ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Obama: How does he respond?

Posted: Monday, March 17, 2008 9:05 AM by Mark Murray

This was easily Obama's toughest weekend as a candidate. This is a test for him as a candidate. Does he wilt or does he get back up off the map and fight on without losing who he is?

The AP's Fournier writes, "Arrogance is a common vice in presidential politics. A person must be more than a little self-important to wake up one day and say, ‘I belong in the Oval Office.’ But there's a line smart politicians don't cross — somewhere between ‘I'm qualified to be president’ and ‘I'm born to be president.’ Wherever it lies, Barack Obama better watch his step."

More: "Obama's cool self-confidence got him into trouble in New Hampshire when he said Clinton was ‘likable enough,’ faint praise that grated on female votes who didn't appreciate him condescending to the former first lady. Privately, aides and associates of Obama tell stories about a boss who can be aloof and ungracious. He holds firmly to views and doesn't like to be challenged, traits that President Bush packaged and sold under the ‘resolute’ brand in the 2004 election. For Bush, those qualities proved to be dangerous in a time of war and in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina.”

“If arrogance is a display of self-importance and superiority, Obama earns the pejorative every time he calls his pre-invasion opposition to the war in Iraq an act of courage. That may seem unfair to a candidate who's running against Clinton, the former first lady who is the model of overbearing pride. This is a woman, after all, who claims experience from her eight years as first lady but won't release her White House records; who trails Obama in delegates but deigned to suggest he'd be her running mate; and who has more baggage than Samsonite yet says Obama lacks ‘vetting.’ But voters expect arrogance from Clinton and her husband, Bill. It's part of the package. It's a 90s-thing. The Clintons' utter self-absorption comes with a record of achievement and brass-knuckle passion that Obama cannot match — and that Democratic voters know could come in handy against GOP nominee-in-waiting John McCain.”

Tom Edsall looks at the real problem Rev. Wright's comments are causing Obama -- the general election should Obama become the Dem nominee.

The New York Times’ Kristol writes about Obama's Rev. Wright issues and concludes, "The more you learn about him, the more Obama seems to be a conventionally opportunistic politician, impressively smart and disciplined, who has put together a good political career and a terrific presidential campaign. But there’s not much audacity of hope there. There’s the calculation of ambition, and the construction of artifice, mixed in with a dash of deceit — all covered over with the great conceit that this campaign, and this candidate, are different."

From the Obama campaign: There is a report on Newsmax’s website, which is repeated in Bill Kristol’s column today, that says Obama was in church to hear a sermon on July 27, 2007. But that report is inaccurate. He was not there; he was traveling to Miami.

The New York Times’ Roger Cohen writes more extensively about Obama's family, including discovering he has a half-brother living in China.

Have you not gotten enough on Rezko? The Chicago Tribune and Sun-Times posted full transcripts (and even audio) of their Friday interviews. 

The Chicago Tribune editorial board was impressed with Obama's candor, though it said it was late. "Barack Obama now has spoken about his ties to Tony Rezko in uncommon detail. That's a standard for candor by which other presidential candidates facing serious inquiries now can be judged."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

It is amazing how much Clinton strategy really worked, the media has truly turned on Obama. That is why I don't respect her as a Democrat. The solution/right thing to do, is to say the media needs to treat all candidates fairly and equally, not blatently say,"the media needs to go more negative on my Democratic opponent". She is sick and the media is sicker for taking the bait.
How can this be Obama's toughest weekend?  He just netted another 10 delegates in Iowa, completely wiping out Hillary's Ohio gains.  Sheesh.
god, I am glad I never bought into this guy. Knew him and his wife were a fraud from the beginning
Obama is toast, he should just give up and crawl back under the rock he vacated.
So when do we hear from Clinton about her taxes, White house papers, Donor list and earmarks???/
Obama has answered every question, when does she???
STOP GIVING HER A PASS MSNBC
I think all he can do is respond honestly...that is, I truly believe, what people want in a leader (and its why we have always been suspicious of politicians in general).  I no longer expect honesty in politicians.  Look how they are bashed when something negative comes out.  And we wonder why they try to spin?

I can only speak for myself.  I value honesty, above all, when it comes to whom I want to lead America.  It goes to trust.

This article (not the whole FR blog) but this article seems to give an overly neg. view of Obama and that's fine.  We can all find the more positive views of Obama for ourselves in other entrees on this blog or in other media.  But I will simply say, he is the better choice than McCain on the issues and the better choice than Clinton on campaign tactics and overall ethics (the secrecy issue is becoming big for me on Clinton as is her overall insistance in bending or breaking every rule as long as she can get some advantage).  It is Clinton who has shown a clear indication to put personal ambition over everything else.  It is Obama who disadvowed his pastor's remarks while saying he honestly couldn't disavow the man, knowing the man as something more than his remarks in two inflammatory sermons.  How is that opportunistic?  He is getting flamed every which way for not condemning the man.  Yet, he stuck to his personal belief in what was right.  On this matter, that is political courage.

Obama 08
The furor over Rev. Wright is only the latest reason for the separation of church and state.

Starting with Robertson and Falwell saying 9/11 was "God getting even!", to Naggy's "Catholics are the whore of Babylon", to Parsley, etc.!  Our politicians are forced to divulge their religious commitment, and then they are going to be punished for the views of their pastors/priests/rabbis/immams?

I support Obama, but do not hold Naggy and Parsley against McCain, Ferraro against Clinton, Wright against Obama.  We cannot expect all of our associates to be free from making statements no matter how insensitive or idiotic!
When will First Read begin to report that on April 25th, a judge in California will set a trial date in a fraud trial case where hillary monster "George Wallace" clinton (as well as Bill and Chelsea) are defendents.  The trial will be in the fall right in the middle of the general election campaign.  Is that the type of distraction hillary monster "George Wallace" clinton supporters want?  Nothing like a 17 million dollar fraud trial in which you're the nominee to destroy a campaign.  hillary monster "George Wallace" clinton defrauded Peter Paul and committed election law violations.  C'mon FR, report on this story!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xq8aopATYyw
....LORD!  So many lies and now its out that in both his books The Audacity of Hope and "Tales Of My FAther" Obama invented characters and events.  Its not a non-fiction but fiction.  Check this out:  
http://www.pr-inside.com/new-york-times-credits-andy-martin-r487729.htm
It really burns how this Obama guy has been shoved down out throats.  The more we find out abot him the more he smells.
The travesty is the fine candidates like Biden, Edwards, and Dodd were swept under the rug and we had no CHOICE.  The feeding frenzy on the wonders of an Obama were astronomical. The Dem party screwed it self AGAIN!
The Media has the ball they can bounce it back to the repukes in the WH.
No reason to vote now, stay home it is a joke played on Ameica.
Obama just keeps gaining delegates. The better he does, the more his opponents slander him. But he remains very popular. He's been smeared from every direction and has withstood it all.
Where are those tax documents Hillary?
Why isn't msnbc raising that issue?
The 5 million she loaned herself came from where???
Just to add context because you guys will not - this part in Fournier's article A few months later, he said, "Every place is Barack Obama country once Barack Obama's been there."  referred to a nightline interview when he was joking with the reporter - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XutQqQiMUx8 - arrogance - no - maybe he says somethings off the cuff joking around but I'll take that over robot Clinton who has to turn the dial to humanity.
MSNBC, please don't reference the Bill Kristol column.  Mr. Kristol included alleged facts that have been proven with a simple google search to be false.  Mr. Kristol said Obama was at the church for the July 22nd sermon when in fact Mr. Obama was in Miami at an event that all news agencies covered.  

Please don't further the falsehoods Mr. Kristol put forward.
Still Fired Up and Ready to Go!!!

Responding forcefully with the truth when the status quo tries to smear our next president.
"...aloof and ungracious. He holds firmly to views and doesn't like to be challenged, "

Are these characteristics of a great uniter?
Confidence and arrogance, a fine line that Senator Obama has crossed repeatedly on his high-minded tour of hope.
How can an arrogant man bring other arrogant politicians together?
Who would listen to a man who thinks he knows it all?
Why would we listen to the same garbage the Bush administration sold us?
http://twocanpete.blogspot.com
Obama does not have to respond. He does have to keep pounding away at our jobs going to China, the economy going to heck and the nee to leave Iraq immediately. He also needs to get his head out of the sand on the issue of illegal aliens. They are not going to vote for him, HRC has already out pandered him on this one.
Really now.

In one of your later posts here, you (First Read) question the guy for preparing what you claim is a "full frontal assault".  This, after weeks of whining that he has not delivered (in a race set up so that it is virutally impossible) a "knockout punch" or can't "close the deal."  Which way do you want it?  You guys are producing 'all spin' on this piece of it.  You have every right to critique, but you can't have it both ways.  Seeing that you seek to do so suggests that Obama is hitting the right notes in the right way at the right time.  If you want something to complain about, call your city councilman and ask him to patch the winter's potholes.

As to this message, now you damn the poor guy for being nearly 'arrogant' or 'aloof.' Personally, he doesn't need to be opening the doors for aides and delivering them soda pop and foot rubs or listening to them yammer.  He has a big job and he is preparing for a bigger one and everyone in the world wants his ear now and it will only get worse.  This sounds to me like the kind of discipline and prioritizing that someone preparing to lead the country out of one hell of a mess had best be exercising.

Report some facts, please.
Here’s another gem from Obama’s pastor, the esteemed Reverend Wright.  This time the subject is missing teen Natalee Holloway:

"Black women are being raped daily in Darfur, Sudan, in the Congo and in Sub-Saharan Africa. That doesn't make news,"
But, "One 18-year-old white girl from Alabama gets drunk on a graduation trip to Aruba, goes off and 'gives it up' while in a foreign country, and that stays in the news for months!" he added. "Maybe I am missing something!"

And I suppose Obama knew nothing about this or other statements from his friend, his mentor, his pastor of 20 years and the man who conducted his wedding, blessed his house, and baptized his daughters.  


he tries to be polite and keep it clean, but how do you manage to keep clean while battling a pig?!  

release your tax returns, hillary!  show us this impressive record of yours.  she is a political pig prancing around like a peacock.  america will not fall for it.  go away.
BS BS!  You don't have to be arrogant to believe you can do a better job as president than George Bush, you just need to have a heart, a brain and a pulse.  I am tired of this arrogant crap being constantly laid on Obama. It is clearly racist code wording for uppity and being raised in Louisiana I know what that means.
Obama should not be held responsible for every stupid thing his pastor has ever said. What would happen if all of us were judged for every insensitive thing people around us said or even did? One may disagree with a spouse, family member, friend or pastor; but still personally hold them in same regard. He condemned the quotes--Not the man. JW is not going to be on the ballot; however, Barack, Hillary or John will be. If this is the vetting process. Let it begin with all three of the canidates being judged on the deeds or actions of others. Let the candidate agree or disagree. Those are the forces they can control and should be judged by.
The Wright stuff is bad news for Obama. It's a huge problem for the white vote he must win over. It's also a huge problem for supporters who see their candidate come up with very weak arguments to explain his long association with the Rev. and the church. His claims of ignorance are pathetic. These sermons were recorded, published and distributed. Was there a vow of silence not to discuss what was being preached with Obama so he could swear he didn't know? It's way too late for Obams to start playing political games and it completely undermines his image of being a different type of candidate. This is so "same old stuff." Next problem is to explain why Ferraro's comments were to terrible while Wright's were nothing to fret over. He's going to have to come up with an Easter miracle to stop the damage before it's too late. But how will he fight it in October? I'm very doubtful and very disappointed after contributing, campaigning and voting for him. Did Edwards withdraw too soon? I would love to see Gore/Edwards save the Democrats.
Why quote Kristol's column if it's based on misinformation?  

Kristol's one major complaint is his assumption that Obama joined his church to establish ties with the Afr-American community and is now distancing himself as a part of his presidential campaingn--which he sees as being nothing more than political convenience.  Kristol makes this assumption based on the fact that Obama has said that he didn't hear the sermon on 22 July, which he didn't, as your post goes on to say.  

If Kristol is going to attack Obama because of misinformation, he needs to post a retraction, and you at First Read should not give credence to his claims when they're based in error.

I think most people, including Obama supporters, know that in order to succeed as a politician, you have to prepare--and some of that includes going down a path you wouldn't want to travel given ideal circumstances.  

What I am interested in is not what Obama has done in the past to get to where he is now--and I should say that I have faith that Obama has followed a fairly honorable path.  I care about what he wants to do now and the spirit of unity and the different kind of politics he will bring to the White House.
After the  Crazy Rev Wright thing, and Obama's obviously disingenuous answer that he never heard a one of those hate-spewing sermons, I've lost a lot of respect for the man.  I was all-Obama-all-the-time.  Now I may just sit out this election.
This campaign mess is as much the fault of the New Media as it is Hillary's. Race and gender comments were bad enough, then reporter's sank to reporting on what Obama's Pastor 'said'.  Shame on the news media for stooping to this level.There are real issues to address; Where are Hillary's tax returns we all know there is something there that she doesn't want us voter's to know or it would not be a big issue for her; and what about Clinton vs. Paul. Hillary has been accused of knowingly accepting 1.2 million dollars in campaign funds in 2000 and the news media believes what someone's pastor said is more important. Shame on you all.
Well said "Lisa, New Britian, CT"

Obama/Webb 08'
"think" said: "...aloof and ungracious. He holds firmly to views and doesn't like to be challenged, "

Are these characteristics of a great uniter?"
-------------------------------------------------
What these are is highly opinionated questionable statements from someone with an agenda to hurt Senator Obama. People aren't falling for it.  
Quite to the contrary Barack is known for being very willing to LISTEN to differing views. A leader willing to listen, THAT would be a change!
Country & Bluegrass Fiddlers for Obama '08
Either Obama is telling the truth and he knew nothing of the controversial remarks his Pastor made during sermons over 20 years or he is lying.

If he didn't know then he is easily fooled by people like his Pastor and Tony Rezko.

If he did and I suspect he did because his campaign disinvited the Pastor from delivery remarks when Obama announced he was running for President.  His campaign also knew the pastor was controversial as they admitted it on a conference call Sunday.  That indicates Obama knew at least in early 2007 and waited until just now to distance himself.

So the next question is how much do we not know about this guy who came out of nowhere?  We need to push the media to give us a real picture of this guy and not a puffed up glossy piece.
Obama has been a PROUD member of his church for 20 some odd years...sorry, I don't believe he wasn't aware of his pastor's preaching style and out right racist remarks...why did Oprah leave this church?  Well, according to Oprah, she left the church because she didn't agree with the Rev.'s preachings...he is a known racist in his community...Obama has no excuse.  As for Obama claiming he wasn't aware of the sermons...bull...his campaign said they knew the Rev. would become a problem for them down the road becuase of his preachings...and yet Obama still put the Rev. on his campaign as an advisor...he had his chance to distance himself long ago...wait, in the words of Obama himself, Re: Rev. Wright..."Just Words?"  What a joke
csh, IL (Sent Monday, March 17, 2008 10:01 AM),

What exactly was inaccurate about the statement by Reverend Wright? You do hear about Natalie Holloway and many other "white women" who go missing.

But you nary hear a word about the genocide in Darfur.

What about this is inaccurate or inflammatory? You have to admit that our media's infatuation with the blonde-haired, blue eyed pretty lady can be overbearing at times.
csh,

you are one of those people that thinks the Holloway story is bigger than the atrocities that are going on in Africa.  Rev. Wright was talking about people like you and he was DEAD ON right.
Obama should not be held responsible for what his Pastor has said but he should be held responsible for choosing to attend a church pastored by an individual so skilled in preaching a gosple of divisivness.  For 20 years Obama has been mentored by Rev. Wright and now he claims he's aware of the Rev. Wright's rhetoric?  Obama claims Wright as his spiritual adviser but pretends not to be aware of the philosophical basis for his spiritualism.

Obama says he didn't leave that congragation because his kids were baptized in that church and he didn't want to take them from that congregation?  Why?  Was he afraid that maybe the kids wouldn't get a good idea of how the white man has held the black man down?  

Obama's supporters have been played.  It's just that simple.  Sorry.  But you have.  As you lick your wounds just keep repeating, "Clinton will say anything to get elected." Or maybe you'd prefer, "Words matter" as you re-play your copy of Rev. Wright's greatest hits.  

Clinton need not make any comment as anyone with a brain can figure this out and need no help at all.
It has helped me to understand what Black people do with the anger that must have accumulated over the years in response to things like serving and dying for their country in the wars which did not protect THEIR rights to vote, to access a fair and reasonable education, and to take part in the American dream.  As well, I can imagine what it must have been like to spend money in and support the economy and to work to build the country up, but to be denied the right even to enter through the front door and sit in the same seats as white people.  You can say it is in the past, but I remember it, and so do a whole lot of people.  What do we expect?  That it is all over now and we should all be "nice" and smile at each other?  For the most part, that is what you see in our country.  Is it fair to ask Black people not to express the grief and anger about that even in the privacy of their own church?  Or would we rather see chaos in the streets as we see in other countries?  I think we should be grateful for the tolerance of our African American citizens.  And I think the window into Obama's church is a gift to those of us who never stop to think how it might feel to be an American whose rights are "less equal" than others.  Obama is right.  We have an opportunity for a dialogue that needs to happen for us to heal as a nation.  These wounds are deep. To Blacks and Whites and Browns.  I'm glad that this came out now.
Here is a question that I don't believe that we truly know the answer to - Does Hillary even ATTEND church? I know her, Bill and John McCain will "campaign" in chruch but do they actually attend? If the Wright sermons are fair game then these questions I beleive must also be answered as well. What say you MSM?!?!?
csh wrote:
Here’s another gem from Obama’s pastor, the esteemed Reverend Wright.  This time the subject is missing teen Natalee Holloway:

"Black women are being raped daily in Darfur, Sudan, in the Congo and in Sub-Saharan Africa. That doesn't make news,"
But, "One 18-year-old white girl from Alabama gets drunk on a graduation trip to Aruba, goes off and 'gives it up' while in a foreign country, and that stays in the news for months!" he added. "Maybe I am missing something!"

Duh, this is true.  Poor precious white girl disappears and it's news for months, same happens to a black girl and no news.  Why is that?  Could it be because all the news organization in this country are run by rich, white men?  Take your blinders off already.
Obama should not be held responsible for every stupid thing his pastor has ever said. What would happen if all of us were judged for every insensitive thing people around us said or even did?
Michelle,, Atlanta (Sent Monday, March 17, 2008 10:11 AM)
-----------------------------------------------------
Ya think Michelle?
I can see president Obama with wife and girls...coverage of the Sunday church service with old uncle Wright!  UGH!! America needs something better than that crap!
The Rev. Wright has done more than anyone to throw cold water on Obama's campaign surge. I am no Clinton supporter but I am glad that this info about the Rev. Wright is coming out now and not in August around the convention. How will Obama respond to this loud-mouthed racist idiot?  Should be interesting...!!!
First was the wife stating she is now proud of been an American, now as in 2008, any other period she was not.  Now  the rev for the last 20 years, you are going to me tell that you never heard him saying anything that sounded off color, for Christ sake, you had dinner with the man, you think this country is composed of morons to believe you Mr. Obama that you never heard anything.  Yeah, right.   I do not know about you, but as a New Yorker and as an American, I knew people that worked at the WTC and they were the most loveable people I ever known and in their live they never did anything to anyone that would associate what happened in that day of 911 to the way they lived they live.  I do not know about you, but after knowing someone for 20 years, hell I better know what they think and what worldview he or she has.  Mr. Obama, I think you are lying and if this is the change you are talking about, I do not want to be part of it..  God bless America.  Go Hillary.  People, wake up!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=774939

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google