happy to see that Americans aren't fools.  All of Senator Clintons moves are so obvious.  And what becomes even more crystal clear is that she will do ANYTHING to win the nomination. It's very ugly.  Mr. Dean, please end this.  Please. The Democratic Party should denounce and reject Hillary Clinton.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=761574

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google