ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Clinton vs. Obama: Ferraro resigns

Posted: Thursday, March 13, 2008 9:15 AM by Mark Murray

The Boston Globe covers Ferraro’s resignation yesterday from Clinton’s finance committee. “‘I am stepping down from your finance committee so I can speak for myself and you can continue to speak for yourself about what is at stake in this campaign. The Obama campaign is attacking me to hurt you. I won't let that happen.’”
 
“Earlier yesterday, the 1984 vice presidential nominee apologized to those who thought it racially insensitive for her to suggest that Obama wouldn't be the Democratic front-runner if he were not black. But she then declared: ‘It wasn't a racist comment. It was a statement of fact.’”

The New York Times uses the resignation as a peg to write how race has once again become an issue in the Clinton-Obama contest. “[R]ace, as well as sex, have been unavoidable subtexts of the Democratic campaign since the two candidates began seeking to be the first African-American or the first woman to lead a party’s presidential ticket. In the primaries and caucuses this winter, too, Mrs. Clinton has enjoyed substantial support from women, while Mr. Obama has increasingly drawn overwhelming votes from blacks."

More: "Clinton’s reluctance to sideline Ms. Ferraro, who made her comments last week to The Daily Breeze in Torrance, Calif., left the specter of race hanging over the Democratic contest. That decision drew a sharp rebuke on Wednesday from the Rev. Al Sharpton … who questioned whether Mrs. Clinton’s campaign was keeping the issue alive as a way to win white votes in Pennsylvania.

The Los Angeles Times adds, "In the latest sign of a racial rift in the contest, two prominent black pastors warned Wednesday that African American voters could become so discouraged by the campaign that they might stay home in November if Clinton is the nominee.

Both campaigns were trying to make this week a battle of military credentials, but race has largely overtaken the issue.

NBC/NJ’s Athena Jones reports that Clinton had to deal with the race issue almost exclusively at last night's black newspaper conference. She was asked about Geraldine Ferraro's remarks and whether she had done enough to make sure those involved in her campaign knew that such comments were not acceptable. "Well, I said yesterday that I rejected what she said, and I certainly do repudiate it and regret deeply that, you know, it was said. Obviously, she doesn't speak for the campaign. She doesn't speak for any of my positions and she has resigned from being a member of my very large finance committee," Clinton said, before going on to say that both she and Obama had had to remind supporters and staffers that this primary campaign should be about the issues.

"We are aware that this happens, but we are particularly sensitive to it because of the nature of this campaign and who each of is. We do stand against it. We repudiate it," she said. "I think that given the intensity of feelings surrounding this campaign, we have been able to manage it well. It's not been common but when it happens, we both have spoken out and taken appropriate action."

When asked afterwards if she was satisfied with Clinton's answer, Barbara Reynolds, the NNPA columnist who asked the question said she had hoped for more. "Sometimes I don't think that she can feel the racial insensitivity like we can. This is why they don't get it. It's not that she's a bad person, but when people say things, you know, she can't get it, because she doesn't feel like we feel and I think some of us are very sensitive anyway, because of how we have lived and sometimes these things can fall on her ears differently. But she should rely on her black staff people to immediately tell her, 'Oh this is horrible,' because she should have come out immediately and demanded that Geraldine Ferraro disassociate herself from the campaign.”

The AP says that Clinton’s biggest apology at the conference last night “came in response to a question about comments by her husband, Bill Clinton, after the South Carolina primary, which Obama won handily.” More: "I want to put that in context. You know I am sorry if anyone was offended. It was certainly not meant in any way to be offensive," Hillary Clinton said. "We can be proud of both Jesse Jackson and Senator Obama."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Some people supporting Ferraro's comments are saying that Obama is winning because blacks are voting for him--how do they explain his overwhelming wins in Wyoming, Wisconsin, Iowa, etc.?  Not exactly locations with high populations of blacks.
Just because you believe that something is true does not mean that you should say it.  Haven't you ever not said something that was true because you did not want to offend someone or make them feel sad?  It is just common courtesy and respect of other people. Before you open your mouth, whether you believe that it is true or not, you have to consider the possible effects.  If it is not necessary to say and it is offensive, whether or not it is true, it should not be said; especially when you are in the pubic's eye!
Good Clinton Interview on NPR.
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=88165077
Steve Innskeep asked the pointed questions we all scream at the TV when some "TV Peronality" throws under hand to her. And Senator Clinton played an excellent game of Dodge ball.

Obama '08
She's right.

J. Merle Stanley, Westchester, NY (Sent Thursday, March 13, 2008 9:34 AM)

So was Samantha Power. Only I would have use a little stronger word.
Hillary only had a chance at becoming the president because of Bill's legacy, but no one was saying out loud, and least no one in the media or the Obama camp; evebthough it is true.  No one wanted to belittle her out of respect, but she obviously did not appreciate that.
I think it's very troubling that msnbc will not show the video of Obama's (Pastor Wright) spewing racial slurs and hatred toward whites and the Clintons,at his church services.

The news media have a obligation to report all the news.  Obama needs to be questioned on his Pastor's statements.

Obama was present when his Pastor made these hate filled and racial remarks.

When is the media going to question Obama on these things?
And what about PA Gov. Rendell saying that a lot of whites in his state won't vote for an African-american for President?  The press accepts it as fact and it very well may be, but why isn't he questioned when he says it.  Is he doing anything to change it?  Is he prepared to say that he rejects those votes for Clinton?  Is he saying that its OK for the racists to vote for my candidate because that's just the way it is?  I reject that thinking and ALL Democrats should reject it as well.
As an Obama supporter, I do not support him because he is black; that had nothing to do with my decision. I support him because he is the only candidate that can offer our country ANY sense of change. When they say he is inexperienced, I see that as a good thing. If you are ingrained in "politics-as-usual" in Washington, you can expect the same old thing. I prefer to see what this young man can bring to the table. At the very least, it will be fresh, new ideas and strageties and how can THAT be wrong for our nation? I am not against Hillary because she is a woman. I'm against Hillary because she represents the "same old thing", as does John McCain. My support was quite simple. Something new, not the same old thing. I never considered this to be such a difficult decision for many of you out there. I also never condsidered it to be a black or white issue, let alone a gender issue. It truly isn't if you look at it with a little commen sense. It's the difference between new and old. Period. For those interested, I'm a 58 year old white woman.
How can Ferraro accuse Obama of using the race card when she is the one who brought of the race issue?
As a republican I think this is very, very funny..  She's playing hardball and Obama is crying.. This is lightweight stuff compared to what the GOP is gonna do to him this fall..  If he keeps crying foul and accusing racism, he will alienate a large percentage of white democrats into voting for McCain.  Omama is a lightweight, and if he gets the dem nomination, and trust me thats who us republicans want to run agains McCain, the democrats haven't seen anything yet.
Ferarro should tell us how his son John Zacarro murdered Jennifer Chambers and got away with it. Maybe he is not among the priviledged.
A summary of Clinton experience:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hwLaCb07lAs

Dear Mark Murray and First Read staff,

As a political junkie it is frustrating to me that all this highly paid pundits fail to pick up on the glossed over inaccurate statements of politicians like Ferraro and worse repeat them like the truth. I hope you guys will do a better job of informing the public.

Here is my beef:
Ferraro saying that Obama's situation is no different than hers when she was selected as a running mate for Mondale. There is a huge difference being SELECTED by some one or some party to run as a running mate versus entering a race as an individual and advancing forward by beating your competitors based on the votes you receieved from the voters. Obama was not SELECTED by some individual or organization to represent the democratic ticket.In fct, we can argue some candidates were unhappy with him because he had the gut to run when it was 'not his turn'. Ferraro was SELECTED by Mondale or the party for strategic reasons such as to appeal to women and to show the party's willingness to become a trail blazer. They could easily have selected somebody else for other strategic reasons such as geography etc..

But on the other hand, Obama EARNED it by running against a group of well known candidates who had establishment backing by the power of his message and the genius of his organizational and planning skills.

So, next time when Ferraro says there is no difference between her VP stint and Obama's accomplishment the media needs to correct her and set the record straight.
Obama will run for President only to give it to McCain.

Even Georgie Bush could get relelected against Obama.



SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=764839

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google