ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Distancing from Ferraro, hitting Obama

Posted: Wednesday, March 12, 2008 6:50 PM by Domenico Montanaro

From NBC/NJ’s Athena Jones
The Clinton campaign sought to make it clear Wednesday that it did not agree with comments Geraldine Ferraro, a supporter and a former vice presidential candidate, has made to the effect that Obama would not be where he is today if he were not a black man.

"Let me make clear that we were completely unaware of Mrs. Ferraro's remarks, prior to their being made.” Communications Director Howard Wolfson said on a conference call with reporters in response to a question about whether this sort of thing might be a campaign tactic. “We did nothing in any way to encourage them. When Sen. Clinton spoke to them, she made clear that she disagreed with them and that she, in fact, rejected them and, look, as she said, there are supporters in both campaigns who have said things that the candidates disagreed with, that the candidates have rejected.

“It's important when that happens to make clear the disagreement, which we did immediately, and I think it is incumbent upon all of us to focus on the issues that matter most to the American people.”

When questioned about why the campaign hadn't taken a more aggressive approach to dealing with Ferraro, who is on the campaign's finance committee, but is not a paid staffer, Wolfson said different situations led to different responses and used the opportunity to instead talk about instances in which Obama supporters had said controversial things.

"Each campaign has taken a different response when confronted with different issues,” Wolfson said. “I would remind everyone at the start of this campaign when David Geffen made comments that many found objectionable, Sen. Obama said he disagreed with them, but said there was no reason to remove him from the campaign and he remains a campaign fundraiser.

“When (Gen.) Merrill McPeak made comments that many found disagreeable, the Obama campaign did not remove him from their campaign. So each circumstance is different.

“Geraldine Ferraro is not an advisor. She's not a member of the staff, and we have made clear that we reject her comments, that we disagree with her comments. She was not speaking on behalf of the campaign and in the interviews that she was engaged in today she is not speaking on behalf of the campaign, and I think she was making that clear.”

Brig. Gen. John Watkins, Jr., who noted that he is African-American, also spoke up to say he lamented Ferraro's comments and did not believe the Clintons were racists, noting the former president's efforts to be inclusive in his administration.

"There is absolutely no doubt in my mind that she [Hillary Clinton] is the farthest thing from being a racist,” Watkins said. “I can say that categorically, having worked with she and her husband to put some key African-Americans in their administration, their first administration and watched those people blossom throughout.”

Wolfson said Clinton had shown renewed strength among some Republicans and Independents in Ohio, Texas and Mississippi because of the increased focus on whether Obama was ready to lead "on Day One," and he rejected the idea as "laughable" that any of these voters would vote for the senator for tactical reasons, for instance because they think she would be easier to beat in the general election.

The conference call, led by the campaign's National Security Advisor Lee Feinstein, was held to talk up Clinton's readiness to be commander in chief. This is a subject the campaign has been pushing hard for several days now and several of the call's participants have participated in other calls or meetings to express their views on the senator's ability to lead.

The bulk of the 50-minute discussion yielded no news, involving instead mostly repetition of many of the same arguments made recently about why these military officers support the Clinton, including what they called her understanding of the challenges presented by Afghanistan, her world vision and her strength as a leader.

The other members of the military on the call were Vice Admiral Joseph A. Sestak -- who is also a congressman from Pennsylvania, Maj. Gen.Paul Eaton, Rear Admiral David Stone and and Fmr. Sec of the Navy John Dalton. They are part of a group of 31 flag and military officers who are supporting her, said Feinstein.

Sestak called Clinton "one strong woman" and hailed what he called her vision and her understanding of how deliberate the redeployment of troops from Iraq would have to be.

Eaton said the former first lady was "brave" and was "graceful under fire" and understood the dynamics of soft power.

"With two sons in the Army, I want her steady in the saddle as commander in chief for my family members,” he said. “She understands the dynamics of soft power, how to move diplomatic power, economic power, to help" deal with conflicts in places like Afghanistan and Iraq.”

Stone cited her work on behalf of veterans and her courage in talking about women's rights as human rights in her 1995 Beijing speech. He also talked about the need for more support from NATO in waging the war on terror in Afghanistan. Watkins called her "a very strong, smart, caring and very deliberative person" who knows how to work across the aisle. Dalton said Clinton had done her homework on Afghanistan and reminisced about having observed Clinton interacting with sailors on several occasions. He said she cared about what was important to them.

Several brought up Clinton's service on the Senate Armed Services Committee and both Eaton and Stone brought up Obama’s lack of hearings with relation to NATO in Afghanistan on a subcommittee he chairs, suggesting he failed to lead when given a the chance to make a difference.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

We strongly support Hillary in PA, and I know from calling voters that if Hillary doesn't get the Democratic nomination, her supporters will switch their vote to McCain.

People wanted "change" with the last president and look what it got us.  I can't imagine anyone voting for that reason.  

Our governor, citizens, and super delegates are all behind Hillary.  Bring it on in PA!
The Clintons' biggest problem is they need a "re-do" on basic math:  

Obama has an insurmountable lead in pledged delegates, an insurmountable lead in the popular vote, and has won over twice as many primaries and caucuses as the Clintons.

We have all endured too much of the Clintons personal entitlement mindset, but the primary/caucus season does eventually end.  Let us all hope that the Clintons win at any cost mentality does not cost the Democratic nominee the White House in November.
Will Hillary have the same answer concerning Spitzer and her campaign?  Will he resign from her campaign?

It's not about GF (or HRC) being racist.

It's about being willing to use "the Southern Strategy" in PA (aka Pennsyltucky).  This is just more evidence that HRC and her followers will do anything to win ... including engaging in the same politics that gave the South to the Republicans for 40+ years.

And, by the way ... the Clintons invented Karl Rove, not the other way around.  Almost everything he's ever done came straight out of the Clinton playbook. All you need to do is ask him.  
Need a correction on the spelling of Geraldine Ferraro not Geraldine Furraro.
Bull the Dog, she was given the same opportunity that Obama's advisor was given. The opportunity to resign. She has done that so be done with it already.
Second Bull the Dog I am quite sure if I began scrutinizing your every word and action I could make you out to be something you are not to. It would just depend on the way I say it. Right? If I ask you to explain every single word you ever said you entire life and then told everybody, and further condemned you words for political advancement you to might hold back something I am sure. Then I could blog everyone and tell them that your hiding something that would stop you from ever being promoted in your job. And then lets say your job was helping handicapped children. A great and rewarding career. I could take a higher ground though and just look at all the very good things you have done in your life and judge you on that.

Now to others, get the transcripts from Brian Hume's show as of today.
If you can with a clear conscious tell me that you are comfortable with Reverend Wrights comments about why Obama would be a good President and why Clinton would not be, as well as his comments concerning William Clinton then I will listen to your views. I will never vote for Obama based on his experience and record of being safe by voting present on over 100 times in the Senate. As well as the way he voted on many issues that I had a concern with. He is in my opinion not qualified for the job.
Experience does count or you would never promote where you work either. Or don't you even get that?
This is with all due respect.
Oh I just hope this backfires HUGELY with the college students, affluent whites, and any white person with a college degree in Pennsylvania.  Wait a minute, what am I saying?  I hope this backfires with EVERYONE EQUALLY!  The Clintons are sick ruthless freaks.

And by the way, Hillary Clinton is shipping your jobs overseas to Bangalore!  You can google this.

Every union member should be running like hell from the Clintons.  Clinton's campaign manager Mark Penn is a union buster!!
If you take note of polls, you will see what Clinton is doing to both Obama's and her possibility of beating a tired old warrior who was out of gas 8 years ago.

In a word, she is bringing the roof down on the party rather than graciously accept the will of both the people.

An example of human nature at its most putrid.
Do you have no sense of patroitism, Hillary Clinton?

Is it really all about how you feel? What You deserve?
 How do you feel, Hillary?

"...to be all alone... without a direction home... like a rolling stone?"

Hell must be living in her skin.


Geraldine Ferra-who?  Why is this old douche bag flapping her pie hole.  Let her go back to her racist eyetalian bretheren.  If Obama is where he is at becuase she is black, then Clinton is where she is at becuase she has a vagina and married Bill.  They are both affirmative action presidential candidates.

And I really enjoy Clinton continuing to destroy the Democrat party.  The first party to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory.  Ha, ha, ha, ha, ... stupid predictable Democrats.  Obama had the only shot to defeat McCain, and now the Democrats are going to either destroy Obama or let Clinton steal the nomination.  Either way, McCain now can defeat a Clinton mauled Obama or an election stealing, racist, horn dog husband having, permanent victim.
Ferraro is laughable. She is lying and her words are hypocritical. She used almost the same words many years back when talking about Jesse Jackson in his run for president. Her comments are racist.
Check out this video on Fox news

http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,337308,00.html
This is right up there with "Pet Bobcat Uses Toilet!". She's still miffed that she wasn't the first woman VP, and now, Hillary can't ask her.
Senator Obama is not a black-American if his mother was a white woman and his father was African. He is instead, a person of color. But if everyone wants to play the race card, might it not be true that some Americans are voting for the Senator because of his Black heritage and some others because he's also half White. There are any number of White-Amercians today who are married to a person of color. Return this race to a race for the Oval Office, not one of poor race relations in this country.  Aaron Knight
You know, Gerry is right, let's send her her FTD flowers. If Obama was white, speaking about change and hope, giving americans something to believe in again, someone with a different last name than what we have had the last many years, yes, he  would have won the number of votes he needed to have closed this sham the dems have going on by now.  

BUT since he is not white, and has not won enough votes to seal the nomination, BUT doing a great job staying ahead in the count, I think her remarks were typical of some of her (wf) generations' basic way of thinking.  

With words like that and other words coming out of HRC's camp, the only thing McCain will need to do is replay all her soundbites.    That is, if and when BO wins the nomination in November if not before.
I suspect all of these Generals and Admirals who are now endorsing Hillary were given their stars by recommendation of then President Clinton.
HILarious. Such a politically incorrect statement. As others have said, if someone pointed out that Hilary is only there because she is a woman( patently obvious) , just how loud would the screams be for that staffers removal.
It does get kinda funny when Hilary is trying to use her "Womans" card and she is trumped by the Race  card and he isn't even using it. Must be tough when your liberalism only extends as far as it gives you an edge....
We see Hilaries' true colors come out and she shows use that underneath her slick veneer of liberalism , she is a petty , power grabbing person.  Just one more of  the many hypocrits that run this country.

Asst. Secretary of State and Chief Spokesman for State Dept. Jamie Rubin on MSNBC Tucker Carlson's Show confirms Senator Clinton's Foreign Relations experience and her involvement in Northern Ireland's Peace Process and her impact on human rights policies worldwide due to her courageous speech in China criticizing the Communist governments' policies stating "women's rights are human rights". Hillary Clinton challenged world leaders and governments to change their treatment of women and children and incouraged women worldwide to pursue government elected positions.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SCjgBAjZBaQ&feature=related

Northern Ireland's Minister and Deputy Minister meet with Senator Clinton on December 7, 2007, in Washington D.C. to discuss Northern Ireland's ongoing Peace Process and Economic Development and to thank her for a decade of involvement and her committment to continue supporting Northern Ireland's Peace Process and Economic Development.
http://youtube.com/watch?v=bZhStkZgveI

Secretary of State Madeleine K. Albright; "I know Hillary will be a true leader because she already is, and she has been for as long as I have known her. When she went to China and stood up and said, "women's rights are human rights" - she was acting as a leader. When she went to Northern Ireland and met with the mothers of children killed by both sides, and brought them together in support of the peace process - she was acting as a leader. In the Senate, on the Armed Services Committee and on trips to Iraq and Afghanistan - she has acted as a leader."

Northern Ireland Secretary Mo Mowlami; "Hillary is one of the essential reasons Ireland had peace. Without her we would have no economic boom."
(Talk Magazine, August 1999)

Hillary met with Macedonian President and Prime Minister offering Economic Development Package.
(Chicago Tribune, 5/16/99)
"First Lady Brings Publicity, Aid to Macedonia. Hillary Clinton met with Prime Minister and Parliamentary President." (Washington Post, 5/15/99)

Just a few documented statements confirming Senator Clinton's Foreign Relations experience and her impact in people's lives and governments' policies worldwide.
America is full of drama queens. Face reality people..this is politics. They say things that aren't nice...blah blah blah blah blah.  Get over it.
Obama is ok I do not like his supporters__ they are fanatical and irrational. Frankly this is exactly
what I do not want to have to deal with for 4 years if Obama gets elected.  I do not want to worry that everytime someone says something an Obama supporter perceives as against Obama the commenter is portrayed as a racist even if they have facts and statistics to back up their statement
I agree the media is doing us a disservice by plunking all the voters in their racial slots.
I think Mrs Ferraro's statements were belittling.  "The only reason he's here is because he's black."  That's pretty much saying the only thing he's got is the color of his skin.  Is that different than calling somebody a "monnster"?
Divisive maybe, but most definitely disrespectful.  And no apology.
I remember how disappointing it was to see Ferraro cry back in 84 then follow that up with a cheezy pepsi commercial.  She set the women's movement back decades and is doing it again with irrational and petty comments.
It's time for superdelegates to put an end to this nonsense before a potentially very strong democratic electorate is totally disenfranchised.  
Hey First Read look into the notion of C. Rice being J. McCain's running mate, have you heard any such suggestions? I just voted yes to a poll that asked that very same guestion. If foreign policy, and national security is the republicans main concern this would be perfect!!!  
Mrs. Clinton has had two chances in recent days to show her leadership ability before Day #1.

The first chance was when her superdelegate, Mr. Spitzer was exposed as a womanizer.  If Mrs. Clinton was true to her self-professed leadership qualities, she would have immediately and publicly stated that the Democratic Party has no place in it for this type of behavior.  A true leader would have demanded his resignation and would not have waited to see "how it played out".  

Her second opportunity to demonstrate leadership was in regards to the comments made by Mrs. Ferraro.  It's amazing to think that a rational person would believe that being black in America somehow makes it easier to run for president.  For 150 years, blacks were in chains and then for the next eight years most were denied the right to vote.  All of our presidents have been white, 99 of our senators are white and 49 of our 50 governors are white.  I can't figure out how being a black man somehow is a benefit.  Mrs. Clinton cried foul when one of Mr. Obama's associates referred to her as a "monster".  But she was far more supportive of her own superdelegate's foul comments.

I believe Mrs. Clinton has failed two tests of leadership in two days.  Is this what we can expect of a "President" Clinton?  
I am qouting this "WE TOTALLY AGREE WITH FERRARO!! Only the Obama camp brought all this out. He is playing the Race card period. And I think she has a solid point, and she explained that it wasn't a racist remark. Obama and his idiot Pastor are making a mountain out of a mole hill".
If you take note of polls, you will see what Clinton is doing to both Obama's and her possibility of beating a tired old warrior who was out of gas 8 years ago.

In a word, she is bringing the roof down on the party rather than graciously accept the will of the people.

An example of human nature at its most putrid.
Do you have no sense of patriotism, Hillary Clinton?

Is it really all about how you feel? What You deserve?
 How do you feel, Hillary?

"...to be all alone... without a direction home... like a rolling stone?"

Hell must be living in her skin.


Hey first read, why are you talking qbout yesterdays news and not commenting at all about the fact that Obama was endorsed today by a group of Military Flag Officers from the Navy, Army, and Marines?   We all know Billary's spin, same spin different day- No one really cares.  We all know that she has lost this election and we all know that her and her camp of clowns will say and do anything.  After she publicly endorsed John Mccain nothing, I repeat NOTHING will surprise me.

So instead of repeating old news how about we focus on the Democratic nominee, Barack Obama.  He is the one that will be competing with Mccain in November, NOT BILLARY, so we all need to just ignore Billary and her pathetic ploys and focus on what REALLY matters, the two nominees, Obama and Mccain.

Let Billary fight it out within her own campaign.

Obama 08
to T. Sunday Torbor:, no, he can't win the general election with only black votes (which, even if they voted as one solid, unified block, still only comprises 12% of the American population). So, your own math should tell you that, given Barack's standings, he's obviously getting more than just "black" votes. He never wanted to be seen as the "black" candidate any more than Hillary wants to be viewed as the "woman" candidate, I would imagine. The media is painting that simplistic characterization. Both want to be considered for what they say they can do, she, based on her professed experience, and he, based on his vision for the country. Geraldine Fferraro just bought into that oversimplification by insinuating that she, herself, wasn't qualified (but only chosen because she was a woman) when she was nominated as Democratic VP in 1984. That's not the message she wants to send to Clinton's supporters or the rest of the nation. That the popular vote/pledged delegates is really nothing more than affirmative action. Where's the voice of the American people in that?
Mrs. Clinton

I love the fact that woman is running for the presidency. But, I was hoping that she would run with no negativity. We as Americans are tired of the same politics of the past. We meed the president that is able to get the job done without the connections of the past. I lost faith in yours and your husband's ability to see things from my propective and my everyday battles as a black woman. When your husband said that there is so evidence of genocide in Rowanda I was extremely disapointed. I know that you say that you have experience in foreign affairs, that is what scares me about you becoming president, your so called experience. We need a clean slate who is willing to let the people of the country have a hand in governing the country. Not someone who changes their personality to cry to the press. I will support whoever becomes the Presidential Nominee (D). But as for now I will support Mr. Obama.
Ferraro just should have started her hate speech with.....
"I'm no racist, but"  It is not as funny when you add that at the end.
Oh, and I do think the Clinton campaign is most definitely on board with racist attacks.  Right Bill?
Mrs. Clinton

I love the fact that woman is running for the presidency. But, I was hoping that she would run with no negativity. We as Americans are tired of the same politics of the past. We meed the president that is able to get the job done without the connections of the past. I lost faith in yours and your husband's ability to see things from my propective and my everyday battles as a black woman. When your husband said that there is so evidence of genocide in Rowanda I was extremely disapointed. I know that you say that you have experience in foreign affairs, that is what scares me about you becoming president, your so called experience. We need a clean slate who is willing to let the people of the country have a hand in governing the country. Not someone who changes their personality to cry to the press. I will support whoever becomes the Presidential Nominee (D). But as for now I will support Mr. Obama.
If Barack was white and named Barry Dunham I agree with Ferraro; he would not be running for the Dem. nom. After 8 yrs. of Bush the Dems, DIM DUMB DEMS have decided we need an historic election. A woman and a AA male. Joe Biden and John Edwards would have been stong contenders; they could have won this against McCain easily. Biden had the race card pulled on him by the Obama campaign and the press. Edwards finally dropped out due to lack of coverage. Edwards continually fought to bring attention to the working and middle classes and the poor- the other America. Obama and Clinton picked up his message and tried to get his endorsement but failed. Biden has the best foreign relations experience and is extremely respected all around and both dudes have charisma. Obama- Americans will ultimately decide he is too much of an unknown quantity; although charismatic - DIVERSITY- just wont cut it in these extremely dangerous times. Clinton? You better hope she gets the nom. She might have a chance . I can't believe this stupidity.
It is so bitterly ironic that women continue to vote for Hillary. This is the wife who enabled her husband to commit perjury against a woman. She enabled and supported her husband in his abuse of power to prevent abused and harassed women from exercising their rights to sue for justice. She allowed innocent women to be vilified and tarnished by the media. She was his accomplice! It is simply tragic that women continue to support this dysfunctional and destructive couple. They have done more insult and injury to women than practically any pair in US history. How you can continue to forgive and forget these misdeeds is beyond all logic and reason.
So as I understand now the Clinton gang is saying "Vote for Hillary for a whiter America!"
If Ferraro is a Super Delegate, she should have that stripped away.
Hillary didn't ask her to leave. Ferraro, after she had put her own foot in her mouth, stepped down willingly. THEN, Hillary rejected her comments. Didn't she ask barack to immediately reject and denounce Farrakhan for similar viewpoints?
Please America read and know your history. Leon Ryan this may confuse you but most Americans of African Descent are racially mixed and we still consider ourselves Black. Sen. Obama is no different.  The recent comments from Ms. Ferraro bears no truth but to some that harbor racist fears and beliefs it sounds like gospel.  It's sad that the Democratic Party has sunk so low.
Mr. Olberman, WOW, what a great show. Congratulations, ca'nt wait to hear Hillarys reaction to this commentary of yours. A loyal viewer.
If the Obama people read this my advice is to quit pandering to her, and letting her lead the spin cycle. Axelrod shouldn't have called for Ferraro's resignation; instead simply say her comments are disagreeable and if that's who she surrounds herself with, that's her choice. Then move on.

Be tough on the issues - infrastructure brings jobs, education brings jobs, better health coverage brings jobs, no tax breaks for outsourcing, saving the environment brings jobs. And be specific. That's what Pennsylvania working people need to hear, not that Clinton's staff are nasty. They know that. Never say it's the fault of the media (that's our job) or complain about her tactics (if at first she doesn't succeed...)Re: her (lack of) experience, again the voters know already. They're probably voting for Bill or because she's a woman. Let it go, move on.

Stay above the fray, being tough on the solutions and get in front of her efforts to drag you down. NEVER let her lead the story. You are the front runner, act like it and dismiss her as irrelevant (but in a classy way so as to not alienate her supporters.)

Stick to what an Obama presidency will be, swat away her remarks with one well-timed remark, and move on to jobs and health care and infrastructure and not just Washington is bad and we will change it - time to say how and not give the media sounds bites attacking her.

Just my thoughts, based on what I feel when watching the news.
Keith Olbermann's special comment was brilliant.
I don't have the exact percentages, but I believe that in 2000, African-Americans gave VP Gore around 90% of their vote, and he is, of course, white.  And if simply being black was enough, per Rep. Ferraro, then why didn't Jesse Jackson or Al Sharpton or Carol Mosely Brown have better support?  A lot of things being said - by Ferraro and by posters here - don't really account for those things.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=762276

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google